Get Premium
Dark mode theme is available exclusively for premium users. Learn more about the benefits of subscribing.
No fees, cancel anytime.
Dark Mode 
No fees, cancel anytime 
53 Things Strangers Said That Made Someone’s Fight-Or-Flight Activate On The Spot
Most interactions with strangers are fine. Forgettable, even. Someone holds a door, someone comments on the weather, someone lets you go ahead in the queue, and you both move on with your lives having made no impression on each other whatsoever.
But when a stranger says something that stops the entire interaction, you start replaying it on the drive home. You might even be thinking about it 3 years later. An online thread asked people to share the creepiest thing a stranger had ever said to them, and the results are chilling. Next time, you might be more aware of who is standing near you while you are waiting for a bus. You have been warned.
This post may include affiliate links.
#1
A random stranger told me "Your mom has been in a car accident and is on her way to the hospital, we need to go now."
It was true. He witnessed the accident, called the paramedics. He was trying to talk to her to make sure she was okay, and all she would say is"I have to go, I have to go pick my son up" and he volunteered to come get me. I was so shaken I never even got his
name. Thank you kind stranger.
RELATED:
#2
I got into a car accident last year, nothing horrific or bloody, but it was a 4 car pile up & my vehicle was totalled. Some random guy pulled over, came up to me & asked if I was hurt. I said I was shaken up, but fine. He said, are you sure you don't have any pain at all? I said my neck was a little sore, but I'm fine. The man then proceeded to grab my shoulder & put his hand on my neck & said I,"I have been given the power to cure pain with prayer, I can take your pain away". I said no thank you & backed up, but he didn't let go. Instead he gripped me harder & proceeded to pray AT me. I was already in an unsettled state & the guy seriously scared me, so I just stood still until he finished his 30 second prayer. When he was done, he asked," do you feel better, now? Do you still have pain?" I said of course I still have pain & I don't need any more of your help - Do not touch me again!
The guy moved on & approached the other 3 drivers with the same line. I was already upset & off kilter from the accident, but this guy made it 100 times worse by touching/grabbing me without consent & subjecting me to his self righteous ritual.
#3
I was working in retail and we were watching a particularly sketchy customer, to prevent her from shoplifting. She was older with grey hair, very strangely dressed. On her way out the door I said goodbye to her, while standing straight up (a mixture of professional and intimidating, if she was trying to steal) she turned to me and said:
"I had to stand like that in prison. I'm not a bad person though. We were sent there because we tried to stop a war."
Creepiness has been studied as a psychological phenomenon because it is too universal not to. A 2016 study by Francis McAndrew and Sara Koehnke at Knox College, one of the first empirical studies on the subject, found that creepiness is triggered when someone violates the unspoken rules of social interaction in ways that are ambiguous enough to prevent a clear response.
The brain detects that something is wrong but cannot classify it as an outright threat, leaving a sense of discomfort about whether to react or laugh it off. The stranger who says something deeply unsettling and then smiles normally is creepy precisely because the signals contradict each other, and the brain has no clean category for it.
#4
A little late to the party. But while staying at a hostel I let a crazy French woman read my chakra. She started off by telling me that I had a lot of pent up anger, but I had a good heart blah blah blah. Then she told me a lot of my anger was directed at a man with a mustache, and birds on his arm.
My grandfather and I don't get on. He's worn a mustache for the last 40 odd years. And he's got our countries national bird of prey tattooed on his upper arm.
Then she asked me if I was joining the military, before I could respond, she said "don't, if you do, you'll lose your life 4 years from today." I was planning on enlisting when I returned home.
She wrote down her name, and "4 years" on a piece of paper, which I keep in my wallet.
I'm still not sure if I believe her.
#5
I was walking around the city with my girlfriend at the time when a random, presumably homeless, man yelled out, "Hey young man. Hey young man young man. If you wrote a book, I would buy it."
Thanks, I think.
#6
Work at a hospital patient comes in for a broken arm. I go in to check up on her and she goes pss to me. I say yes she then whispers "how much do you think I could get if I sell one of my kidney's".
The same study found that the most universally creepy behaviors involve unpredictability, unusual patterns of eye contact, and comments that demonstrate an inappropriate level of knowledge or interest in another person. Standing too close, steering conversation toward personal details too quickly, and saying something that implies observation over time all register as threat signals. The body responds before the conscious mind has finished processing the interaction, which is why people often describe the feeling as arriving before they can explain it.
#8
Hi. The other day you gave me your phone number and told me to pick you up here. I think you're really pretty and I like your hair.
I just stared at him, mumbled something incoherent and practically ran off.
#9
I get stopped and asked for directions roughly once a week. No idea why, maybe my stature (5" and 100lbs) or the fact that I "walk with purpose". Whatever.
So I'm walking to class and I have this disheveled old man stop me, he's confused, he reeks, he obviously is on substances. He hands me a piece of paper, he needs to find this address.
It's my address exactly, down the the apartment number. This is in the city, with tons of apartments around and this guy needs to find MY address. We're a good 10 minute walk away.
Instantly I'm scared. Trying to not sound suspicious, I ask why this address? It's most likely residential, knowing the area we're in. Does he know someone there?
No, he says, I live there.
Panic sets in. No this guy does NOT live there. I tell him I don't know, doesn't sound familiar. I'm sorry, gotta get to class. He just kinda shuffles away. I mass-text my roommates, this creep totally had our address and was looking for the building.
Turns out, he did live there. In the apartment below me. The old people moved out and we had no idea, and he got the apartment number wrong.
Gavin de Becker, author of The Gift of Fear, spent decades studying predatory behavior and reached a conclusion that this thread echoes: the gut feeling that something is wrong is the brain processing information faster than language can keep up with. It is not you being irrational.
De Becker argues that the discomfort people feel and then talk themselves out of, "I am probably overreacting," "they probably meant nothing by it," is one of the most dangerous habits available. The feeling exists for a reason. The stranger who says something that makes every hair on your arms stand up has already communicated something, and your evolutionary skills are kicking in, so you better listen.
#10
Long ago when I was working in a pub as a waitress, I was taking out the trash when an old guy stopped me at the door and wanted to speak to me. This pub was operated by an elderly couple who had seen very interesting times during their younger days, and had a large group of elderly folks supporting their business, so I wasn't alarmed to have this stranger old man wanting to talk to me, since all the elderly folks do like me a lot. But I was taking out the trash and it was beginning to smell, so I was a tad impatient. This guy told me, "Girl what are you doing in a place like this. This is not the place for you, and you need to remember that, the next day someone is going to need to tell you her problems. Walk away. Let that moment pass. Go wash your hands, take out the trash, anything. Just let that moment pass." I looked at this new stranger face, and I replied, "okay sir you have my attention but I really need to take this trash out, but do tell me, what's your name? I'll get back to you immediately."
"You may call me Uncle Albert. Remember that you cannot stop yourself from helping others, but you can let that moment pass so that you don't hear what they need you to help."
I went out, came back, and Uncle Albert was gone. I asked around, and no one knows who he is, not even my bosses. The next day my classmate (who sabotaged my graduation work but I didn't know it was her) came by to talk to me. Suddenly I remembered what Uncle Albert said, and i told her I need to go to the washroom and I'll be back later. When I'm back, she's gone. A few years later, I then learned that it was her who sabotaged my work.
LakotaWolf (she/her) 1 hour ago
Oh...kay? But The classmate had already sabotaged OP's work? So what did fleeing her in that moment actually do?
#11
I have red hair, and the number of men who think it's totally cool to just come up and run their hands through my hair to "check if I'm a natural red head" or ask me if "everything is red" is pretty high.
Gross.
Gingersnap In Iowa 3 hours ago
I've never had anyone touch my hair but I have been asked if the carpet matched the drapes. 🙄
#12
Sitting on a train with my mate, old man sat behind us leans forward and says, "They're just little boxes, trains, aren't they? Won't be long before we're all in the littlest boxes of all."
The concept of 'stranger danger', introduced in public safety campaigns in the 1960s, is actually very misleading. According to research, the vast majority of harm done to people, particularly children, comes from people they already know rather than strangers. Shockingly, as much as 90%. The campaign created a fear of the unknown that in many cases redirected attention away from the more statistically significant risk.
#13
I was walking down the street on another country (I was on a Summer course) when a guy decided to join me and started to ask if I was single. I was so naive to tell him that yes I was because I thought I was supposed to be nice.
Anyway this guy started to ramble about how I shouldn't be and that I should also consider being a good wife and a mom. He invited me to a pub and in that moment I walked on another direction to a mall just in case this guy tried to kidnap me. Don't try to pick girls like this please.
#14
I was on a public elevator at Uni with other people and some idiot turned around and said "You're probably wondering why I gathered you all here".
#15
I was at a training for work and we have to sit at round tables with people we've never met before ("networking"). As an icebreaker, everybody wrote down a fun fact about themselves on a card and one person read the cards out loud and then we guessed whose fact belonged to who.
So this one guy who looked very much like he had always been male, wrote on his card, "I'm a real man". The girl reading the cards reads it aloud and he's the last one left so we've like...uhh yours? And he just sorta smirks in the creepiest way and doesn't even look up at the table. No idea what to make of that one. It was super bizarre.
Predatory conversation has identifiable patterns that researchers and behavioral analysts warn us about. Strategies include accelerated intimacy, pushing a conversation toward personal territory faster than the situation warrants, and testing compliance, making a slightly inappropriate comment to gauge whether the other person will object or go along with it.
De Becker calls the latter "forced teaming," where a stranger creates a false sense of shared experience or obligation. The comments that end up in threads like this one often have the structure of a test that the commenter did not realize they were being given.
#16
"I've really struggled learning to drive on the left side of the road."
Random American woman that picked me up hitch-hiking here in Australia (as she began veering toward the right lane).
#17
It was late night in the subway. An old weird looking guy was sitting infront of me and my friend.
-Hey, are you playing a game?
+Excuse me?
-Are you playing a game?
+Ehm, no.
-Imagine you're playing a game, can i play too?
+We are not playing a game.
-But am I able to manipulate your mind?
Can i influence you?
+No. You can't.
Im glad we had to leave the train at this point of conversation.
#18
I was walking home from work one night around 8:30-9. I was 16yrs old and a van pulled over and 4 older men in their 60s got out a split up, one walked directly up to me and asked "if you passed away tonight would you go to heaven or hell?"
I thought for sure this man was going to take my life on the spot until he handed me a brochure about a church and some Christian stuff. Still confused to this day why a group of Christian's were spreading Gods word at 9 at night.
The amygdala, the brain's threat detection center, processes social information faster than any conscious reasoning system and has been doing so for considerably longer than modern society has existed. It was calibrated in an environment where a misreading of another person's intentions could be fatal, which is why the response to a creepy stranger feels physical rather than intellectual.
Heart rate increases. Skin conductance changes. Attention narrows. The body prepares options before the brain decides whether they are needed, and this happens within milliseconds of the trigger, which in many of these stories was a single sentence.
#19
So there was an independent package delivery service dropping off a package for me, but the car was unmarked. I parked in my parking spot and went out to see what the person was doing and he said "Get in the car." And I was like "um what?" And then he looked at me seriously and was like "Get in the car." And I was about to have a panic attack and then he just started laughing and handed me my package.
Guys. I could have been kidnaped.
#20
Took a cab home from the airport. We were on a long stretch of road that passed a cemetery, which had really high walls surrounding it. He told me that his mother was buried there, and he visits her all the time. He said he liked how private it was, especially since the walls were so high. I'll never forget what he said next:
"Seriously, it's really peaceful in there. I could scream as loud as I wanted and nobody would hear me."
edit: grammar.
#21
a old women approached me and told me her dog can talk, tbh the dog look so creepy it almost had human eyes.
The bystander effect is all about witnesses who said nothing. Research by social psychologists John Darley and Bibb Latané, developed after the 1964 Kitty Genovese case, found that the presence of other people in a situation actually decreases the likelihood that any individual will intervene, because each person assumes someone else will act. The creepy stranger on a crowded train who says something disturbing to a single passenger is statistically less likely to be challenged than if the same thing happened with only one witness. The crowd provides cover in both directions.
#22
A lady drove past me as I was walking on the footpath, we locked eyes for a second.
She then chucked a U-turn, pulled up next to me and told me 'I can tell your special, god told me just then that he has plans for you.' I said 'cheers, catchya later.'
#24
Walking down the street with my girlfriend at the time, and we pass a house where a small girl, maybe 8 or 10 years old, is sitting outside on a fold up chair. It was creepy because she had this hollow look in her eyes, but they still followed our movement. Also she was alone with no toys or anything, so it was like she was just sitting there all spaced out. I assumed she was slow or something, and my girlfriend whispered to me, "creepy...". We pass the house, and keep walking. 5 seconds later we hear "I'm following you..." with that kind of childish inflection that is so terrifying. I turn around and of course it's that little girl.
The stories people carry from these encounters share a common feature beyond the obvious one: they are almost never resolved. The stranger said the thing and then walked away, or the bus stopped, and one of them got off, or the interaction ended before any kind of reckoning was possible.
The unresolved quality is part of what keeps them circulating in memory, because the brain treats unfinished threat assessments as open files. De Becker's advice for these situations is to trust the feeling, create distance, and do not spend energy trying to be polite about it. You officially have permission to walk away.
Have a stranger's words ever made your hair stand on end? Tell us about it in the comments!
#25
I was 13 and bringing trash to the dumpster after a church youth activity on a Wednesday night. As I get close to the dumpster a homeless man started to crawl out of the dumpster while yelling "people pass away every day".
#27
The woman who lived next door to my best friends had become senile over the years and just sat on her porch all day. When she was younger, she would have someone bring her groceries and he would come in through the basement door (basement door was on the ground floor, main door was up a bunch of stairs). As she got older she would tell kids - thinking it was the delivery boy - to come into her basement with a big grin on her face. I was 5.
My friends were cousins and lived in a duplex, one family upstairs, another downstairs. One day I was going up the stairs and there was a window facing her home. I happened to glance out the window and she was sitting inside (the first time I had ever seen that) staring into the window I had been walking by. I mean intensely, no smile, no facial expression at all. 5 year old me ran up the stairs faster than 30 year old me ever could.
#28
Ok aside from all the invasive street harassment comments, I'd have to say the creepiest yet totally innocent thing was said to me by a shopkeeper in Syria.
We were walking in a street behind the main market area, and all of these little shops and stalls etc are set up and people would call out and try to get you to check out their stuff. This older man was sitting on a stool outside of a tent, which looked like it had some nice rugs or something inside. He sees us foreigners walking by and yells out in English: "We can make pleasure to your eyes inside!!!"
Needless to say...we did not go into his tent.
#29
A stranger farted loudly while maintaining eye contact with me. I've never felt so intimidated in my life.
#30
When I rode the bus. One night as I got off. A Mexican lady stood up, pointed at me, and screamed "EL DIABLO!!!" Never ran so fast in my entire life.
#31
Not me, but my parents. We had a party with the extended family and there was this old woman who told our families fortune.
She said my mom had been cursed by my grandmother(which grandma later admitted to) and would always struggle in life. She was told not to cut her hair because that's where her strength came from.
She said my dad would be rich, but never truly happy.
And for me, she said "watch him and be careful with his mind."
I'm not really one for psychics, but it still creeps me out.
#32
I was at work, standing at the checkout, when a customer came. I rang him up, he took two steps before stopping. Then he turned to me, looked me in the eyes and said "God loves you" with a calm, almost cold voice... that was so creepy.
#34
A guy at a gas station came over to me as I filled up my car and started pestering with questions about where I was going. I lied and said “I’m going to meet my friends, they are waiting for me” and he asked “can I come with you” and I said “no no it’s closed invite haha” and he said “that’s okay, I’ll wait for you to leave and then I will follow you…” I hid inside the store til he left.
#35
One grandma grabbed my hand and put it on her forehead and said "your the one" WHAT DOES THAT MEAN.
#36
I guy grabbed me at a park when I was like 10 and kept screaming “you’re my daughter you’re my daughter, why did you leave?!” His daughter had passed away along time ago and I apparently looked like her.
#37
bro when i was 12 i was home alone and someone knocked on our front door i looked through the peephole and saw a man i didnt recognize so i js ignored him a few mins later my phone got a msg from an unknown number that said “why did u look at me through the door and not open it” i froze bro then another msg came in saying “its okay ill wait until ur alone again” i called my mom crying and she told me to hide in my room till she got home the creepiest part?? when she checked the security camera later the man had been standing outside our house for almost 40 mins before he even knocked, the police came and checked the cameras but they couldnt identify him and a few days later we got another msg from the same number saying “tell ur mom to stop looking for me” and we literally moved houses a few months later.
#38
I was at a McDonald's drive through late at night and the dude said "enjoy the mayonnaise" I didn't end up eating.
#39
"You are standing on an unalive body." Was in a very crowded local train in Mumbai, India and a guy just passed away and his body was on the floor. I didn't notice him and had to stand on him for 2.5 minutes until I jumped off at the next station.
#41
I was walking to see a friend a couple of years ago, when an old lady came up to me and said she wanted to read out of my hand. I don't believe in that kind of stuff so I just said "No thanks" and walked on. While passing her I could hear her say "Oh stop! I can tell you about your great love, an older man!"
Today I am happily engaged to a man who is ten years older than me.
#42
I used to work at Wal-Mart in a city about 4-5 hours away from the city where I was born and raised until 6. We left that city after my father passed away.
I was ringing people up, wasn't really paying attention until the next guy stopped putting stuff on the counter. I looked up and he was pale as hell.
He says "I just saw a ghost of a man I once knew. Is (my father's first and last name) your father?" I was kind of scared, being so far from a place where people could have recognized me. I told him my father had passed away a long time ago, and he didn't know. Probably not that creepy to some, but it shocked me.
#43
not exactly a stranger; rather my cell phone. i sent a text yesterday then put my phone in my pocket without locking it. when i pulled my phone back out it was still on the same text thread and in the line where i would typically type, it just said 'i see you'.
#44
Standing in a parking lot of a nearby business complex at 2 AM smoking a cigarette with two friends. We were approached by a strange man walking through, probably 35-40. He told us he didn't know if he wanted to live or not and that his whole life was messed up. He didn't elaborate when we tried to console him, and then he walked off. I checked local police reports and found nothing. Still wonder/worry about that dude.
#45
I was about to go into the bank forgetting it would be locked due to the it being the weekend. I went to go swipe my debit card to open the door and I didn't see it but there was a man using the ATM. I thanked him and said "I didn't even see you there!", he just replied with "Good." I'm not sure what he meant but it definitely creeped me out. He just said it so matter of factly and then walked out directly after.
#46
not that creepy but when i was in the psych ward, one of the more psychotic patients walked up to me outside (i was alone) and started asking me questions about me being possessed by the devil? then a few hours later i got an epileptic seizure and he went like full on nuts because ofc he thought i was completely possesed and the he get sent to the closed ward.
#47
so I was at SeaWorld and I was going on the ride mantas if you don't know is a upside-down and I was scared so I was like I am going to lose my life the worker said one day you will.
#48
The creepiest thing a stranger ever told me happened when I was walking home late one evening. An old man sitting outside a small shop suddenly called me by my name. I had never seen him before, so I stopped and asked him how he knew me. He smiled and said, “Your mother still leaves the hallway light on for you, doesn't she?” I laughed nervously and asked him how he knew that. He ignored my question and said, “When you were little, you used to cry every night because you could hear someone walking around your room after everyone had gone to sleep.” My smile disappeared because that was actually something I remembered from childhood, but I had never told anyone about it. I asked him who he was, and he stood up slowly, looked me straight in the eyes, and said, “I'm sorry I couldn't protect you back then.” I immediately walked away without saying another word. When I got home, I asked my mother if she remembered anything strange about our old house. She went completely silent. Then she asked me, “Who told you about the man who used to stand beside your bed when you were sleeping?” I told her about the stranger, and she started crying. She said that when I was four years old, I used to describe an old man who stood in the corner of my room every night. But the part that still scares me to this day is what my mother told me next. She showed me an old family photograph and pointed at a man standing in the background. It was the exact same stranger I had met that evening. Then she whispered, “That's your grandfather. He passed away three years before you were born.”
#49
When I was 16 I worked at a breakfast restaurant. We had this "usual" customer. He was an older man, maybe 60s, white hair, and wore a cowboy hat. He couldn't speak, my coworkers told me it was due to his diabetes that he lost the ability to speak or something like that. Anyways, he came in once a week and we gave him the same thing every time, blueberry pancakes, sugar free syrup, and black coffee. He never had to order it, we were all just trained to give this guy the same stuff every time he came. Again, the dude NEVER talked. Not once.
Anyways, one Monday morning I was waitressing alone and he came in. When it came time to pay, he looked me in the eyes and said "I gotta tell you, the fun is over".
I just smiled and booked it into the kitchen and waited for him to leave - the chef and I were the only people there besides the pancake cowboy.
#53
One time a random guy threatened me and accused him of stealing his watch and he beat me up and he got sentenced to life imprisonment.
LakotaWolf (she/her) 1 hour ago
With the way most justice systems work today, no way in hell did someone get sentenced to life just for beating someone up.
What do you think ?
Richard Graham 3 hours ago
I had a man approach me and say, in a gutteral voice, "You look like Son of Sam."
Richard Graham 3 hours ago
I had a man approach me and say, in a gutteral voice, "You look like Son of Sam."
Related on Bored Panda
