Woman Is Stunned When A Random Person Teaches Her Child A Lesson About Hurting Animals
Children need role models and guidance—positive examples help them make good choices. So when Reddit user Shasta017 spotted a little boy misbehaving, they decided to correct him.
The kid was tricking wild geese into eating rocks while his mother was cheering for him. Concerned for the animals’ safety, Shasta017 intervened and put an end to it, but the child and his mother had such an emotional reaction that after the encounter, the Redditor began to question whether they had overreacted and made a post on r/AITAH, asking its members to weigh in on the situation.
We start learning how to interact with wildlife at a very young age and can make a lot of mistakes along the way
Image credits: RDNE Stock project / Pexels (not the actual photo)
So when this person noticed a boy doing something they probably shouldn’t, they stepped in
Image credits: Anna Shvets / Pexels (not the actual photo)
Image credits: shasta017
Image credits: Rüveyda / Pexels (not the actual photo)
Feeding birds raises ethical questions
Interestingly, it is not harmful for geese to swallow small rocks. On the contrary, it is a natural and necessary behavior for them. Geese, like many other birds, do it to aid in digestion. These stones collect in their digestive organs called gizzards, where they help grind down food since birds do not have teeth.
Interestingly, the issue in this particular scenario isn’t the rocks themselves but the peanut butter, which can be harmful to birds because it isn’t a part of their natural diet.
According to the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, feeding birds raises ethical questions and is widely considered a bad practice because teaching wild animals to associate humans with handouts can lead to serious problems.
Think “bad” bears at campsites and alligators stalking people. And the danger is not just to us. Supplemental feeding can cause digestive problems and alter normal behaviors.
When it comes to birds, the big three are disease, predation, and collision.
Drawing birds into close contact on shared surfaces makes it easy for them to spread bacteria like salmonella and E. coli, and luring them to the same place on a predictable schedule makes them more vulnerable to predators, like cats and hawks. Some birds may also accidentally smash into glass windows near feeding spots (though windows in tall buildings are greater collision hazards).
While throwing some crumbs might feel like a nice way to spend your time, bird numbers are down by almost one-third since 1970, so maybe it’s best not to add to these grim stats.
Later, the person behind the story clarified what kind of rocks were being used
Most people said they did the right thing
But some believe everyone could have handled the situation better
And some think the author of the post was in the wrong
Poll Question
Thanks! Check out the results:
Explore more of these tags
"She might not have known that eating rocks is bad for the geese" Mhm, sure. Maybe she should eat some rocks. Oh, she got sick? Sorry, didn't know. It's not like it's common sense that ANIMALS SHOULDN'T EAT STONE.
First off(of?) not normal behaviour and should not be allowed, and don't think peanuts are part of the list for healthy food for them? But (some?) birds do eat gravel, sand, and small(!) rocks to process the food in their Crop and Gizzard. But this sounds like large stones, and also they where tricked into eating them! 😠😡 There are smol stones to buy just for this reason, but the birds are not tricked into eating them, they eat them to process the food and at own will. And the size of the rocks are accoridng to the birds needs (like 1-2 mm or 2-4 mm depending on the need). I would probably would liked to to the same as OP in this situation.. https://www.quora.com/How-does-a-birds-digestive-system-work-when-they-consume-sand-gravel-or-solid-food-without-chewing-it-first
Load More Replies...I feel bad for the kid, to be honest. 5 years old, he does not know better. You could argue about he should know not to feed them rocks, but I'm willing to bet he did something innocent at first that got a laugh from the mother. The mother should have corrected the behavior, the bystander should have dealt with the mother not child.
Don't know why you got downvoted, it's a very reasonable assumption. Also, communication (in this case between OP and mother) might have gone a long way
Load More Replies...I know people like that. I once went to a farm excursion with my toddler and his kindergarten group. There was a set of brothers who would hold a goat by her horns (each boy holding one horn) and shake her head and the father would cheer them on for that "funny" idea. Later, I saw how the younger child took a hen up by her wings and he also didn't interfere. The poor boys have no chance to develop into decent adults with a parent like that...
I'm just so glad you were there. You saved a lot of geese from great suffering
The mom's the problem. A: allowing the kid to abuse animals. B: allowing a kid to get that close to Canadian geese. They are evil birds that bite, and the mom is a f*****g moron. A 5 year old is a stupid person and needs to be told but the mom laughing probably reinforced the behavior. She's the problem.
Even without stones...is peanut butter with salt innit really a good diet for geese?
They sell unsalted peanut butter in basically any place they sell salted peanut butter. You should find it on the same aisle, right next to the salted peanut butter.
Load More Replies...Just another parent who shouldn't have been allowed to breed. More of them than you'd think.
May a flock of geese with diarrhea fly over the mother
Load More Replies...100% this shouldn't have happened. It is true that a five-year-old may possibly not realize that feeding quarter sized stones covered in peanut butter is inappropriate. Maybe possibly they had seen birds eating pea gravel, (teeny tiny stones), maybe someone explained to them that some birds eat teeny tiny stones in order to help digest their food. It's possible that the kid wasn't being malicious and might have just possibly been ignorant. However, I have seen some shocking examples of what anyone would call future psychopathic abusive behavior in children that young, that you'd have to be some kind of moralless defense attorney to try to explain away as youthful ignorance. (Tearing wings off of butterflies, chopping worms in half, these are cruel acts that for some reason some kids seem to get a real kick out of.) Parent 100% should have corrected child. She thought it was funny? She's a f****** psycho raising a f****** psycho. Fantastic. That's just what this world needs more of
Or the mother. Then again, OP might have been charged with cruelty to animals.
Load More Replies..."She might not have known that eating rocks is bad for the geese" Mhm, sure. Maybe she should eat some rocks. Oh, she got sick? Sorry, didn't know. It's not like it's common sense that ANIMALS SHOULDN'T EAT STONE.
First off(of?) not normal behaviour and should not be allowed, and don't think peanuts are part of the list for healthy food for them? But (some?) birds do eat gravel, sand, and small(!) rocks to process the food in their Crop and Gizzard. But this sounds like large stones, and also they where tricked into eating them! 😠😡 There are smol stones to buy just for this reason, but the birds are not tricked into eating them, they eat them to process the food and at own will. And the size of the rocks are accoridng to the birds needs (like 1-2 mm or 2-4 mm depending on the need). I would probably would liked to to the same as OP in this situation.. https://www.quora.com/How-does-a-birds-digestive-system-work-when-they-consume-sand-gravel-or-solid-food-without-chewing-it-first
Load More Replies...I feel bad for the kid, to be honest. 5 years old, he does not know better. You could argue about he should know not to feed them rocks, but I'm willing to bet he did something innocent at first that got a laugh from the mother. The mother should have corrected the behavior, the bystander should have dealt with the mother not child.
Don't know why you got downvoted, it's a very reasonable assumption. Also, communication (in this case between OP and mother) might have gone a long way
Load More Replies...I know people like that. I once went to a farm excursion with my toddler and his kindergarten group. There was a set of brothers who would hold a goat by her horns (each boy holding one horn) and shake her head and the father would cheer them on for that "funny" idea. Later, I saw how the younger child took a hen up by her wings and he also didn't interfere. The poor boys have no chance to develop into decent adults with a parent like that...
I'm just so glad you were there. You saved a lot of geese from great suffering
The mom's the problem. A: allowing the kid to abuse animals. B: allowing a kid to get that close to Canadian geese. They are evil birds that bite, and the mom is a f*****g moron. A 5 year old is a stupid person and needs to be told but the mom laughing probably reinforced the behavior. She's the problem.
Even without stones...is peanut butter with salt innit really a good diet for geese?
They sell unsalted peanut butter in basically any place they sell salted peanut butter. You should find it on the same aisle, right next to the salted peanut butter.
Load More Replies...Just another parent who shouldn't have been allowed to breed. More of them than you'd think.
May a flock of geese with diarrhea fly over the mother
Load More Replies...100% this shouldn't have happened. It is true that a five-year-old may possibly not realize that feeding quarter sized stones covered in peanut butter is inappropriate. Maybe possibly they had seen birds eating pea gravel, (teeny tiny stones), maybe someone explained to them that some birds eat teeny tiny stones in order to help digest their food. It's possible that the kid wasn't being malicious and might have just possibly been ignorant. However, I have seen some shocking examples of what anyone would call future psychopathic abusive behavior in children that young, that you'd have to be some kind of moralless defense attorney to try to explain away as youthful ignorance. (Tearing wings off of butterflies, chopping worms in half, these are cruel acts that for some reason some kids seem to get a real kick out of.) Parent 100% should have corrected child. She thought it was funny? She's a f****** psycho raising a f****** psycho. Fantastic. That's just what this world needs more of
Or the mother. Then again, OP might have been charged with cruelty to animals.
Load More Replies...



































45
42