European Is Shocked To Learn How American Suburbs Work, Goes Online To Ask Some Accurate Questions
Ah, the great American suburbs. Nothing better than being confined to a neighborhood where all the houses look exactly the same, and the closest stores are 2 miles away. (And don’t forget that you have to drive to them because there are no sidewalks or bike lanes…) While I have never experienced living in a suburb myself, I’ve visited the cookie cutter communities many times. However, for many people outside of the United States, the concept of suburbs can be mind boggling.
Last week, a suburb discussion was sparked on Twitter after a Slovakian Reddit user watched a video about these confusing American neighborhoods then reached out to the Urban Planning subreddit to get some answers. Below, you can read the questions that were raised about US suburbs, as well as some responses to the queries from other Twitter users. Then we’d love to hear your thoughts in the comments down below: have you ever lived in an American suburb or are they a bizarre foreign concept to you too?
This urban planner sparked an interesting discussion on Twitter after finding the following questions about American suburbs posed by a confused Slovakian on Reddit
Image credits: LUrbaniste
Image credits: LUrbaniste
Image credits: LUrbaniste
Image credits: LUrbaniste
Image credits: LUrbaniste
ADVERTISEMENTWhile versions of suburbs do exist in many countries, the United States is unique in the layout of its suburbs and how much of the nation resides in them. According to the Pew Research Center, as of 2018, 55% of Americans lived in the suburbs. They’re not all the same across the country, though. Politically, the suburbs are evenly divided overall, with certain areas leaning more Democratic or Republican. In New England, for example, 57% of suburbanites tend to vote left. Meanwhile, in the East South Central region (including Alabama, Mississippi, Kentucky and Tennessee) 56% of voters identify as Republicans. The suburbs are also growing, particularly with older Americans. The 65-and-older population in the suburbs has increased 39% since 2000.
Though they may be famous for their perfectly manicured lawns, the suburbs are not all white picket fences and smiles. In 2016, suburban communities were found to have the highest “drug overdose fatality rate of any community type” in the US. And about one third of all suburbanites report that drug addiction is a major issue in their communities. One reason for the prevalence of addiction in suburbs may be the isolation people often feel being surrounded by almost nothing but other homes. Being bored is another factor that can lead to people experimenting with drugs, especially youths. Dr. Keith Humphreys, professor of psychiatry at Stanford University’s School of Medicine, told Modern Healthcare that although people living in suburbs often have better resources available to treat addiction, with most people in these communities being “more educated, [having] better jobs and [living] closer to more healthcare professionals than rural people”, the stigma around addiction can still be powerful. “If they believe that addiction ‘can’t happen here’, they will neglect to screen their patients for substance use as they should and respond appropriately to addiction when they detect it.”
American suburbs are a strange and fascinating concept. While they’re not a monolith, many of them do seem like inefficient uses of space and resources. Perhaps, over time, urban planners can learn a thing or two from countries like Slovakia and shift communities away from being so car dependent and focus more on quality of life. Let us know in the comments what your neighborhood is like in your country and if you think you could ever live in an American suburb!
Many Twitter users have responded agreeing with the absurdity of these suburbs and comparing the US to other countries
Image credits: postingtwink
Image credits: LRoordaLaw
ADVERTISEMENTImage credits: TapirDNB
Image credits: Kyberian
Image credits: hughjanos13
Image credits: nextdoorsv
ADVERTISEMENTImage credits: TawnosMTG
Image credits: voidcrittermon
Image credits: CobbleEnd
Image credits: Basinke
ADVERTISEMENTImage credits: BenRossTransit
Image credits: sojapojke
Image credits: pawelabrams
Image credits: Masterfrogg
ADVERTISEMENTImage credits: azzageddi
Image credits: ronheck
Image credits: gallerychapel
Image credits: Omnibuscc
ADVERTISEMENTImage credits: idreamAmsterdam
Image credits: lizlovesmusic
Image credits: BDesco
Image credits: Mario_Vilas
ADVERTISEMENTImage credits: Chando_Bear
Image credits: _neelc
Image credits: Metr0xX
Image credits: LJTLatham
ADVERTISEMENTAnyone can write on Bored Panda. Start writing!
Follow Bored Panda on Google News!
Follow us on Flipboard.com/@boredpanda!
Howdy, I'm Adelaide! I'm originally from Texas, but after graduating from university with an acting degree, I relocated to sunny Los Angeles for a while. I then got a serious bite from the travel bug and found myself moving to Sweden and England before settling in Lithuania about three years ago. I'm passionate about animal welfare, sustainability and eating delicious food. But as you can see, I cover a wide range of topics including drama, internet trends and hilarious memes. I can easily be won over with a Seinfeld reference, vegan pastry or glass of fresh cold brew. And during my free time, I can usually be seen strolling through a park, playing tennis or baking something tasty.
Read less »
Adelaide May Ross
Writer, BoredPanda staff
Howdy, I'm Adelaide! I'm originally from Texas, but after graduating from university with an acting degree, I relocated to sunny Los Angeles for a while. I then got a serious bite from the travel bug and found myself moving to Sweden and England before settling in Lithuania about three years ago. I'm passionate about animal welfare, sustainability and eating delicious food. But as you can see, I cover a wide range of topics including drama, internet trends and hilarious memes. I can easily be won over with a Seinfeld reference, vegan pastry or glass of fresh cold brew. And during my free time, I can usually be seen strolling through a park, playing tennis or baking something tasty.
Read more »
Kotryna is a Photo Editor at Bored Panda with a BA in Graphic Design. Before Bored Panda, she worked as a freelance graphic designer and illiustrator. When not editing, she enjoys working with clay, drawing, playing board games and drinking good tea.
Read less »
Kotryna Br
Author, BoredPanda staff
Kotryna is a Photo Editor at Bored Panda with a BA in Graphic Design. Before Bored Panda, she worked as a freelance graphic designer and illiustrator. When not editing, she enjoys working with clay, drawing, playing board games and drinking good tea.
HOAs are Karen breeding grounds. I'd never live in an area with one if there was any other choice.
First rule of house hunting to our realtor was do NOT show us ANY homes with an HOA!
Load More Replies...This comment is hidden. Click here to view.
A dozen drive thrus of the ghetto with the windows rolled up and doors locked, gingerly stepping over broken paving and urine puddles, and you were skipping up to the gates of a secured community like Dorothy and Toto
Karen breeding grounds! I love it! It's a prerequisite for each block to have a karen to keep things lively. This is why I live in New Hampshire in a rural area. 5 + acres, flower gardens, deer in the back yard. Lawns prevent soil erosion.
Not really, it’s more like “people need to keep up their homes and not let them get dilapidated over time”. When people let their homes go (ie: not keep up with maintenance issues, let the outside paint peel and look disgusting, not keep their yards clean and free from non-running project cars up on blocks, etc.) it brings the neighborhood home values down. NO ONE WANTS TO LIVE NEXT/NEAR A HOME THAT LOOKS LIKE A JUNK YARD! A home will be the most valuable thing you’ll purchase in your lifetime (for most people) and I’m sure you don’t want to loose money when you go to sell your home.
My first house had an HOA. Bought the house because of the price. Hated the HOA. Next house, no HOA. And guess what all my neighbors keep neat lawns and do their maintenance without an HOA. HOAs are horrible. The people who run them are control freaks.
Our current house is around 70 years old and the other house is being built on vacant land less than a quarter mile from Lake Erie. No developments, no HOA's.
I tried finding a place with no HOA when I moved. There wasn't one. Every frickin neighborhood.
But not every house. I bought a house in a HOA neighborhood that was specifically excluded from the HOA, so no fees, no rules, etc. It's also twice the size of the other houses, and the land alone accounts for about 25% of the entire community.
Some hoas aren't as strict as others. We pay $350/year and it covers community lawn maintenance. But we all get together twice a year to clean/pretty up the front entrance area. But we do have Karen's and kens who like to stir up trouble 😵💫
It depends on the style of hoa. For instance our takes care of all the yard work, security and the pools and walking paths. There are no arbitrary landscaping rules because its all covered by the hoa itself.
No it doesn't though, all it takes is for a few controlling neighbors to tke over the board and your toast. Next thing you know, some jerk is measuring your grass, sending you notices that the Christmas lights you put up are too "colorful" and another one demanding you park your car in the garage at night under penalty of a fine if you dont. Ask me how I know. I moved into one that had 2 requirements, keep the yard clean and house in good condition. When I sold my house, there was a booklet of what was "allowed", "not allowed" and ANY alteration needed to be approved by the board.
I feel sorry for you. That kind of overlord control should be illegal. HOAs should NOT be able to fine anyone as if they were the police. What's stopping them from going further? Americans, of all people, should understand the consequences of when we give up our rights to anyone.
That's called a lien. Anyone you owe money to can sue you and if you don't pay the judge will force the sale of your home to pay what you owe. That's not an HOA-specific thing.
We had a condo homeowner not pay her dues for over 2 years with the the old homeowners board, they let the homeowner not pay and they ended up getting their unpaid dues up to $14,000 (they were fined for not paying after 150 days), while all the other 107 homeowners were paying their dues on time each month. The dues are to help maintain the overall esthetic of our complex: landscaping, asphalt resurfacing, repainting of strips and numbered/guest spots, gutter cleaning, etc.
A few bad apple always will ruin a good pie… that’s what happens when you live in a free-for-all neighborhood and there’s not a structured guideline to help homeowners the keep their homes kept up. It’s not taking the rights to freedom away, it’s keeping the neighborhood looking respectable and inviting to enter.
Many people move into landscape controlled hoas for the one reason that they hate doing yard work. I personally would love to never mow my yard again and thats why im in an hoa like this. But plenty of people like the outdoors and dont understand this mindset. Both ways are fine, the main problems arise from people who join an hoa sign the contract then try to ignore the legally binding rules they signed no matter how dumb they think they are. A signed contract is a signed contract.
You can pay for lawn service without signing your life over so a bunch of curtain twitching Karens with nothing better to do than crawl up your bum looking for something they can use to blackmail you into bankrupting yourself.
This comment is hidden. Click here to view.
You'd think so, but we have heard far more about Johnny Depp and Amber Heard than the overturning of Roe v Wade.
Not necessarily, in many hoas not every rule can be changed even by a unanimous board ruling. For instance the lanscaping, security, solar panel, pool maintenance rules in our hoa requires a 98% for vote of every owner in the complex. We have 500 homes so any change to the basic tenants requires a full bosrd aproval and a yes votes from 490 of the 500 homes.
How nice of them...a book of ways to p**s off hoa bullies...saves me the time of thinkin up something on my own...lol
Yep, my relatives live some place like that. They can choose the front door wreath and that's about it. And keep the garage door closed.
This comment is hidden. Click here to view.
The irony is that these people decrying the result of these HOAs in suburbs are liberal urbanites. But an HOA is nothing more than a democratic government done at small scale. I'm not a fan of HOAs for the same reason I don't like an unnecessarily controlling government.
So, your gardens aren't your gardens, because there's always some strangers being there mowing and planting stuff. How's that not weird? What if you want to garden yourself? What if you want your garden to be different from what the HOA sent guys do? What if you want to have no strangers being on your property, because you might just enjoy bein alone there and scratch your butt in peace and unwatched?
Baleygr, amazonqt sounds like she's/he's talking about a condo or townhouse community, rather than a single family home community
That’s what ours does (minus the pool- they didn’t put in a pool bc they were worried about the liability) all of our roofs, siding, gutters are covered and insurance (if anything happens walls in) is covered by the HOA insurance. So, for an example, if the toilet overflows/septic backs up and damages the flooring, any cabinets, baseboards or walls, the HOA pays up to $25,000 of that damage and then the homeowners insurance kicks in after that. We’ve had (in the passed 3 years) about 8 homes (out of 108 units) that have had this issue and a few others. I love not having to do landscaping or maintenance upkeep on the outside of our homes- it’s all done by the HOA, from the dues we pay each month. We have an attached garage and a detached garage, which is also on the maintenance program each week for upkeep. They pressure wash all the buildings and the walkways when needed. It’s really nice.
I live in a townhouse and my next door neighbor is the President and you've never met someone with such boundary and control issues. She treats my property as though it's hers. I have put up barriers and she is SO POed at me she slams her door whenever she leaves her house!😂😂😂😂
But not living within a HOA community means you could live next to someone that has several non-working project vehicles up on blocks in their yard, a dilapidated house with a roof caving in from roofing being placed on top of roofing over the years, over grown front and back lawn, etc. I’ll take my chances with the HOA helping to keep the property up- which is what my hubby and I have done since 2007. We just had our siding on our condo building (built in 1993) renovated to hardy planking in 2020 along with all new windows (updated to code) throughout and a new roof (updated to code). And we didn’t have to pay for it all out of pocket (which would have between $30,000-$45,000 if we had to pay for it ourselves), but we just pay an extra $200 on top of our HOA dues we pay for each month (along with 107 other condo owners in our complex).
European suburbs aren't great either but for many different reasons
I'm interested, too. I watch alot of British tv and their suburban houses look alot like ours without the big yards.
Then don't. This is the beauty of America. Free choice. Some people like them because they don't have time nor the inclination to do yard work. Only dumbass people who don't like hoas and move into one are the idiots. Then they try to change the rules. Typical libs, if we don't live according to them, they demand change.
Typical Libs? ROFL! I'm a lib and I love my HOA. BTW, it's the other guys who are forcing us to live like they prefer so get off your horse and accept your neighbors as the typical humans they are.
This comment is hidden. Click here to view.
If you live in an area covered by an HOA, you help make the rules. If you do not like them, change them! This is democracy at its best. Go to the meetings and ask questions, complain, and get the majority of homeowners on your side. If you do not like the HOA rules, do not buy a house there.
Anyone who would describe HOAs as "democracy at its best" is not to be taken seriously.
This comment is hidden. Click here to view.
HOAs: 1) Keep property values up, no wrecked junkers in front yards or ugly swingsets. 2) Maintain the community grounds. 3) Maintain the community resources like swimming pools, athletics facilities, and tennis courts etc. 4) Maintain security and a safer environment.
I live in a very small town in Pennsylvania in the US. I have a rather large yard that's broken up by many large trees, some bearing fruit, a small koi pond, herb gardens, and four large vegetable plots. We walk to the post office and bank, and store sometimes. This doesn't address typical suburbs, though, which I personally don't care for. The US is really a huge country, which does explain the sprawl, somewhat. There are a lot of factors at play which brought about the suburbs.
I live in a Suburb just outside Boston... We have stores and schools etc where you can walk or use other transportation. My property is half surrounded by forest and we have a stream... It's also Conservation Land. Meaning we can only change so much, in order to protect the environment. However I can walk the length of my street (probably 1 mile) and get to the grocery store, banks, CVS, Dunkin's etc. The town I grew up is a DRY town, no liquor stores... The town I live in now (30 min from my childhood house) has one of the biggest Malls in our State. Everywhere is different. I def agree with Tamra!
Load More Replies...Yours is an exception to the rule. Consider also that you are just outside a major metropolitan city, which has a large impact on its surrounding areas. The typcial suburb across the country is simply a vast wasteland of cardboard houses, multi-car garages, and little else. First rule of statistics, you cannot use an exception to define a majority. First rule in sociology, you can't use personal experience, or anectdotal experience to define a majority either.
You're outside of Boston that's old school. Like literally 13 colonies old school...
No, strict very crude zoning is what brought it on in large cities. In stead of using the space efficiently, crazy huge distances between stores and homes are a thing. And the nothing in between comes from laws that are just plain racist. https://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/how-federal-government-intentionally-racially-segregated-american-cities-180963494/ That doesn't mean it's as bad everywhere, it just means that literal black and white thinking (it's either high rise or detached, nothing in between) results in broke cities because with such space comes impossible to maintain infrastructure. You really need to read up on your own history and maybe experience life outside of the us to have an opinion about this...
And BINGO was his name!! Thank u!! Maj. Whites I've sumized, feel racism has been over since 70's with "occasional' sit's..since only approx 23% @ most of populat. being Black persons, many Whites either by design of White Flight/Exodus, or rural areas don't live near or with Black persons. It allows their White privilege to continue. Yet are completely unaware of it @least 90% of the time. Well, untill it's threatened!! By allowing seemingly "less" harmful-"little"racist thoughts, sayings=actions, it continue 2 b tolerated. Those that want 2 stand up-but don't want 2 be viewed trying to stir things up/insult in ppl in their home-etc. I Recog. my own FLABBY-considerate, yet righteous indig. stand-taking- 2 get firm-back in front/center- vowed to stop my selfish silence. Finding every Fact, Truth, & Proof, being earnest, & considerate as poss., Yet 2 stand up 2 these "little" deep rooted Poisonous ideas--& b Roundup again! God's Kindom Gov't-Eradicates soon!!!
The chief reason is the automobile and the desire to get away from poorly designed and overcrowded cities. And now, we're paying for it because we're stuck in this way of life.
Yeah you can get dropped off in any Main Street in America and any neighborhood in America it was rare exception not know where you're at because everything looks exactly the horrible same.
I also live in a very small town in PA. We have a decent yard with a small pond at the end, trees, a garden and all wildflowers that I planted. I'm ten minutes from town, but have nature as my backyard and can do what we'd like (for the most part) on the land. I'm less than a five minute's walk from a river. I love it here.
The country is so big, probably 75% of it is still virgin forest or desert. We can have as much land as we can afford.
No, actually the vast majority of so-called virgin forest was chopped down and used for home building in their respected areas, or lumbering long before most of us were born. Most virgin forest is within either State or Federally protected areas set aside for posterity like the Adirondacks, or Yellow Stone and such places. Agriculture did away with most of what home building didn't, even up until the 70s. It wasn't that long ago that 80% of the population was rural and involved in some kind of farming. That number reversed by the 50s through the 80s. Now 80% of the population lives in the cities. Consider that we are now at 330,000,000 people, and fity years ago only 195,000,000.
Really scraping the bottom of the barrel in terms of “things to pretend are bad in America”. They’re just houses, calm down.
Agreed. They're just houses and I live in one and everything I need is right around the corner. Not a problem.
Load More Replies...Do you drive to these places in your car, though? If you ride your bike, how often, and what do you do with your bike?
I love where I live; there is an outdoor mall a ten minute walk from where I live in each direction. But I live in Texas and where I am it's gated communities with shopping centers on every corner. But in the city close by, it's gas stations and cvs's on every corner rather than a whole shopping center. So suburbs are different everywhere.
I live in a home, only thing within 2 miles a bar, video game shop (gambling) and a gas station. What we do not have, sidewalks, food nor bus stop. Capital City in our state. ALL due to greed, Ford cars screwed the American people.
Times have changed since Model-T. They've got other companies nowadays. Cars didn't "do" anything. People wanted a convenience that was unimaginable, back then. Blame the donkeys or horses, for making people too lazy, back in the olden days. If people hadn't gotten a taste of getting over the hill and back in the same day, maybe we wouldn't have felt the need to get their faster. I blame the dinosaurs for dying and turning into oil. They started it.
Well… your avatar was chosen wisely, that much I can say about your comment. But the truth is that much was done specifically and purposely to undermine the existing mass transit system that existed at the time Ford's cars were being sold. The grants, tax credits, etc., that were provided to various elements of the auto industry to expand it while at the same time undermine everything else is only a part of it all. Whole books have been written and classes taught about this. It is all much more complex than you seem to want to think.
This comment is hidden. Click here to view.
They're not "just houses," the people who live there share a particular mindset. They have been called "sh*tlibs."
I don't think these questions were meant to be, bad things in America necessarily but rather trying understand a different way of life. Honestly my daughter has had similar questions and she has never been out of the United States. No one can deny, most Americans are more private which feeds what looks to be lonely neighborhoods. One more thing, I have lived in the city, countryside and in suburbs. They all have their pluses and minuses.
That's the way I took it. Every country is different. Different cultures, etc. I really think this person was just trying to understand these differences. I, myself, have a lot of questions about HOAs.
HOAs can be annoying, but they provide a set of rules that help ensure your house maintains value. I personally don't like them, but I can understand why other people do.
This comment is hidden. Click here to view.
There is nothing negetive about living in a suburb
Gosh, how I wish I could live in your State. I hear that in the State of Denial, they don't have to pay taxes either and that everything is free too! Like the infrastructure fairy keeps all the roads in good repair, and she pays the salaries and benefits of the po po, and the fire beaters too! Not to mention, those of the teachers, and keeps the schools, and libraries well cared for. Denial is just one of those ideal places where everyone seems to want to relocate to these days if they don't already live there like you do!
Very true. When run fairly and with fairness, HOA's are both necessary and beneficial. I think what partly lies behind some people's hatred of them is that they do not like rules, or being told what to do or not do. Unfortunately, without rules and guidelines, there are always going to be those who use the absence of them to take advantage of situations that cause problems for the rest of the community. This is like hating government, for government’s sake. This is an idiotic meme that has taken root in the conservative world, but it lacks serious thought. The idea is that people are good at self-policing themselves. Unfortunately, that isn't true, with far more instances to prove that than not. But facts are not an accepted concept when they go against those who want the freedom to do whatever they wish, regardless of how it affects those around them. In fact, they don't care, and that is at the root of the problem.
Yeah but a lot of the responses were self deprecating Americans crying the woe in disparity of, as one person but it, “forced suburbia”. I get tired of hearing Americans to cry everything about America and everything in Europe is just tiptop 100% great.
They would stop crying about it if idiots like you would stop voting to keep it below the rest of the civilized world.
This comment is hidden. Click here to view.
I've seen a lot of the world. You "idiots" can have it. Why should we vote to be like you. YTA and I don't envy the people around you.
Everything on Bored Panda is negative towards America. It gets really old.
It really does. I mind my own business, every man in my family are combat veterans, my brother was a volunteer firefighter and I was a volunteer emt. Why does the rest of the world make us out to be monsters? I watch the news, I know what goes on in the rest of the world. People forget how huge our country really is and it's under ONE government. We aren't multiple small countries under separate governments. It's hard enough to keep track of all the c**p that happens here. P.S. I vote, in every election, even the midterms.
As of early 2022, the WHO announced the results of its current population longevity ratings. Those in the EU, Singapore, and other nation's life-spans have increased to the low 80s. As for us, here in America? Our average life-spans have decreased, dropping below the 70s to the high 60s. This has nothing to do with the pandemic as the EU and other countries were hit just as hard if not more so and still their longevity has increased. So, despite not liking to self-reflect and criticize issues we're deficient in, those issues exist anyway and in increasingly more depressing ways with each passing year. Pretending that America is and will always be #1 in all things is an unfortunate denial. It is that denial that is partially contributing to our decline, another is greed. Unfortunately, it is denial that seems to be in the majority, which does not bode well for us at all.
Actually, the average American lifespan is 78. It has been for a long time. Plenty of people are living even longer, into their 80s and 90s. But, being 80 is a tough life. My husband works in a retirement facility. Medications, constant doctor appointments, caretakers. Your license gets taken away, as it should.
Is it not more the dearth of mid density housing in the US tends to mean it is suburbs or urban? I live in a UK suburb. I can easily walk to most things and take public transport where I can't. If there were some towns designed like college campuses that were walkable I think that would be a nice alternative.
Yes they do, but in this case, those pluses and minuses are not balancing each other out. It's an equation that currently we are beginning to pay for in many ways, because it is a lopsided one. I understand not wanting to contribute to what is a conflict of interest, but sometimes trying to equate both sides of an issue as being equal when it isn't is being overly diplomatic. As for our privacy, that we do have, but that too is coming at a serous cost. Of all the western industrialized nations, we have become one of the least cohesive societies as a result of that desire to be left alone. It's as if we've all succumbed to some Norma Desmond neurotic syndrome.
Personally I am glad this article exists. I never thought a place on earth existed where people live in big agglomeration like the suburbs and there's no convenience store within walking distance, a Cafe, a restaurant or even bus stops, or even more important, clinics and or/hospital. That's mind blowing to me. How do the elderly live? How do people go shopping? Is car required to exist there? I have so many questions! In any other country housing in such an area would be so devalued. Main focus for housing value is how close it is to basic necessities and from my understanding, suburbs there have none of that? It's like living in the country side with none of the perks of country side but all the issues..!
Cars are required to live here,yes. You drive to the store. Maybe 10 minutes drive. My old neighborhood had a convenience store within walking distance, and that neighborhood is about 7 miles from my current one. There's transportation services for the elderly to get to the doctor, but they kinda suck. I have a vegetable garden. The kids use the grass as a playing surface, soccer and baseball, running in the sprinkler when it's hot. I like it because I can't hear my neighbors on the other side of the wall, but I do see and talk to them when I'm outside. Privacy when I want it, social opportunity when I want that too. It's a luxury to have this space.I grew up in an apartment in the city, I don't think I could go back to the crowded noise. But true country life us isolating. This is a happy medium
We live in the country - and the noise from town is the cars. When we have an ice event or during COVID - everything was so quiet. Same with early mornings on the front porch. I'd love to live in a place where walking and biking were the norm and cars were the exception. Even quiet cars like EVs make alot of noise with their tires at 40+ mph. We love cars - and own several - including antiques but we see a big need to change how American cities function...
Change begins at home. Having multiple vehicles while stating you wish America could make big changes to the contrary is somewhat incongruent. Also, living far out away from those things that are typical of and what make properly functioning cities work such as efficient and effective mass transportation is another issue. We say it doesn't work, because we don't want it to work. We elect politicians who systematically under fund it and other programs so as to set them up to fail. Then, when they do, they can run straight to the media screaming to one and all “See we told you! Government can't do anything!” And then we believe it our self-fulfilling prophecies, of which we have many.
When we lived in Texas, the town we were in had laws against public transit of any kind, no alleys, and no sidewalks. That's because (and I'm quoting a sheriff's deputy here), "if you don't have a car you have no business being here and buses only bring (racist epithet deleted) here."
That is why I would never wish to live there, or anywhere like it. To think that there are enough people living in such a place that they allow that to be is astonishing. It isn't as if they can't change it if they truly wished to. The fact that they don't, says everything one needs to know about those who live there.
You raise important and valid questions. But despite our wanting to accept or believe it, Americans are and have always been in the midst of a class struggle. One of the ways one groups likes to believe they are above the other, or have “made it”, is by moving out into the suburbs. To live in the burbs is in some way a status symbol and means you've attained the “American Dream”. It is also very much rooted in racism. Being that minorities are disproportionately poorer, particularly Black people, moving out to the burbs has always been a way to self-segregate.
Why would I want to cluster around those places? I can get to a hospital in fifteen minutes, a store in five or so minutes. My elderly relative lived in her own home alone after her husband died, and that is how she wanted it. We like our space and our gardens and less people sticking their noses into our business.
If you are having a heart attack (or stroke) you only have five minutes to re-establish blood flow to keep your heart muscle (or neurons) alive. 15 minutes is likely a death sentence; severe disability at a minimum.
I wouldn't be driving myself to that hospital. The fire department is just up the road. They have ambulances.
Well, for the elderly, medicare will arrange rides to doctor appointments. Otherwise, there's Lyft, Uber, taxis. A lot of elderly live in communities that help take care of them. Not, necessarily homes, over 55 communities.There's also caretakers and aides. I haven't had a car, myself, for a couple years, I do miss the autonomy having one provides. I can get around, it's just a hassle. And there is a commuter train stop in town, but I have to taxi to it. But, I could get into NYC, if I wanted to.
We use our car. Elderly are helped by others. You need a car in winter anyway or if you have kids and babies and groceries. You can’t carry that by hand. The bus was ok when I was young and it was only me and maybe one bag-but even then it was very unpleasant you never knew who would sit next to you when it got full-a smelly, crazy weirdo who might follow you home? A pickpocket? The fights that would happen even on the bus-it’s just not safe or good for kids. You also have to live by the bus schedule and route. I like the freedom of our own vehicle to go where we want, when we want. We go shopping by getting into by getting into the van and driving the 5-10 minutes to the grocery store downtown-or maybe even up the street if you live on the far far ends of Main Street (that’s us-it doesn’t feel like main st which is nice!) I used to live in a more “convenient” area as people see it-but I would NEVER go back to that. I’ll take driving 2 hrs for the Walmart for the peace we have.
The more "regular people" ride mass transit - the less percentage of weirdos are there to shape the experience. Ride mass transit in another country. More regular folks going to school or work or shopping. They sort of set a standard. Also, countries help their addicts and homeless - not leaving these people to struggle along day to day.
One of the major reason reasons all them weirdos are out and about these past three plus decades is because Reagan and his conservative congress began defunding and thus closing down all the state hospitals. That along with continued underfunding and cutting of already seriously lacking social programs for decades has made matters not only worse, but at this point so systemic that it is doubtful anything can be done to solve these problems. But no one wants to pay taxes-- for anything, let alone social services, teachers, roads, fire and safety, etc. So we get what we deserve. There is a reason why other countries “help their addicts and homeless”, and that is done through the taxes they pay. It is something they choose and accept because they understand the benefits to their community. But we're too selfish to understand that, thinking only of our desires. What we don't understand, we disparage ridiculously.
This comment is hidden. Click here to view.
>>"I never thought a place on earth existed" _____________________ Seriously. You need to buy yourself of set of Encyclopedia, or get off social media and find educational websites, with no comment sections. Crack a book maybe.
This comment is hidden. Click here to view.
It seems to me if an American approached an issue this way, they would be called ignorant and stupid. Yet Europeans can act willfully dim on such an easy thing to understand, all for the purpose of saying, "If it's not like how we do it, it's bad." It's ultimately just a continuance of an attitude of arrogance and superiority that is so common from a European. In reality, it is simply close-mindedness and small thinking that allows you to be so dismissive of American differences.
No, they just mock out s**t hole country for being slaves to corporations and putting the beauty of houses before our own people. As they should.
Now this sounds like an answer, thank you. (The advantage of living in the countryside in Europe over the American suburb is still though that you can survive even without a car. It's not much great but it's possible. And we are allowed to grow damn plants on soil we own...(there probably isn't a place where this wouldn't be possible, I mean.))
No it's just easier to see those things from the outside .. of course there are similar things in Europe looking weird to Americans. I have sat in traffic to work many times thinking when did this become normal each person sitting in a 2 to 4 ton tin can wasting fossil fuel during an hour of commute...every day. Nobody questions it.
"It's not really that bad in America, the internet skews a lot." "It's literally that bad in America."
This comment is hidden. Click here to view.
Lots of people question it, it's just such a dumb question, nobody bothers answering it.
I disagree... These questions are pretending it's bad. They're pointing out that they are literally bad. They exist to segregate classes, increase the fuel industry while decreasing community/development/public transport. They increase peoples inability to access necessities in a timely manner. Etc. Those questions literally make sense because American suburbs are literally incapable of self sustaining themselves
I agree. If the suburbs don't suit you, you can live in the city or more urbane area alongside businesses. Also, many people like their lawns just the way they are abs kids don't play with grass. That's what toys, swingsets, athletic equipment etc is for. Most people that move to suburbs do so for the yards and the distance from business traffic. This is a bunch of hogwash.
I prefer to live where there are large spaces between homes, no businesses except people having fruit or veggies stands or egg stands, homemade soaps-no ugly stores or loud bars. Peace, quiet, and privacy. Lots of space for my kids to run, and lots of other kids doing the same. I’ve lived in apartment complexes and apartment houses where my kids had to share their yard space-kids from other houses would destroy our kids outdoor toys, heavy older kids would use my little kids’ swing set without permission, they’d uncover the sandbox when we weren’t home and peoples outdoor cats would poop in it (and in our veggie gardens). Kids would dig up the veggies our kids proudly planted as soon as it germinated. I think they’d wait for us to not be home to do this. More than once they used our hose and got everything wet (increased water bill!). Cops would have to be called from loud music at 1am-not just normal but LOUD waking babies and kids, and people who work. I’d prefer a suburb with fence.
This comment is hidden. Click here to view.
Hogwash? Calm down Karen. Go turn on your oxygen tank and fix news
It's the usual gaw everything in America equals bad?!? I wish we could put a disclaimer on any of these types of posts that the poster represents no one other than himself. Cities, towns and suburbs differ all over the country and trying to pretend like any one voice represents the experience of every American is absurd. Plenty of people live in walkable areas with plenty of public transport. Also weird that someone would purposely move into a planned community and have an issue with it; there's a problem there but it's probably you.
The only problem America has is that there are too many people in the country that we don't want to live next to. I'm white, but I'm not talking about racial prejudice. Living next to a respectable minority family is the least of my worries. I'm talking about moral values, law-abiding, and perhaps economic values. I don't want to live near any: drug addicts, drug gang members, criminals, or other lowlife; or "good ol' boy" rednecks or other white trailer trash. If I could be assured that those kind people wouldn't be in my neighborhood, I could gladly live anywhere. I think that is true about all of us. We just don't want to have to deal with the systemic social problems that America has right now, and living in the suburbs gives us a way to avoid it. I do wish that they would be more progressive. I would appreciate more public transportation, just so I wouldn't have to face my daily commute every day. And it would be better for our environment - not to have so many cars on the road.
You do realize the article did state it was found drug abuse and overdose is prevalent in suburban communities often right? I get it though. I've lived city life 80% of my life and you tend to be reminded of America's societal failings daily here.
It sounds to me like you're part of the social problems that you decry. I think that you need to get out of your bubble and grow some compassion. It's all about "me" with you, which is a huge contributing factor in our society.
"We live in the suburbs because we want our social, mental health and addiction issues hidden away in McMansions rather than out on the street where everyone can see it and might be forced to do something about it" If you don't think your perfect suburbs aren't full of drugs, racism, criminals and lowlifes, then you're living in wilful oblivion.
Still those weird hoods with the blatant disadvantages cited above exist, and I suppose there are many... But you are right, it should be claimed somewhere this isn't the only way American suburbs are like. It actually was - although the final message of this article hits a bit as you describe... And yes, your argument "if you don't like it move elsewhere" has something to it. But, let's hope their ideal living ("suburbia without the crazy HOA and with buses") is possible to be made reality without much extra cost... (I'm not American and sorry for my English)
The way the American society functions is bad. By design. It is designed to extract the maximum profits from each and every one of us. And the side effects are undesirable. Most people have little job security, must own and operate expensive cars, there are cultural differences caused by economic differences (schools' budgets being tied to neighborhood tax revenue rather than every school getting the same budgets) which is just discrimination. Until these things (and more) are corrected then I too would rather live in my smallish town on a big patch of ground that gives us privacy. However, it doesn't have to be that way. Changes to how our economy functions and how our society is designed could create more diversified neighborhoods that would be desirable places to live in closer proximity to our neighbors. More walking or bicycling, less driving. People who are more uniformly and reliably employed and thus not pushed out of society to live on the fringes in poverty. It is complex...
It's not scrapping the barrel. You should look at this zoning in the US, the answers do get some clues (you seem not to have read those). This thing in the US is definitely pretty bad.
Things ARE bad in America. Take off your rose colored boomer glasses and look around. These are all valid points.
I’m a millennial and I’ve lived in the crowded areas with business and now a rural area-rural and suburban beats crowded city. There is a lot wrong with our county but suburban living is not it-most young families dream of either the suburbs (best for kids) or rural (also great for kids, but fewer other kids to play with). Don’t confuse suburbs with HOAs-those are the ones where you pay a fee to have everything controlled.
Yeah, it is sort of a silly article. Most people find suburbs a desirable place to live-- all the conveniences of living in the big city without all the hassle of partiers, crime, traffic, and other things you would find while living in the city.
But the convenience of living in the big city IS the urban life, lots of cafés and bars, public transportation and not needing a car to get around, lots of shopping possibilities including the obscure small shops in in side streets...
Shopping ain't all it's cracked up to be. I like to get in, get what I need, and get out and go home. I don't need lots of shopping possibilities.
I like to walk to the grocery store if I notice that I don't have any bread left ... Also the freedom that I have not to be shackled to the need to own my own car. Not to mention the independence I could enjoy as an older child and teenager, able to go to a corner store to buy sweets and comic books, drive to the library on my own via public transport and all such things.
Yeah... White people to get away from minorities... It's literally why they were developed
Black and Hispanic people love the suburbs too! Decent ones do. I am Puerto Rican, brown skin and all! My relatives all bought single family homes in the suburbs and they are content living there, and growing veggies in the fenced in yard. My own household chose to move to rural Aroostook County, Maine. There may not be many people of my own culture up there but that has never mattered to me (honestly they don’t like the cold, don’t like change, and don’t adapt to new cultures well) but I am more open minded and moved up here. Loving the Acadian culture and the ability to cross into Canada daily if I want. I love driving around and seeing cows on green hills instead of apartments and stores. Used to live in Massachusetts and it was a nightmare. We have the stores we need near center of town anyone can drive 5 min when they need to get stuff-but at home you can relax and kids play in fenced in yard. My point is-it’s not White people getting away from minorities-it’s decent hard working people (of any race or nationality) wanting to live in a decent place and have a peaceful quiet life. Oh and there are a few fellow Puerto Ricans up here and one PR family owns the one tattoo shop-they have done well and are important in our small town of 3,000. They came up after Maria and were welcomed-people gave furniture and helped them get established-now they run a successful business.
Did you just insinuate that minorities are responsible for crime in big cities??? Just wanna make sure I understand your point.
Didn't sound like it to me. Perhaps you wrote something in your mind that wasn't there?
Minorities have been short changed for decades. We see the consequences every day. In my state, the minority neighborhoods are the poorest and their schools have the least amount of money to spend on each student and to hire faculty and maintain the school. Guess what that looks like? Guess what the long term consequences are? Same at the edge of the counties where the poor whites live. Long distance commutes to work and shop, substandard schools, etc - same as in the minority neighborhoods. And, the similar problems with drugs and violence. As money moves into these places (educated people move in) - everything improves, and the problems diminish (diluted?) Perhaps help the poorer neighborhoods along sooner than when growth do it automatically decades later?
Actually, no. My area of the suburbs has seven houses, three white families, three black, and one is vacant for now. We used to have some nice Mexicans who lived on the street back behind our house on the other side of the woods. One of our dogs loved to go visit them.
But the economic impact of these houses is imo quite severe, so much so they have led to some cities going bankrupt. I strongly recomend watching Not just bikes’ Strong Town series.
Right?! I’m in CA and public transportation is everywhere. All over. Also prop 13 is a good thing which allows generations to pass down family homes without bankrupting the rest of their family.
Thank you for understanding. Finally. Someone from another country (I’m guessing from the Britain flag on the username) understands.
Nope. They're not just houses. It's a cultural phenomenon that is unique to us. That and the fact that suburban lifestyle is vastly different from city lifestyle. It is even different from what some consider true or strict rural living. It isn't so simplistic as being just about “houses”. Thinking it suggests that you either haven't spent much time elsewhere, or are not that observant as to the environment around you and don't care to be, or live in the suburbs and don't like reading critical articles about it. So, this is your passive-aggressive way of letting everyone know that, while trying to seem above it all. So which is it, or is it all of the above? Because, your comment is not really accomplishing what you would expect of it.
Only a fool or a Karen would love ve under a HOA. 😄 Thank God HOAs are few and far between.
I regret so much I am too young I can't compare the Communism here with the today's reality (as presented by the internet) of for example America....
Tell me you don't understand communism without telling me you don't understand communism.
Californian, born and raised, and even I am amazed that people can be talked into forming/joining an HOA. I don't think the organizers of such things even have good intentions, considering the petty, self-important dictators that gravitate to these positions of "power". They might pitch the idea as something that will be beneficial for all, but, on the inside, they're just salivating at the chance to tell other people what to do. There's a lot of embezzling that goes on, too.
This comment is hidden. Click here to view.
Its poor design and planning, we need to be building and zoning up, not outward. You rural bumpkins really don't know what's best.
I love how you are so stupid the only comeback you had was something a second grader would come up with. "I know you are but what am I?"
I’ve lived in a crowded area and it was a nightmare-try living somewhere nice and rural and tell me you would then want to go back to living with neighbors messing with your kids stuff-cops having to stop criminals-hearing domestic violence-hearing kids get smacked and then wailing-your plants getting dug up-having to see people’s garbage and hoards building up in their windows and yards attracting pests to everyone’s property…that’s a nightmare! Now I can make my breakfast and eat it on the porch under my hanging flower basket-sit on the porch swing-grow veggies with my kids-send them to the backyard to play while I clean, even my 2 year old because it’s fenced and and as safe as any other room inside my house. My neighbor is friendly and has pretty flowers and little figurines on her front porch. My kids pick flowers for her and say hello. I push my baby on the swing. My daughter does homework on the trampoline. We make s’mores and grill hotdogs. It’s wonderful.
God forbid you don't/can't drive (minors, elders, disabled, temporarly injured...)... In Italy we do have some places like that, where all you get is houses, no stores, no bars, no schools... They are called quartieri-dormitorio (dormitory blocks), but it's usually very low-income neighborhoods, definitely not middle/upper class... And it's considered a bad thing honestly
Tell me about it I am disabled, can't drive, and live in RURAL America. I'm pretty much a hermit unless someone takes me somewhere
Load More Replies...Europe isn’t always better. Many of the cities in Europe I’ve visited aren’t handicapped accessible at all. Stairs into public buildings with no ramps, public restrooms in basements that are only accessible via steep staircases etc. Neither place is perfect.
This comment is hidden. Click here to view.
So why do you live in rural America if you don’t like it? You should be enjoying the beauty that many people would love to have and the peace.
Because some people have no choice or has their house paid for or something. Easier said than done to just up and move...
Exactly, moving requires finding a new job, a new house and a lot of money in general. And it might involve leaving relatives, friends, a familiar situation... Anyway, I've always found this argument very hypocritical: "If you don't like your country, just move". But when people immigrate from poorer countries, and they if fact don't like (or find impossible to) living there, suddenly it's "GO BACK TO YOUR COUNTRY!!!".
Emmy, it's because Americans refuse to believe that their (& my) country has any faults at all. F**k the stupid arrogant Americans who say that. This IS my country, and it IS every American's country. The solution is not to leave, but to demand change from our elected leaders to make America a better place to live for all of us.
Emmy, it seems very logical. My family will be moving from the US to Jordan in September. I know there are many things that the US has that Jordan does not have, and that it will be difficult in some ways to adjust. But if you ever find me constantly complaining and hating Jordan, please do encourage me to leave because why would I stay there? Who does it benefit for me to berate that country because of my own unhappiness? Everyone should actively seek a place you feel you belong... you only get this one life. If the US ain't it for you, hasta la vista baby.
Actually, we used to move a lot when I was younger, but then we moved to Tennessee, Mom got sick, I was disabled, she was disabled, there's literally no way to make a living out here. I can't afford to move, as much as I would like to live closer to doctors somewhere with public transportation or at least Ubers. Instead I'm stuck in a 121 year old house that's falling apart in the middle of nowhere. It's beautiful here sure, and I appreciate that in the spring and Summer, when I'm well enough to walk our dangerous lawn and not fall into a rabbit hole and keep an eye out for cottonmouths, instead of what I have been unable to walk far on even the flat hardwood floor.
Have you looked into Access? Also, in my state, disabled people can get aides.
Choices have consequences. I choose to live in a rural area because my preference for space, quiet and a small town feel outweighs the consequences of having to drive for anything I need. When my circumstances change, I will re-evaluate and possibly move to a denser area.
The downside of course, is that you live next to a cornfield with nothing to do or to go see.
I'm 65, currently living in a large city 😒 and I bicycle to work in good weather. I avoid busy roads and dangerous traffic as much as possible. I own a car because the city is large and one still needs to visit family, grocery shop etc. I dream of moving to a small town or quiet suburb. Nothing stopping people from walking, biking or getting an Uber. If people are too lazy to walk more than a few feet, use public transportation etc then stay in the congested impersonal City. I prefer small towns and other low population areas where the people are friendly and know one another.
Even if you can drive, home delivery is popular in the US for almost anything you want or need.
Thats true i can have literally anything delivered to my house 18 hours a day. Heck half my regular amazon orders are 2 hour delivery same day orders.
They walked, rode a bicycle even without sidewalks. Most took a bus to shop downtown. I know, I'm from 1956, all original equipment too. 😄
I live in a tiny rural town in the largest US interconnected state. If my van breaks down, we are completely screwed. The nearest actual grocery store is 25 minutes away by car. Even the tiny store in my town is 4 miles. Too far to walk for any substantial amount of food. And too far for me to walk as I have musculoskeletal health issues. There are also ZERO sidewalks, even through town. I hate that there's nothing out here. BUT my kids ARE far safer than in a city.
This comment is hidden. Click here to view.
That’s what I like about having land, it’s a barricade. When the government forces low income housing into every neighborhood for you to pay for them they are busy doing drugs and other unseemly things. I liked it better when there were no sidewalks, strange characters are up and down the road all the time. I walked many places without a sidewalk, these people sound like they can’t walk on a ground. No way I would trade to live in the city.
Wow Daisy, what a shitty little rant. When I was a kid, I lived in low income housing. My parents weren't criminals and I assure you, none of us did anything "unseemly" that might force someone with such delicate sensibilities as yours, to clutch her pearls. Trust me, everyone is glad you have your land to barricade you from the rest of us.
I live in a senior citizen apartment complex where your rent is determined by your income and water, heat, electricity and trash pickup are included. It's quiet, peaceful and crime-free. You have to be 60 or over, disabled or a student - and pass a criminal background check - to live here. It's certainly nothing like Daisy imagines. I do miss having my own place, but I'm 69 and have COPD. I'm no longer able to do things like mowing the lawn or shoveling snow.
I lived low income housing too as a kid- it’s true there were good people, but also a LOT of criminals, drugs, domestic violence. My parents would tell us don’t play with this kid, they are a bad influence-they were Victims of their toxic parents and many grew up to be criminals too. It’s not a good way to live and all they did was acknowledge that. The good people will fight hard to get out of there and have something better-if they can’t, they teach their kids good values and morality and not to imitate the neighbors. I grew up and started raising my own kids in an apartment too-but we owned the building and screened tenants. Then hated being landlords and still having bad neighbors in other houses, no privacy, and no respect for boundaries-dug up veggies and damaged outdoor toys-sold the house, quit being landlords and now live in rural America. I’m a minority and some childhood neighbors were white. Don’t believe in this white privilege bs-I’m Hispanic worked hard did things right.
Wow! Easy on the stereotyping! You just told us you were from a rural community without having to tell us with your ignorance so here’s some FACTS: NOT ALL ppl who find themselves needing low income housing do drugs! NOT ALL even do unseemly things! Some are actually disabled veterans and/or single moms who have been widowed young or maybe not by choice and are working but with rental costs being so high still need help! So since I’m sure you wouldn’t like being called a backwoods redneck that sits around all day thinking up racist ideas to post online while you hide behind the safety of your keyboard, start practicing a little compassion! Btw, NO I don’t live in low income housing, I live in a lovely condo on the beach but I volunteer at a shelter and food pantry so I know poverty doesn’t discriminate.
I don't know about where you live. But where I live being low income does not mean you do drugs it means your not being paid a living wage. There is far more drug use by middle class then by the poor because here's a surprise for you. Drugs cost money. A large part due to the opioid crisis. Guess who's insurance covered those drugs. Not the poor on public health. Now fentanyl and heroine are rampant among the middle class. The poor smoke weed as it's affordable and get us through our shitty lives and not to mention legal.
This comment is hidden. Click here to view.
They are safe - for now. Just wait until XiBiden dumps 5,000 illegals in your community!
Illegal immigrants would at least be able to self sustain not to mention they'd increase the likelihood of closer stores, a stronger community bond (because most nations outside the US aren't individualist) and would be able to increase your likelihood of getting help if something like your car breaks down. Because and this might shock you... Illegal immigrants are people fleeing from corruption and poverty not criminals and assholes
The suburbs aren't rural and are not far from all the amenities of the city. And in my city the public transportation does stop outside each subdivision so you can take it if you need to as well as my city has personal public transportation for the elderly and disabled some free or for only a few dollars they can call the day before and schedule a pickup and a transit will pick them up and take them directly where they need to go and the city even has programs for free punch cards so they don't even have to pay for that
But also on the same token in my city the only people that use public transportation are people who can't drive because they either can't afford to or because they literally can't
In Canada , they’re making 15 minute cities .. where everything will be 15 walking minutes .. I think its neat!
My niece wanted to get a job to save money for college, but her mother has work and her father is deployed, so she is stuck babysitting the kids in her neighborhood until she saves enough money to by a car so she can save enough money to go to college. Slightly ironic isn't it? She has to save money in order to get more money.
Get an uber and just stop. Suburb are not low income areas. Rural areas are different, it sucks if you can get around there
Doesn't exist in some towns. I live in a small town in Texas. There is no taxis and no Ubers...no public transport.
In my country we don't have Uber. And taxis are only available in big cities, certainly not in my small town. Not everybody shares the same experience.
No one is forced to live in the suburbs. We Americans can choose where to live. I understand the questions and confusion, but people live where they want. My in-laws loved having a house in an HOA neighborhood, I chose to live in a non-HOA neighborhood. Most towns and counties in the US do provide free public transportation for elderly and disabled people. Just because it's not regular bus service doesn't mean it doesn't exist.
"We Americans can choose where to live.".... what an odd statement. As if you are implying that people living in other countries don't choose where they live, because the original post was from Slovakia, and they also get to choose where they live. Secondly, I actually challenge the statement that Americans can choose where to live, since many Americans can't due to economic conditions. I'm sure there are plenty of people living in suburbs that wished that they didn't live in a suburb, but are not able to move.
Load More Replies...More I think they meant it as in the original article/questions they wonder why people would live in these suburbs. Simply put people choose to live in them because they want to. Not because it's forced apon them
I think the statement was a perfectly appropriate response to another comment that had seemed to imply that Americans did not have freedom in terms of living in a suburb.
That is not at all how that statement was intended, you either don't understand the language or you're being a tool, most people in the U.S.A. love where and how they live, because we don't need or want businesses next door or because everyone doesn't require a vegetable garden, by no means we are suffering, most of us like the fact we have large yards, and are not on top of each other, if someone would rather live in a city, they do, if they prefer the countryside, then they live there instead, you watch too much tv
Love where and how they live... What bubble are you living in? Like I get it, life is enjoyable here, it has it's moments. But love? Nah most Americans in the city get reminded by homelessness, crime, and weaponized poverty on the daily. This country is predatory both on the global and national level. I don't look at pharmaceutical companies getting away with mass murder by being fined as loving living here. I don't see poor people enlisting at the recruitment office to go shoot foreigners to escape poverty as loving it. I don't see how anyone not ignorant of the massive societal failings of america are loving where and how they live.
Moving costs aside, the same amount of $ could afford you to live in the city, Suburbs or countryside of America. FYI- for lower income families- The Suburbs are often seen as a "safer" alternative to city life.
True many Americans are restricted by economics. But the strange thing happening in my city right now is that the rent on a small 2 bedroom poorly maintained apartment is about $1200-$1400 a month while at the same time a mortgage in the suburbs for a nice 3-4 bedroom house is also $1200-$1400 a month but most people in the city can't buy a house because they can't get a mortgage due to credit and not having a down payment because every cent they make goes to pay there bills while working two or more jobs and having to live with 3 or more other people also working to make rent for the shitty 2 bedroom apartment
This comment is hidden. Click here to view.
"People living in suburbs" are not poor people, they're upper middle class and own their homes. They can choose to move to the inner city if they'd like. In fact, if they take a lower-paying job, they can get a government subsidy and live there nearly free.
Good luck moving to the city from the burbs in any city in North America. Where have you been the last five years? Let alone thirty...
Yeah, good luck with that. The waiting list for section 8 housing, where your rent is adjusted according to your income, is so long in Virginia that the lists have been mostly closed for at least a decade. People who work low income jobs don't do so because it makes their life easier; they'd much rather be paid a living wage and not need assistance. The wealthy welfare woman with 10 kids and no job, driving a Cadillac is a myth that was purposely perpetuated by the republican party. There was a huge investigation into welfare fraud because of that myth and they found it was almost non-existent. Google it.
"....I'm sure there are plenty of people living in suburbs that wished that they didn't live in a suburb, but are not able to move." I think you're very confused here. People actually WANT to live in suburbs. We actually have very low supply of new housing developments now. No one lives here because they couldn't live anywhere else. Is it really hard to understand why someone would want to live in a home that's brand new with every up to date system installed? I'm sorry but the premise of this whole thread is simply bizarre.
The article is specifically about American suburbs, not not-American suburbs.
The article is a European person commenting on American suburbs. Non-American suburbs are fair game.
Yes, that sentence struck me as odd, too. It sounds like that typical American thinking that their country is the only one where people are free and have freedom of speech and all that. Brainwashed or poorly educated is what I call it.
You are experiencing what we call bias. Nothing was said about other countries. This person only expressed that her experience is limited to America, and there is nothing wrong with that
Vicky, ironic to call someone else uneducated when your own reading comprehension is subpar. The article is focused on criticizing American suburbs, this commenter said "We Americans can choose where to live" as in "I'm an American and I'm not forced to live where I don't want" even though the article seems to suggest it. There was zero insinuation that other countries don't get to choose where they live. I'm discovering every day Europeans' view of America isn't grounded in reality, but in their own arrogance, ignorance, superiority complex, and projected insecurities. Y'all need help... seriously.
This comment is hidden. Click here to view.
Your country is a hotbed of far right wing movements throughout the last century + Imagine a german talking s**t about America... pot, meet kettle.
This comment is hidden. Click here to view.
You definitely can walk your a*s to the city if you're poor and dont like the suburbs. Get a job, save money, stop being poor.
Many Americans "choose" to live in the suburbs because 1) they grew up there, 2) their parents grew up there, and 3) their grandparents moved there out of fear of "those people." They literally never go into the city if they can help it. Their impressions of city life come from Law and Order reruns rather than reality.
I live 10 minutes outside a city of several million. I do everything I can not to approach any closer than that, unless I'm heading downtown for a sports event at one of the stadiums. Being packed into a concrete jungle with millions of people all around, I couldn't imagine a worse hell. The moment I can get clear of the people and vehicles and floor the gas out of there, I'm gone. Absolute hell, way too many people.
lol you are probably right... I'm sure all of the people in my neighborhood with $1m+ homes and a few hundred thousand of vehicles (many of which have a secondary condo in uptown) can't afford to live in the city. Definitely the case. Certainly not the choice of allocating their funds differently or just flat out wanting to be here. Nope... They can't afford it. 100%. Nailed it!
"More like they don't go to the city because they can't afford it." Living in an overpriced condo above a noisey, traffic-filled city street vs. living in a quiet, maintained neighborhood surrounded by city parks and fun things for kids to do. Thanks-- I'll take the suburbs.
Also: 4) It is nice, all the advantages and conveniences of living in the city, without the hassle and downsides. The suburbs are typically some of the highest price real estate because of this.
I don't think anyone moved to the suburbs out of fear of "those people". They moved during the postwar baby boom for " No down payment for veterans" loans for tiny ranch houses, nice yards, good schools,and safety. Pretty much the same reasons people live there today and there are "those people" here, too who moved for the same reasons.
Ever think maybe people live in suburban areas because they want a balance between “leave me the f**k alone” rural living (like me), and being packed in like sardines in urban living? To me the urban living scenario is the absurd concept.
Yes it is! Very much do NOT need to know my neighbors that well.
Load More Replies...People and racism have turned me from a happy hafu to a hafu who treasures her hermitness and her two friends. One is or was a racist until I told her that I was half yellow. She said no, you're white. I said, no. When my mother came to the U.S from Japan and then to Cleveland, they could only rent a house in the colored section. My dad was the only white face in an ocean of black faces. And was treated better by them than his so-called race. My friend has since revised her opinion after I told her the many names I have been called by whites, browns and blacks. Only the native american/indigenous people haven't. They only said "close enough ". My brothers and I were accepted by the kids on the reservation. They took us on a mad dash on horses through a bull's pasture. To their burial grounds (real, not a tourist trap), a murdered hermit's car. We helped clean, brush and put our horses to bed or pasture. We were accepted 100%.
I forgot. We fell in love with fry bread and they fell in love with japanese rice and food
In rural areas people know each other much better than packed in cities. They are much more friendly and sincere. They enjoy more privacy not loneliness or solitude. Judging by your comment you milage definitely differs. LOL
People just can't get to know with other with the hectic lives we live in cities. People think just because you meet ransoms in night clubs they have relationships
Lived in cities most of my life... I've met over 30 years like a handfull of my neighbors? You go to work, get off work, and then go do s**t around the city or go home and relax. I'd imagine it's the same for the suburbs, just less car usage, and instead of wrongly assuming no one is taking drugs to cope with modern reality, you assume most people are using some sort of drug like substance.
Right. And you don’t have to dig a well or whatever, set up a septic system, find electricity… Setting up my own infrastructure is too much for me. But I’m super-introverted, so I wouldn’t love having people right on the other sides of my walls, hearing them, but it would maybe be OK to live in a townhouse. I would hate living in an apartment again though, esp. now w/ kids (we have 3, also my mother-in-law lived w/ us for 10 yrs until she died). People on every side, lots of noise inside & outside. A married couple w/ maybe 1 kid might pretty easily live in the average apartment, I guess.
I think the problem here is not: "why on earth would you want to live in the suburbs?!". It's more about: "why do the suburbs are designed like that?". We have suburbs here in Italy but it's not just houses after houses, no other "useful" buildings, immaculate lawns and that's it. We have shops, bars, restaurants, schools, parks, people keep their backyards as they please, they grow vegetables if they feel like it, they can take a stroll in the evening for ice-cream, you know.
That’s how it is where I live in the US. I’m not sure if the assumption is that all suburbs in US are all the same (HOA, no uniqueness to the homes, etc.)… but that’s nothing like where I live.
We love our suburbs in American. A five minute drive from me there are literally hundreds of stores and a mall. No knees to go anywhere else for those things. Every store you've ever heard of.
Exactly. I don't want to live in a city. There's definitely an advantage in some aspects to living in a city but I like my privacy and I like my open space (and my lower crime rates).
This comment is hidden. Click here to view.
Nah it's mostly racism, always has been.
I’m a brown Puerto Rican and I hate cities-I really do prefer suburbs and rural. Live in rural now and I’m never going back to city living. I dont care what color people are-I don’t want to live around criminals and low life’s. I don’t my kids raised around them. Stop assuming it’s racism-people just want safe places to live. Black people do the same thing-work hard to buy a nice peaceful house in the suburbs or rural area. Oh we have Black people living in my rural area too-they aren’t racist they just want to live a nice life in a peaceful place! Cities are a nightmare.
IKR! The myth lives on. If you can afford to buy a house here you are welcome.
The Americans here defending their verson of suburb life I understand, but they have never lived in the European way of living where everything is geared to community. I'm biased (U.K.), but have lived abroad, last stop Turkey for 10 years where it's even more 'community first, and gardens are for productive use. and the children play out making god knows what with mud and lolly sticks, come at teatime. I think it's sad, and would love for the U.S. defenders to try the alternative just for a while.
I would absolutely love to live in that kind of community. There are some places like that in the US, but they aren't the norm, sadly.
Load More Replies...Small towns in the Midwest are like this. Shops along main street, houses in walkable distance
I just think it's a misconception that we have never experienced this. Not everyone in the US lives in the suburbs. It's kind of a culture unto itself. I live in an urban neighborhood, there are, stores, pubs and restaurants all within walking distance with side walks and crosswalks. Parks and gardens where people grow vegetables, one of my neighbors has chickens. We have this here in the cities. Suburbs exist on the outskirts of the city but planners are now changing the way they design communities so that they look more like our urban neighborhoods. The biggest issue now, is that homes are so outrageously expensive, people with jobs in shops and restaurants cannot afford to live anywhere near those places. Forcing them once again to drive very far to go to work.
Very true. We are planning on building a new place and will sell our current home to our oldest son at what we owe and the other house will be for youngest son.
Wait a second, do you actually believe those areas don't exist in the USA? Seriously?
Amazing how little the people who love to criticize us actually know about us, isn't it?
This want the case where I lived. We had stores withing a 15min walk. Back yards were used for fires ,cook outs , and for the children to play in. Even in my mostly empty back yard we had hours apon hours of fun times. Plus people could grow vegetables if they so pleased ,but most just didn't.
It's part of the culture. Americans aren't big on tight knit communities, which often feel taxing on their privacy and independence. American culture is in a way more "selfish" by many other country standards
My mother was japanese and not liked by my dad's family. Racism in the family tree (except for my Aunt Gen and Aunt Georgia), yeah. NOT. It was my two brothers, mom and me against the world. My dad joined our attitude later. Maybe some U.S. citizens are selfish, but on the average, no. Otherwise, why would we send over 40 billion dollars in aid to Ukraine. Yes, the politicians voted on the Aid, but the VAST majority of us are behind the Ukranian people and their right to live and be free. GO PRESIDENT ZALENSKY and THE UKRANIAN PEOPLE. My best friend and my sister in heart and soul is a republican. I am a VERY liberal buddhist atheist. Her husband loves me as her sister and would never try to separate us. I generally don't talk politics, religion or money expect with her. We respect and love each and refuse to let poo-poo get between us. Nope, never gonna happen. So yes, we can be selfish but everyone has to watch out for such negativity. Sorry for the rant.
Buddhism is a way of life where there is no belief in a god. Athiest is believing there is no god. It was redundant to include athiest.
I have lived many years in the UK, Russia, and Germany as well as traveling to 90 precent of Europe and what is mostly said in this forum about suburbs is false and hyperbolic. Most American suburbs actually have sidewalks and stores within walking distance. Additionally most suburbs in the US don't have HOA's. And the idea that yards are not used for gardening is just a lie. A homeowner can do whatever gardening they want is their backyard. Additionally most suburbs have parks and walking paths and other recreational activities all available. And as for the kids the play outside with one another just as European kids do. As for Europe if you want to live stacked on top one another, have very small living spaces, no garage, no privacy, no ability to live where you want do to overall low average income then by all means move to Europe. I'm guessing most on here are leftist just dreaming of just such living arrangements. I for one like the privacy and freedom.
Here in Indonesia too, if there are empty space (that has soil) people will plant it with veggies or fruits or flowers. My parents does it and it saves money and healthier since its organic. Some house sell snacks or other household-related things which makes it easier to develop micro (nano even) businesses at their own home
So I believe that a lot of people live in the burbs because they enjoy the privacy, at least that's why I do, but am lucky enough for my kids to have other kids so close by to play with and keep busy and an HOA that is useless really, they don't enforce much at all and fees are very minimal and used for the park and playground in the neighborhood. I do miss when I was younger though and had all this plus a small neighborhood market across the main street. Only problem was there, the main street was more of a highway than a cross road.
For my kids and now for my grandsons We picked our city for proximity to Lake Erie and for the city school system. Our school district has a pretty good rating in Ohio and low crime average. When we had a family shooting with suicide, we mourned and are still mourning the victims, humans and animal. This is the only one that I know of and I have lived here since 1994.
Yes, crime rate is another big thing that I left out, but unfortunately, as you know, crime can and will happen anywhere. Just some places are obviously more prone to crime than most suburbs
I live in the USA now and in my town it is " community first" we have community functions(every weekend the town comes to main street for music, movies in the park ect) community gardens as well as private ones . Not everywhere in the USA is the same, just like in the UK not all places are "community first".
Here is what "community" means in the USA- helping your neighbor, giving to charity, donating time and/or money to support the local community, forming sports leagues for kids funded by the parents and businesses in the local community, having picnics and dinners and holiday events that brings everyone together, and much much more. "Community" in the USA means a great deal more than just living close to your neighbor and walking to the store, it is infinitely better in the USA.
Here in Texas, we have European-style living with bars, restaurants, parks, shops, entertainment and businesses in a planned development They are very nice but it doesn't really work here. Owning a "McMansion" in the suburbs is cheaper than renting an apartment in one of those developments. And most suburbs have every convenience nearby.
This is a huge assumption on your part. I personally have lived in India, and I think that is comparable. Nonetheless, I want to live in a place where I have quiet and space, clean air, low crime rate, and very low cost of living. This is why I have chosen to live in a small town now, here in America, instead of a city. When cities have more green spaces, less noise, then I might consider moving. The closeness of urban life causes too much stress. And to be quite honest, our costs for housing and gas,etc. are extremely low because of living in a rural area.
Thats cool for you, but i don't like people. I need my space and privacy
I live in the US and have been to Sweden, Romania, and the Netherlands (Amsterdam). Where I live, it’s very much like Timisoara Romania. Not all suburbs are the same.
Perhaps you should try living in a suburb. That knife cuts both ways.
Community first is socialist living. Socialism is the interim government when transitioning to communism. The United States suburbs are not the true subject of this article. When a country is taken over by communists, the first thing the people lose is their property. No more property ownership is the subject of this article. Living in the suburbs means open spaces to walk, run, cycle, play any number of games, and space to sit and watch a sunrise or sunset without the noise of the bustling city. If you're bored, drive into town and go-to a club, movie, ball game, or play. There's a grocery store a quarter mile from my suburban home. Within walking distance are a McDonalds, KFC, two Mexican restaurants, a Caribbean restaurant, an optometrist, hair salon, ice cream parlor, liquor store, two gas stations, a car wash, a sandwich shop, orthopedic shoe store, a medical clinic, a mental health inpatient facility, a cancer center, and several schools and churches. Freedom.
Right? People are being fed lies-lies about their financial situation and their control over it (nothing you can do! You need the gvt! Your skin color prevents success! Everyone is racist!). So many lies…I am Hispanic and minimum wage income. Followed the Dave Ramsey ways to manage money and my Puerto Rican parents taught me good values and openness to culture and experience. Now I am 34 expecting my 5th kid (all with my wonderful husband) and live in a nice rural area. Our house is almost paid off-we pay cash for good condition used cars so no car payment ever-mortgage is our remaining debt and will be gone in the next year. Lower income by choice we don’t want cubicle work-my husband didn’t buy the lies. My parents taught me well and I didn’t buy the lies-I’ve never had opportunity blocked for being brown-I gave things up because I realized they were traps. 9-5 is a trap. Where I live is Aroostook County Maine-it doesn’t get whiter than that-yet people have been wonderful-strangers help you for no reason-nobody cares your color-just that you are decent. If you want a bigger income-most have-they can be rich easily as we manage our low income correctly and are living better than ppl we know with more. It’s mismanagement-that’s the problem. You can absolutely get by and no you don’t need socialism-you need a budget and to not use debt-if you have debt use the snowball method to get rid of it and never do it again.
Right on, Leila. Your strong family sounds amazing. You and your husband are living out the American dream.
Plus, each neighborhood has nice wide sidewalks. Our streets have bike lanes. My neighborhood has no HOA and I grow veggies in my back yard with roses and drought resistant plants in the front. As children we rode bikes, flew kites, played touch football, tag, hide and seek, and other normal kid things. Remember yelling CAR!!
Unfortunately these days it's not always safe for kids to play outside anymore.
Well yes and no. I definitely keep an eye on them when they are playing either me or my wife, even though we live well off the main road. Only reason people come to our neighborhood is if you live here or you are lost, but still yes, we keep an eye on them. I think back in my day, I'm 43 so I grew up as a kid in the 80s, I think there was just as much crime back then but there was no social media to put it out there like today. And it was just another time then. I was always out on my own with all my friends all over town and it wasn't a big deal. More accepted back then if that's the right word? But no, I definitely don't think I will let my son roam around the way I did when he gets a little older. I guess it all depends on where you live to. I grew up in a smaller, everyone knows everyone town so....
How different are we? We love our children, grandchildren, our extended family. My friends are my family also. The dangers inherent in the city, the pollution and the school systems made the move to the suburbs a no brainer. I am a born suburbian and played in the woods and made forts, ran from rabid animals made mud pies, rode my bike to the STORES. Went the park, swam in creeks. I did not miss out on anything!!!!!!!!!!! The only thing I missed out on was the types of racism between city and suburb. I am hafu.
That's because you don't have the space and convenience and fairly inexpensive compared with UK shopping that we have. I can order my groceries online, drive up to my local grocery store or Walmart have them loaded into my car or delivered for far cheaper than they cost there. Don't get me wrong, I love the UK and watch mainly British shows. But, everything here is just much easier and more convenient. Also, Children play together in the suburbs. Not sure what your point is.
Part of the problem here is that a lot of posters seem to be confusing Housing Developments with Suburbs. Housing Developments, like the one seen in Edward Scissorhands with identical houses, perfectly manicured lawns with no trees or other foliage, and no nearby businesses do exist, but they are the exception rather than the rule. The suburb where I grew up had a corner drugstore, a diner right next door, a bakery, a pizzeria, and yes, a liquor store all within walking distance. We also had several community parks, picnic areas, and playgrounds. We walked to school and on the street behind mine there was a creek at the bottom of the hill where we sledded in the winter and caught crayfish in the summer. And it seems to me here that a lot of Europeans are criticizing the American way of life while never having lived it, while at the same time accusing us of the same in reverse. Ultimately I believe comfort comes down to what you are used to.
True there's a difference between a Housing Development and Suburb. I though am in a suburb but we don't have anything like you described. Nothing within walking distance. Not that I can walk far anyways due to a chronic illness and chronic pain due to having Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome. But yeah just houses here. It isn't strict nor lenient. But no public transport. Must be nice to be where you grew up. Even where I grew up in North Carolina (currently in Texas) things weren't really like that. In one house there there was a small strip of businesses and I remember one was a salon where I got my hair cut when I was like 12. But unfortunately places like that is real rare it seems.
Load More Replies...The poster of this query should have grown up in Slovakia when it was under the USSR. They would realize how good America is and probably would have tried to defect here. Most only know about America by what they see on TV or movies and we all know how Hollywood screws everything up.
I couldn’t stand living in a high rise apartment. People on top of people. If I want or need something, I get in my truck and go to the store to get it close by. Very easy, no biggie.
That's why the suburbs were created. To get away from being on top of eachother.
Load More Replies...Correction: That’s why urban places outside of downtown and streetcar suburbs were created. Car dependent suburbs were created for three reasons: as an “experiment”, to fuel the car industry, and for white flight reasons.
I don't know if "white flight" was a reason since most white people already lived in white neighborhoods, contrary to myth. Space, nice houses, good schools and safety would be primary reasons. Believe it or not, most white people don't consider race in their primary decision making. There was also post WWII "No down payment for veterans" financing. Those are all the mid-century ranch houses that are still standing today.
Same here. Nothing less pleasant than having to listen to your neighbors, left, right, below above, conceiving their next family member!
This. My suburb has a population density of 2,486/sq.mi. For comparison New York City is 27,000/sq.mi. Absolute hell. I don't know how anyone could stand to live in such tight quarters.
https://www.strongtowns.org/journal/2020/8/27/in-praise-of-streetcar-suburbs?format=amp I suggest you to look at the low density map of this streetcar suburb layout. It’s 7668 people per square mile with mostly single family homes. Lots of people will be able to have their own space while also being able to walk to places. There are more options than car dependent suburbia and the financial district of Manhattan.
Guess what? They’re something in between car dependent suburbia and 50 floor apartments. People just don’t know because US cities are usually one extreme or another. You should check out streetcar suburbs built before the postwar car dependent white picket fence craze.
There does need to be better public transportation and it needs to be clean, safe and fast. NYC subways are a disgrace. Filthy, rat infested and dangerous. I lived in Japan in the 80s and 6 year olds would go to school on the trains alone.
I don't live in a high rise apartment and can still walk to the grocery store, to public transport and to my family doctor (and in a pinch also to the library, although I'd rather take the bus at least back :P ) ... the problem seen is not so much the idea of the single family home, but of there being no useful buildings within walking distance and cities in general apparently not planned to be used by humans, who get around using their feet. Having to have a car is unnatural.
THANK YOU!!! I’ve literally had to tell people that there are more places than 100ppl/sq mi car dependent suburbs with no amenities within 5 miles and 100000ppl/sq mi skyscraper areas with 50 floor apartments.
Some people like the peace and quiet of suburbs, especially when raising a family. Yuppie cosmopolitan snobs stay mad. I'm glad I grew up in the suburbs. My early years were spent in a more urban setting, and it had gangs, crime, graffiti, homeless, and other wonderful culture lol.
You know just because you are avoiding those things doesn't mean their not still a massive societal problem in america right? That isn't city culture btw, it's american culture.
Load More Replies...Where I live there are no gangs, no crime, no homeless people. Maybe a little crime in the poorest neighbourhoods. Homeless people are taken care for in a humain way.
Because your country either exported their poor and criminals to the new world or killed them in a World War. So tired of the centuries old "we're better than you" Euros - when is that ever gone wrong?
Yeah, I don’t think it works like that. Because if it works like you said, then the solution for poverty and crime would be to kill off all the poor and criminals, and none would spawn over 100 years? No, for example, we don’t have many homeless people where I live, because in the end, every single homeless person is provided with a place to stay through social welfare, because it is physically almost impossible to survive one winter outside here… and the humane thing to do. And, at least where I am from, criminals are not seen as someone who should die or rot in jail, but someone who is in jail to repent and to rehabilitate to be a part of the community, study and learn day-to-day skills, and be treated with respect and empathy. So that when they are set free, they have kept their humanity and empathy intact, and they can actually survive on their own, evaluate their life choises and not again have to turn to crime due to money/bad friends/etc.
The whole world went to America and now that they come to Europe and we have no houses for them, they stay outside on chairs. Easy to blame America for not being as social as a tiny rich European country, but now that all the poor ppl come, they aren't as social anymore. Poles can live with 20 in a house and do the horrible bad paid jobs.
You must be from England. I watch alot of British TV and they're always slamming the Poles. Half my ancestors came from Poland around the turn of the 20th century and the other half came from England in the 1700s. My DNA is always at war with each other.
Your comment does not fit the BP agenda; I'm surprised it got past their PC Police. Good for you for having the courage to write with common sense and clarity.
That’s why there should be more walkable streetcar suburbs and less car dependent suburbs. Car dependent suburbs often have high crime too, and specific types. For example, school shootings often due to isolation. In my experience, I’ve seen just as many homeless in the suburbs as the city. People who think living in a place with copy paste houses, identical lawns, no real nature, and no amenities within 5 miles is better than any other place to raise a family are the same people who wonder why their kids don’t play outside enough.
HOAs are Karen breeding grounds. I'd never live in an area with one if there was any other choice.
First rule of house hunting to our realtor was do NOT show us ANY homes with an HOA!
Load More Replies...This comment is hidden. Click here to view.
A dozen drive thrus of the ghetto with the windows rolled up and doors locked, gingerly stepping over broken paving and urine puddles, and you were skipping up to the gates of a secured community like Dorothy and Toto
Karen breeding grounds! I love it! It's a prerequisite for each block to have a karen to keep things lively. This is why I live in New Hampshire in a rural area. 5 + acres, flower gardens, deer in the back yard. Lawns prevent soil erosion.
Not really, it’s more like “people need to keep up their homes and not let them get dilapidated over time”. When people let their homes go (ie: not keep up with maintenance issues, let the outside paint peel and look disgusting, not keep their yards clean and free from non-running project cars up on blocks, etc.) it brings the neighborhood home values down. NO ONE WANTS TO LIVE NEXT/NEAR A HOME THAT LOOKS LIKE A JUNK YARD! A home will be the most valuable thing you’ll purchase in your lifetime (for most people) and I’m sure you don’t want to loose money when you go to sell your home.
My first house had an HOA. Bought the house because of the price. Hated the HOA. Next house, no HOA. And guess what all my neighbors keep neat lawns and do their maintenance without an HOA. HOAs are horrible. The people who run them are control freaks.
Our current house is around 70 years old and the other house is being built on vacant land less than a quarter mile from Lake Erie. No developments, no HOA's.
I tried finding a place with no HOA when I moved. There wasn't one. Every frickin neighborhood.
But not every house. I bought a house in a HOA neighborhood that was specifically excluded from the HOA, so no fees, no rules, etc. It's also twice the size of the other houses, and the land alone accounts for about 25% of the entire community.
Some hoas aren't as strict as others. We pay $350/year and it covers community lawn maintenance. But we all get together twice a year to clean/pretty up the front entrance area. But we do have Karen's and kens who like to stir up trouble 😵💫
It depends on the style of hoa. For instance our takes care of all the yard work, security and the pools and walking paths. There are no arbitrary landscaping rules because its all covered by the hoa itself.
No it doesn't though, all it takes is for a few controlling neighbors to tke over the board and your toast. Next thing you know, some jerk is measuring your grass, sending you notices that the Christmas lights you put up are too "colorful" and another one demanding you park your car in the garage at night under penalty of a fine if you dont. Ask me how I know. I moved into one that had 2 requirements, keep the yard clean and house in good condition. When I sold my house, there was a booklet of what was "allowed", "not allowed" and ANY alteration needed to be approved by the board.
I feel sorry for you. That kind of overlord control should be illegal. HOAs should NOT be able to fine anyone as if they were the police. What's stopping them from going further? Americans, of all people, should understand the consequences of when we give up our rights to anyone.
That's called a lien. Anyone you owe money to can sue you and if you don't pay the judge will force the sale of your home to pay what you owe. That's not an HOA-specific thing.
We had a condo homeowner not pay her dues for over 2 years with the the old homeowners board, they let the homeowner not pay and they ended up getting their unpaid dues up to $14,000 (they were fined for not paying after 150 days), while all the other 107 homeowners were paying their dues on time each month. The dues are to help maintain the overall esthetic of our complex: landscaping, asphalt resurfacing, repainting of strips and numbered/guest spots, gutter cleaning, etc.
A few bad apple always will ruin a good pie… that’s what happens when you live in a free-for-all neighborhood and there’s not a structured guideline to help homeowners the keep their homes kept up. It’s not taking the rights to freedom away, it’s keeping the neighborhood looking respectable and inviting to enter.
Many people move into landscape controlled hoas for the one reason that they hate doing yard work. I personally would love to never mow my yard again and thats why im in an hoa like this. But plenty of people like the outdoors and dont understand this mindset. Both ways are fine, the main problems arise from people who join an hoa sign the contract then try to ignore the legally binding rules they signed no matter how dumb they think they are. A signed contract is a signed contract.
You can pay for lawn service without signing your life over so a bunch of curtain twitching Karens with nothing better to do than crawl up your bum looking for something they can use to blackmail you into bankrupting yourself.
This comment is hidden. Click here to view.
You'd think so, but we have heard far more about Johnny Depp and Amber Heard than the overturning of Roe v Wade.
Not necessarily, in many hoas not every rule can be changed even by a unanimous board ruling. For instance the lanscaping, security, solar panel, pool maintenance rules in our hoa requires a 98% for vote of every owner in the complex. We have 500 homes so any change to the basic tenants requires a full bosrd aproval and a yes votes from 490 of the 500 homes.
How nice of them...a book of ways to p**s off hoa bullies...saves me the time of thinkin up something on my own...lol
Yep, my relatives live some place like that. They can choose the front door wreath and that's about it. And keep the garage door closed.
This comment is hidden. Click here to view.
The irony is that these people decrying the result of these HOAs in suburbs are liberal urbanites. But an HOA is nothing more than a democratic government done at small scale. I'm not a fan of HOAs for the same reason I don't like an unnecessarily controlling government.
So, your gardens aren't your gardens, because there's always some strangers being there mowing and planting stuff. How's that not weird? What if you want to garden yourself? What if you want your garden to be different from what the HOA sent guys do? What if you want to have no strangers being on your property, because you might just enjoy bein alone there and scratch your butt in peace and unwatched?
Baleygr, amazonqt sounds like she's/he's talking about a condo or townhouse community, rather than a single family home community
That’s what ours does (minus the pool- they didn’t put in a pool bc they were worried about the liability) all of our roofs, siding, gutters are covered and insurance (if anything happens walls in) is covered by the HOA insurance. So, for an example, if the toilet overflows/septic backs up and damages the flooring, any cabinets, baseboards or walls, the HOA pays up to $25,000 of that damage and then the homeowners insurance kicks in after that. We’ve had (in the passed 3 years) about 8 homes (out of 108 units) that have had this issue and a few others. I love not having to do landscaping or maintenance upkeep on the outside of our homes- it’s all done by the HOA, from the dues we pay each month. We have an attached garage and a detached garage, which is also on the maintenance program each week for upkeep. They pressure wash all the buildings and the walkways when needed. It’s really nice.
I live in a townhouse and my next door neighbor is the President and you've never met someone with such boundary and control issues. She treats my property as though it's hers. I have put up barriers and she is SO POed at me she slams her door whenever she leaves her house!😂😂😂😂
But not living within a HOA community means you could live next to someone that has several non-working project vehicles up on blocks in their yard, a dilapidated house with a roof caving in from roofing being placed on top of roofing over the years, over grown front and back lawn, etc. I’ll take my chances with the HOA helping to keep the property up- which is what my hubby and I have done since 2007. We just had our siding on our condo building (built in 1993) renovated to hardy planking in 2020 along with all new windows (updated to code) throughout and a new roof (updated to code). And we didn’t have to pay for it all out of pocket (which would have between $30,000-$45,000 if we had to pay for it ourselves), but we just pay an extra $200 on top of our HOA dues we pay for each month (along with 107 other condo owners in our complex).
European suburbs aren't great either but for many different reasons
I'm interested, too. I watch alot of British tv and their suburban houses look alot like ours without the big yards.
Then don't. This is the beauty of America. Free choice. Some people like them because they don't have time nor the inclination to do yard work. Only dumbass people who don't like hoas and move into one are the idiots. Then they try to change the rules. Typical libs, if we don't live according to them, they demand change.
Typical Libs? ROFL! I'm a lib and I love my HOA. BTW, it's the other guys who are forcing us to live like they prefer so get off your horse and accept your neighbors as the typical humans they are.
This comment is hidden. Click here to view.
If you live in an area covered by an HOA, you help make the rules. If you do not like them, change them! This is democracy at its best. Go to the meetings and ask questions, complain, and get the majority of homeowners on your side. If you do not like the HOA rules, do not buy a house there.
Anyone who would describe HOAs as "democracy at its best" is not to be taken seriously.
This comment is hidden. Click here to view.
HOAs: 1) Keep property values up, no wrecked junkers in front yards or ugly swingsets. 2) Maintain the community grounds. 3) Maintain the community resources like swimming pools, athletics facilities, and tennis courts etc. 4) Maintain security and a safer environment.
I live in a very small town in Pennsylvania in the US. I have a rather large yard that's broken up by many large trees, some bearing fruit, a small koi pond, herb gardens, and four large vegetable plots. We walk to the post office and bank, and store sometimes. This doesn't address typical suburbs, though, which I personally don't care for. The US is really a huge country, which does explain the sprawl, somewhat. There are a lot of factors at play which brought about the suburbs.
I live in a Suburb just outside Boston... We have stores and schools etc where you can walk or use other transportation. My property is half surrounded by forest and we have a stream... It's also Conservation Land. Meaning we can only change so much, in order to protect the environment. However I can walk the length of my street (probably 1 mile) and get to the grocery store, banks, CVS, Dunkin's etc. The town I grew up is a DRY town, no liquor stores... The town I live in now (30 min from my childhood house) has one of the biggest Malls in our State. Everywhere is different. I def agree with Tamra!
Load More Replies...Yours is an exception to the rule. Consider also that you are just outside a major metropolitan city, which has a large impact on its surrounding areas. The typcial suburb across the country is simply a vast wasteland of cardboard houses, multi-car garages, and little else. First rule of statistics, you cannot use an exception to define a majority. First rule in sociology, you can't use personal experience, or anectdotal experience to define a majority either.
You're outside of Boston that's old school. Like literally 13 colonies old school...
No, strict very crude zoning is what brought it on in large cities. In stead of using the space efficiently, crazy huge distances between stores and homes are a thing. And the nothing in between comes from laws that are just plain racist. https://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/how-federal-government-intentionally-racially-segregated-american-cities-180963494/ That doesn't mean it's as bad everywhere, it just means that literal black and white thinking (it's either high rise or detached, nothing in between) results in broke cities because with such space comes impossible to maintain infrastructure. You really need to read up on your own history and maybe experience life outside of the us to have an opinion about this...
And BINGO was his name!! Thank u!! Maj. Whites I've sumized, feel racism has been over since 70's with "occasional' sit's..since only approx 23% @ most of populat. being Black persons, many Whites either by design of White Flight/Exodus, or rural areas don't live near or with Black persons. It allows their White privilege to continue. Yet are completely unaware of it @least 90% of the time. Well, untill it's threatened!! By allowing seemingly "less" harmful-"little"racist thoughts, sayings=actions, it continue 2 b tolerated. Those that want 2 stand up-but don't want 2 be viewed trying to stir things up/insult in ppl in their home-etc. I Recog. my own FLABBY-considerate, yet righteous indig. stand-taking- 2 get firm-back in front/center- vowed to stop my selfish silence. Finding every Fact, Truth, & Proof, being earnest, & considerate as poss., Yet 2 stand up 2 these "little" deep rooted Poisonous ideas--& b Roundup again! God's Kindom Gov't-Eradicates soon!!!
The chief reason is the automobile and the desire to get away from poorly designed and overcrowded cities. And now, we're paying for it because we're stuck in this way of life.
Yeah you can get dropped off in any Main Street in America and any neighborhood in America it was rare exception not know where you're at because everything looks exactly the horrible same.
I also live in a very small town in PA. We have a decent yard with a small pond at the end, trees, a garden and all wildflowers that I planted. I'm ten minutes from town, but have nature as my backyard and can do what we'd like (for the most part) on the land. I'm less than a five minute's walk from a river. I love it here.
The country is so big, probably 75% of it is still virgin forest or desert. We can have as much land as we can afford.
No, actually the vast majority of so-called virgin forest was chopped down and used for home building in their respected areas, or lumbering long before most of us were born. Most virgin forest is within either State or Federally protected areas set aside for posterity like the Adirondacks, or Yellow Stone and such places. Agriculture did away with most of what home building didn't, even up until the 70s. It wasn't that long ago that 80% of the population was rural and involved in some kind of farming. That number reversed by the 50s through the 80s. Now 80% of the population lives in the cities. Consider that we are now at 330,000,000 people, and fity years ago only 195,000,000.
Really scraping the bottom of the barrel in terms of “things to pretend are bad in America”. They’re just houses, calm down.
Agreed. They're just houses and I live in one and everything I need is right around the corner. Not a problem.
Load More Replies...Do you drive to these places in your car, though? If you ride your bike, how often, and what do you do with your bike?
I love where I live; there is an outdoor mall a ten minute walk from where I live in each direction. But I live in Texas and where I am it's gated communities with shopping centers on every corner. But in the city close by, it's gas stations and cvs's on every corner rather than a whole shopping center. So suburbs are different everywhere.
I live in a home, only thing within 2 miles a bar, video game shop (gambling) and a gas station. What we do not have, sidewalks, food nor bus stop. Capital City in our state. ALL due to greed, Ford cars screwed the American people.
Times have changed since Model-T. They've got other companies nowadays. Cars didn't "do" anything. People wanted a convenience that was unimaginable, back then. Blame the donkeys or horses, for making people too lazy, back in the olden days. If people hadn't gotten a taste of getting over the hill and back in the same day, maybe we wouldn't have felt the need to get their faster. I blame the dinosaurs for dying and turning into oil. They started it.
Well… your avatar was chosen wisely, that much I can say about your comment. But the truth is that much was done specifically and purposely to undermine the existing mass transit system that existed at the time Ford's cars were being sold. The grants, tax credits, etc., that were provided to various elements of the auto industry to expand it while at the same time undermine everything else is only a part of it all. Whole books have been written and classes taught about this. It is all much more complex than you seem to want to think.
This comment is hidden. Click here to view.
They're not "just houses," the people who live there share a particular mindset. They have been called "sh*tlibs."
I don't think these questions were meant to be, bad things in America necessarily but rather trying understand a different way of life. Honestly my daughter has had similar questions and she has never been out of the United States. No one can deny, most Americans are more private which feeds what looks to be lonely neighborhoods. One more thing, I have lived in the city, countryside and in suburbs. They all have their pluses and minuses.
That's the way I took it. Every country is different. Different cultures, etc. I really think this person was just trying to understand these differences. I, myself, have a lot of questions about HOAs.
HOAs can be annoying, but they provide a set of rules that help ensure your house maintains value. I personally don't like them, but I can understand why other people do.
This comment is hidden. Click here to view.
There is nothing negetive about living in a suburb
Gosh, how I wish I could live in your State. I hear that in the State of Denial, they don't have to pay taxes either and that everything is free too! Like the infrastructure fairy keeps all the roads in good repair, and she pays the salaries and benefits of the po po, and the fire beaters too! Not to mention, those of the teachers, and keeps the schools, and libraries well cared for. Denial is just one of those ideal places where everyone seems to want to relocate to these days if they don't already live there like you do!
Very true. When run fairly and with fairness, HOA's are both necessary and beneficial. I think what partly lies behind some people's hatred of them is that they do not like rules, or being told what to do or not do. Unfortunately, without rules and guidelines, there are always going to be those who use the absence of them to take advantage of situations that cause problems for the rest of the community. This is like hating government, for government’s sake. This is an idiotic meme that has taken root in the conservative world, but it lacks serious thought. The idea is that people are good at self-policing themselves. Unfortunately, that isn't true, with far more instances to prove that than not. But facts are not an accepted concept when they go against those who want the freedom to do whatever they wish, regardless of how it affects those around them. In fact, they don't care, and that is at the root of the problem.
Yeah but a lot of the responses were self deprecating Americans crying the woe in disparity of, as one person but it, “forced suburbia”. I get tired of hearing Americans to cry everything about America and everything in Europe is just tiptop 100% great.
They would stop crying about it if idiots like you would stop voting to keep it below the rest of the civilized world.
This comment is hidden. Click here to view.
I've seen a lot of the world. You "idiots" can have it. Why should we vote to be like you. YTA and I don't envy the people around you.
Everything on Bored Panda is negative towards America. It gets really old.
It really does. I mind my own business, every man in my family are combat veterans, my brother was a volunteer firefighter and I was a volunteer emt. Why does the rest of the world make us out to be monsters? I watch the news, I know what goes on in the rest of the world. People forget how huge our country really is and it's under ONE government. We aren't multiple small countries under separate governments. It's hard enough to keep track of all the c**p that happens here. P.S. I vote, in every election, even the midterms.
As of early 2022, the WHO announced the results of its current population longevity ratings. Those in the EU, Singapore, and other nation's life-spans have increased to the low 80s. As for us, here in America? Our average life-spans have decreased, dropping below the 70s to the high 60s. This has nothing to do with the pandemic as the EU and other countries were hit just as hard if not more so and still their longevity has increased. So, despite not liking to self-reflect and criticize issues we're deficient in, those issues exist anyway and in increasingly more depressing ways with each passing year. Pretending that America is and will always be #1 in all things is an unfortunate denial. It is that denial that is partially contributing to our decline, another is greed. Unfortunately, it is denial that seems to be in the majority, which does not bode well for us at all.
Actually, the average American lifespan is 78. It has been for a long time. Plenty of people are living even longer, into their 80s and 90s. But, being 80 is a tough life. My husband works in a retirement facility. Medications, constant doctor appointments, caretakers. Your license gets taken away, as it should.
Is it not more the dearth of mid density housing in the US tends to mean it is suburbs or urban? I live in a UK suburb. I can easily walk to most things and take public transport where I can't. If there were some towns designed like college campuses that were walkable I think that would be a nice alternative.
Yes they do, but in this case, those pluses and minuses are not balancing each other out. It's an equation that currently we are beginning to pay for in many ways, because it is a lopsided one. I understand not wanting to contribute to what is a conflict of interest, but sometimes trying to equate both sides of an issue as being equal when it isn't is being overly diplomatic. As for our privacy, that we do have, but that too is coming at a serous cost. Of all the western industrialized nations, we have become one of the least cohesive societies as a result of that desire to be left alone. It's as if we've all succumbed to some Norma Desmond neurotic syndrome.
Personally I am glad this article exists. I never thought a place on earth existed where people live in big agglomeration like the suburbs and there's no convenience store within walking distance, a Cafe, a restaurant or even bus stops, or even more important, clinics and or/hospital. That's mind blowing to me. How do the elderly live? How do people go shopping? Is car required to exist there? I have so many questions! In any other country housing in such an area would be so devalued. Main focus for housing value is how close it is to basic necessities and from my understanding, suburbs there have none of that? It's like living in the country side with none of the perks of country side but all the issues..!
Cars are required to live here,yes. You drive to the store. Maybe 10 minutes drive. My old neighborhood had a convenience store within walking distance, and that neighborhood is about 7 miles from my current one. There's transportation services for the elderly to get to the doctor, but they kinda suck. I have a vegetable garden. The kids use the grass as a playing surface, soccer and baseball, running in the sprinkler when it's hot. I like it because I can't hear my neighbors on the other side of the wall, but I do see and talk to them when I'm outside. Privacy when I want it, social opportunity when I want that too. It's a luxury to have this space.I grew up in an apartment in the city, I don't think I could go back to the crowded noise. But true country life us isolating. This is a happy medium
We live in the country - and the noise from town is the cars. When we have an ice event or during COVID - everything was so quiet. Same with early mornings on the front porch. I'd love to live in a place where walking and biking were the norm and cars were the exception. Even quiet cars like EVs make alot of noise with their tires at 40+ mph. We love cars - and own several - including antiques but we see a big need to change how American cities function...
Change begins at home. Having multiple vehicles while stating you wish America could make big changes to the contrary is somewhat incongruent. Also, living far out away from those things that are typical of and what make properly functioning cities work such as efficient and effective mass transportation is another issue. We say it doesn't work, because we don't want it to work. We elect politicians who systematically under fund it and other programs so as to set them up to fail. Then, when they do, they can run straight to the media screaming to one and all “See we told you! Government can't do anything!” And then we believe it our self-fulfilling prophecies, of which we have many.
When we lived in Texas, the town we were in had laws against public transit of any kind, no alleys, and no sidewalks. That's because (and I'm quoting a sheriff's deputy here), "if you don't have a car you have no business being here and buses only bring (racist epithet deleted) here."
That is why I would never wish to live there, or anywhere like it. To think that there are enough people living in such a place that they allow that to be is astonishing. It isn't as if they can't change it if they truly wished to. The fact that they don't, says everything one needs to know about those who live there.
You raise important and valid questions. But despite our wanting to accept or believe it, Americans are and have always been in the midst of a class struggle. One of the ways one groups likes to believe they are above the other, or have “made it”, is by moving out into the suburbs. To live in the burbs is in some way a status symbol and means you've attained the “American Dream”. It is also very much rooted in racism. Being that minorities are disproportionately poorer, particularly Black people, moving out to the burbs has always been a way to self-segregate.
Why would I want to cluster around those places? I can get to a hospital in fifteen minutes, a store in five or so minutes. My elderly relative lived in her own home alone after her husband died, and that is how she wanted it. We like our space and our gardens and less people sticking their noses into our business.
If you are having a heart attack (or stroke) you only have five minutes to re-establish blood flow to keep your heart muscle (or neurons) alive. 15 minutes is likely a death sentence; severe disability at a minimum.
I wouldn't be driving myself to that hospital. The fire department is just up the road. They have ambulances.
Well, for the elderly, medicare will arrange rides to doctor appointments. Otherwise, there's Lyft, Uber, taxis. A lot of elderly live in communities that help take care of them. Not, necessarily homes, over 55 communities.There's also caretakers and aides. I haven't had a car, myself, for a couple years, I do miss the autonomy having one provides. I can get around, it's just a hassle. And there is a commuter train stop in town, but I have to taxi to it. But, I could get into NYC, if I wanted to.
We use our car. Elderly are helped by others. You need a car in winter anyway or if you have kids and babies and groceries. You can’t carry that by hand. The bus was ok when I was young and it was only me and maybe one bag-but even then it was very unpleasant you never knew who would sit next to you when it got full-a smelly, crazy weirdo who might follow you home? A pickpocket? The fights that would happen even on the bus-it’s just not safe or good for kids. You also have to live by the bus schedule and route. I like the freedom of our own vehicle to go where we want, when we want. We go shopping by getting into by getting into the van and driving the 5-10 minutes to the grocery store downtown-or maybe even up the street if you live on the far far ends of Main Street (that’s us-it doesn’t feel like main st which is nice!) I used to live in a more “convenient” area as people see it-but I would NEVER go back to that. I’ll take driving 2 hrs for the Walmart for the peace we have.
The more "regular people" ride mass transit - the less percentage of weirdos are there to shape the experience. Ride mass transit in another country. More regular folks going to school or work or shopping. They sort of set a standard. Also, countries help their addicts and homeless - not leaving these people to struggle along day to day.
One of the major reason reasons all them weirdos are out and about these past three plus decades is because Reagan and his conservative congress began defunding and thus closing down all the state hospitals. That along with continued underfunding and cutting of already seriously lacking social programs for decades has made matters not only worse, but at this point so systemic that it is doubtful anything can be done to solve these problems. But no one wants to pay taxes-- for anything, let alone social services, teachers, roads, fire and safety, etc. So we get what we deserve. There is a reason why other countries “help their addicts and homeless”, and that is done through the taxes they pay. It is something they choose and accept because they understand the benefits to their community. But we're too selfish to understand that, thinking only of our desires. What we don't understand, we disparage ridiculously.
This comment is hidden. Click here to view.
>>"I never thought a place on earth existed" _____________________ Seriously. You need to buy yourself of set of Encyclopedia, or get off social media and find educational websites, with no comment sections. Crack a book maybe.
This comment is hidden. Click here to view.
It seems to me if an American approached an issue this way, they would be called ignorant and stupid. Yet Europeans can act willfully dim on such an easy thing to understand, all for the purpose of saying, "If it's not like how we do it, it's bad." It's ultimately just a continuance of an attitude of arrogance and superiority that is so common from a European. In reality, it is simply close-mindedness and small thinking that allows you to be so dismissive of American differences.
No, they just mock out s**t hole country for being slaves to corporations and putting the beauty of houses before our own people. As they should.
Now this sounds like an answer, thank you. (The advantage of living in the countryside in Europe over the American suburb is still though that you can survive even without a car. It's not much great but it's possible. And we are allowed to grow damn plants on soil we own...(there probably isn't a place where this wouldn't be possible, I mean.))
No it's just easier to see those things from the outside .. of course there are similar things in Europe looking weird to Americans. I have sat in traffic to work many times thinking when did this become normal each person sitting in a 2 to 4 ton tin can wasting fossil fuel during an hour of commute...every day. Nobody questions it.
"It's not really that bad in America, the internet skews a lot." "It's literally that bad in America."
This comment is hidden. Click here to view.
Lots of people question it, it's just such a dumb question, nobody bothers answering it.
I disagree... These questions are pretending it's bad. They're pointing out that they are literally bad. They exist to segregate classes, increase the fuel industry while decreasing community/development/public transport. They increase peoples inability to access necessities in a timely manner. Etc. Those questions literally make sense because American suburbs are literally incapable of self sustaining themselves
I agree. If the suburbs don't suit you, you can live in the city or more urbane area alongside businesses. Also, many people like their lawns just the way they are abs kids don't play with grass. That's what toys, swingsets, athletic equipment etc is for. Most people that move to suburbs do so for the yards and the distance from business traffic. This is a bunch of hogwash.
I prefer to live where there are large spaces between homes, no businesses except people having fruit or veggies stands or egg stands, homemade soaps-no ugly stores or loud bars. Peace, quiet, and privacy. Lots of space for my kids to run, and lots of other kids doing the same. I’ve lived in apartment complexes and apartment houses where my kids had to share their yard space-kids from other houses would destroy our kids outdoor toys, heavy older kids would use my little kids’ swing set without permission, they’d uncover the sandbox when we weren’t home and peoples outdoor cats would poop in it (and in our veggie gardens). Kids would dig up the veggies our kids proudly planted as soon as it germinated. I think they’d wait for us to not be home to do this. More than once they used our hose and got everything wet (increased water bill!). Cops would have to be called from loud music at 1am-not just normal but LOUD waking babies and kids, and people who work. I’d prefer a suburb with fence.
This comment is hidden. Click here to view.
Hogwash? Calm down Karen. Go turn on your oxygen tank and fix news
It's the usual gaw everything in America equals bad?!? I wish we could put a disclaimer on any of these types of posts that the poster represents no one other than himself. Cities, towns and suburbs differ all over the country and trying to pretend like any one voice represents the experience of every American is absurd. Plenty of people live in walkable areas with plenty of public transport. Also weird that someone would purposely move into a planned community and have an issue with it; there's a problem there but it's probably you.
The only problem America has is that there are too many people in the country that we don't want to live next to. I'm white, but I'm not talking about racial prejudice. Living next to a respectable minority family is the least of my worries. I'm talking about moral values, law-abiding, and perhaps economic values. I don't want to live near any: drug addicts, drug gang members, criminals, or other lowlife; or "good ol' boy" rednecks or other white trailer trash. If I could be assured that those kind people wouldn't be in my neighborhood, I could gladly live anywhere. I think that is true about all of us. We just don't want to have to deal with the systemic social problems that America has right now, and living in the suburbs gives us a way to avoid it. I do wish that they would be more progressive. I would appreciate more public transportation, just so I wouldn't have to face my daily commute every day. And it would be better for our environment - not to have so many cars on the road.
You do realize the article did state it was found drug abuse and overdose is prevalent in suburban communities often right? I get it though. I've lived city life 80% of my life and you tend to be reminded of America's societal failings daily here.
It sounds to me like you're part of the social problems that you decry. I think that you need to get out of your bubble and grow some compassion. It's all about "me" with you, which is a huge contributing factor in our society.
"We live in the suburbs because we want our social, mental health and addiction issues hidden away in McMansions rather than out on the street where everyone can see it and might be forced to do something about it" If you don't think your perfect suburbs aren't full of drugs, racism, criminals and lowlifes, then you're living in wilful oblivion.
Still those weird hoods with the blatant disadvantages cited above exist, and I suppose there are many... But you are right, it should be claimed somewhere this isn't the only way American suburbs are like. It actually was - although the final message of this article hits a bit as you describe... And yes, your argument "if you don't like it move elsewhere" has something to it. But, let's hope their ideal living ("suburbia without the crazy HOA and with buses") is possible to be made reality without much extra cost... (I'm not American and sorry for my English)
The way the American society functions is bad. By design. It is designed to extract the maximum profits from each and every one of us. And the side effects are undesirable. Most people have little job security, must own and operate expensive cars, there are cultural differences caused by economic differences (schools' budgets being tied to neighborhood tax revenue rather than every school getting the same budgets) which is just discrimination. Until these things (and more) are corrected then I too would rather live in my smallish town on a big patch of ground that gives us privacy. However, it doesn't have to be that way. Changes to how our economy functions and how our society is designed could create more diversified neighborhoods that would be desirable places to live in closer proximity to our neighbors. More walking or bicycling, less driving. People who are more uniformly and reliably employed and thus not pushed out of society to live on the fringes in poverty. It is complex...
It's not scrapping the barrel. You should look at this zoning in the US, the answers do get some clues (you seem not to have read those). This thing in the US is definitely pretty bad.
Things ARE bad in America. Take off your rose colored boomer glasses and look around. These are all valid points.
I’m a millennial and I’ve lived in the crowded areas with business and now a rural area-rural and suburban beats crowded city. There is a lot wrong with our county but suburban living is not it-most young families dream of either the suburbs (best for kids) or rural (also great for kids, but fewer other kids to play with). Don’t confuse suburbs with HOAs-those are the ones where you pay a fee to have everything controlled.
Yeah, it is sort of a silly article. Most people find suburbs a desirable place to live-- all the conveniences of living in the big city without all the hassle of partiers, crime, traffic, and other things you would find while living in the city.
But the convenience of living in the big city IS the urban life, lots of cafés and bars, public transportation and not needing a car to get around, lots of shopping possibilities including the obscure small shops in in side streets...
Shopping ain't all it's cracked up to be. I like to get in, get what I need, and get out and go home. I don't need lots of shopping possibilities.
I like to walk to the grocery store if I notice that I don't have any bread left ... Also the freedom that I have not to be shackled to the need to own my own car. Not to mention the independence I could enjoy as an older child and teenager, able to go to a corner store to buy sweets and comic books, drive to the library on my own via public transport and all such things.
Yeah... White people to get away from minorities... It's literally why they were developed
Black and Hispanic people love the suburbs too! Decent ones do. I am Puerto Rican, brown skin and all! My relatives all bought single family homes in the suburbs and they are content living there, and growing veggies in the fenced in yard. My own household chose to move to rural Aroostook County, Maine. There may not be many people of my own culture up there but that has never mattered to me (honestly they don’t like the cold, don’t like change, and don’t adapt to new cultures well) but I am more open minded and moved up here. Loving the Acadian culture and the ability to cross into Canada daily if I want. I love driving around and seeing cows on green hills instead of apartments and stores. Used to live in Massachusetts and it was a nightmare. We have the stores we need near center of town anyone can drive 5 min when they need to get stuff-but at home you can relax and kids play in fenced in yard. My point is-it’s not White people getting away from minorities-it’s decent hard working people (of any race or nationality) wanting to live in a decent place and have a peaceful quiet life. Oh and there are a few fellow Puerto Ricans up here and one PR family owns the one tattoo shop-they have done well and are important in our small town of 3,000. They came up after Maria and were welcomed-people gave furniture and helped them get established-now they run a successful business.
Did you just insinuate that minorities are responsible for crime in big cities??? Just wanna make sure I understand your point.
Didn't sound like it to me. Perhaps you wrote something in your mind that wasn't there?
Minorities have been short changed for decades. We see the consequences every day. In my state, the minority neighborhoods are the poorest and their schools have the least amount of money to spend on each student and to hire faculty and maintain the school. Guess what that looks like? Guess what the long term consequences are? Same at the edge of the counties where the poor whites live. Long distance commutes to work and shop, substandard schools, etc - same as in the minority neighborhoods. And, the similar problems with drugs and violence. As money moves into these places (educated people move in) - everything improves, and the problems diminish (diluted?) Perhaps help the poorer neighborhoods along sooner than when growth do it automatically decades later?
Actually, no. My area of the suburbs has seven houses, three white families, three black, and one is vacant for now. We used to have some nice Mexicans who lived on the street back behind our house on the other side of the woods. One of our dogs loved to go visit them.
But the economic impact of these houses is imo quite severe, so much so they have led to some cities going bankrupt. I strongly recomend watching Not just bikes’ Strong Town series.
Right?! I’m in CA and public transportation is everywhere. All over. Also prop 13 is a good thing which allows generations to pass down family homes without bankrupting the rest of their family.
Thank you for understanding. Finally. Someone from another country (I’m guessing from the Britain flag on the username) understands.
Nope. They're not just houses. It's a cultural phenomenon that is unique to us. That and the fact that suburban lifestyle is vastly different from city lifestyle. It is even different from what some consider true or strict rural living. It isn't so simplistic as being just about “houses”. Thinking it suggests that you either haven't spent much time elsewhere, or are not that observant as to the environment around you and don't care to be, or live in the suburbs and don't like reading critical articles about it. So, this is your passive-aggressive way of letting everyone know that, while trying to seem above it all. So which is it, or is it all of the above? Because, your comment is not really accomplishing what you would expect of it.
Only a fool or a Karen would love ve under a HOA. 😄 Thank God HOAs are few and far between.
I regret so much I am too young I can't compare the Communism here with the today's reality (as presented by the internet) of for example America....
Tell me you don't understand communism without telling me you don't understand communism.
Californian, born and raised, and even I am amazed that people can be talked into forming/joining an HOA. I don't think the organizers of such things even have good intentions, considering the petty, self-important dictators that gravitate to these positions of "power". They might pitch the idea as something that will be beneficial for all, but, on the inside, they're just salivating at the chance to tell other people what to do. There's a lot of embezzling that goes on, too.
This comment is hidden. Click here to view.
Its poor design and planning, we need to be building and zoning up, not outward. You rural bumpkins really don't know what's best.
I love how you are so stupid the only comeback you had was something a second grader would come up with. "I know you are but what am I?"
I’ve lived in a crowded area and it was a nightmare-try living somewhere nice and rural and tell me you would then want to go back to living with neighbors messing with your kids stuff-cops having to stop criminals-hearing domestic violence-hearing kids get smacked and then wailing-your plants getting dug up-having to see people’s garbage and hoards building up in their windows and yards attracting pests to everyone’s property…that’s a nightmare! Now I can make my breakfast and eat it on the porch under my hanging flower basket-sit on the porch swing-grow veggies with my kids-send them to the backyard to play while I clean, even my 2 year old because it’s fenced and and as safe as any other room inside my house. My neighbor is friendly and has pretty flowers and little figurines on her front porch. My kids pick flowers for her and say hello. I push my baby on the swing. My daughter does homework on the trampoline. We make s’mores and grill hotdogs. It’s wonderful.
God forbid you don't/can't drive (minors, elders, disabled, temporarly injured...)... In Italy we do have some places like that, where all you get is houses, no stores, no bars, no schools... They are called quartieri-dormitorio (dormitory blocks), but it's usually very low-income neighborhoods, definitely not middle/upper class... And it's considered a bad thing honestly
Tell me about it I am disabled, can't drive, and live in RURAL America. I'm pretty much a hermit unless someone takes me somewhere
Load More Replies...Europe isn’t always better. Many of the cities in Europe I’ve visited aren’t handicapped accessible at all. Stairs into public buildings with no ramps, public restrooms in basements that are only accessible via steep staircases etc. Neither place is perfect.
This comment is hidden. Click here to view.
So why do you live in rural America if you don’t like it? You should be enjoying the beauty that many people would love to have and the peace.
Because some people have no choice or has their house paid for or something. Easier said than done to just up and move...
Exactly, moving requires finding a new job, a new house and a lot of money in general. And it might involve leaving relatives, friends, a familiar situation... Anyway, I've always found this argument very hypocritical: "If you don't like your country, just move". But when people immigrate from poorer countries, and they if fact don't like (or find impossible to) living there, suddenly it's "GO BACK TO YOUR COUNTRY!!!".
Emmy, it's because Americans refuse to believe that their (& my) country has any faults at all. F**k the stupid arrogant Americans who say that. This IS my country, and it IS every American's country. The solution is not to leave, but to demand change from our elected leaders to make America a better place to live for all of us.
Emmy, it seems very logical. My family will be moving from the US to Jordan in September. I know there are many things that the US has that Jordan does not have, and that it will be difficult in some ways to adjust. But if you ever find me constantly complaining and hating Jordan, please do encourage me to leave because why would I stay there? Who does it benefit for me to berate that country because of my own unhappiness? Everyone should actively seek a place you feel you belong... you only get this one life. If the US ain't it for you, hasta la vista baby.
Actually, we used to move a lot when I was younger, but then we moved to Tennessee, Mom got sick, I was disabled, she was disabled, there's literally no way to make a living out here. I can't afford to move, as much as I would like to live closer to doctors somewhere with public transportation or at least Ubers. Instead I'm stuck in a 121 year old house that's falling apart in the middle of nowhere. It's beautiful here sure, and I appreciate that in the spring and Summer, when I'm well enough to walk our dangerous lawn and not fall into a rabbit hole and keep an eye out for cottonmouths, instead of what I have been unable to walk far on even the flat hardwood floor.
Have you looked into Access? Also, in my state, disabled people can get aides.
Choices have consequences. I choose to live in a rural area because my preference for space, quiet and a small town feel outweighs the consequences of having to drive for anything I need. When my circumstances change, I will re-evaluate and possibly move to a denser area.
The downside of course, is that you live next to a cornfield with nothing to do or to go see.
I'm 65, currently living in a large city 😒 and I bicycle to work in good weather. I avoid busy roads and dangerous traffic as much as possible. I own a car because the city is large and one still needs to visit family, grocery shop etc. I dream of moving to a small town or quiet suburb. Nothing stopping people from walking, biking or getting an Uber. If people are too lazy to walk more than a few feet, use public transportation etc then stay in the congested impersonal City. I prefer small towns and other low population areas where the people are friendly and know one another.
Even if you can drive, home delivery is popular in the US for almost anything you want or need.
Thats true i can have literally anything delivered to my house 18 hours a day. Heck half my regular amazon orders are 2 hour delivery same day orders.
They walked, rode a bicycle even without sidewalks. Most took a bus to shop downtown. I know, I'm from 1956, all original equipment too. 😄
I live in a tiny rural town in the largest US interconnected state. If my van breaks down, we are completely screwed. The nearest actual grocery store is 25 minutes away by car. Even the tiny store in my town is 4 miles. Too far to walk for any substantial amount of food. And too far for me to walk as I have musculoskeletal health issues. There are also ZERO sidewalks, even through town. I hate that there's nothing out here. BUT my kids ARE far safer than in a city.
This comment is hidden. Click here to view.
That’s what I like about having land, it’s a barricade. When the government forces low income housing into every neighborhood for you to pay for them they are busy doing drugs and other unseemly things. I liked it better when there were no sidewalks, strange characters are up and down the road all the time. I walked many places without a sidewalk, these people sound like they can’t walk on a ground. No way I would trade to live in the city.
Wow Daisy, what a shitty little rant. When I was a kid, I lived in low income housing. My parents weren't criminals and I assure you, none of us did anything "unseemly" that might force someone with such delicate sensibilities as yours, to clutch her pearls. Trust me, everyone is glad you have your land to barricade you from the rest of us.
I live in a senior citizen apartment complex where your rent is determined by your income and water, heat, electricity and trash pickup are included. It's quiet, peaceful and crime-free. You have to be 60 or over, disabled or a student - and pass a criminal background check - to live here. It's certainly nothing like Daisy imagines. I do miss having my own place, but I'm 69 and have COPD. I'm no longer able to do things like mowing the lawn or shoveling snow.
I lived low income housing too as a kid- it’s true there were good people, but also a LOT of criminals, drugs, domestic violence. My parents would tell us don’t play with this kid, they are a bad influence-they were Victims of their toxic parents and many grew up to be criminals too. It’s not a good way to live and all they did was acknowledge that. The good people will fight hard to get out of there and have something better-if they can’t, they teach their kids good values and morality and not to imitate the neighbors. I grew up and started raising my own kids in an apartment too-but we owned the building and screened tenants. Then hated being landlords and still having bad neighbors in other houses, no privacy, and no respect for boundaries-dug up veggies and damaged outdoor toys-sold the house, quit being landlords and now live in rural America. I’m a minority and some childhood neighbors were white. Don’t believe in this white privilege bs-I’m Hispanic worked hard did things right.
Wow! Easy on the stereotyping! You just told us you were from a rural community without having to tell us with your ignorance so here’s some FACTS: NOT ALL ppl who find themselves needing low income housing do drugs! NOT ALL even do unseemly things! Some are actually disabled veterans and/or single moms who have been widowed young or maybe not by choice and are working but with rental costs being so high still need help! So since I’m sure you wouldn’t like being called a backwoods redneck that sits around all day thinking up racist ideas to post online while you hide behind the safety of your keyboard, start practicing a little compassion! Btw, NO I don’t live in low income housing, I live in a lovely condo on the beach but I volunteer at a shelter and food pantry so I know poverty doesn’t discriminate.
I don't know about where you live. But where I live being low income does not mean you do drugs it means your not being paid a living wage. There is far more drug use by middle class then by the poor because here's a surprise for you. Drugs cost money. A large part due to the opioid crisis. Guess who's insurance covered those drugs. Not the poor on public health. Now fentanyl and heroine are rampant among the middle class. The poor smoke weed as it's affordable and get us through our shitty lives and not to mention legal.
This comment is hidden. Click here to view.
They are safe - for now. Just wait until XiBiden dumps 5,000 illegals in your community!
Illegal immigrants would at least be able to self sustain not to mention they'd increase the likelihood of closer stores, a stronger community bond (because most nations outside the US aren't individualist) and would be able to increase your likelihood of getting help if something like your car breaks down. Because and this might shock you... Illegal immigrants are people fleeing from corruption and poverty not criminals and assholes
The suburbs aren't rural and are not far from all the amenities of the city. And in my city the public transportation does stop outside each subdivision so you can take it if you need to as well as my city has personal public transportation for the elderly and disabled some free or for only a few dollars they can call the day before and schedule a pickup and a transit will pick them up and take them directly where they need to go and the city even has programs for free punch cards so they don't even have to pay for that
But also on the same token in my city the only people that use public transportation are people who can't drive because they either can't afford to or because they literally can't
In Canada , they’re making 15 minute cities .. where everything will be 15 walking minutes .. I think its neat!
My niece wanted to get a job to save money for college, but her mother has work and her father is deployed, so she is stuck babysitting the kids in her neighborhood until she saves enough money to by a car so she can save enough money to go to college. Slightly ironic isn't it? She has to save money in order to get more money.
Get an uber and just stop. Suburb are not low income areas. Rural areas are different, it sucks if you can get around there
Doesn't exist in some towns. I live in a small town in Texas. There is no taxis and no Ubers...no public transport.
In my country we don't have Uber. And taxis are only available in big cities, certainly not in my small town. Not everybody shares the same experience.
No one is forced to live in the suburbs. We Americans can choose where to live. I understand the questions and confusion, but people live where they want. My in-laws loved having a house in an HOA neighborhood, I chose to live in a non-HOA neighborhood. Most towns and counties in the US do provide free public transportation for elderly and disabled people. Just because it's not regular bus service doesn't mean it doesn't exist.
"We Americans can choose where to live.".... what an odd statement. As if you are implying that people living in other countries don't choose where they live, because the original post was from Slovakia, and they also get to choose where they live. Secondly, I actually challenge the statement that Americans can choose where to live, since many Americans can't due to economic conditions. I'm sure there are plenty of people living in suburbs that wished that they didn't live in a suburb, but are not able to move.
Load More Replies...More I think they meant it as in the original article/questions they wonder why people would live in these suburbs. Simply put people choose to live in them because they want to. Not because it's forced apon them
I think the statement was a perfectly appropriate response to another comment that had seemed to imply that Americans did not have freedom in terms of living in a suburb.
That is not at all how that statement was intended, you either don't understand the language or you're being a tool, most people in the U.S.A. love where and how they live, because we don't need or want businesses next door or because everyone doesn't require a vegetable garden, by no means we are suffering, most of us like the fact we have large yards, and are not on top of each other, if someone would rather live in a city, they do, if they prefer the countryside, then they live there instead, you watch too much tv
Love where and how they live... What bubble are you living in? Like I get it, life is enjoyable here, it has it's moments. But love? Nah most Americans in the city get reminded by homelessness, crime, and weaponized poverty on the daily. This country is predatory both on the global and national level. I don't look at pharmaceutical companies getting away with mass murder by being fined as loving living here. I don't see poor people enlisting at the recruitment office to go shoot foreigners to escape poverty as loving it. I don't see how anyone not ignorant of the massive societal failings of america are loving where and how they live.
Moving costs aside, the same amount of $ could afford you to live in the city, Suburbs or countryside of America. FYI- for lower income families- The Suburbs are often seen as a "safer" alternative to city life.
True many Americans are restricted by economics. But the strange thing happening in my city right now is that the rent on a small 2 bedroom poorly maintained apartment is about $1200-$1400 a month while at the same time a mortgage in the suburbs for a nice 3-4 bedroom house is also $1200-$1400 a month but most people in the city can't buy a house because they can't get a mortgage due to credit and not having a down payment because every cent they make goes to pay there bills while working two or more jobs and having to live with 3 or more other people also working to make rent for the shitty 2 bedroom apartment
This comment is hidden. Click here to view.
"People living in suburbs" are not poor people, they're upper middle class and own their homes. They can choose to move to the inner city if they'd like. In fact, if they take a lower-paying job, they can get a government subsidy and live there nearly free.
Good luck moving to the city from the burbs in any city in North America. Where have you been the last five years? Let alone thirty...
Yeah, good luck with that. The waiting list for section 8 housing, where your rent is adjusted according to your income, is so long in Virginia that the lists have been mostly closed for at least a decade. People who work low income jobs don't do so because it makes their life easier; they'd much rather be paid a living wage and not need assistance. The wealthy welfare woman with 10 kids and no job, driving a Cadillac is a myth that was purposely perpetuated by the republican party. There was a huge investigation into welfare fraud because of that myth and they found it was almost non-existent. Google it.
"....I'm sure there are plenty of people living in suburbs that wished that they didn't live in a suburb, but are not able to move." I think you're very confused here. People actually WANT to live in suburbs. We actually have very low supply of new housing developments now. No one lives here because they couldn't live anywhere else. Is it really hard to understand why someone would want to live in a home that's brand new with every up to date system installed? I'm sorry but the premise of this whole thread is simply bizarre.
The article is specifically about American suburbs, not not-American suburbs.
The article is a European person commenting on American suburbs. Non-American suburbs are fair game.
Yes, that sentence struck me as odd, too. It sounds like that typical American thinking that their country is the only one where people are free and have freedom of speech and all that. Brainwashed or poorly educated is what I call it.
You are experiencing what we call bias. Nothing was said about other countries. This person only expressed that her experience is limited to America, and there is nothing wrong with that
Vicky, ironic to call someone else uneducated when your own reading comprehension is subpar. The article is focused on criticizing American suburbs, this commenter said "We Americans can choose where to live" as in "I'm an American and I'm not forced to live where I don't want" even though the article seems to suggest it. There was zero insinuation that other countries don't get to choose where they live. I'm discovering every day Europeans' view of America isn't grounded in reality, but in their own arrogance, ignorance, superiority complex, and projected insecurities. Y'all need help... seriously.
This comment is hidden. Click here to view.
Your country is a hotbed of far right wing movements throughout the last century + Imagine a german talking s**t about America... pot, meet kettle.
This comment is hidden. Click here to view.
You definitely can walk your a*s to the city if you're poor and dont like the suburbs. Get a job, save money, stop being poor.
Many Americans "choose" to live in the suburbs because 1) they grew up there, 2) their parents grew up there, and 3) their grandparents moved there out of fear of "those people." They literally never go into the city if they can help it. Their impressions of city life come from Law and Order reruns rather than reality.
I live 10 minutes outside a city of several million. I do everything I can not to approach any closer than that, unless I'm heading downtown for a sports event at one of the stadiums. Being packed into a concrete jungle with millions of people all around, I couldn't imagine a worse hell. The moment I can get clear of the people and vehicles and floor the gas out of there, I'm gone. Absolute hell, way too many people.
lol you are probably right... I'm sure all of the people in my neighborhood with $1m+ homes and a few hundred thousand of vehicles (many of which have a secondary condo in uptown) can't afford to live in the city. Definitely the case. Certainly not the choice of allocating their funds differently or just flat out wanting to be here. Nope... They can't afford it. 100%. Nailed it!
"More like they don't go to the city because they can't afford it." Living in an overpriced condo above a noisey, traffic-filled city street vs. living in a quiet, maintained neighborhood surrounded by city parks and fun things for kids to do. Thanks-- I'll take the suburbs.
Also: 4) It is nice, all the advantages and conveniences of living in the city, without the hassle and downsides. The suburbs are typically some of the highest price real estate because of this.
I don't think anyone moved to the suburbs out of fear of "those people". They moved during the postwar baby boom for " No down payment for veterans" loans for tiny ranch houses, nice yards, good schools,and safety. Pretty much the same reasons people live there today and there are "those people" here, too who moved for the same reasons.
Ever think maybe people live in suburban areas because they want a balance between “leave me the f**k alone” rural living (like me), and being packed in like sardines in urban living? To me the urban living scenario is the absurd concept.
Yes it is! Very much do NOT need to know my neighbors that well.
Load More Replies...People and racism have turned me from a happy hafu to a hafu who treasures her hermitness and her two friends. One is or was a racist until I told her that I was half yellow. She said no, you're white. I said, no. When my mother came to the U.S from Japan and then to Cleveland, they could only rent a house in the colored section. My dad was the only white face in an ocean of black faces. And was treated better by them than his so-called race. My friend has since revised her opinion after I told her the many names I have been called by whites, browns and blacks. Only the native american/indigenous people haven't. They only said "close enough ". My brothers and I were accepted by the kids on the reservation. They took us on a mad dash on horses through a bull's pasture. To their burial grounds (real, not a tourist trap), a murdered hermit's car. We helped clean, brush and put our horses to bed or pasture. We were accepted 100%.
I forgot. We fell in love with fry bread and they fell in love with japanese rice and food
In rural areas people know each other much better than packed in cities. They are much more friendly and sincere. They enjoy more privacy not loneliness or solitude. Judging by your comment you milage definitely differs. LOL
People just can't get to know with other with the hectic lives we live in cities. People think just because you meet ransoms in night clubs they have relationships
Lived in cities most of my life... I've met over 30 years like a handfull of my neighbors? You go to work, get off work, and then go do s**t around the city or go home and relax. I'd imagine it's the same for the suburbs, just less car usage, and instead of wrongly assuming no one is taking drugs to cope with modern reality, you assume most people are using some sort of drug like substance.
Right. And you don’t have to dig a well or whatever, set up a septic system, find electricity… Setting up my own infrastructure is too much for me. But I’m super-introverted, so I wouldn’t love having people right on the other sides of my walls, hearing them, but it would maybe be OK to live in a townhouse. I would hate living in an apartment again though, esp. now w/ kids (we have 3, also my mother-in-law lived w/ us for 10 yrs until she died). People on every side, lots of noise inside & outside. A married couple w/ maybe 1 kid might pretty easily live in the average apartment, I guess.
I think the problem here is not: "why on earth would you want to live in the suburbs?!". It's more about: "why do the suburbs are designed like that?". We have suburbs here in Italy but it's not just houses after houses, no other "useful" buildings, immaculate lawns and that's it. We have shops, bars, restaurants, schools, parks, people keep their backyards as they please, they grow vegetables if they feel like it, they can take a stroll in the evening for ice-cream, you know.
That’s how it is where I live in the US. I’m not sure if the assumption is that all suburbs in US are all the same (HOA, no uniqueness to the homes, etc.)… but that’s nothing like where I live.
We love our suburbs in American. A five minute drive from me there are literally hundreds of stores and a mall. No knees to go anywhere else for those things. Every store you've ever heard of.
Exactly. I don't want to live in a city. There's definitely an advantage in some aspects to living in a city but I like my privacy and I like my open space (and my lower crime rates).
This comment is hidden. Click here to view.
Nah it's mostly racism, always has been.
I’m a brown Puerto Rican and I hate cities-I really do prefer suburbs and rural. Live in rural now and I’m never going back to city living. I dont care what color people are-I don’t want to live around criminals and low life’s. I don’t my kids raised around them. Stop assuming it’s racism-people just want safe places to live. Black people do the same thing-work hard to buy a nice peaceful house in the suburbs or rural area. Oh we have Black people living in my rural area too-they aren’t racist they just want to live a nice life in a peaceful place! Cities are a nightmare.
IKR! The myth lives on. If you can afford to buy a house here you are welcome.
The Americans here defending their verson of suburb life I understand, but they have never lived in the European way of living where everything is geared to community. I'm biased (U.K.), but have lived abroad, last stop Turkey for 10 years where it's even more 'community first, and gardens are for productive use. and the children play out making god knows what with mud and lolly sticks, come at teatime. I think it's sad, and would love for the U.S. defenders to try the alternative just for a while.
I would absolutely love to live in that kind of community. There are some places like that in the US, but they aren't the norm, sadly.
Load More Replies...Small towns in the Midwest are like this. Shops along main street, houses in walkable distance
I just think it's a misconception that we have never experienced this. Not everyone in the US lives in the suburbs. It's kind of a culture unto itself. I live in an urban neighborhood, there are, stores, pubs and restaurants all within walking distance with side walks and crosswalks. Parks and gardens where people grow vegetables, one of my neighbors has chickens. We have this here in the cities. Suburbs exist on the outskirts of the city but planners are now changing the way they design communities so that they look more like our urban neighborhoods. The biggest issue now, is that homes are so outrageously expensive, people with jobs in shops and restaurants cannot afford to live anywhere near those places. Forcing them once again to drive very far to go to work.
Very true. We are planning on building a new place and will sell our current home to our oldest son at what we owe and the other house will be for youngest son.
Wait a second, do you actually believe those areas don't exist in the USA? Seriously?
Amazing how little the people who love to criticize us actually know about us, isn't it?
This want the case where I lived. We had stores withing a 15min walk. Back yards were used for fires ,cook outs , and for the children to play in. Even in my mostly empty back yard we had hours apon hours of fun times. Plus people could grow vegetables if they so pleased ,but most just didn't.
It's part of the culture. Americans aren't big on tight knit communities, which often feel taxing on their privacy and independence. American culture is in a way more "selfish" by many other country standards
My mother was japanese and not liked by my dad's family. Racism in the family tree (except for my Aunt Gen and Aunt Georgia), yeah. NOT. It was my two brothers, mom and me against the world. My dad joined our attitude later. Maybe some U.S. citizens are selfish, but on the average, no. Otherwise, why would we send over 40 billion dollars in aid to Ukraine. Yes, the politicians voted on the Aid, but the VAST majority of us are behind the Ukranian people and their right to live and be free. GO PRESIDENT ZALENSKY and THE UKRANIAN PEOPLE. My best friend and my sister in heart and soul is a republican. I am a VERY liberal buddhist atheist. Her husband loves me as her sister and would never try to separate us. I generally don't talk politics, religion or money expect with her. We respect and love each and refuse to let poo-poo get between us. Nope, never gonna happen. So yes, we can be selfish but everyone has to watch out for such negativity. Sorry for the rant.
Buddhism is a way of life where there is no belief in a god. Athiest is believing there is no god. It was redundant to include athiest.
I have lived many years in the UK, Russia, and Germany as well as traveling to 90 precent of Europe and what is mostly said in this forum about suburbs is false and hyperbolic. Most American suburbs actually have sidewalks and stores within walking distance. Additionally most suburbs in the US don't have HOA's. And the idea that yards are not used for gardening is just a lie. A homeowner can do whatever gardening they want is their backyard. Additionally most suburbs have parks and walking paths and other recreational activities all available. And as for the kids the play outside with one another just as European kids do. As for Europe if you want to live stacked on top one another, have very small living spaces, no garage, no privacy, no ability to live where you want do to overall low average income then by all means move to Europe. I'm guessing most on here are leftist just dreaming of just such living arrangements. I for one like the privacy and freedom.
Here in Indonesia too, if there are empty space (that has soil) people will plant it with veggies or fruits or flowers. My parents does it and it saves money and healthier since its organic. Some house sell snacks or other household-related things which makes it easier to develop micro (nano even) businesses at their own home
So I believe that a lot of people live in the burbs because they enjoy the privacy, at least that's why I do, but am lucky enough for my kids to have other kids so close by to play with and keep busy and an HOA that is useless really, they don't enforce much at all and fees are very minimal and used for the park and playground in the neighborhood. I do miss when I was younger though and had all this plus a small neighborhood market across the main street. Only problem was there, the main street was more of a highway than a cross road.
For my kids and now for my grandsons We picked our city for proximity to Lake Erie and for the city school system. Our school district has a pretty good rating in Ohio and low crime average. When we had a family shooting with suicide, we mourned and are still mourning the victims, humans and animal. This is the only one that I know of and I have lived here since 1994.
Yes, crime rate is another big thing that I left out, but unfortunately, as you know, crime can and will happen anywhere. Just some places are obviously more prone to crime than most suburbs
I live in the USA now and in my town it is " community first" we have community functions(every weekend the town comes to main street for music, movies in the park ect) community gardens as well as private ones . Not everywhere in the USA is the same, just like in the UK not all places are "community first".
Here is what "community" means in the USA- helping your neighbor, giving to charity, donating time and/or money to support the local community, forming sports leagues for kids funded by the parents and businesses in the local community, having picnics and dinners and holiday events that brings everyone together, and much much more. "Community" in the USA means a great deal more than just living close to your neighbor and walking to the store, it is infinitely better in the USA.
Here in Texas, we have European-style living with bars, restaurants, parks, shops, entertainment and businesses in a planned development They are very nice but it doesn't really work here. Owning a "McMansion" in the suburbs is cheaper than renting an apartment in one of those developments. And most suburbs have every convenience nearby.
This is a huge assumption on your part. I personally have lived in India, and I think that is comparable. Nonetheless, I want to live in a place where I have quiet and space, clean air, low crime rate, and very low cost of living. This is why I have chosen to live in a small town now, here in America, instead of a city. When cities have more green spaces, less noise, then I might consider moving. The closeness of urban life causes too much stress. And to be quite honest, our costs for housing and gas,etc. are extremely low because of living in a rural area.
Thats cool for you, but i don't like people. I need my space and privacy
I live in the US and have been to Sweden, Romania, and the Netherlands (Amsterdam). Where I live, it’s very much like Timisoara Romania. Not all suburbs are the same.
Perhaps you should try living in a suburb. That knife cuts both ways.
Community first is socialist living. Socialism is the interim government when transitioning to communism. The United States suburbs are not the true subject of this article. When a country is taken over by communists, the first thing the people lose is their property. No more property ownership is the subject of this article. Living in the suburbs means open spaces to walk, run, cycle, play any number of games, and space to sit and watch a sunrise or sunset without the noise of the bustling city. If you're bored, drive into town and go-to a club, movie, ball game, or play. There's a grocery store a quarter mile from my suburban home. Within walking distance are a McDonalds, KFC, two Mexican restaurants, a Caribbean restaurant, an optometrist, hair salon, ice cream parlor, liquor store, two gas stations, a car wash, a sandwich shop, orthopedic shoe store, a medical clinic, a mental health inpatient facility, a cancer center, and several schools and churches. Freedom.
Right? People are being fed lies-lies about their financial situation and their control over it (nothing you can do! You need the gvt! Your skin color prevents success! Everyone is racist!). So many lies…I am Hispanic and minimum wage income. Followed the Dave Ramsey ways to manage money and my Puerto Rican parents taught me good values and openness to culture and experience. Now I am 34 expecting my 5th kid (all with my wonderful husband) and live in a nice rural area. Our house is almost paid off-we pay cash for good condition used cars so no car payment ever-mortgage is our remaining debt and will be gone in the next year. Lower income by choice we don’t want cubicle work-my husband didn’t buy the lies. My parents taught me well and I didn’t buy the lies-I’ve never had opportunity blocked for being brown-I gave things up because I realized they were traps. 9-5 is a trap. Where I live is Aroostook County Maine-it doesn’t get whiter than that-yet people have been wonderful-strangers help you for no reason-nobody cares your color-just that you are decent. If you want a bigger income-most have-they can be rich easily as we manage our low income correctly and are living better than ppl we know with more. It’s mismanagement-that’s the problem. You can absolutely get by and no you don’t need socialism-you need a budget and to not use debt-if you have debt use the snowball method to get rid of it and never do it again.
Right on, Leila. Your strong family sounds amazing. You and your husband are living out the American dream.
Plus, each neighborhood has nice wide sidewalks. Our streets have bike lanes. My neighborhood has no HOA and I grow veggies in my back yard with roses and drought resistant plants in the front. As children we rode bikes, flew kites, played touch football, tag, hide and seek, and other normal kid things. Remember yelling CAR!!
Unfortunately these days it's not always safe for kids to play outside anymore.
Well yes and no. I definitely keep an eye on them when they are playing either me or my wife, even though we live well off the main road. Only reason people come to our neighborhood is if you live here or you are lost, but still yes, we keep an eye on them. I think back in my day, I'm 43 so I grew up as a kid in the 80s, I think there was just as much crime back then but there was no social media to put it out there like today. And it was just another time then. I was always out on my own with all my friends all over town and it wasn't a big deal. More accepted back then if that's the right word? But no, I definitely don't think I will let my son roam around the way I did when he gets a little older. I guess it all depends on where you live to. I grew up in a smaller, everyone knows everyone town so....
How different are we? We love our children, grandchildren, our extended family. My friends are my family also. The dangers inherent in the city, the pollution and the school systems made the move to the suburbs a no brainer. I am a born suburbian and played in the woods and made forts, ran from rabid animals made mud pies, rode my bike to the STORES. Went the park, swam in creeks. I did not miss out on anything!!!!!!!!!!! The only thing I missed out on was the types of racism between city and suburb. I am hafu.
That's because you don't have the space and convenience and fairly inexpensive compared with UK shopping that we have. I can order my groceries online, drive up to my local grocery store or Walmart have them loaded into my car or delivered for far cheaper than they cost there. Don't get me wrong, I love the UK and watch mainly British shows. But, everything here is just much easier and more convenient. Also, Children play together in the suburbs. Not sure what your point is.
Part of the problem here is that a lot of posters seem to be confusing Housing Developments with Suburbs. Housing Developments, like the one seen in Edward Scissorhands with identical houses, perfectly manicured lawns with no trees or other foliage, and no nearby businesses do exist, but they are the exception rather than the rule. The suburb where I grew up had a corner drugstore, a diner right next door, a bakery, a pizzeria, and yes, a liquor store all within walking distance. We also had several community parks, picnic areas, and playgrounds. We walked to school and on the street behind mine there was a creek at the bottom of the hill where we sledded in the winter and caught crayfish in the summer. And it seems to me here that a lot of Europeans are criticizing the American way of life while never having lived it, while at the same time accusing us of the same in reverse. Ultimately I believe comfort comes down to what you are used to.
True there's a difference between a Housing Development and Suburb. I though am in a suburb but we don't have anything like you described. Nothing within walking distance. Not that I can walk far anyways due to a chronic illness and chronic pain due to having Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome. But yeah just houses here. It isn't strict nor lenient. But no public transport. Must be nice to be where you grew up. Even where I grew up in North Carolina (currently in Texas) things weren't really like that. In one house there there was a small strip of businesses and I remember one was a salon where I got my hair cut when I was like 12. But unfortunately places like that is real rare it seems.
Load More Replies...The poster of this query should have grown up in Slovakia when it was under the USSR. They would realize how good America is and probably would have tried to defect here. Most only know about America by what they see on TV or movies and we all know how Hollywood screws everything up.
I couldn’t stand living in a high rise apartment. People on top of people. If I want or need something, I get in my truck and go to the store to get it close by. Very easy, no biggie.
That's why the suburbs were created. To get away from being on top of eachother.
Load More Replies...Correction: That’s why urban places outside of downtown and streetcar suburbs were created. Car dependent suburbs were created for three reasons: as an “experiment”, to fuel the car industry, and for white flight reasons.
I don't know if "white flight" was a reason since most white people already lived in white neighborhoods, contrary to myth. Space, nice houses, good schools and safety would be primary reasons. Believe it or not, most white people don't consider race in their primary decision making. There was also post WWII "No down payment for veterans" financing. Those are all the mid-century ranch houses that are still standing today.
Same here. Nothing less pleasant than having to listen to your neighbors, left, right, below above, conceiving their next family member!
This. My suburb has a population density of 2,486/sq.mi. For comparison New York City is 27,000/sq.mi. Absolute hell. I don't know how anyone could stand to live in such tight quarters.
https://www.strongtowns.org/journal/2020/8/27/in-praise-of-streetcar-suburbs?format=amp I suggest you to look at the low density map of this streetcar suburb layout. It’s 7668 people per square mile with mostly single family homes. Lots of people will be able to have their own space while also being able to walk to places. There are more options than car dependent suburbia and the financial district of Manhattan.
Guess what? They’re something in between car dependent suburbia and 50 floor apartments. People just don’t know because US cities are usually one extreme or another. You should check out streetcar suburbs built before the postwar car dependent white picket fence craze.
There does need to be better public transportation and it needs to be clean, safe and fast. NYC subways are a disgrace. Filthy, rat infested and dangerous. I lived in Japan in the 80s and 6 year olds would go to school on the trains alone.
I don't live in a high rise apartment and can still walk to the grocery store, to public transport and to my family doctor (and in a pinch also to the library, although I'd rather take the bus at least back :P ) ... the problem seen is not so much the idea of the single family home, but of there being no useful buildings within walking distance and cities in general apparently not planned to be used by humans, who get around using their feet. Having to have a car is unnatural.
THANK YOU!!! I’ve literally had to tell people that there are more places than 100ppl/sq mi car dependent suburbs with no amenities within 5 miles and 100000ppl/sq mi skyscraper areas with 50 floor apartments.
Some people like the peace and quiet of suburbs, especially when raising a family. Yuppie cosmopolitan snobs stay mad. I'm glad I grew up in the suburbs. My early years were spent in a more urban setting, and it had gangs, crime, graffiti, homeless, and other wonderful culture lol.
You know just because you are avoiding those things doesn't mean their not still a massive societal problem in america right? That isn't city culture btw, it's american culture.
Load More Replies...Where I live there are no gangs, no crime, no homeless people. Maybe a little crime in the poorest neighbourhoods. Homeless people are taken care for in a humain way.
Because your country either exported their poor and criminals to the new world or killed them in a World War. So tired of the centuries old "we're better than you" Euros - when is that ever gone wrong?
Yeah, I don’t think it works like that. Because if it works like you said, then the solution for poverty and crime would be to kill off all the poor and criminals, and none would spawn over 100 years? No, for example, we don’t have many homeless people where I live, because in the end, every single homeless person is provided with a place to stay through social welfare, because it is physically almost impossible to survive one winter outside here… and the humane thing to do. And, at least where I am from, criminals are not seen as someone who should die or rot in jail, but someone who is in jail to repent and to rehabilitate to be a part of the community, study and learn day-to-day skills, and be treated with respect and empathy. So that when they are set free, they have kept their humanity and empathy intact, and they can actually survive on their own, evaluate their life choises and not again have to turn to crime due to money/bad friends/etc.
The whole world went to America and now that they come to Europe and we have no houses for them, they stay outside on chairs. Easy to blame America for not being as social as a tiny rich European country, but now that all the poor ppl come, they aren't as social anymore. Poles can live with 20 in a house and do the horrible bad paid jobs.
You must be from England. I watch alot of British TV and they're always slamming the Poles. Half my ancestors came from Poland around the turn of the 20th century and the other half came from England in the 1700s. My DNA is always at war with each other.
Your comment does not fit the BP agenda; I'm surprised it got past their PC Police. Good for you for having the courage to write with common sense and clarity.
That’s why there should be more walkable streetcar suburbs and less car dependent suburbs. Car dependent suburbs often have high crime too, and specific types. For example, school shootings often due to isolation. In my experience, I’ve seen just as many homeless in the suburbs as the city. People who think living in a place with copy paste houses, identical lawns, no real nature, and no amenities within 5 miles is better than any other place to raise a family are the same people who wonder why their kids don’t play outside enough.
































173
810