Man Throws Tantrum Over Sister’s 38-Week IVF Pregnancy Getting More Attention Than His Wife’s, Gets A Reality Check
Family dynamics can be complicated, especially when it comes to parenting. A recent post on the subreddit ‘Am I the A**hole?’ has sparked a conversation about how to navigate your closest relationships when you’re expecting a baby.
A man who goes by the nickname u/throwingaway1939 shared a story about how his wife got hurt over her pregnancy during a big get-together. His sister and her wife are also preparing to give birth, and the grandparents were eagerly discussing their impending arrival, leaving the man’s wife feeling left out.
Image credits: Rawpixel (not the actual photo)
Image credits: Anna Guerrero (not the actual photo)
Image credits: throwingaway1939
Vicki Broadbent of Honest Mum thinks that it’s crucial for partners to stick together during their pregnancy
Image credits: honestmum.com
Pregnant couples go through a range of emotions during this period, so conflicts like the one we just read are to be expected.
“Pregnancy is an intense period for couples, especially first-time pregnancy as you veer into the unknown,” writer, director, broadcaster, and founder of the parenting blog Honest Mum, Vicki Broadbent, told Bored Panda. “Fear is natural but it’s important to candidly discuss your concerns and be there to listen to one another/seek resolutions to any worries.”
And whether or not you support the author of the post in this particular situation, I think we can agree that his loyalty to his wife is admirable.
“It’s important the pregnant woman’s partner works hard to empathize with the colossal changes she is experiencing physically and mentally and to understand how tiring growing another human being can be. Showing understanding and being thoughtful and supportive will help both of you. If the relationship feels consistently strained, couples’ therapy can be incredibly useful,” Broadbent, who is also the author of Mumboss: The Honest Mum’s Guide to Surviving and Thriving at Work and at Home, said.
According to her, in practical terms, this can mean a variety of things, from ensuring there will be somewhere comfortable for her to sit and rest to arranging for non-alcoholic drinks and foods she’s able to eat (pregnant women are advised against unpasteurized foods) and arranging for gatherings in the daytime rather than later in the evening when she is likely to be tired.
There’s no rulebook for navigating in-law relationships
Experts say that part of the reason why in-law relationships are often tricky is the fact that families have to define them themselves. It’s not clear how close people should live to their in-laws, how often couples see them, and what responsibilities they might shoulder.
Gretchen Perry, professor at the University of Canterbury, New Zealand, and co-author of the paper In-Law Relationships in Evolutionary Perspective: The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly, points out that there won’t necessarily be shared beliefs and mutual understanding. While people might have friction with their own families, she says, “it’s more likely you’re going to agree and have common interests with them” and there might be “less of an overlap in common agreement.”
In one Finnish study, researchers found that compared to child-free couples, mothers and fathers were as likely to report conflict with their own parents, but more likely to report individual conflict with their in-laws. Many young adults found in-law conflict increased after the birth of their first child, with the shared interest of a grandchild providing fresh reasons for grandparents to “influence and interfere in the lives of other family members.”
So the key is not trying to avoid fights. On some level, they’re bound to happen. It’s how civil you can make them and come out without destroying your bond with those around you.
Some people think the man (and his wife) crossed the line
But some justify their reaction
Explore more of these tags
If OP and wife aren't AH then why weren't they also excited about their new nieces arrival ?? My youngest sister helped my husband plan his proposal to me. We got engaged. She's super excited for me. A few weeks later her husband proposed to her. Now I'm super excited for her!! They get married BEFORE we do!!! Again... SUPER EXCITED FOR HER!! She gets pregnant but doesn't want to tell anyone until the second trimester. She officiates our wedding and she's SUPER EXCITED FOR ME! She tells us she's pregnant when she planned to and I'm SUPER EXCITED AGAIN!! We buy our first home and she's Super excited for ME! She gives birth a few months later... SUPER EXCITED AGAIN!!! Even if the timing coincides with what we have going on we are excited for the other one more than ourselves most of the time because we want to see each other happy and we celebrate each other because that's how love and families should operate. No comparison. No competition. No complaints. Why is that so hard for people?
I feel mixed actually. While I am completely understanding that excitement will be higher -first child for the sister and her wife via IVF and the baby is arriving soon vs 2nd baby for the OP n his wife, not arriving sooner, it's rude to ignore OP's wife and barely showing any interest. 2nd baby is as precious as first baby. Just coz it's not OP's first baby now doesn't mean this baby doesn't matter as much. OP's wife was feeling left out. OP did try to at least initiate a conversation which will throw light on "Hey we're here too. We too would like to share our happiness with you. We're planning to host a gender reveal party and would be so happy to see you all there!" But no avail. Nobody likes to be left out. It's actually on the hosts - mom and grandma who weren't tactful enough. They could've easily asked OP and wife to come on a different day if possible. And sister is mildly AH for making it into competition.
The fact is, after the first baby, most parents see a drop in excitement, from everyone. You've now successfully procreated already. There's no longer any worry you'll be childless. So people are happy, but not super excited. There's also a bit of "been there, done that" quality about it. It might be just as emotional for the parents-to-be, but for everyone else, well they've been there before. They now want to make a fuss over the *next* couple who are doing this for the first time. And the already-successful parents shouldn't want to rob another couple of *their* chance to be the center of attention - you know, the same attention *they* enjoyed once upon a time without having to share it.
Load More Replies...Absolutely YTA. Your wife and baby isn't the only one that matters. You're expecting your second child in 6 months, you sister is expecting her first child in 2 weeks. It's completely reasonable that they're focusing on her.
I mean, I'd give it a YTA for the gender reveal alone.
Load More Replies...So often we see situations where the wife gets upset about how her in-laws are treating her, and the husband sides with his family instead of his wife. And in those situations, the comments are always about how he should have stuck up for his wife, etc. Now we get a case where the husband does stick up for his wife with his family and the comments are mostly saying he's TA. I don't get it. I think he did right by sticking up for his wife instead of invalidating her feelings.
Yea, he's good for caring about his wife, but at the same time, he's an a*****e for trying to dictate all the attention be on his wife. Like everyone else has said, 1. it's his second child, which isn't due for ages, 2. it's his sisters first, through ivf treatment (which can be incredibly difficult for some women), and 3. his sisters baby is literally about to be born, of course grandparents are going to be mega excited. I'm sure closer to the time, OP's wife will get the attention she craves.
Load More Replies...He's definitely the a*****e for thinking he can dictate what people focus on, talk about.
OP’s wife already was the center of attention for their first baby. Now it’s sister and SIL’s turn, ffs—-and no one is even mentioning how goddamned difficult IVF is, on both your mental health and your pocketbook! What OP and wife should’ve been doing is gently asking if the new parents want any pointers, based on OP and wife’s experience, and offering to be of any help they could give,——“just give us a call if you need any help or advice”. As long as Sis and SIL don’t take advantage, the two couples should end up getting along splendidly—-maybe Sis and SIL would offer to babysit the oldest child for a couple days when OP’s wife gives birth. As it stands now, OP and wife can f*****g forget about asking Sis and SIL for any favors.
If there is a conversation and it is not yet finished you don't interrupt and change the topic. The grandparents were being socially correct to exhaust the topic and everything that mattered to them about it before changing their focus. I'm sure after they were finished they would welcome the next topic regarding the Ops pregnancy but I can see why it would not be so urgent as one is 2 weeks from the due date and the Ops wife and he are still 26 weeks from the same.
Let's be honest here as well, it is so hard for women to go through IVF, it's a huge commitment putting your body under that much stress. Plus OP never mentioned how many years his sister and wife had been trying because what is the chances of it happening the 1st time. The cost of IVF are astronomical as well, plus at 38 weeks she is at full gestation. The little brother threw his toys out of the pram, and his wife is giving me full Megan Markle vibes. The family will get to you when it's you about to welcome a baby in two weeks. Also OP should appreciate that he and his wife (I presume, as he had not mentioned it) had got pregnant the old fashioned way. Can he not stop for a minute and realise how lucky he is, this is his sisters journey and I bet it was a bumpy road. I honestly think out of all of the AITA stories you sir are the biggest AH of them all. That being said good luck with your wife's pregnancy, I'm sure when you put this aside your children will be best friends.
This reminded me of Scrubs episode where Turk is upset that Carla's 2nd pregnancy didn't ignite as much excitement as the 1st one.
If OP and wife aren't AH then why weren't they also excited about their new nieces arrival ?? My youngest sister helped my husband plan his proposal to me. We got engaged. She's super excited for me. A few weeks later her husband proposed to her. Now I'm super excited for her!! They get married BEFORE we do!!! Again... SUPER EXCITED FOR HER!! She gets pregnant but doesn't want to tell anyone until the second trimester. She officiates our wedding and she's SUPER EXCITED FOR ME! She tells us she's pregnant when she planned to and I'm SUPER EXCITED AGAIN!! We buy our first home and she's Super excited for ME! She gives birth a few months later... SUPER EXCITED AGAIN!!! Even if the timing coincides with what we have going on we are excited for the other one more than ourselves most of the time because we want to see each other happy and we celebrate each other because that's how love and families should operate. No comparison. No competition. No complaints. Why is that so hard for people?
I feel mixed actually. While I am completely understanding that excitement will be higher -first child for the sister and her wife via IVF and the baby is arriving soon vs 2nd baby for the OP n his wife, not arriving sooner, it's rude to ignore OP's wife and barely showing any interest. 2nd baby is as precious as first baby. Just coz it's not OP's first baby now doesn't mean this baby doesn't matter as much. OP's wife was feeling left out. OP did try to at least initiate a conversation which will throw light on "Hey we're here too. We too would like to share our happiness with you. We're planning to host a gender reveal party and would be so happy to see you all there!" But no avail. Nobody likes to be left out. It's actually on the hosts - mom and grandma who weren't tactful enough. They could've easily asked OP and wife to come on a different day if possible. And sister is mildly AH for making it into competition.
The fact is, after the first baby, most parents see a drop in excitement, from everyone. You've now successfully procreated already. There's no longer any worry you'll be childless. So people are happy, but not super excited. There's also a bit of "been there, done that" quality about it. It might be just as emotional for the parents-to-be, but for everyone else, well they've been there before. They now want to make a fuss over the *next* couple who are doing this for the first time. And the already-successful parents shouldn't want to rob another couple of *their* chance to be the center of attention - you know, the same attention *they* enjoyed once upon a time without having to share it.
Load More Replies...Absolutely YTA. Your wife and baby isn't the only one that matters. You're expecting your second child in 6 months, you sister is expecting her first child in 2 weeks. It's completely reasonable that they're focusing on her.
I mean, I'd give it a YTA for the gender reveal alone.
Load More Replies...So often we see situations where the wife gets upset about how her in-laws are treating her, and the husband sides with his family instead of his wife. And in those situations, the comments are always about how he should have stuck up for his wife, etc. Now we get a case where the husband does stick up for his wife with his family and the comments are mostly saying he's TA. I don't get it. I think he did right by sticking up for his wife instead of invalidating her feelings.
Yea, he's good for caring about his wife, but at the same time, he's an a*****e for trying to dictate all the attention be on his wife. Like everyone else has said, 1. it's his second child, which isn't due for ages, 2. it's his sisters first, through ivf treatment (which can be incredibly difficult for some women), and 3. his sisters baby is literally about to be born, of course grandparents are going to be mega excited. I'm sure closer to the time, OP's wife will get the attention she craves.
Load More Replies...He's definitely the a*****e for thinking he can dictate what people focus on, talk about.
OP’s wife already was the center of attention for their first baby. Now it’s sister and SIL’s turn, ffs—-and no one is even mentioning how goddamned difficult IVF is, on both your mental health and your pocketbook! What OP and wife should’ve been doing is gently asking if the new parents want any pointers, based on OP and wife’s experience, and offering to be of any help they could give,——“just give us a call if you need any help or advice”. As long as Sis and SIL don’t take advantage, the two couples should end up getting along splendidly—-maybe Sis and SIL would offer to babysit the oldest child for a couple days when OP’s wife gives birth. As it stands now, OP and wife can f*****g forget about asking Sis and SIL for any favors.
If there is a conversation and it is not yet finished you don't interrupt and change the topic. The grandparents were being socially correct to exhaust the topic and everything that mattered to them about it before changing their focus. I'm sure after they were finished they would welcome the next topic regarding the Ops pregnancy but I can see why it would not be so urgent as one is 2 weeks from the due date and the Ops wife and he are still 26 weeks from the same.
Let's be honest here as well, it is so hard for women to go through IVF, it's a huge commitment putting your body under that much stress. Plus OP never mentioned how many years his sister and wife had been trying because what is the chances of it happening the 1st time. The cost of IVF are astronomical as well, plus at 38 weeks she is at full gestation. The little brother threw his toys out of the pram, and his wife is giving me full Megan Markle vibes. The family will get to you when it's you about to welcome a baby in two weeks. Also OP should appreciate that he and his wife (I presume, as he had not mentioned it) had got pregnant the old fashioned way. Can he not stop for a minute and realise how lucky he is, this is his sisters journey and I bet it was a bumpy road. I honestly think out of all of the AITA stories you sir are the biggest AH of them all. That being said good luck with your wife's pregnancy, I'm sure when you put this aside your children will be best friends.
This reminded me of Scrubs episode where Turk is upset that Carla's 2nd pregnancy didn't ignite as much excitement as the 1st one.






















57
56