Get Premium
Dark mode theme is available exclusively for premium users. Learn more about the benefits of subscribing.
No fees, cancel anytime.
Dark Mode 
No fees, cancel anytime 
then open in external browser
and click "Open in External Browser" 
2
Rich Grandparents Promise Grandchild Inheritance, But His Mom Doesn’t Like What She Has To Do For It
Inheriting a significant fortune is something that most people can only dream of. Generational wealth is life-changing, and the vast majority of parents don’t manage to leave anything behind for their children except heirlooms and a closet full of sweaters. But what if an inheritance comes with specific conditions? Is the money worth making a sacrifice for?
One mother was faced with a difficult choice when her son’s grandparents promised her child a hefty inheritance, as long as she changes his surname to match theirs. Before making any decisions, the mom reached out to the AITA community on Reddit seeking advice on her dilemma. So below, you’ll find the full story, as well as some of the replies invested readers left her.
RELATED:
Family members want what’s best for their smallest relatives. However, sometimes, they have very different opinions
Image credits: Mikhail Nilov (not the actual photo)
One mom shared how she’s considering not changing her son’s surname, however, that may come at the cost of him inheriting generational wealth
Image credits: cottonbro studio (not the actual photo)
Image credits: Pavel Danilyuk (not the actual photo)
Image credits: Pixabay (not the actual photo)
Image credits: alinabuphoto (not the actual photo)
Image credits: GeorgeMcMinty
The author felt conflicted about the situation and turned to the net for some advice
Image credits: Andrew Neel (not the actual photo)
The mom argued that money isn’t the only thing that matters and her own family seems to be doing fairly well financially. However, her primary concern seems to be the fact that her son would take the surname of a man “who didn’t want him, see him, or love him.”
Some of the people in the redditor’s social circle pointed out that she would be wrong to give up “this kind of money” for her son, which is why she turned to the AITA community in the first place. According to the mom, the question is best left for later, when her son is 16 and “old enough to understand the implications but young enough not to be tied professionally to his last name.”
The mom’s feelings are perfectly valid here. But so is the desire for financial stability. Many parents would leap at the chance to secure generational wealth for their child given the chance. And that’s the sentiment reigning in the AITA thread.
There were mixed reactions to the post. Many readers thought that u/GeorgeMcMinty would be a jerk if she passed on this opportunity. Not only that, this may lead to greater friction not just with the grandparents, but with her son as well, when he fully understands what she did on his behalf.
Some Reddit users phrased it spot on that the child’s grandparents appear to want a genuine relationship with him. So much so that they’re making him their primary heir. Others noted that it’s important to remember that the surname isn’t just the boy’s father’s, but his grandparents’, too. So the surname has a positive connotation, not just a negative one.
Meanwhile, other readers pointed out that the mom was right to teach her son that changing oneself for the sake of money doesn’t send the right message, and that nobody should have to get a new surname just for the sake of an inheritance.
Strong relationships tend to be far more important than money when it comes to happiness and health
Image credits: Jordan Whitt (not the actual photo)
At the end of the day, money is important in that it provides stability and opportunities, and also saves you time and energy. However, it isn’t the only factor that leads to happiness and isn’t the only measure of success. Your health, sense of purpose, and social connections all play huge roles. The latter is especially important and impacts your daily life.
An 85-year Harvard study unequivocally found that positive relationships keep people happier, healthier, and help them live longer. So it makes sense to develop and strengthen the relationships that you have in your life with the people you care about most.
And there are no real shortcuts here. At the core of any solid relationship lies a simple fact: people need to spend quality time together, regularly. Sometimes, physical distance or busy schedules get in the way. So carving out a few hours whenever you can is well worth it.
At the end of the day, a lot depends on your priorities. A lot of people say that family and friends are the most important thing in their lives… and then they continue prioritizing work, their hobbies, and other things. Deep social connections require practical commitments—namely, meeting up, physically, and being present.
You can’t fake interest in someone else because it’s very obvious when someone’s only making a superficial effort for show. When you do spend time with the people you care about, try to focus on them and them alone. That means not checking your phone every few minutes. That means actively listening to the other person so you can bond over shared activities.
And it’s only natural that we want to support and protect our nearest and dearest. Any grandparent worth their salt is going to want to provide their grandchildren with as much financial stability as they can. It’s just important to raise your kids to understand that it’s not money alone that makes life worth living.
The story received mixed reactions on the internet. Some people thought the mom was in the wrong
Others, however, believed that the grandparents could have approached things very differently
Poll Question
Total votes ·
Thanks! Check out the results:
Total votes ·
Newsletter
Subscribe to Access
Exclusive Polls
By entering your email and clicking Subscribe, you're agreeing to let us send you customized marketing messages about us and our advertising partners. You are also agreeing to our Privacy Policy.
Thank you! You've successfully subscribed to newsletters!
Explore more of these tags
What do you think ?
Dusty's mom 2 months ago
Hyphenate both last names. When your son gets old enough he can choose to keep it that way or decide otherwise. Don't think of it as honoring his father, but rather the grands who love him.
ॐBoyGanesh 2 months ago (edited)
Some parallels to my mom’s situation 50+ years ago. Met a guy on holiday in foreign country for both. He is Dutch, her parents are French-American & British-American. I was her holiday romance child. She notified my dad before I was born. My paternal grandparents came over for my birth. They wanted to be heavily involved in my life. I spent summers & holidays with them. They contributed to giving me a very secure future. They understood my father was an absentee, trust fund (not their choice) wanna-be playboy & it made sense I wouldn’t take his/their name. But they did ask if she’d consider hyphenating. She gladly agreed & wanted me to have an identity based on both families. This was at a time when hyphenated names were rare. Granted, I still would have had a relationship & an inheritance with my paternal family without their name. My mom respected they were my family no matter how involved my dad was.
Load More Replies...
Earonn - 2 months ago
It's not just the father's surname, it's also the grandparents' surname, who seem to love the child. Also, if the child shares her resentment of his father, he can change his surname later.
Angela C 2 months ago
If the grandparents actually loved their grandchild they wouldn't hold his inheritance hostage over his name
Load More Replies...
geraldrboyle@aol.com 2 months ago
The grandparents seem to be good and loving people. Dusty's mum's idea is brilliant. (Wish I was as clever as her.) "That which we call a rose would smell as sweet by any other name".
KatSaidWhat 2 months ago
Yeah, that didn't work out well for Romeo or Juliet...
Load More Replies...
Heffalump 2 months ago
I get where both parties are coming from, but if it was me, I'd change the kid's last name in a heartbeat, both for the financial advantages to him, but also out of kindness to the grandparents. They lost their only child, and even if he was a bit of a s**t, he was the kid's father. I can understand why it would mean a lot to them to see his child have his name. Let's face it, lot's of kid's with useless fathers still use his name, and for much less reason.
StrangeOne 2 months ago
I have some questions about the grandparents. Are they aware of the costs and hassles of changing a name? I get the sense OP has a more turbulent relationship with her child's grandparents than she's wanting to reveal. She needs to ask the hard questions, like why is changing her kid's last name that important? Why are they wanting to put her and her son through that hassle of changing his name, that would including having to change all his documents and relearning his name? This is a twisted ultimatum with money and parental guilt used as bait. I agree with OP. Her idea of letting her kid decide when he's older. They won't feel the same explaining their conditions to their grandson. The ball will be in his court when he's old enough to understand better and can make such decisions, but I would say wait until he's 18. I just feel there's a lot more going on here than money.
J R 2 months ago
This! People see to be framing it as this simple, easy decision, but it's not one the mom should have to make. I have a different last name than my maternal grandparents; I suspect many people do. They never treated me differently than my cousins who shared their last name. They never threatened to disinherit me or my siblings if we didn't change our last names. I have to wonder how many people who think this is a reasonable request would feel the same if it were a mom who walked out on her kid, paid child support, died, and them her parents asked the father to change his kid's last name to hers.
Load More Replies... K Barnes 2 months ago (edited)
Those who make offers with strings attached are often more likely to go back on the agreement or to add more strings, in my experience. If they love the grandchild they should want him to get an inheritance regardless of name. If she goes for the money I would make sure a lawyer locks it in for them. airtight I, personally, would not change my kid's name to that of grandparents who see them a few times a year (at best), but I don't idolize being rich the way some people do.
tori Ohno 2 months ago
The YTAs are unhinged again. From the verbage, they're somewhere in the UK. They don't need the name for the inheritance, they have the DNA test, that's all that's needed when the grandparents pass. Laws are different over there when it comes to that. It's the child's right to have that money.
Day Andie 2 months ago
First, there is not one d**n thing that would guarantee that those people could change their will at anytime afterwards and deny him the money if she does change the name. IF I did it, it would have to be done with an irrevocable trust that couldn't ever be changed. Second, ten to one changing the name would be the door that opens to let them get all up in her business about how she raises the kid, what he wears, where they live, where he goes to school, etc. Because they will want him to "better himself" to live up to that money. Third, if she changes the name and they have enough money, they could potentially argue she meant to give him to them and changed her mind, and and with money, they could win and take him away from her. Big money and power can do some weird s**t. If nothing else, it would make her life hell. Maybe they need a talk that when he's 21 he can make the decision for himself. Not until he's 21 and a real adult. A teen can't handle that kind of decision.
Uncle Panda 2 months ago
"What's more important, getting your way or getting what you want?" This often cuts through a lot of clutter.
J R 2 months ago
I think the mom's solution is the best idea. It's not selfish for a mom to want her child to share her last name, especially when the father only reluctantly paid child support. It is very selfish to try to pressure a parent into changing their child's last name. Lots of grandparents have grandchildren with different lasts names; the ones who aren't aholes don't have it make any difference in terms of inheritance.
Mark Childers 2 months ago
I don't have kids and don't want them, but I have to think that if I had a kid, I couldn't bring myself to keep him from generational wealth, especially from grandparents who love him.
Mike F 2 months ago
We read in post after post about how d@mned hard it is to make ones way in the world right now. I understand that she feels like she is selling out, but it certainly wouldn't hurt to look into the future a bit. For instance, she decides she's cool with the name change, the kid could study virtually anything he wanted to in college, then come out and perhaps do something that truly makes a difference without being concerned about how to make ends meet. Or, she follows through with her initial instincts and says thanks but no thanks, then the poor b@stard has to slog HIS way through life. H3ll, if they extended the offer to me I'd do it at my age, lol. I had to get a car yesterday and I'm gonna be one broke old boy for a while. All that aside, think of the kid and how he would never have to struggle for money for the rest of his life.
Jo Firth 2 months ago
I don't understand why the child would resent his dead father. Ultimately he paid support for his unplanned child and doesn't seem to have prevented his parents from helping out. The only way the child would resent his father is if his mother caused it by badmouthing him. Agree with the person who suggested a hyphenated name. Imagine how much he'd resent his mother if she turned down this offer and he ended up struggling for money.
Nils Skirnir 2 months ago
It’s very weird how women ‘get’ or ‘fall’ pregnant, but that men ‘impregnate’ them. It’s also great that she had to prove paternity. DNA tests should be mandatory in these cases.
Cee Cee 2 months ago
It's the inheritance that comes with conditions not the grandparents love.
Load More Replies...
Dusty's mom 2 months ago
Hyphenate both last names. When your son gets old enough he can choose to keep it that way or decide otherwise. Don't think of it as honoring his father, but rather the grands who love him.
ॐBoyGanesh 2 months ago (edited)
Some parallels to my mom’s situation 50+ years ago. Met a guy on holiday in foreign country for both. He is Dutch, her parents are French-American & British-American. I was her holiday romance child. She notified my dad before I was born. My paternal grandparents came over for my birth. They wanted to be heavily involved in my life. I spent summers & holidays with them. They contributed to giving me a very secure future. They understood my father was an absentee, trust fund (not their choice) wanna-be playboy & it made sense I wouldn’t take his/their name. But they did ask if she’d consider hyphenating. She gladly agreed & wanted me to have an identity based on both families. This was at a time when hyphenated names were rare. Granted, I still would have had a relationship & an inheritance with my paternal family without their name. My mom respected they were my family no matter how involved my dad was.
Load More Replies... Earonn - 2 months ago
It's not just the father's surname, it's also the grandparents' surname, who seem to love the child. Also, if the child shares her resentment of his father, he can change his surname later.
Angela C 2 months ago
If the grandparents actually loved their grandchild they wouldn't hold his inheritance hostage over his name
Load More Replies... geraldrboyle@aol.com 2 months ago
The grandparents seem to be good and loving people. Dusty's mum's idea is brilliant. (Wish I was as clever as her.) "That which we call a rose would smell as sweet by any other name".
KatSaidWhat 2 months ago
Yeah, that didn't work out well for Romeo or Juliet...
Load More Replies... Heffalump 2 months ago
I get where both parties are coming from, but if it was me, I'd change the kid's last name in a heartbeat, both for the financial advantages to him, but also out of kindness to the grandparents. They lost their only child, and even if he was a bit of a s**t, he was the kid's father. I can understand why it would mean a lot to them to see his child have his name. Let's face it, lot's of kid's with useless fathers still use his name, and for much less reason.
StrangeOne 2 months ago
I have some questions about the grandparents. Are they aware of the costs and hassles of changing a name? I get the sense OP has a more turbulent relationship with her child's grandparents than she's wanting to reveal. She needs to ask the hard questions, like why is changing her kid's last name that important? Why are they wanting to put her and her son through that hassle of changing his name, that would including having to change all his documents and relearning his name? This is a twisted ultimatum with money and parental guilt used as bait. I agree with OP. Her idea of letting her kid decide when he's older. They won't feel the same explaining their conditions to their grandson. The ball will be in his court when he's old enough to understand better and can make such decisions, but I would say wait until he's 18. I just feel there's a lot more going on here than money.
J R 2 months ago
This! People see to be framing it as this simple, easy decision, but it's not one the mom should have to make. I have a different last name than my maternal grandparents; I suspect many people do. They never treated me differently than my cousins who shared their last name. They never threatened to disinherit me or my siblings if we didn't change our last names. I have to wonder how many people who think this is a reasonable request would feel the same if it were a mom who walked out on her kid, paid child support, died, and them her parents asked the father to change his kid's last name to hers.
Load More Replies... K Barnes 2 months ago (edited)
Those who make offers with strings attached are often more likely to go back on the agreement or to add more strings, in my experience. If they love the grandchild they should want him to get an inheritance regardless of name. If she goes for the money I would make sure a lawyer locks it in for them. airtight I, personally, would not change my kid's name to that of grandparents who see them a few times a year (at best), but I don't idolize being rich the way some people do.
tori Ohno 2 months ago
The YTAs are unhinged again. From the verbage, they're somewhere in the UK. They don't need the name for the inheritance, they have the DNA test, that's all that's needed when the grandparents pass. Laws are different over there when it comes to that. It's the child's right to have that money.
Day Andie 2 months ago
First, there is not one d**n thing that would guarantee that those people could change their will at anytime afterwards and deny him the money if she does change the name. IF I did it, it would have to be done with an irrevocable trust that couldn't ever be changed. Second, ten to one changing the name would be the door that opens to let them get all up in her business about how she raises the kid, what he wears, where they live, where he goes to school, etc. Because they will want him to "better himself" to live up to that money. Third, if she changes the name and they have enough money, they could potentially argue she meant to give him to them and changed her mind, and and with money, they could win and take him away from her. Big money and power can do some weird s**t. If nothing else, it would make her life hell. Maybe they need a talk that when he's 21 he can make the decision for himself. Not until he's 21 and a real adult. A teen can't handle that kind of decision.
Uncle Panda 2 months ago
"What's more important, getting your way or getting what you want?" This often cuts through a lot of clutter.
J R 2 months ago
I think the mom's solution is the best idea. It's not selfish for a mom to want her child to share her last name, especially when the father only reluctantly paid child support. It is very selfish to try to pressure a parent into changing their child's last name. Lots of grandparents have grandchildren with different lasts names; the ones who aren't aholes don't have it make any difference in terms of inheritance.
Mark Childers 2 months ago
I don't have kids and don't want them, but I have to think that if I had a kid, I couldn't bring myself to keep him from generational wealth, especially from grandparents who love him.
Mike F 2 months ago
We read in post after post about how d@mned hard it is to make ones way in the world right now. I understand that she feels like she is selling out, but it certainly wouldn't hurt to look into the future a bit. For instance, she decides she's cool with the name change, the kid could study virtually anything he wanted to in college, then come out and perhaps do something that truly makes a difference without being concerned about how to make ends meet. Or, she follows through with her initial instincts and says thanks but no thanks, then the poor b@stard has to slog HIS way through life. H3ll, if they extended the offer to me I'd do it at my age, lol. I had to get a car yesterday and I'm gonna be one broke old boy for a while. All that aside, think of the kid and how he would never have to struggle for money for the rest of his life.
Jo Firth 2 months ago
I don't understand why the child would resent his dead father. Ultimately he paid support for his unplanned child and doesn't seem to have prevented his parents from helping out. The only way the child would resent his father is if his mother caused it by badmouthing him. Agree with the person who suggested a hyphenated name. Imagine how much he'd resent his mother if she turned down this offer and he ended up struggling for money.
Nils Skirnir 2 months ago
It’s very weird how women ‘get’ or ‘fall’ pregnant, but that men ‘impregnate’ them. It’s also great that she had to prove paternity. DNA tests should be mandatory in these cases.
Cee Cee 2 months ago
It's the inheritance that comes with conditions not the grandparents love.
Load More Replies... You May Like "He's Had This Name For A Decade?": Sister Wants To Name Her Son, Freaks Out Over Family Cat Man Expects Sympathy After Wife Bans All His Guests, Gets A Brutal Reality Check Instead Mom Shamelessly Dumps Kids On Parents, Acts Like Martyr Mommy Now That They’re Grown Up, Irks Them
Mantas Kačerauskas
Shelly Fourer
Denis Krotovas
Related on Bored Panda
13
29