“[Am I The Jerk] For Leaving A Party Because My Date Refused To Get Me Water?”

A good relationship is all about equal give and take. Both partners should care for each other, make an effort, and accept help from the other person. The moment things become one-sided, it can damage the couple’s bond and make one partner feel like they are doing too much.

This is what happened to a person whose date refused to get them a glass of water. The guy’s reasoning was that doing so would be very submissive. This obviously didn’t go down well with the poster, who wondered whether to continue the relationship ahead.

More info: Reddit

When a person lets their ego stand in the way of helping or looking after their loved one, it can begin to cause problems in the relationship

A joyful group of people celebrating indoors, some holding cameras, with raised arms, highlighting a vibrant social gathering.

Image credits: Matheus Bertelli / Pexels (not the actual photo)

The poster went with their date to his friend’s holiday party, brought wine to serve, helped people out by getting their drinks, and tried being as helpful as possible

Text about leaving a party due to a date refusing to get water.

Text recounting holiday party with friends and a date, mentioning preparing mulled wine and people serving drinks at the event.

Text about a date refusing to get water, with someone asking for help while blocked in on a couch.

Person in a yellow sweater pouring water into a glass at a kitchen sink.

Image credits: cottonbro studio / Pexels (not the actual photo)

During the party, the poster asked their date to get them a glass of water, but the man refused, stating that he had just sat down

Text about dating etiquette and refusal to get water, emphasizing basic acts of care.

Text excerpt about feeling drained, leaving a party, and declining a date's offer to walk out.

Text image about a conversation where someone jokes about surprise over not getting water.

Person leaving a wooden cabin on a sunny day, holding a handbag, with trees visible outside.

Image credits: Dương Nhân / Pexels (not the actual photo)

The author left the party midway because they felt bad at their date’s refusal to get them a glass of water, and later, when the couple discussed it, the guy became defensive

Text conversation about misunderstandings and attempting to resolve issues, reflecting themes of "date refuse getting water.

Text about refusing to get water, discussing perceptions of subservience and small acts of kindness.

Text discussing the handling of a situation and questioning disrespect, related to date refuse getting water scenario.

Image credits: Important-Pianist783

The man explained that getting a glass of water for his date felt “subservient” and that he’d only do it for someone who earned it by “being in the trenches with him”

The OP had gone out of their way to connect with their partner’s friends right from the beginning. From making mulled wine to serving people drinks and helping out at their party, it seems like acts of service are part of their love language and something that they value a lot from other people as well.

The idea behind love languages is that they can tell us how a person likes to give and receive love. Every person likes to get and give affection in different ways, and understanding what that means for your partner can help you show up in a better way for them. Unfortunately, even though the man knew his date valued small gestures, he still didn’t want to get them a glass of water.

To understand why someone would think in such a way, Bored Panda contacted Dr. Jodi Aman. She is a psychotherapist who shares trauma-informed mental health and relationship advice with educators, counselors, parents, and teens.

Dr. Jodi explained that the “man must have had some belief that if he did it once, the woman would start to control him. Someone in his past may have controlled him, or he may have seen this model in a way that led him to believe if he did it once, it would continue or go downhill from there.” 

“If he held this belief, he might have mistakenly seen this request as a threat to himself and not only refused but got angry and gaslighted her about making it,” she added. Though the man acted in this way, he couldn’t believe the OP had decided to leave his friend’s party early. In fact, he felt hurt that his date was leaving, but he didn’t recognize the pain he had caused through his actions.

Woman relaxing on couch, holding mug, reading a smartphone.

Image credits: Andrea Piacquadio / Pexels (not the actual photo)

The OP tried to bring up the issue with their date later on because it was still a topic of contention between them. The man then explained that he felt getting water for someone was subservient and that he would only do it if the other person had earned it. The way of viewing this simple gesture was very different for both people. 

One felt that it was a loving act of service, and the other saw it as a form of submissiveness. Sometimes in relationships, one partner might feel the need to be the dominant one and may not want to give away their power or control. This need often stems from insecurity and might come out in unconscious ways. 

Right now, the guy might refuse to get a glass of water for his date, but this type of behavior can also take more sinister forms. That’s why we asked Dr. Jodi what someone could do if they were in a relationship with a dominating person who refused to be kind or helpful.

She advised that one should “get out of it. If it is at the beginning, don’t get into it. If you are into it, build a community outside it because you will need that for confidence and support when you decide to leave finally.”

Although it might be a very small issue to fight over, the OP’s questioning of the behavior helped them see their date in a new light. Hopefully, they also realized that they deserve much better in a relationship.

What would you do in a situation like this, or has anyone ever done this to you? Let us know in the comments below.

Folks felt that the poster wasn’t overreacting and urged them to dump the man

Text post about ego and chauvinism relating to a date refusing to get water.

Text discussing a situation where a date refuses to get water, emphasizing kindness and connection in relationships.

Reddit comment discussing refusal, highlighting a "need to be guarded" comment and calling someone weird.

Text response discussing emotional manipulation and self-worth.

Comment describing refusal to get water, highlighting manipulation and narcissistic behavior in a relationship.

Comment discussing relationships and holiday party treats.

Text response discussing red flags about refusal to get water in a relationship context.

Comment discussing refusing to get water in relationships, emphasizing mutual care after 20 years of marriage.

Comment advising breakup over a refusal to get water, highlighting relationship issues.

Comment discussing relationship issues and validating feelings, related to refusing to get water.

Comment discussing relief after a confrontation, emphasizing self-awareness.

Poll Question

Total votes ·

Thanks! Check out the results:

Total votes ·

Newsletter

Subscribe to Access
Exclusive Polls

Subscribe

By entering your email and clicking Subscribe, you're agreeing to let us send you customized marketing messages about us and our advertising partners. You are also agreeing to our Privacy Policy.

Thank you! You've successfully subscribed to newsletters!

Anyone can write on Bored Panda. Start writing!

Follow Bored Panda on Google News!

Follow us on Flipboard.com/@boredpanda!