Friends Beg Mom Of 3 To Get Help After She Claims Her Kids Are Not Her Greatest Accomplishment
There are millions of things people can be proud of, which is why one’s greatest achievements don’t always coincide with what others are proud of the most.
This redditor—a mom of three—got into a heated discussion about such achievements with her neighbors. One of them assumed that the three wonderful children were her greatest accomplishment in life, which is why when she said that they weren’t, people around were shocked and even suggested that she seek help.
Seeking to learn more about how people view womanhood in relation to motherhood, Bored Panda got in touch with a Professor of Sociology at the University of Maine, author of Childfree by Choice: The Movement Redefining Family and Creating a New Age of Independence, Dr. Amy Blackstone, who was kind enough to answer a few of our questions. You will find her thoughts in the text below.
People’s greatest accomplishments tend to differ from person to person
Image credits: o1559kip/Envato elements (not the actual photo)
This woman said she resented the assumption that having kids is her greatest accomplishment
Image credits: astrakanimages/Envato elements (not the actual photo)
Image credits: cassiecasscassi
Changing certain deeply ingrained beliefs might take time
Image credits: Andre Furtado/Pexels (not the actual photo)
According to Dr. Amy Blackstone, motherhood and womanhood are so intertwined that to disentangle them is, for many, blasphemous. “Yet these are distinct concepts,” she pointed out in a recent interview with Bored Panda. “We tend to link these two concepts because we live in a pronatalist society where our political, economic, and religious institutions are designed to encourage childbearing.”
The expert continued to suggest that within this system, women are taught that motherhood is the greatest thing they can aspire to and achieve.
“Teaching women that motherhood is the one and only role they should aspire to—or at least the only important role than can achieve—not only severely limits their potential, it totally dismisses the millions of women who either can’t or don’t want to become mothers and the millions of women who are mothers and achieve so much in addition to that singular role,” she said.
Comparing mothers with their male counterparts, Prof. Blackstone pointed out that while men are socialized toward parenthood as are women, they are not limited to a single role in the way that women are. “Men are expected—and believed to be capable of—achieving success in multiple roles. Again, this goes back to the project of pronatalism which relies on the production of new workers for the economy and new worshippers for our religious institutions. Women are expected to bear those new workers and worshippers and to raise them.”
Needless to say, both men and women are more than just someone’s parents when they acquire such a title. But in many people’s views, there is no greater accomplishment than bringing someone precious into this world. And while there is nothing wrong with such a view—if one feels like being a parent is what they’re most proud of—it doesn’t necessarily mean that all moms and dads feel the same way; nor does it mean that the others love their children any less.
According to Dr. Blackstone, changing deeply ingrained beliefs takes time. “Multiple waves of the feminist movement have worked to change this – from the first wave’s efforts focused on voting rights to more recent efforts focused on expanding our views of gender more generally,” she said, adding that we’ve already witnessed decades of a slow but sure chipping away at the narrow and limiting belief that women can only fulfill one role.
For many people, raising a child is the most important achievement
Image credits:Taryn Elliott/Pexels (not the actual photo)
The redditor’s neighbors’ reaction to her views are not that surprising, considering how many people view being a parent as their main achievement. A survey of 2,000 Brits found that raising a child is what the majority of them feel most proud of, followed by buying their first home, paying off their mortgage, and getting their first job respectively. They also reportedly feel proud over achieving an undergraduate degree and getting a promotion at work.
Bearing in mind that parenthood and professional life are usually two of the most time-consuming things in one’s life, it is natural that many of their achievements relate to exactly that. However, surveyees also shared feeling proud of traveling on their own, learning a new skill, or volunteering, among other personal wins.
The survey found that close to half of the respondents regretted not having more moments they’re proud of in their life, and close to a third of them said it might be difficult to find something that provides a true sense of accomplishment.
Some of the OP’s neighbors have figured out that it’s being a mom or a dad that provides them with a sense of accomplishment, and they’re not alone; according to the Pew Research Center, as many as 80% of parents find their role to be rewarding. However, the redditor herself believed that other achievements were more important to her than the “biological functions”, as she put it, which is something many redditors agreed with. “Children are people, not an accomplishment,” one of them wrote in the comments, where many shared their opinions; scroll down to find more of them below.
Some netizens sided with the woman, saying that she was not a jerk in the situation
Others shared different opinions
Poll Question
Thanks! Check out the results:
I would be very wary of people who claim their kids are their greatest accomplishments, since their sense of self-worth is so tied-up with their kids. Kids have their own personalities, they are not an extension of their parents. What if their kid doesn't turn out the way the parents have envisioned? These people are not the right company for you. They are entitled to their opinion of course, but I'm afraid you will never see eye-to-eye with them and this will always be a bone of contention in one way or another. Maybe try to agree to disagree if it's not possible to have just a superficial contact?
And what are the age differences? OP had a full life before the kids but for people that had kids right away, maybe that is all they have done. There are also value differences at play. This is like arguing about whether a sahm or working mom is "better". Do what you need to do for your and your families mental health
Load More Replies...Uuurgh. My children are absolutely not my greatest accomplishment. Birthing them and keeping them alive are bare minimum requirements. If I manage to raise them into well rounded respectful kind human beings then I will be proud of that but they are not my accomplishments (nor are their accomplishments mine).
Exactly. How many children grow up into better humans despite their parents? Not denigrating good parenting but a lot of that 'raising' is done by the kids themselves. Some with good guidance, some without. They are their own personalities.
Load More Replies...I'd probably be more angry about 'Tom' jumping in and answering on my behalf, rather than about assumptions he made concerning accomplishments, especially since it he's just a neighbour, not a close friend.
Tom seems like a twat in general, so that's really only part of the reason people ought to be angry with him.
Load More Replies...These are the sort of people who when they find out I don't have kids pity me and consider me some kind of less than because of it. Adults are not defined by their kids, and whilst it's ok to be proud of your kids it's also ok not to see them as your proudest achievement.
My greatest accomplishment is eating an extra large pizza in 10 minutes. No kid will compare to that.
🙄 at the person who said getting a degree and climbing mountains are trivial compared to the sum of a human life. Those things contribute to the sum of her life!
People like that don't see value in women's lives no matter what they accomplish. All the value they see is in the lives of potential males women could birth.
Load More Replies...Kids are not some project that you improve, saying they're your accomplishment is like saying that they're just extension of you. It's ok to be proud of your kids, but raising them well shouldn't be your greatest accomplishment, it's your responsibility as a parent.
I'm getting tired of people saying that birthing a child, or just children in general are miracles. No, they are not. Women have been getting pregnant and giving birth for centuries.
Load More Replies...I would be sick to my stomach if my parents described me as an accomplishment. Fair enough if someone says being a good parent, or turning their life around or breaking the abuse cycle is *an* accomplishment, but children aren't milestones, it's degrading to regard them that way.
My father (who I'm NC with for a lot of reasons now) always used to say we were raised "right" so we turned out well. No, I raised myself and then my siblings for you while navigating the other abuses. We turned out well despite him.
Load More Replies...F_cking and reeding are not "achievements", and raising kids is an obligation most take on voluntarily. An achievement is fulfilling an ambition.
Kids aren't an accomplishment. They are people. Don't spend time with people who think they've churned out trophies, they are without empathy and out of touch with reality.
I have 3 children. They are NOT my greatest accomplishments. Making them was mad easy and quite enjoyable (ok pearl clutchers go ahead and downvote) but my GREATEST achievement by far was keeping myself and them alive, fed, clothed & housed when the entire world seemed to be against us at every turn. THAT was an accomplishment.
The other moms were jealous. They didn't have any great accomplishments that could compare with OP, so they went for the lowest common denominator and then tried to shame her for saying something different. "If you don't stand as tall as someone else, start digging a hole under them to make yourself look bigger."
I was so taken aback by the weird convo that I forgot about the part where they followed up and reported her to her husband for not equating children with gold star stickers. Hopefully the kids aren't too fond of each other because OP and husband need to get away from that toxic cult and find friends who want to be people and not checklists for better homes and gardens.
Classic controlling mom behaviour, pretending you are sharing something out of concern but really just doing your best to inspire someone to join your rage.
Load More Replies...The only accomplishment I'm proud of when it come to my kid is the fact that she made it to adulthood without me killing her....kid was rough!
I had someone tell me that Marie Curie winning *two* Nobel Prizes wasn't as big an accomplishment as the fact that she had children was. Apparently nothing a woman achieves can possibly compare to a biological function that even a rat can do: give birth and raise offspring.
Having my 3 children was not my greatest accomplishment, but getting out of an abusive marriage with me and my 3 children alive is one of my greatest accomplishments.
Do you think they just have a weird alternate universe definition of achievement? They seem to be confusing things I love with biggest achievement, which aren't even close. Maybe adoration and achievement? Toxic weirdos though, I'd avoid as much as possible, but it's their children I really feel sorry for.
Perhaps they have never achieved anything. Growing up is not an accomplishment. Getting married is not an accomplishment. Cleaning and preparing some mediocre food, good enough for a family, is not an accomplishment. It is just the definition of existing and surviving in a mild environment. If that's all they've done in their lives, then their children probably are their greatest achievements, the only thing that they have put some serious hard work on, beyond the minimum required to survive.
Load More Replies...Gee, I wonder if Charles Manson, Ted Bundy, and more all had mothers who thought their kids were their greatest accomplishment?
Oh but they weren't well behaved, so they would have to be listed after any fancy cars and big houses, but before county fair ribbons and employee of the month awards.
Load More Replies...Breeding is not some miraculous accomplishment. Reducing women to breeders and cattle is offensive. People like that have no self worth. They have accomplished nothing to be proud that doesn’t rely on outdated stereotypes and using their children as their “accomplishments”.
God I am so tired of people telling me I can’t do certain things or have certain things because I’m a woman. Being told I’m not smart enough or I’m too emotional. Being told having kids and being a good wife is the only use for me and if I don’t do it, I’m somehow broken. I am so, so, so tired of this. It’s 2024, I can’t believe some people still haven’t woken up yet.
I love being a mom. I wanted to be a mom my whole life. The first time my mom dropped me at daycare as a toddler, I spent the time following around the people taking care of the infants and wanting to help. That never changed. I started babysitting early, volunteered at a daycare center at age 12, and worked with kids as a preschool teacher, substitute teacher, nanny, etc. I was over the moon when I had my first baby. And two more followed. I love kids, and having my own has definitely been the highlight of my life. But when people ask about my greatest accomplishment, I never think of my kids. That's a separate thing. Having kids was just something I chose to do. It's not an accomplishment. Goals that I've set for myself, worked toward and achieved--those are accomplishments. And I have a list of those that have nothing to do with my being a mom.
What people don't understand is that everyone has different strengths and resources. So for some raising good kids is a piece of cake but getting an education and being resilient is difficult and for others it is the reverse. Your greatest accomplishment is the thing that was hardest for you
But how about following up with the partner with depression claims for not sharing the average point of view?
Load More Replies...Any cat, bug or jellyfish can produce offspring, FFS. Getting pregnant is NOT an accomplishment, and once you're beyond a certain point backing out of the "project" is all but impossible anyway (and having it go wrong is not a shame either). Raising your kids well IS one - but not in the same category as climbing a mountain or finishing a master's degree. Both of the latter are ambitious, *personal* goals and involve a lot of training, one way or another. The outcome of raising kids is not a single person's effort or accomplishment - there are other people involved, not least of them the children themselves.
NTA. First of all, just giving birth on its own doesn't achieve anything. It's hard to bear, but doesn't seem like hard to understand how to do. Second, your kids upbringing isn't finished yet, so calling it an accomplishment is out of date, to the early side, for ANY of you. Not because it wouldn't be something to be proud of if done considerably well, of course it is, but it just isn't time to call yet. You still could make it your greatest mistake, or, maybe that's worded better, it still could turn to be the greatest failing in your life, if you screw up from here on. Ok, not likely to happen, but ... the third reason I wouldn't want to call it so is that kids are persons, not just a result of your upbringing. Of course, they're that, too, but they also aren't in your complete control, and somewhat of themselves anyway. They're not trophies, but (growingly so) independent persons.
Nope. Absolutely NTA. I love my 3 kids to bits. They are AN accomplishment. They are not my GREATEST accomplishment. Raising offspring isn't and shouldn't be a noteworthy thing. Is it hard? Abso-effing-lutely! Does it take a huge chunk of your time and life? Yep! But so do so many other things. Having children IS rewarding. But it's not worth an award.
NTA - anyone can give birth. Parenting is harder, but most Americans don't seem to factor that in following BIRTH. Don't delete yourself for the sake of your offspring: teach them that they are valued, respected and should be capable of living up to their own decent values.
If she's a jerk for feeling attacked by a comment like that, then he's also a jerk for butting in and answering for her, and -he- was a jerk first. She didn't say anything rude out loud: those were just her thoughts at the time. All she told him was that she didn't want to be reduced to her female body, which is perfectly reasonable...
Nearly anyone can have kids, it's not exactly hard. Very few can climb Kili, never mind all her other achievements.
Good grief my kids fall about half way. They have grown into Good, kind, smart adults with their heads on tge right way. All I did was give birth and tried to teach them how to be adults - I did my job. My greatest accomplishments are other things that define me as the person I am. My kids are their own people creating their own greatest accomplishments
I overheard my dad told my mom that he didn't accomplish as a good father. I felt sorry for him. He shoulld not have felt he failed. He loved us and worked very hard to provide for his family. In my view my siblings and I are not to be his accomplishment. Our efforts and achievements depend on our own capabilities as adults.
It depends on the person. Everyone views their accomplishments as something different. Accomplishments are subjective.
Your children are the greatest accomplishments of the process of evolution, not yours. You did what you were biologically able to do. Hurra! You did not traumatize your offspring to the point of ruining their future lives. Hurra! Here's your medal. What nonsense. I guess most people have nothing noteworthy, nothing that isn't trivial to show for themselves, so they say that their children are their accomplishments. Personally, I see such people as failures, as people who never worked or strived, or accomplished anything that wasn't easy, necessary, and common.
Mom's feelings are totally valid. As long as the kids are taken care of and loved, who cares??
A woman of many achievements, the double Noble Prize winner Maria Curie had two children. We don't know whether she considered them her greatest accomplishment, but she positively glowed when she talked about them.
I logged in just to ask BP to stop with this AITA stupid stories from reddit and bring back non-political, non-ethical, non-private-people-arguments-I-don't-care-about artistic and creative stuff we sometimes years ago knew and loved. For several years now BP became everything but what it was before. I liked comics, illustrations, creative cakes and furniture, silly houses and rooms, arts, crafts... I hate political stuff here, I want to hide from it sometimes, I don't care about stupid private arguments people have, you're adults, deal with it, don't ask strangers for validation! Bring back old Bored Panda, I hate this!
My daughter is a massively important person in my life, I’m proud of who she has become and how she carries hereslf, however she’s not my greatest achievement, that reduces her to being a thing. My achievements are all focussed on what I have done personally, mountains I’ve conquered literally and metaphorically. She is the combination of many people, many experiences and she can claim her own mountains and I’ll happily stand by as one of her supporters. She can tell you what her greatest achievement is.
OP sounds so full of themselves it isn't even funny. News flash: no one else gives a shite about you climbing mountains. Good for you, now get over yourself. All you had to do was say "Well actually Tom, my greatest achievement is ...x,y,z..." but, instead you hop on your high horse and act superior. Like someone else said, not everyone has written a novel (and just because you've written a novel doesn't mean it's a GOOD novel. It's not actually that hard to get published these days." So why are YOU so offended that others see their children as their greatest achievement? Because it seems this whole thing is more of a reflection on YOUR insecurities and not Tom and Jen's.
Sounds to me like you are one of those people with zero accomplishments, who despite being terrible parents, claim parenting to be their biggest accomplishment.
Load More Replies...This is 100% a cultural and/or personal perspective thing. Read through all the comments and see the different perspectives. I don't think either of the people are wrong for having their own perspectives, but the way they're delivering them isn't right. OP clearly felt like like her other accomplishments in life were being invalidated, whereas other parents have gotten the "you were so good at XYZ before you were a parent" spiel, which is also invalidating. People need to be more sensitive when they approach these topics.
Sorry, but doing the same thing a cat or a dog can do is not an accomplishment. There is a reason there are no medals, or prizes, or the like for people who have had children. Furthermore, whether you have done a good job as a parent is not for you to decide, but for your child. There are plenty of people who claim to have raising children as an achievement while their adult children are in weekly therapy for childhood trauma.
Load More Replies...Seriously? This woman took a well-meaning compliment and turned it into an insult. Wtf is wrong with people. I doubt their reactions were as “smug” as she claims, and who could blame them if they were, given her unnecessary aggression and anger in this scenario. Does not sound like a happy person to me! While I wouldn’t define children as an “accomplishment”, they are a GIFT, the greatest one I could hope for. Some people are not so fortunate to have children. This lady should take a hard look at herself and her resentment because there is definitely bitterness there, but I have no idea why she can’t embrace both her past accomplishments and motherhood with grace and joy. Reducing motherhood to a basic “biological function” is just beyond ridiculous, it’s demeaning.
One of those women was Reddit-bullying her by reporting her to her husband for possible depression, which I am 100% certain she is not qualified to diagnose. Just because some people can't have children, it doesn't mean that having them is an accomplishment. Some people are paralyzed from the waist down. That doesn't make walking on your own two feet an accomplishment. That's just absurd. There was no compliment there. Only the demeaning of a woman and the erasure of her accomplishments in favour of her biological capability. "Giving birth" was literally mentioned. Without it, motherhood is no more special than fatherhood. And notice how the man in the story didn't claim fatherhood as his greatest accomplishment. It's OK if you have nothing to show for your life but birthing and raising children. But that's what the females of all mammal species do. They don't just birth them. They teach them what they need to survive as adults.
Load More Replies...I would be very wary of people who claim their kids are their greatest accomplishments, since their sense of self-worth is so tied-up with their kids. Kids have their own personalities, they are not an extension of their parents. What if their kid doesn't turn out the way the parents have envisioned? These people are not the right company for you. They are entitled to their opinion of course, but I'm afraid you will never see eye-to-eye with them and this will always be a bone of contention in one way or another. Maybe try to agree to disagree if it's not possible to have just a superficial contact?
And what are the age differences? OP had a full life before the kids but for people that had kids right away, maybe that is all they have done. There are also value differences at play. This is like arguing about whether a sahm or working mom is "better". Do what you need to do for your and your families mental health
Load More Replies...Uuurgh. My children are absolutely not my greatest accomplishment. Birthing them and keeping them alive are bare minimum requirements. If I manage to raise them into well rounded respectful kind human beings then I will be proud of that but they are not my accomplishments (nor are their accomplishments mine).
Exactly. How many children grow up into better humans despite their parents? Not denigrating good parenting but a lot of that 'raising' is done by the kids themselves. Some with good guidance, some without. They are their own personalities.
Load More Replies...I'd probably be more angry about 'Tom' jumping in and answering on my behalf, rather than about assumptions he made concerning accomplishments, especially since it he's just a neighbour, not a close friend.
Tom seems like a twat in general, so that's really only part of the reason people ought to be angry with him.
Load More Replies...These are the sort of people who when they find out I don't have kids pity me and consider me some kind of less than because of it. Adults are not defined by their kids, and whilst it's ok to be proud of your kids it's also ok not to see them as your proudest achievement.
My greatest accomplishment is eating an extra large pizza in 10 minutes. No kid will compare to that.
🙄 at the person who said getting a degree and climbing mountains are trivial compared to the sum of a human life. Those things contribute to the sum of her life!
People like that don't see value in women's lives no matter what they accomplish. All the value they see is in the lives of potential males women could birth.
Load More Replies...Kids are not some project that you improve, saying they're your accomplishment is like saying that they're just extension of you. It's ok to be proud of your kids, but raising them well shouldn't be your greatest accomplishment, it's your responsibility as a parent.
I'm getting tired of people saying that birthing a child, or just children in general are miracles. No, they are not. Women have been getting pregnant and giving birth for centuries.
Load More Replies...I would be sick to my stomach if my parents described me as an accomplishment. Fair enough if someone says being a good parent, or turning their life around or breaking the abuse cycle is *an* accomplishment, but children aren't milestones, it's degrading to regard them that way.
My father (who I'm NC with for a lot of reasons now) always used to say we were raised "right" so we turned out well. No, I raised myself and then my siblings for you while navigating the other abuses. We turned out well despite him.
Load More Replies...F_cking and reeding are not "achievements", and raising kids is an obligation most take on voluntarily. An achievement is fulfilling an ambition.
Kids aren't an accomplishment. They are people. Don't spend time with people who think they've churned out trophies, they are without empathy and out of touch with reality.
I have 3 children. They are NOT my greatest accomplishments. Making them was mad easy and quite enjoyable (ok pearl clutchers go ahead and downvote) but my GREATEST achievement by far was keeping myself and them alive, fed, clothed & housed when the entire world seemed to be against us at every turn. THAT was an accomplishment.
The other moms were jealous. They didn't have any great accomplishments that could compare with OP, so they went for the lowest common denominator and then tried to shame her for saying something different. "If you don't stand as tall as someone else, start digging a hole under them to make yourself look bigger."
I was so taken aback by the weird convo that I forgot about the part where they followed up and reported her to her husband for not equating children with gold star stickers. Hopefully the kids aren't too fond of each other because OP and husband need to get away from that toxic cult and find friends who want to be people and not checklists for better homes and gardens.
Classic controlling mom behaviour, pretending you are sharing something out of concern but really just doing your best to inspire someone to join your rage.
Load More Replies...The only accomplishment I'm proud of when it come to my kid is the fact that she made it to adulthood without me killing her....kid was rough!
I had someone tell me that Marie Curie winning *two* Nobel Prizes wasn't as big an accomplishment as the fact that she had children was. Apparently nothing a woman achieves can possibly compare to a biological function that even a rat can do: give birth and raise offspring.
Having my 3 children was not my greatest accomplishment, but getting out of an abusive marriage with me and my 3 children alive is one of my greatest accomplishments.
Do you think they just have a weird alternate universe definition of achievement? They seem to be confusing things I love with biggest achievement, which aren't even close. Maybe adoration and achievement? Toxic weirdos though, I'd avoid as much as possible, but it's their children I really feel sorry for.
Perhaps they have never achieved anything. Growing up is not an accomplishment. Getting married is not an accomplishment. Cleaning and preparing some mediocre food, good enough for a family, is not an accomplishment. It is just the definition of existing and surviving in a mild environment. If that's all they've done in their lives, then their children probably are their greatest achievements, the only thing that they have put some serious hard work on, beyond the minimum required to survive.
Load More Replies...Gee, I wonder if Charles Manson, Ted Bundy, and more all had mothers who thought their kids were their greatest accomplishment?
Oh but they weren't well behaved, so they would have to be listed after any fancy cars and big houses, but before county fair ribbons and employee of the month awards.
Load More Replies...Breeding is not some miraculous accomplishment. Reducing women to breeders and cattle is offensive. People like that have no self worth. They have accomplished nothing to be proud that doesn’t rely on outdated stereotypes and using their children as their “accomplishments”.
God I am so tired of people telling me I can’t do certain things or have certain things because I’m a woman. Being told I’m not smart enough or I’m too emotional. Being told having kids and being a good wife is the only use for me and if I don’t do it, I’m somehow broken. I am so, so, so tired of this. It’s 2024, I can’t believe some people still haven’t woken up yet.
I love being a mom. I wanted to be a mom my whole life. The first time my mom dropped me at daycare as a toddler, I spent the time following around the people taking care of the infants and wanting to help. That never changed. I started babysitting early, volunteered at a daycare center at age 12, and worked with kids as a preschool teacher, substitute teacher, nanny, etc. I was over the moon when I had my first baby. And two more followed. I love kids, and having my own has definitely been the highlight of my life. But when people ask about my greatest accomplishment, I never think of my kids. That's a separate thing. Having kids was just something I chose to do. It's not an accomplishment. Goals that I've set for myself, worked toward and achieved--those are accomplishments. And I have a list of those that have nothing to do with my being a mom.
What people don't understand is that everyone has different strengths and resources. So for some raising good kids is a piece of cake but getting an education and being resilient is difficult and for others it is the reverse. Your greatest accomplishment is the thing that was hardest for you
But how about following up with the partner with depression claims for not sharing the average point of view?
Load More Replies...Any cat, bug or jellyfish can produce offspring, FFS. Getting pregnant is NOT an accomplishment, and once you're beyond a certain point backing out of the "project" is all but impossible anyway (and having it go wrong is not a shame either). Raising your kids well IS one - but not in the same category as climbing a mountain or finishing a master's degree. Both of the latter are ambitious, *personal* goals and involve a lot of training, one way or another. The outcome of raising kids is not a single person's effort or accomplishment - there are other people involved, not least of them the children themselves.
NTA. First of all, just giving birth on its own doesn't achieve anything. It's hard to bear, but doesn't seem like hard to understand how to do. Second, your kids upbringing isn't finished yet, so calling it an accomplishment is out of date, to the early side, for ANY of you. Not because it wouldn't be something to be proud of if done considerably well, of course it is, but it just isn't time to call yet. You still could make it your greatest mistake, or, maybe that's worded better, it still could turn to be the greatest failing in your life, if you screw up from here on. Ok, not likely to happen, but ... the third reason I wouldn't want to call it so is that kids are persons, not just a result of your upbringing. Of course, they're that, too, but they also aren't in your complete control, and somewhat of themselves anyway. They're not trophies, but (growingly so) independent persons.
Nope. Absolutely NTA. I love my 3 kids to bits. They are AN accomplishment. They are not my GREATEST accomplishment. Raising offspring isn't and shouldn't be a noteworthy thing. Is it hard? Abso-effing-lutely! Does it take a huge chunk of your time and life? Yep! But so do so many other things. Having children IS rewarding. But it's not worth an award.
NTA - anyone can give birth. Parenting is harder, but most Americans don't seem to factor that in following BIRTH. Don't delete yourself for the sake of your offspring: teach them that they are valued, respected and should be capable of living up to their own decent values.
If she's a jerk for feeling attacked by a comment like that, then he's also a jerk for butting in and answering for her, and -he- was a jerk first. She didn't say anything rude out loud: those were just her thoughts at the time. All she told him was that she didn't want to be reduced to her female body, which is perfectly reasonable...
Nearly anyone can have kids, it's not exactly hard. Very few can climb Kili, never mind all her other achievements.
Good grief my kids fall about half way. They have grown into Good, kind, smart adults with their heads on tge right way. All I did was give birth and tried to teach them how to be adults - I did my job. My greatest accomplishments are other things that define me as the person I am. My kids are their own people creating their own greatest accomplishments
I overheard my dad told my mom that he didn't accomplish as a good father. I felt sorry for him. He shoulld not have felt he failed. He loved us and worked very hard to provide for his family. In my view my siblings and I are not to be his accomplishment. Our efforts and achievements depend on our own capabilities as adults.
It depends on the person. Everyone views their accomplishments as something different. Accomplishments are subjective.
Your children are the greatest accomplishments of the process of evolution, not yours. You did what you were biologically able to do. Hurra! You did not traumatize your offspring to the point of ruining their future lives. Hurra! Here's your medal. What nonsense. I guess most people have nothing noteworthy, nothing that isn't trivial to show for themselves, so they say that their children are their accomplishments. Personally, I see such people as failures, as people who never worked or strived, or accomplished anything that wasn't easy, necessary, and common.
Mom's feelings are totally valid. As long as the kids are taken care of and loved, who cares??
A woman of many achievements, the double Noble Prize winner Maria Curie had two children. We don't know whether she considered them her greatest accomplishment, but she positively glowed when she talked about them.
I logged in just to ask BP to stop with this AITA stupid stories from reddit and bring back non-political, non-ethical, non-private-people-arguments-I-don't-care-about artistic and creative stuff we sometimes years ago knew and loved. For several years now BP became everything but what it was before. I liked comics, illustrations, creative cakes and furniture, silly houses and rooms, arts, crafts... I hate political stuff here, I want to hide from it sometimes, I don't care about stupid private arguments people have, you're adults, deal with it, don't ask strangers for validation! Bring back old Bored Panda, I hate this!
My daughter is a massively important person in my life, I’m proud of who she has become and how she carries hereslf, however she’s not my greatest achievement, that reduces her to being a thing. My achievements are all focussed on what I have done personally, mountains I’ve conquered literally and metaphorically. She is the combination of many people, many experiences and she can claim her own mountains and I’ll happily stand by as one of her supporters. She can tell you what her greatest achievement is.
OP sounds so full of themselves it isn't even funny. News flash: no one else gives a shite about you climbing mountains. Good for you, now get over yourself. All you had to do was say "Well actually Tom, my greatest achievement is ...x,y,z..." but, instead you hop on your high horse and act superior. Like someone else said, not everyone has written a novel (and just because you've written a novel doesn't mean it's a GOOD novel. It's not actually that hard to get published these days." So why are YOU so offended that others see their children as their greatest achievement? Because it seems this whole thing is more of a reflection on YOUR insecurities and not Tom and Jen's.
Sounds to me like you are one of those people with zero accomplishments, who despite being terrible parents, claim parenting to be their biggest accomplishment.
Load More Replies...This is 100% a cultural and/or personal perspective thing. Read through all the comments and see the different perspectives. I don't think either of the people are wrong for having their own perspectives, but the way they're delivering them isn't right. OP clearly felt like like her other accomplishments in life were being invalidated, whereas other parents have gotten the "you were so good at XYZ before you were a parent" spiel, which is also invalidating. People need to be more sensitive when they approach these topics.
Sorry, but doing the same thing a cat or a dog can do is not an accomplishment. There is a reason there are no medals, or prizes, or the like for people who have had children. Furthermore, whether you have done a good job as a parent is not for you to decide, but for your child. There are plenty of people who claim to have raising children as an achievement while their adult children are in weekly therapy for childhood trauma.
Load More Replies...Seriously? This woman took a well-meaning compliment and turned it into an insult. Wtf is wrong with people. I doubt their reactions were as “smug” as she claims, and who could blame them if they were, given her unnecessary aggression and anger in this scenario. Does not sound like a happy person to me! While I wouldn’t define children as an “accomplishment”, they are a GIFT, the greatest one I could hope for. Some people are not so fortunate to have children. This lady should take a hard look at herself and her resentment because there is definitely bitterness there, but I have no idea why she can’t embrace both her past accomplishments and motherhood with grace and joy. Reducing motherhood to a basic “biological function” is just beyond ridiculous, it’s demeaning.
One of those women was Reddit-bullying her by reporting her to her husband for possible depression, which I am 100% certain she is not qualified to diagnose. Just because some people can't have children, it doesn't mean that having them is an accomplishment. Some people are paralyzed from the waist down. That doesn't make walking on your own two feet an accomplishment. That's just absurd. There was no compliment there. Only the demeaning of a woman and the erasure of her accomplishments in favour of her biological capability. "Giving birth" was literally mentioned. Without it, motherhood is no more special than fatherhood. And notice how the man in the story didn't claim fatherhood as his greatest accomplishment. It's OK if you have nothing to show for your life but birthing and raising children. But that's what the females of all mammal species do. They don't just birth them. They teach them what they need to survive as adults.
Load More Replies...


































27
92