Person Goes To Celebrate Christmas With Fiancé’s Family For The First Time, Loses It After Getting 18 Pieces Of Coal As Gifts
Spending the holiday season with your significant other’s family for the first time can be daunting. The pressure to make a good impression and fit in with their traditions can be overwhelming.
However, Reddit user Virtual_Ad_3893 took the plunge and embraced the opportunity. Things were going great at first. They felt welcomed. The initial nervousness subsided and everyone was enjoying the festivities.
But that quickly changed when the Redditor started opening the presents. Turns out, their in-laws decided to play a “joke” on them. Unprompted. With no heads up. It was so bad that eventually, Virtual_Ad_3893 teared up and bailed.
Unsure about their reaction, the Redditor told the whole story to the platform’s ‘Am I the [Jerk]?‘ community, asking for their feedback. Continue scrolling to read it and tell us what you think about the ordeal in the comments.
This person, for the first time, chose to spend Christmas with their fiancé’s family instead of their own
Image credits: Kira auf der Heide (not the actual photo)
But started regretting their decision the moment they began unpacking their gifts
Image credits: eve lloyd (not the actual photo)
Image credits: MART PRODUCTION (not the actual photo)
Image credits: Virtual_Ad_3893
Part of the reason why navigating in-law relationships can be tricky is the fact that there is no rulebook for them. For example, it’s not entirely clear how close people should live to their in-laws, how often couples see them, and what responsibilities they might shoulder.
While the mother-in-law to daughter-in-law link is the most complex, virtually all in-law relationships come under tension as couples move through life together. The most frequent intra-familial flashpoints are religious celebrations and holidays. Occasions like Christmas are a major point of conflict because it’s where people are expected to be together.
Thrown together for an extended period of time, without sufficient room for autonomous behaviors, families come up against the phenomenon of ‘hypercopresence,’ which can happen with any interaction involving forced closeness – holiday gatherings included. Melanie Booth-Butterfield, a professor of communication studies at West Virginia University, US, who is writing a book on the topic, is certain that the negative effects can be long-lasting. “Hypercopresence can result in conflicts with relatives, angry words that cannot be taken back, and cold, rude nonverbal behaviors which leave lasting impressions,” she explains.
Additionally, holidays are when families carry out much-anticipated traditions and rituals, which research shows makes them feel closer and increases people’s enjoyment of these occasions. However, each family’s traditions might be different – and when in-laws diverge from our beloved rituals and traditions (or vice versa), tensions can flare.
However, judging from their post, the Redditor’s in-laws weren’t even trying. Gift-giving is a social ritual that requires careful thought and consideration. Whether a present is a home run or a fail depends less on cost, design, style, presentation, or practicality and more on the giver’s ability to listen, observe and empathize with the receiver.
“Gifts are an expression of feeling,” psychoanalyst Dr. Bonnie Buchele, who has heard her share of angst about gifts, both given and received, tells The New York Times. “So in the rush of the holidays — that panic of ‘Oh my God, I’ve got to get gifts’ — it is a good idea to take a little time to think about ‘What do I want to say here with this gift?’”
It sounds, like the Redditor behind this post was simply… ignored. And that hurts.
People unanimously said the author of the post was not being a jerk and their reaction was completely valid
Explore more of these tags
The only present that he got her was coal?? Her FIANCÉ. He didn’t even just not tell her about this, he gave. her. coal. I would not marry this man.
My father would have called it "checking her sense of humor". I call it for what it really is, seeing how much bullying they will take. My mother was miserable with his "humor" tests. I HATE bullies with a passion.
Test his humor. Blue m&ms and adult diapers.
Load More Replies...He should have warned her, it's not as if it was a pleasant surprise for her. That way she could have given all of them a piece of coal too as the 'newby' and let the fun and games commence!
Party of the hazing is the not warning her. He's totally complicit.
Load More Replies...Exactly as Deborah Harris2 says - then it might have actually been funny - everyone gets coal! But for them to accept her thoughtful gifts and not see the wrong in what they've done is bizarre and probably shows they don't have much emotional intelligence or empathy. I definitely wouldn't rush to marry into a family like that! And WTH is wrong with Dan, why is he buying her coal?? Surely he knows her well enough to choose a gift for her. This bit is mind boggling. I don't think this relationship can be saved at this point.
One piece of coal, one, would have been fine. I'd have found it quite funny if it happened to me. 18 pieces though, to sit there and have everyone watch 18 TIMES is actually pretty sick. Even if that was your twisted sense of humour wouldn't it get really boring after like the 3rd piece? A) The fiancé should have warned her B) he shouldn't have joined in C) he should have got her a real present - other than the gift of showing her his true colours.
Exactly! If the first gift is coal, then the 2nd gift better be Diamonds!!
Load More Replies...I would have picked up every single one of their presents I got them and taken them all back ( even if they had opened them) and handed them each a piece of the coal. I would have then laughed, wished them a merry effing Xmas, packed my bags and gone. She also needs to ditch the fiancé. If that is what his family thinks is funny, she will have bigger problems in the future.
Why not a tradition of $50 each for the newcomer, with a lovely card saying looking forward to getting to know you so I can disappoint you next year with a gift I pick out.
Now THAT would be hilarious and also make the newcomer feel great!
Load More Replies...This "tradition" really shows how uncomfortable this family is with welcoming new people and their attempt to gain control over the outsider. They are essentially saying if you want to be part of this family you have to put up with the way we treat you and if you stand up for yourself then we're going to gaslight you and beat you down again. They are showing who is in charge and who matters, and they are doing something like this so the new person will either cede control to the family or leave. Any truly loving family would not do this because they would realize how hurtful it is to give a new family member prank gifts like this on their first Christmas with them when that person is already feeling anxious about being welcomed into the family.
Aww, it's okay! With the nice new coal from your EFFING FIANCE, you can light things on fire and lob the flaming rocks at that pathetic excuse for a family's heads!
The only present that he got her was coal?? Her FIANCÉ. He didn’t even just not tell her about this, he gave. her. coal. I would not marry this man.
My father would have called it "checking her sense of humor". I call it for what it really is, seeing how much bullying they will take. My mother was miserable with his "humor" tests. I HATE bullies with a passion.
Test his humor. Blue m&ms and adult diapers.
Load More Replies...He should have warned her, it's not as if it was a pleasant surprise for her. That way she could have given all of them a piece of coal too as the 'newby' and let the fun and games commence!
Party of the hazing is the not warning her. He's totally complicit.
Load More Replies...Exactly as Deborah Harris2 says - then it might have actually been funny - everyone gets coal! But for them to accept her thoughtful gifts and not see the wrong in what they've done is bizarre and probably shows they don't have much emotional intelligence or empathy. I definitely wouldn't rush to marry into a family like that! And WTH is wrong with Dan, why is he buying her coal?? Surely he knows her well enough to choose a gift for her. This bit is mind boggling. I don't think this relationship can be saved at this point.
One piece of coal, one, would have been fine. I'd have found it quite funny if it happened to me. 18 pieces though, to sit there and have everyone watch 18 TIMES is actually pretty sick. Even if that was your twisted sense of humour wouldn't it get really boring after like the 3rd piece? A) The fiancé should have warned her B) he shouldn't have joined in C) he should have got her a real present - other than the gift of showing her his true colours.
Exactly! If the first gift is coal, then the 2nd gift better be Diamonds!!
Load More Replies...I would have picked up every single one of their presents I got them and taken them all back ( even if they had opened them) and handed them each a piece of the coal. I would have then laughed, wished them a merry effing Xmas, packed my bags and gone. She also needs to ditch the fiancé. If that is what his family thinks is funny, she will have bigger problems in the future.
Why not a tradition of $50 each for the newcomer, with a lovely card saying looking forward to getting to know you so I can disappoint you next year with a gift I pick out.
Now THAT would be hilarious and also make the newcomer feel great!
Load More Replies...This "tradition" really shows how uncomfortable this family is with welcoming new people and their attempt to gain control over the outsider. They are essentially saying if you want to be part of this family you have to put up with the way we treat you and if you stand up for yourself then we're going to gaslight you and beat you down again. They are showing who is in charge and who matters, and they are doing something like this so the new person will either cede control to the family or leave. Any truly loving family would not do this because they would realize how hurtful it is to give a new family member prank gifts like this on their first Christmas with them when that person is already feeling anxious about being welcomed into the family.
Aww, it's okay! With the nice new coal from your EFFING FIANCE, you can light things on fire and lob the flaming rocks at that pathetic excuse for a family's heads!








































125
103