Guy Fakes Proposal While Joking Around With GF, Confused As She Says ‘Yes’ With Tears In Her Eyes

What would you do if you accidentally proposed to your partner? Well, they do say romance can bloom anywhere, but apparently that includes the plumbing aisle of a home improvement store.

Some people choreograph dances for their proposals, others write poems, and then there are those who wing it with a prayer and a prop. Whether it’s under the Eiffel Tower or in a fast-food parking lot, the moment you drop to one knee, you’d better mean it.

One Redditor didn’t expect a practical joke to land him accidentally engaged when he pretended to propose to his girlfriend with a washer ring.

More info: Reddit

Fake proposals are like prank texts to your boss—sent in seconds, but regretted for a long time

Car parked outside The Home Depot on a clear day, relating to boyfriend fakes a proposal SEO concept.

Image credits: Julia A. Keirns / Unsplash (not the actual photo)

One guy accidentally gets engaged after his girlfriend says yes, seriously, to a fake proposal he makes while role-playing

Couple jokingly roleplaying proposal at Home Depot leads to unexpected serious yes, causing boyfriend to fear telling the truth.

Couple joking about a fake proposal, with the girlfriend saying yes seriously, leaving the boyfriend scared to tell the truth.

Text on white background showing a woman laughing and saying a comment about a proposal while joking with her boyfriend.

Woman in casual clothes shopping for kitchenware, looking thoughtfully at stainless steel pots and pans on display.

Image credits: prostooleh / Freepik (not the actual photo)

The man and his girlfriend are out shopping at Home Depot when they start pretending to be “boring suburban homeowners”

Text on a white background showing a boyfriend jokingly proposing with a washer ring and asking will you marry me.

Text excerpt showing a boyfriend jokingly faking a proposal while the girlfriend seriously says yes, creating tension.

Text quote saying I froze I panicked I was not proposing I was pretending, relating to fake proposal and scared to tell truth.

Man playfully proposing on one knee while girlfriend reacts with surprise in front of rustic red barn doors

Image credits: Mason Hassoun / Unsplash (not the actual photo)

The man jokes about getting married, telling his girlfriend he wants to build a life with her

Text image with a message about a fake proposal joke turning serious and the couple now engaged.

Man nervously reflecting with text overlay saying he hasn't told girlfriend the fake proposal wasn't real.

Couple at Home Depot where boyfriend fakes a proposal as a joke, and girlfriend says yes seriously, causing fear to reveal truth.

Image credits:WallInternational103

The man fakes a proposal while role-playing with his girlfriend, but ends up engaged when she takes him seriously and actually says yes

The OP (original poster), was out picking shower heads with his girlfriend, like any other slightly bored couple on a Saturday. The fluorescent lights, the faint smell of lumber, and the occasional intercom announcement about a rogue forklift created the perfect setting for jokes, banter, and a little flirting in aisle 9.

In the middle of a role-play game, pretending to be a suburban couple with 2 golden retrievers and a mortgage, the OP cracked a cheesy line about building a life together and maybe tiling a backsplash someday, like on an HGTV show. His girlfriend chuckled and teased that it almost sounded like a proposal. That’s when the OP made The Mistake.

In true chaotic romantic fashion, he dropped to one knee in the plumbing aisle, holding a washer ring, and said, “Will you marry me, babe?” Harmless, right? Wrong. Because she actually believed him and said yes. Not haha-yes. Not giggly yes. No, she said it with full misty eyes, a trembling voice, and all the emotional weight of a rom-com.

The dude froze—this wasn’t part of the bit anymore. This was the bit becoming real life. And instead of clearing the air, what did he do? He went with it. And just like that, boom, he’s engaged. There’s a group chat, families know, and there might be Pinterest boards involved. All because of a joke that went a little too far in the plumbing section of Home Depot.

Young man sitting with hands on head, looking distressed after joking proposal was taken seriously by girlfriend.

Image credits: MART PRODUCTION / Pexels (not the actual photo)

But before you judge him for not fessing up, let’s take a moment to appreciate the panic paralysis that happens when a harmless joke turns into a life-altering commitment. Panic (or anxiety) paralysis is basically your brain going “ummm…” in the most inconvenient way possible. It’s a freeze response triggered by intense stress or surprise—think deer-in-headlights, but make it emotional.

The pros say it happens when the amygdala (the brain’s panic button) hijacks your rational thinking, leaving you momentarily stuck. It’s especially common in emotionally loaded situations where stakes feel high and pressure is sudden, like, say… accidentally proposing while shopping.

So, let’s give this guy a break. Proposals are high-stakes pressure cookers. Some people pop the question on a mountain, others in a candlelit restaurant. And some, well, they accidentally propose with plumbing supplies. But a memorable proposal doesn’t need to involve drones, flash mobs, or plumbing tools—just a little planning and a lot of heart.

The best proposals are personal—think a shared hobby, an inside joke, or a place that means something to you both. Keep the moment focused on your connection, not the spectacle. Whether it’s under the stars or over brunch, make sure your partner is in a good mood, maybe not hangry, and definitely not in gym clothes (unless that’s your vibe).

And yes, proposals matter—they’re a big milestone that kicks off your engagement story. So maybe skip the washer ring, unless you’re very sure she’s into hardware store chic.

What would you do if you were in the poster’s shoes? Would you confess immediately or wait until the wedding day to decide what to do? Drop your thoughts and comments below!

Netizens had a field day with this story, suggesting the man tell the truth about not wanting to get married before it’s too late

Text message from user catchemist117 advising to quickly remove a bandaid to avoid prolonged pain or discomfort.

Text post about a boyfriend jokingly proposing to his girlfriend, who seriously accepts, causing fear to reveal the truth.

Comment about boyfriend faking a proposal while joking with girlfriend, leading to serious reaction and unexpected consequences.

Screenshot of a Reddit comment sharing a story about a fake proposal leading to an unexpected engagement.

Comment on a post saying Now is the time to ask yourself if you want to get married or not about a boyfriend faking a proposal while joking with his girlfriend.

Man jokingly pretends to propose to girlfriend, she seriously says yes, leaving him scared to tell the truth.

A boyfriend jokingly fakes a proposal to his girlfriend who seriously says yes, leaving him scared to reveal the truth.

Comment warning boyfriend who faked proposal and now scared to tell the truth before she or family commits to plans.

Comment suggesting two options after a boyfriend fakes a proposal and the girlfriend says yes, leaving him scared to tell truth.

Comment text on social platform about a boyfriend jokingly proposing and the girlfriend seriously saying yes.

Text post describing a boyfriend jokingly proposing to his girlfriend while camping, and she seriously said yes.

Screenshot of a Reddit comment saying "Yeah maybe don't tell her that, like ever" about a fake proposal prank.

Poll Question

Total votes ·

Thanks! Check out the results:

Total votes ·

Newsletter

Subscribe to Access
Exclusive Polls

Subscribe

By entering your email and clicking Subscribe, you're agreeing to let us send you customized marketing messages about us and our advertising partners. You are also agreeing to our Privacy Policy.

Thank you! You've successfully subscribed to newsletters!

Anyone can write on Bored Panda. Start writing!

Follow Bored Panda on Google News!

Follow us on Flipboard.com/@boredpanda!