Mom Leaves $250k Inheritance To Son, Throws A Fit When Daughter Stops Looking After Her
Middle-aged woman and Reddit user Poesbutler has been having trouble with her elderly mother.
The lady is accident-prone and requires a lot of attention and care, which has increasingly fallen on her shoulders.
However, the woman has a busy life of her own, and finding time to travel and attend to the parent’s needs is difficult.
Image credits: Andrea Piacquadio / pexels (not the actual photo)
Image credits: Malte Luk / pexels (not the actual photo)
Image credits: Michael Jin / unsplash (not the actual photo)
Image credits: Melinda Gimpel / unsplash (not the actual photo)
Image credits: Poesbutler
Image credits: RDNE Stock project / pexels (not the actual photo)
Roughly two-thirds of Americans (66%) say grown children should provide caregiving for an elderly parent who needs it (this includes 32% who say they have a great deal of responsibility to do so).
But many in the so-called sandwich generation — adults who are caring for their parents as well as their own kids — are stretching their own resources thin or facing difficult money decisions between their own needs and those who rely on them.
In fact, 66% of sandwich generation members reported feeling at least somewhat stressed about affording their family’s financial obligations over the next 10 years, according to a recent Policygenius survey.
Furthermore, a 2017 AARP survey revealed that 40% of family caregivers were not prepared to take on that role.
Clearly, the author of the post does feel an obligation to look after her mother, but her story highlights that people need to establish boundaries for how much they’re willing and able to provide.
“We need to figure out where those boundaries lie, and how much we can really handle ourselves as family caregivers,” Danielle Miura, a certified financial planner who specializes in planning for the sandwich generation, told CNBC. “Is there a plan B in place to take care of ourselves so that we don’t feel obligated to put ourselves in a … position that we’re not comfortable with?”
Hopefully, this incident will help Poesbutler and her relatives figure out what works best for all of them.
As her story went viral, the woman provided additional context about her situation
People who expressed their support for her said the woman did nothing wrong
But some believe the daughter should suck it up
Eventually, the woman issued an update
Poll Question
Thanks! Check out the results:
I never fail to be astonished by the number of YTAs. She's not doing it for the money, none of us are. But I can totally understand why it hurts.
The money does matter though, cause op has had to spend her own to run down to take care of her mother, orevwn just visit cause the mother wont come see op and her family.
Load More Replies...the YTA people are wild. Yes, money is money, and you cannot expect anything from anybody's will like one said, but by that logic of money is money, time is money, travelling is money, and helping is money, so how come the YTA expect OP to go and help.
NTA. Don’t let the comments of virtue-signallers get you down. Being a mother does not change selfish manipulative people into a nice caring person. Your first duty is to be an available mother to your own children. Why are you making your entire family sacrifice for this manipulative woman. She’s not starving. She’s enough money to hire a carer. I fear you may be drawn back into this manipulative web because you appear a very loving and forgiving woman.
"Guess what money won't buy, health and family" yeah, and doing all the grunt work is draining the health and money of her and her family. My husband and I almost split over c**p like this.
It is not about money but about being totally unappreciated and yet expected to carry all the load.
And it's amazing that nine times out of ten, it's the female in the family stuck with the load.
Load More Replies...OP's mother said that her brother couldn't help with some things because he's a guy. THAT is a key part of this. I've seen it with family and friends. The daughter is expected to shoulder the caretaking burdens of aging parents instead of the son. Doesn't always happen that way, but it's very common.
I was thinking hygiene issues myself. But mostly as an excuse.
Load More Replies...NTA. You've been disinherited for no reason. Honestly, it sounds like OP's Mom is sexist, the type that values boys over girls yet expects girls to do all the heavy domestic work because it's "women's work". The fact she actively tried to hide this also shows that the Mom knows it's wrong but wants to keep the arrangement. When my parents redid their wills, they were VERY clear to my brothers and I about how they were dividing things up and why. They were also apologetic about certain things (like how my younger brother was getting a lot more since he's 14 years younger than me and at the time was still in middle school). My older brother and I didn't care how they split things, we just wanted them to be happy and taken care of.
It appears that the reason she is so upset is because her mum doesn't appreciate what she has been doing for her all these years. To keep saying how fantastic her brother is when he does so little must really hurt. To now learn that her brother is going to inherit everything must suck majorly. She was not estranged from her mum when the will was written and mum obviously knew she had done the wrong thing by hiding it from her. Both children should be POA both medically and financially, this was the first red flag. To not divide the assets equally between the brother and sister is truly awful. I'd go LC if it was me, maybe the aunt can arrange for the mother to go to a facility near the brother, it's his turn now. I'd definitely voice my feelings to the mother sooner rather than later so that she can know the consequences of her actions before dementia sets in.
I'm the grumpy old troll 🧌 living under a bridge 🌉
Load More Replies...Likely, your brother will inherit nothing if your mother goes into memory care. That will blow through $250,000 in a few years.
Then they will be equally situated when mom dies.
Load More Replies...NTA. Take care of your own family. Your brother who stands to benefit from being the golden child can step up.
The YTA crowd are AH themselves. Honestly OP has sacrificed her own family for years fir an ungrateful mother. It's time to step back. She needs to not feel guilty about ignoring that shrew if a mother. She should feel guilty about how she has treated her spouse and kids actually.
My father disinherited me and my 2 sisters in favor of his new family. I acted nobly, and I regret every sevond of time I gave to any of them. Disinheriting is disowning, declaring lack of relationship. Keep your time and your love for your spouse and children. Tha pain never ever goes away for the wasted time. She will never love you.
Let her spend her money on caretakers then, since her son is absolutely worthless except to mooch off other people. That's what I'd tell her, "you have the money, just pay for a caretaker".
So I am a caregiver for many years and many humans and now I care exclusively for my mom. Pictures of my sister who never helps hang everywhere in the house but none of me. Sometimes I want to take them all down and throw them in the creek. It is not about the money. It is about the lack of respect and expression of disloyalty. Her mother COST her money, time and experiences and then says her money is hers to do with as she pleases? So true. As is true for the daughter's resources as well. She should spend them where they are appreciated.
This! Screaming, locking herself in the bathroom, all of the "woe is me" texts... histrionic. Sounds like mom has manipulated OP her whole life.
Load More Replies...I can't understand why people think she should carry on regardless. I was the primary on-site (next door) care giver for Mum with my sister helping as much as she could from far away( trips to do home maintenance, dealing with agencies etc). I could not imagine a situation in which my mother would not have split the money in two. To be quite honest in our case it was unclear what was going to happen. We did not bank on the money as rest homes can take it all. It's not the money so much as the emotional meaness to expect someone to do lots of care and then cut them out of the will.
NTA . Cut contact and move on. It's toxic and abusive to use you like that. My mother was the exact the same way life insurance and all. I cut her out and moved and I've never been happier.
If she moves into an assisted living facility, there will be no money left to inherit.
The “mother” is a Witch, with a B . Leave her rely on brother dearest , NOT , and stay home with your husband and children. If family members complain , tell them to call your brother , then hang up !
The YTA people really saw money and went "how dare you! " and left the rest of the post. I don't think op cares if she left her with anything or not. It's the fact that her mom hid everything from her, won't let her make decisions with her when there are other people involved, and then gas lights her when she doesn't get her way. The money is only important because it was the straw that broke the camels back. She didn't say she's worried about anyone, she hid it because she Knew what it said. "I don't care about you" She just doesn't wanna change the status quo she made along time ago. Op broke the cycle, sure it's late but better late than never. People are raised on these beliefs, sometimes brainwashed into them because it's all they've known. It's extremely hard to break these habits. I've watched many people literally panic over nothing simply because to them it's not, it's decades of conditioning. Kudos on the supportive husband and may they figure things out and enjoy life.
It's not the money that's most important here; it's the cruelty, manipulation and ingratitude. Expressed by driving this poor bloody woman to the crazy house and the poorhouse simultaneously and not even bothering to pay her back.
"Mamma, you may have nothing to say, but you are going to hear me out. Then, I'm going home while you think about it. I love you. I won't fight over your money. But you should use it to take some of the pressure off me, because I have a household to care for also. I cannot be in 2 places at once. Either you come to me, and contribute to your own care financially, or you get my brother here to lift some of this weight off my shoulders. I am one person, and can only take so much. I have been past my breaking point for a long time. Now, I feel like I've been slapped in the face. You've watched me sacrifice ALL of this for nothing in return, and then when it comes time to divide up things, you don't seem to care about the things my kids have missed out on, my spouse has missed out on, or the sleepless nights I've gone just to balance you and them. This is where I draw the line. I love you. I'll talk to you when you make a decision. So-n-so is scheduled to be here for you."
Unfortunately, I see mom not listening and will probably lock herself in the bathroom again.
Load More Replies...My neighbour unintentionally killed herself in attention seeking attempt, because it was impossible to fool her daughter ( the nurse) with fake sickness. Just to consider…
This looks like the mother could have narcissistic personality disorder: emotionally immature, refuses to engage in straight talk because it risks making her look bad, trash talking daughter to others, golden child brother, lack of empathy, self-victimisation, entitled to daughters time and resources but complaining she's not doing enough and never appreciative... I'm no diagnostician but OP needs to look after her mental health and stop being mummy's 'supply'
My elderly mother is pulling a similar stunt. I don't have siblings but nothing I do for her is enough and she accuses me of never being out there enough. I've tried for years to get her to move closer so I can do things for her but she refuses and wants me to drive 2 hours every other day to do little tasks for her. Sorry, I'm employed full-time and have a household to maintain. Don't have time to maintain another one if it sucks 16 hours per week just in drive time. I don't know if it's a boomer thing or an old-person thing, but there's frequently this expectation that the kids place their whole lives on hold at the drop of a hat whenever the parents need the slightest thing.
I'm the boomer and my mother pulled these stunts all the time. I moved completely across the country (US) so she could only whine and complain. Even after I was promoted to a detective in my department, she kept trying to tell me to come "home" because I wasn't "doing anything", i.e. not married and no kids.
Load More Replies...I'm just waiting for my grandmother's will to come out this way. Her son does help, but only because she literally pays him to. For anything 'extra' it's always my mom. Despite the fact that my mom is the one trying to keep their mostly failed business afloat, so she's really just shooting herself and my uncle in the foot. I've told my mom she needs to drop the rope. She vents/dumps onto me and I'm sick of the whole situation just from that.
You should spend the time you don't taking care of a clearly manipulative mother getting therapy to deal with all.the things she has done to you over the years. This is far more than just take care of me, she has been emotionally abusing you and manipulating you your whole life.
NTA. You need to focus on your own family. If I were your husband I'd be livid you're spending your PTO, family funds and missing out on your children to enable this entitled person. Stop engaging with her and this so-called family who expect you to be the skivvy because you're female. Stop engaging with her, too. 'You need to hire professionals, I'm not available for care anymore.'
Okay, BP. Get rid of the damn Hulu Ad. On every page and you literally can't see anything as it takes up the entire screen.
That's just on your screen dude. Not everyone is seeing it. Also, get an ad blocker.
Load More Replies...WTH is wrong with these YTA people? I'll bet they will be a burden on their children in their declining years and be donkey rears to their dutiful children. This women bent over backwards out of love for her mother. Her mother is showing that the golden child has all of the love, none of the duty, and all of the inheritance. Mother and golden son are massive AHs.
This seems to be the way it is 90% of the time. I am the youngest of four. I'm the one that stayed home and took care of her. Drove her every where she wanted. The only one that didn't take money from her GI loan account for various failed attempts at higher education. My sister, (the oldest) and my oldest brother were always asking her for money for one school or another that they never completed. At least my second to oldest brother went to teck school and came out with a degree and ended up working for Boeing. I was the one, along with my now wife, that drove here 50 miles to the hospital when she had a stroke. Went into debt so she could go into rehab and had to file bankruptcy and so much more. She left everything she had to oldest brother and sister and left me a dollar to symbolize "All I had taken from her in life". Because, as her story went, she had "died" for several minutes while giving birth to me.
My mother was a passive aggressive narcissist who would pull the 'I fell I need help' c**p any time that I would just drop what I was doing to attend to a non-emergency issue. She threw a toddler sized temper tantrum when I wouldn't go pick up pants at the place she had them altered. She didn't NEED them right then, she WANTED them. I told her that I had food on the oven and on the stove, my husband was on his way home (trucker) and I would get the pants the next day. She threw a complete fit. It's so manipulative. She even admitted to me the very last time she was taken to the hospital that she got on the floor and pressed her emergency life alert button when I wouldn't come over as demanded. I'm so glad she's dead.
Classic narcissist-codependent relationship. Codependent saying "I feel guilty, I feel like I've been bad" for considering applying a tourniquet -- as the narc greedily drains the last drop of the codependent's blood. Being a codependent is like having Stockholm Syndrome. The positive attention is so sparse that you will grovel for one crumb and be grateful forever, regardless of endless mistreatment. It's a disease.
Sounds like OPs mom is a vulnerable narcissist (guilt is a large part of their arsenal). Bro isn't far behind. And those calling her YTA may suffer from just straight up stupidity.
It's not about the money but mom declared she doesn't even like her daughter, only uses her. OP maybe doesn't know yet, but she's upset because she finally realised this. She's not loved by her mom. It takes many years to process this. At the end, you have two choices. Either you help them, even though they don't even like you, or leave them, and get yourself healed and focus your own life. Many will say that mom loves her but... There's no but. They always use this phrase as a shield to hide behind "I'm not concerned about your future, you're doing good on your own, your sibling needs more help". I have a golden sister and my mom also says this. She didn't let me eat the food she cooked because I ate at school, so it's not for me, to mention only one of her kind deeds... My sister leave in another country, so I'm the one who she calls when she needs to set up her wi-fi or anything. Things she could do on her own but she likes to make me jump.
It hurts as hell, and those who have loving parents or haven't realised yet that their parents don't like them, will never understand. It's not about not loving your parent. It's about being hurt deeply.
Load More Replies...I'm really hoping YTA people didn't read the WHOLE story. Like how OP is spending her OWN MONEY to travel and take care of Mom. Leaving HER family & job when Bro barely has a job and no kids so CHOOSES to be an a$$. Mom SHOULD NOT be driving and the fact that Mom would rather pay for everyone to come to her than travel shows she's pathetic. Because that means less work for her and more time to be pitiful
As someone who has been in a similar situation, I can tell you there is no way to win here. My mother GAVE a house to my sibling--as a reward for getting their act together. Yes, she always had to worry about this one having a job & a roof over their head; never with me, and I was a single parent that owned my responsibilities. When Mom was preparing her will, my sibling was actually living WITH her and renting out the home Mom had given them...Mom chose to put both our names on the home she was living in, and leave me the contents. Sibling got irate that I would get everything in the house, as well as half ownership of it. I acquiesed and told mom to split that too (spoiler alert--when mom passed, sibling got b****y about SO MUCH that I ended up giving them EVERYTHING in the house). To this day, because sibling is agian dealing with demons, everything I've tried to help with has been turned around on me & I've been made to feel like $h!+ for aiming for fairness. Haven't spoken 3 yrs
The house is half yours; make the co-owner pay rent.
Load More Replies...My brother was the favored one in our family. My Mom was a chronic alcoholic. My sister handled her finances and I got all the phone calls — calls saying she passed out in public — calls that she went to the hairdresser naked and poopy, etc. And gold brother who lived the closest? Nothing. However, my point is this to you: Your Mom is an ungrateful person who plays favorites — therefore, a bad Mom. Sadly, I see you unwilling to cut the cord. She taught you to be a "good girl" and it's hard to stop, but at this point you must think of your family. Some of your anger surely sifts into your family life. Stop. trying. to. please. everybody. Stop. worrying. about. what. people. think.
YTA troop ain't never run through all their own finances only to be told they're not getting reimbursed either financially or emotionally. GTFO.
Wow, I really felt this. My mom is very similar. She relies on me to do everything, rarely asking my older brothers for help. I'm the only one that still has a kid at home, but she always thinks I'm avoiding her if I tell her I am busy. Meanwhile, my oldest brother is her favorite. She goes on and on about any little thing he does for her.
If your mother has $250,000, she can damn well take care of her medical and caregiver needs. You are behind time in taking care of YOU and YOUR family. Let your mother and your brother handle this now. She's not broke. NTA.
NTA. Your mom doesn't appreciate all what you've done for her and sacrificed on her behalf. She's had the child moments and family moments that you are now missing with your own. Those are important. Your brother has made his own choices (and yes, I can see how the favor has played for him and being entitled is a consequence of those actions). Your mom needs to realize that the only way to help him, is to not bail him out of life. Leaving him that money is doing him a disservice. She should have discussed things with both of you regarding her POA (especially if he doesn't know what that entails), the will, the future plans, etc. Her passing is an absolute. To do it the best way is communication.
Assisted living takes that money to pay for her care. It won't matter what the will says, the house may eventually have to be sold to pay for her care. When all the money is gone, then that is when government support takes over. Depending upon how long she lives, there might not be 250k left.
NTA ... I bought my birth pod a house, where she wanted to live. After I signed all the paperwork and had the keys, she decided that she didn't want to contribute to the mortgage, she would have received housing benefit due to being retired. Needless to say I ended up with a house in an area I would never live so it's been rented ever since and not to her. Thankfully she's dead now, don't have deal with her or her toxic personality.
Do what my grandparents did and take money out of the equation. Meaning, goes to charity. Then you'll really see who has a fit once the will reading commences. My grandparents were well off. My father's older sister raised holy hell once she realized no one was getting anything. Huge fallout once the dust settled. Needless to say, most of us haven't heard from her in over a dozen years.
Been there, in a manner of speaking. I was the only one who took care of my wheelchair bound mother after a stroke for four years (she couldn't even stand or go to the washroom, I had to supply and change her diapers l, etc etc etc) yet she split everything equally between me and my siblings. But as soon as she passed, they somehow made the time to come and get what heirlooms they wanted, and basically I was forced to sell the house I had lived in for 24 years to settle her estate. Do not for one second think your family is different, money makes people do crazy things! She is totally NTA.
Guess what...once she goes into the home THEY WILL be taking all her assets to care for her. If she has property it will have to sold. That's how it works. Brother dear won't be getting 250,000 anything!
I hate when people generalize about baby boomers and believe we all think alike. I went through something similar, but it was my father who gave away things my mother wanted me to have and I had actually bought some of the items for her. He gave things to my SIL because my niece is the “golden child” in his eyes and he’s trying to buy her affection. I was the one that did all the errands and emergency room visits, but it’s my brother and SIL who will get everything. My feeling is that they can take care of him now (plus I’m disabled!) so I definitely believe she’s NTA and her mom is an AH.
I think if her mother wants the daughter to care for her, the mother needs to move close to her daughters home..we moved my mom into our home after my brother's refused to help in anyw way..I was 150 miles away, they lived in the same city..it was difficult, but had help from my hubby, and she had a great last 6 years..glad we could help her.. Btw, no inheritance was left, she spent it all..my younger brother couldn't believe it..ugh Some people cannot be pleased..same brother visited two times in Six years..other brother came up 2 or 3 times per year
NTA. Yes, it's about MONEY! It's about that OP spent all of HER OWN MONEY to drop her own life on a dime & run to take care of an ungrateful mother, who in turn saved up all of HER money to bestow on the favored but truly unworthy sibling. These days, don't try & act as if money isn't the main factor of EVERY decision, because that's just delusional.
If it wasn't about the money, mom would have hired a care aide, offered money to OP, paid for the whole family to come down, or made sure OOP didn't lose out financially at the very *least*. She should have told her, but she didn't because she knew what she was doing, and how it would hurt. She made it in secret and deliberately kept it from the daughter even as she was *actively helping her with a task*. Mom knew how it looked. Mom knew what and how much it would hurt. If mom had had her way, OP would have continued sacrificing her own life to her mother (and by extension her brother) and would have been dealt this absolute combo slap to the face punch to the gut kick to the groin *as she was mourning her mom*. Money is a two way street, and while money doesn't directly equal love, using someone for their money is the opposite of love - indifference. She didn't give two shits for her daughter or family. Now she can live with the natural and just fallout of her own actions.
I have a sister with autism(eldest) and an older brother. All my adult life, it's been expected that I'm the one to call to help out. I went throug vacation time, time off without pay and my own personal savings to do so. Never any thanks or any thought to the time off or money spent. The will divided the estate equally between all 3 siblings. I have requested reimbursement of expenditures for traveling costs, or personal items for my sister always backed up with a receipt. It is a problem for my brother who has asked the bank to hold any requests until he approved them ( no requests for reimbursement from him, as he never visited her or had her over to his place) . I'm still expected to attend all appointments, pick her up and bring her back to the group home for home visits. Last month I finally said "enough" and stepped away until the finances are worked out. It seems they are coping very well without me.
Mom can obviously afford a home care assistant. I had to move across the country (USA) to get away from my drunken parents who argued and fought constantly. My mother used to call me at work because she needed a quart of milk; there was a mom and pop grocery on the next block and their son would have delivered it for no charge. My mother used to say that I owed her. After she died, I discovered that my parents didn't get married until she was five months pregnant, and this was not acceptable in the 1940s. Apparently, lots of fighting went on.
If Mom wants you around for things, let her know you want to be there for her, but you need to be there for your family, too. So the best way to do that is have you all living near each other! And gosh, Mom, spouse and I can't really leave our jobs, but maybe you could move up near us. Aunt said you were considering a move - I know change can be scary, but with you up near us, I'd get to visit with you not just when you're sick, but also just for fun! And grandkid 1 and grandkid 2 would love to visit with you too - they know how special you are to me, and want to get to know you. This way she moves to a place where she gets some professional care, you get to be there providing support, and you don't have to use PTO and leave your family to do it. And Golden Boy can still come visit when it's convenient for him. Win-win.
I would have been dropkicked the mom and anyone calling to scold me for not going would have gotten chewed the f**k out and cut off. Mom wants to hide in the bathroom instead of talking to me she can suck a d**k from the back. I would tell the mom to drink a lot of icewater where she is going, its hot AF.
I don’t think the OP is at fault for withdrawing. Boundaries should have been set years ago. Help but within reason - not spending vacations, savings or missing important moments with children and spouses to do so. Voice of experience here. Also, sometimes, we incorrectly assume money correlates to our value or regard in the eyes of others. We see our familial relationships as transactional - like employment, which it is not. When you have a close-knit group of friends and one is not as financially solvent as the rest, generally the others will pitch in to allow that individual to participate if an activity is too luxurious for them. No one rants “what about me?”. The OP did say her younger brother is typically employed in low wage jobs - to offer a differing perspective, what if that money was set aside so OP didn’t have to become responsible for him later in life? Inheriting a home and then a quarter mil, would do just that.
No need to put it this way. She did not do this because of the will. She made changes because the will made clear what she needed to see all along! So, AITAH for leaving my injured mom on her own because she cut me out of her will.
Your mother can call the Dept. of Employment if she needs help. No help for a parent who treats you like a stranger on the street.
Load More Replies...Friend, I understand that you want to take care of your mom but I think seeing the will confirmed how you knew your mom felt all along.P.O.A.'s are put in place for a reason and as the role you have played as a caretaker,it's your right to call a family meeting to get everyone that calls you regarding mom-emergencies a part to play in her care.If everyone is that busy hire a full time caretaker and install cameras so everyone can respond to the mom-emergencies. You must have a balance because you are already drained. In my closing,the Bible says to honor your parents but it says parents don't provoke your children to wrath,so parents and children play a part. God bless dear.
After she is gone, bill her estate for your monies spent caring for her. Lost wages, traveling expenses. I have high hopes that the total excides $250,000.00
I know how she feels it's not about the money it's more being not appreciated and shown it. Plus you hear about the ones or one that is loved or cared for that won't take the time to drop a meal by or offer to take to take the parent to doctor's appointment. I feel you and I hear you.Stop! Reset! And change the dynamics of your relationship with your Mother, she's using you Up!
Inheritance isn't a measure of love or app.... BS!!! You must be y2k kids thinking that!! For the boomers that is EXACTLY what it is! Its the post life Bonus for the dutiful children that PROVED thier worth, denieing it means either there wasn't any or you screwed up! Remember this gen was raised on achievement and appearances, and $ was the currency of affection & worth, and if you ever saw an 80's movie you'd know!! Also, why is she so far away if she's so needy? Again, nodding to the generational value system, only "contributors" get feelings and/or are catered to,("when you pay the bills, you get a vote", et al) so by their rules, if they aren't prepared to make financial arrangements and they require your time/effort, then they are obligated to ease the burden or fend for themselves!(ie: move close to you or hire help) You youth be glad we figured out healthier forms of affection since they also spent OUR retirement, so you won't have to worry about this with us! Lol
NTA Just because someone gives birth to you doesn't mean you owe them your life. The money although painful it isn't the issue. (Nice to see you dont care about it ) Your brother is the problem here , it's the principle of the thing. Your mum is selfish as hell just like mine and just expects you to be there and drop everything when ever she wants something . Your brother needs to step up, but won't as you always do. I've walked away from my family for very similar reasons and I'm much happier for it . Unfortunately because you're a good person and obviously capable you've made a rod for your own back and your brother has taken advantage of the situation, and unfortunately your mum like mine idolises the kid who's a d**k as they don't want to have to admit to themselves their kid is a waster. Remind then that your kindness is no sign of weakness . It is strength and can be recinded at any moment of your choosing. You obviously help because you care and no other reason. Good luck :-)
I really don't think we owe our parents anything if they are not offering up reasonably healthy relationships. If she has a quarter of $1 million to leave to somebody, she has plenty of money to hire help around the house. My mother was like this too and my brother and I just freaking gave up. She had more than enough money to hire help -- she was just too neurotic. All she wanted was her two children who lived thousands of miles away to be dancing attendance upon her. And perhaps unlike this woman's situation, my mother was never a nice person and never offered anything resembling love or affection, so we did not care. She was incredibly toxic, so she got exactly what she deserved.
I took care of my mother for 12.5 years as my siblings were all dead. I didn't regret any of it. However, when I was diagnosed with cancer and my mother's needs increased significantly, I arranged for her to go into assisted living. Her response, she tried to commit suicide in my home. When the hospital called saying she was being discharged and could come home, I told them she didn't have a home. Seemed harsh; however, my own physician said she had to go to a facility for my own health. I will never pose such a burden on my own girls. I loved my mother; however, she exhausted her own resources trying to help my d**g addicted brother and his d**g addled wife. The stress she added to our home was crushing. OP should change her phone number or tell her mother she is on her own. OP's family deserves better.
Nine times out of 10 it is the woman who is asked to do the caregiving. Maybe several decades ago that might have been more realistic, but now in two income households from one parent families, that's not viable. The responsibility should be shared! And the brothers a jerk playing. the irresponsible. "I don't know what's going on." Person.
I think you should sit down with your mother and tell her what you said here: I am the one responsible for you, and you are leaving the bulk of your estate to my brother. How would you feel if you were in my position? I'm hurt. I'm offended. I never cared for you out of expectations of remuneration, but your decision shows no appreciation for my efforts. Just be straight. I say that as someone who wishes she had spent more time caring for her mother, whose favored child she was not, and less time going to every ballgame etc. I wish I had been straightforward with my mother about how I felt about her preferences. We both would have benefited. Were I your mother, I'd be deeply grateful for your efforts. But you are right to feel as you do----hurt and neglected. She doesn't see that. Give her a chance to see it, at least. BinThereDunThet
Had similar situation. I gave up work to care for mum full time as needed round the clock care. I gave up my life, even the 2 years beforehand had to keep taking time off unpaid to catch up with mums stuff that needed doing as my 3 siblings were doing absolutely nothing even though one of them used to come down and stay a night and day every week and one next door. Mum passed away a few months ago. Mum had split the will evenly between the 4 of us. None of them gave me any help or respite the whole 4 years. I was exhausted caring for mum all day and up a few times every night. If I hadn’t done this mum would’ve gone into care. Before mums body was even taken away my brother was already talking about the house, the next day getting it valued, third day throwing her clothes out etc etc. It was awful. Mums house was also my only home which I grew up in. My siblings all have their houses paid off and plenty of money. When mum died they were happy to leave me homeless at nearly 60.
Those who attacked OP should have a quiet word with themselves. Yes OP got herself in this position but I’m guessing the dynamic was established a long time ago! Yes it’s hard that her children have lost out but kids aren’t stupid, they know the difference between a disinterested parent and one who’s trying to be there for family. Failing at it, unfortunately but trying is more important that success for most.
Case of mother is a narcissist. Had one of them. She wrote a will which stated "all my children" and named them all singly except me the first born (of her first marriage). Just get a lawyer. As someone commented up above leaving someone out of a will is a denial of kinship basically.
i witnessed dynamic w/my grandmother & the different treatment she gave to my mom & my aunt. aunt lived in alaska; we lived in the same state as "nannie". nan depended on mom for everthing but also treated her w/distain. when my aunt came for her annual visit nan announce we weren't to bother her bc aunt was there to visit her. when my uncle passed my aunt moved close to us. nan expected aunt to take care of her, including living w/her which she did for a while. nan contacted mom & asked if she could move in w/her & my dad as she was unhappy living w/the golden daughter. of course mom allowed her. when nan got very frail w/age mom was there. when she passed all went to my aunt. asked her once about how she felt about that & mom only said 'she was my mom. i loved her even if she didn't love me the same as my sister. let her have it all. in the end mom knew who she could count on.'
The only thing that sounds "off" is how she has had car accidents, cancer, pneumonia etc but she wasn't 'like that' before she retired. What does that mean and who or what was she 'like"? She was like a healthy person who hadn't all the needs? Now she is probably getting dementia or something similar.. With that much money 250 000 that could pay for a little help. Who has power of attorney anyhow? Sounds like you have been doing all this help out of a sense of duty not love. There ought to be a way to set up something that doesn't require you or someone else to be there in person Too bad you feel you cannot speak to her openly or honestly and mute her after all these years of addressing her neediness and helplessness in person...Why not just tell brother mother and everyone else concerned you feel this resentment and feel under appreciated? That it was a sacrifice and expensive etc. But I guess no one will care.] Yet it will make things clearer and might be a relief.
The YTAs are absolutely disgusting. Let them cater to someone that demanding, ungrateful and clearly a hard core gaslighter. Will is the nail.in the f**k you coffin proving she doesn't value her daughter at all. Otherwise she'd be open to explaining why and not hiding from it. The mom is filth and should be NC because thata not how you treat your daughter.
My aunt planned to give the money from the sale of her house (that she lived in for over 50 years) to her brother after he invited her to move down to the coast and live with him. She was only there a year when he kicked her out, saying he "feels like he's got a wife" (he was married at the time; his wife had mental issues and they didn't live together for quite a few years before his wife died) and some other stuff. Apparently they made up, but she can't remember now (she's over 90) and I'm her godchild. But I don't know if she's leaving me anything, or is going to leave money to all her nieces and nephews (she never had kids). I'd rather have her than the money.
NTA- It isn’t about the money. The Will is just the item that is telling her daughter that she is NOT appreciated. There is also a clear “golden child” memo in this. Why keep doing something VERY difficult for someone who doesn’t appreciate it? I’m sure the mom loves her daughter and daughter to mom. Love isn’t the question. How many times has the mom bragged about what a “good daughter” she has?
NTA. The YTA's that think it's about money are being simplistic and have no understanding of what it feels like to be classed as second or third best.
NTA-However, if she's going to spend the rest of her life feeling guilty then I think she should continue some form of communication. Just for her own peace of mind. Boundaries definitely need to be made though. She's being used every which way with that side of her family. I'm glad an aunt stepped up to help.
I am the oldest and when my mother ended up on hospice my sister who is much better off financially (career military officer with 40 years in service) than myself flew me, herself to sit with my mom while she was dying. As the eldest I was the executor of her will. I received my stepdads truck, my brother her car. My sister knowing she was much better off financially than me or my brother stated she was fine with that distribution. We cleaned out their home and property and split the proceeds from the property sale. Thankfully no resentment between us.
Your Mother's care should not fall on your shoulders, PERIOD! Your brother should tend to all her needs going forward. If the hospital or ER calls you, refer them to your brother! Your Mother made her choice, so now she has to live with it. Don't permit your Mother to take advantage of you. Stand your ground!
NTA, it's clearly favoritism on her moms part. The inheritance should be divided equally - the brother too gets 1/2 even when he doesn't contribute much - that should be enough compensation for his low wages. Why should only 1 shoulder all the responsibility, and the other get the entire benefit? Very unfair
Ok this is not a boomer thing unless they are mostly this and that is a Narcissist. It's not just about giving more to the one who has less but to continue to bully the one they can. Over and over. Once u put ur foot down they wail. Complain to any who will listen. And use their situation to get others to side with them. Open ur eyes and see. Yes it's not about the money but about what is just and equal in a family dynamic. Even if u don't like the person, family member, or friend, u can't take the money with u so might as well be fair...
ii understand how OP feels. my mother and sister are more concerned with leaving everything to my good for nothing great niece, even pressuring my childless brother to do the same. my kids mean nothing to them. my brother said he's not leaving a dime to that spoiled brat (27yr old). she can pick my sister a nice little nursing home before frittering away her inheritance. I'm walking away after my mom passes. family should be treated fairly, more so if the care falls to one person. anything else is a slap in the face.
My dad was physically, emotionally, and verbally abusive to me growing up. Guess who ended up taking care of him when he got old and disabled? And I am so glad we took him in. I actually got to know him, minus the alcohol. He became a good friend. Forgiveness isn't for everyone, but I am so glad I gave it a shot.
I wonder, people who writing YTA are the golden children? I heard that “ how can you think about, blah- blah”, then GKid went to the Aid and declared her to return her payments, because those money went from gran retirement, and he is only one on the will, so it was his money… But for all other family members it’s always:“ how can you even think about money, it’s MaMa!”
And yeah, gran was alive and needed this aid ‘s help
Load More Replies...I've been in this situation twice (and betrayed twice) in my life. and although receiving an inheritance is always helpful to one's finances, money is not really the issue. Time, family, and one's own health are ultimately what matters. Sometimes you simply don't have anything left to give, and your own life is in shambles. Help loved ones as you can, but don't wear yourself to exhaustion. It hurt like hell when I had to pur my aunt in assisted living; but what the situation required was beyond my capacity. Vultures who come in and persuade a loved one to give them everything despite doing little or nothing are hurtful and disappointing, but I have always provided for my own famly through good times and bad whether someone gave me a financial boost or not. I love the people in the Bahamas. Even if a cruise ship in in port and there is tons of money to be gotten from tourists, everything shuts down by late afternoon so people can enjoy their lives.
From each according to his ability. To each according to his needs. Doesn't work in government. Doesn't work in family either.
I think those that considered her TA have a screw loose. The amount wasn’t the issue, it was the lack of respect and acknowledgement for providing her time and money to someone ungrateful while baby brother doesn’t do c**p. Also she’s not taking care of the dad, so who cares if there’s acknowledgment there. Brother and mother are TA, daughter is not.
People passing judgement while hearing just one side of the story is wild to me. I've had so many people distort reality when sharing their view of past events that I've become increasingly sensitive to this b******t. While reading I couldn't help notice a frantic effort to paint herself in a good light while doing the opposite for her brother and mother. Judging her brother's lifestyle, claiming he should be doing more cause he doesn't have kids is just one red flag there. I couldn't even imagine chiming in without hearing their side of the story.
There are a few things that seem to be fact in the story. Her brother is the power of attorney, why does he keep having people call the sister? It's his duty. The sister has been going down more frequently than the brother to care for the mother. That can lead to frustration. The mother is leaving the majority of her assets to the brother. To some people that can make it seem that the care that you have given was unappreciated. Even if the brother and the mother wrote their sides of the story, would those three things change? My guess is no.
Load More Replies...The way her mother treats OP is literally on the same level as Disney Step-Mothers are treating their Step Daughters. And they know just as well that they're the Villains and are proud about it
Send your Mom a bill. For all of the travel, loss of holidays and loss of seeing those milestones . Take it to her lawyer and contest the will. Don't take 'no' for an answer.
This is a bullsh*t story. You the daughter are getting what you deserve. You know your mother is an a*s and has been behaving like this forever. You know your brother is an a*s and has probably greatly influenced your mother. After all, you have a husband to take care of you. I would say your husband is married to a man, but you do not have any balls.
You need to be able to live with yourself and your decisions. If you can face yourself knowing you didn't go when she asked you, fine. Your brother seems to do alright with his decisions. Don't let the money be a factor, doesn't sound like you have concrete info, and anything can happen.
Nice virtue signaling. I'm empathetic to this woman who is sacrificing the well being of her marriage and children for someone who doesn't appreciate it. The will was just the last straw and I support anyone who is no longer willing to be a doormat due to "traditional" views on caregiving.
Load More Replies...I never fail to be astonished by the number of YTAs. She's not doing it for the money, none of us are. But I can totally understand why it hurts.
The money does matter though, cause op has had to spend her own to run down to take care of her mother, orevwn just visit cause the mother wont come see op and her family.
Load More Replies...the YTA people are wild. Yes, money is money, and you cannot expect anything from anybody's will like one said, but by that logic of money is money, time is money, travelling is money, and helping is money, so how come the YTA expect OP to go and help.
NTA. Don’t let the comments of virtue-signallers get you down. Being a mother does not change selfish manipulative people into a nice caring person. Your first duty is to be an available mother to your own children. Why are you making your entire family sacrifice for this manipulative woman. She’s not starving. She’s enough money to hire a carer. I fear you may be drawn back into this manipulative web because you appear a very loving and forgiving woman.
"Guess what money won't buy, health and family" yeah, and doing all the grunt work is draining the health and money of her and her family. My husband and I almost split over c**p like this.
It is not about money but about being totally unappreciated and yet expected to carry all the load.
And it's amazing that nine times out of ten, it's the female in the family stuck with the load.
Load More Replies...OP's mother said that her brother couldn't help with some things because he's a guy. THAT is a key part of this. I've seen it with family and friends. The daughter is expected to shoulder the caretaking burdens of aging parents instead of the son. Doesn't always happen that way, but it's very common.
I was thinking hygiene issues myself. But mostly as an excuse.
Load More Replies...NTA. You've been disinherited for no reason. Honestly, it sounds like OP's Mom is sexist, the type that values boys over girls yet expects girls to do all the heavy domestic work because it's "women's work". The fact she actively tried to hide this also shows that the Mom knows it's wrong but wants to keep the arrangement. When my parents redid their wills, they were VERY clear to my brothers and I about how they were dividing things up and why. They were also apologetic about certain things (like how my younger brother was getting a lot more since he's 14 years younger than me and at the time was still in middle school). My older brother and I didn't care how they split things, we just wanted them to be happy and taken care of.
It appears that the reason she is so upset is because her mum doesn't appreciate what she has been doing for her all these years. To keep saying how fantastic her brother is when he does so little must really hurt. To now learn that her brother is going to inherit everything must suck majorly. She was not estranged from her mum when the will was written and mum obviously knew she had done the wrong thing by hiding it from her. Both children should be POA both medically and financially, this was the first red flag. To not divide the assets equally between the brother and sister is truly awful. I'd go LC if it was me, maybe the aunt can arrange for the mother to go to a facility near the brother, it's his turn now. I'd definitely voice my feelings to the mother sooner rather than later so that she can know the consequences of her actions before dementia sets in.
I'm the grumpy old troll 🧌 living under a bridge 🌉
Load More Replies...Likely, your brother will inherit nothing if your mother goes into memory care. That will blow through $250,000 in a few years.
Then they will be equally situated when mom dies.
Load More Replies...NTA. Take care of your own family. Your brother who stands to benefit from being the golden child can step up.
The YTA crowd are AH themselves. Honestly OP has sacrificed her own family for years fir an ungrateful mother. It's time to step back. She needs to not feel guilty about ignoring that shrew if a mother. She should feel guilty about how she has treated her spouse and kids actually.
My father disinherited me and my 2 sisters in favor of his new family. I acted nobly, and I regret every sevond of time I gave to any of them. Disinheriting is disowning, declaring lack of relationship. Keep your time and your love for your spouse and children. Tha pain never ever goes away for the wasted time. She will never love you.
Let her spend her money on caretakers then, since her son is absolutely worthless except to mooch off other people. That's what I'd tell her, "you have the money, just pay for a caretaker".
So I am a caregiver for many years and many humans and now I care exclusively for my mom. Pictures of my sister who never helps hang everywhere in the house but none of me. Sometimes I want to take them all down and throw them in the creek. It is not about the money. It is about the lack of respect and expression of disloyalty. Her mother COST her money, time and experiences and then says her money is hers to do with as she pleases? So true. As is true for the daughter's resources as well. She should spend them where they are appreciated.
This! Screaming, locking herself in the bathroom, all of the "woe is me" texts... histrionic. Sounds like mom has manipulated OP her whole life.
Load More Replies...I can't understand why people think she should carry on regardless. I was the primary on-site (next door) care giver for Mum with my sister helping as much as she could from far away( trips to do home maintenance, dealing with agencies etc). I could not imagine a situation in which my mother would not have split the money in two. To be quite honest in our case it was unclear what was going to happen. We did not bank on the money as rest homes can take it all. It's not the money so much as the emotional meaness to expect someone to do lots of care and then cut them out of the will.
NTA . Cut contact and move on. It's toxic and abusive to use you like that. My mother was the exact the same way life insurance and all. I cut her out and moved and I've never been happier.
If she moves into an assisted living facility, there will be no money left to inherit.
The “mother” is a Witch, with a B . Leave her rely on brother dearest , NOT , and stay home with your husband and children. If family members complain , tell them to call your brother , then hang up !
The YTA people really saw money and went "how dare you! " and left the rest of the post. I don't think op cares if she left her with anything or not. It's the fact that her mom hid everything from her, won't let her make decisions with her when there are other people involved, and then gas lights her when she doesn't get her way. The money is only important because it was the straw that broke the camels back. She didn't say she's worried about anyone, she hid it because she Knew what it said. "I don't care about you" She just doesn't wanna change the status quo she made along time ago. Op broke the cycle, sure it's late but better late than never. People are raised on these beliefs, sometimes brainwashed into them because it's all they've known. It's extremely hard to break these habits. I've watched many people literally panic over nothing simply because to them it's not, it's decades of conditioning. Kudos on the supportive husband and may they figure things out and enjoy life.
It's not the money that's most important here; it's the cruelty, manipulation and ingratitude. Expressed by driving this poor bloody woman to the crazy house and the poorhouse simultaneously and not even bothering to pay her back.
"Mamma, you may have nothing to say, but you are going to hear me out. Then, I'm going home while you think about it. I love you. I won't fight over your money. But you should use it to take some of the pressure off me, because I have a household to care for also. I cannot be in 2 places at once. Either you come to me, and contribute to your own care financially, or you get my brother here to lift some of this weight off my shoulders. I am one person, and can only take so much. I have been past my breaking point for a long time. Now, I feel like I've been slapped in the face. You've watched me sacrifice ALL of this for nothing in return, and then when it comes time to divide up things, you don't seem to care about the things my kids have missed out on, my spouse has missed out on, or the sleepless nights I've gone just to balance you and them. This is where I draw the line. I love you. I'll talk to you when you make a decision. So-n-so is scheduled to be here for you."
Unfortunately, I see mom not listening and will probably lock herself in the bathroom again.
Load More Replies...My neighbour unintentionally killed herself in attention seeking attempt, because it was impossible to fool her daughter ( the nurse) with fake sickness. Just to consider…
This looks like the mother could have narcissistic personality disorder: emotionally immature, refuses to engage in straight talk because it risks making her look bad, trash talking daughter to others, golden child brother, lack of empathy, self-victimisation, entitled to daughters time and resources but complaining she's not doing enough and never appreciative... I'm no diagnostician but OP needs to look after her mental health and stop being mummy's 'supply'
My elderly mother is pulling a similar stunt. I don't have siblings but nothing I do for her is enough and she accuses me of never being out there enough. I've tried for years to get her to move closer so I can do things for her but she refuses and wants me to drive 2 hours every other day to do little tasks for her. Sorry, I'm employed full-time and have a household to maintain. Don't have time to maintain another one if it sucks 16 hours per week just in drive time. I don't know if it's a boomer thing or an old-person thing, but there's frequently this expectation that the kids place their whole lives on hold at the drop of a hat whenever the parents need the slightest thing.
I'm the boomer and my mother pulled these stunts all the time. I moved completely across the country (US) so she could only whine and complain. Even after I was promoted to a detective in my department, she kept trying to tell me to come "home" because I wasn't "doing anything", i.e. not married and no kids.
Load More Replies...I'm just waiting for my grandmother's will to come out this way. Her son does help, but only because she literally pays him to. For anything 'extra' it's always my mom. Despite the fact that my mom is the one trying to keep their mostly failed business afloat, so she's really just shooting herself and my uncle in the foot. I've told my mom she needs to drop the rope. She vents/dumps onto me and I'm sick of the whole situation just from that.
You should spend the time you don't taking care of a clearly manipulative mother getting therapy to deal with all.the things she has done to you over the years. This is far more than just take care of me, she has been emotionally abusing you and manipulating you your whole life.
NTA. You need to focus on your own family. If I were your husband I'd be livid you're spending your PTO, family funds and missing out on your children to enable this entitled person. Stop engaging with her and this so-called family who expect you to be the skivvy because you're female. Stop engaging with her, too. 'You need to hire professionals, I'm not available for care anymore.'
Okay, BP. Get rid of the damn Hulu Ad. On every page and you literally can't see anything as it takes up the entire screen.
That's just on your screen dude. Not everyone is seeing it. Also, get an ad blocker.
Load More Replies...WTH is wrong with these YTA people? I'll bet they will be a burden on their children in their declining years and be donkey rears to their dutiful children. This women bent over backwards out of love for her mother. Her mother is showing that the golden child has all of the love, none of the duty, and all of the inheritance. Mother and golden son are massive AHs.
This seems to be the way it is 90% of the time. I am the youngest of four. I'm the one that stayed home and took care of her. Drove her every where she wanted. The only one that didn't take money from her GI loan account for various failed attempts at higher education. My sister, (the oldest) and my oldest brother were always asking her for money for one school or another that they never completed. At least my second to oldest brother went to teck school and came out with a degree and ended up working for Boeing. I was the one, along with my now wife, that drove here 50 miles to the hospital when she had a stroke. Went into debt so she could go into rehab and had to file bankruptcy and so much more. She left everything she had to oldest brother and sister and left me a dollar to symbolize "All I had taken from her in life". Because, as her story went, she had "died" for several minutes while giving birth to me.
My mother was a passive aggressive narcissist who would pull the 'I fell I need help' c**p any time that I would just drop what I was doing to attend to a non-emergency issue. She threw a toddler sized temper tantrum when I wouldn't go pick up pants at the place she had them altered. She didn't NEED them right then, she WANTED them. I told her that I had food on the oven and on the stove, my husband was on his way home (trucker) and I would get the pants the next day. She threw a complete fit. It's so manipulative. She even admitted to me the very last time she was taken to the hospital that she got on the floor and pressed her emergency life alert button when I wouldn't come over as demanded. I'm so glad she's dead.
Classic narcissist-codependent relationship. Codependent saying "I feel guilty, I feel like I've been bad" for considering applying a tourniquet -- as the narc greedily drains the last drop of the codependent's blood. Being a codependent is like having Stockholm Syndrome. The positive attention is so sparse that you will grovel for one crumb and be grateful forever, regardless of endless mistreatment. It's a disease.
Sounds like OPs mom is a vulnerable narcissist (guilt is a large part of their arsenal). Bro isn't far behind. And those calling her YTA may suffer from just straight up stupidity.
It's not about the money but mom declared she doesn't even like her daughter, only uses her. OP maybe doesn't know yet, but she's upset because she finally realised this. She's not loved by her mom. It takes many years to process this. At the end, you have two choices. Either you help them, even though they don't even like you, or leave them, and get yourself healed and focus your own life. Many will say that mom loves her but... There's no but. They always use this phrase as a shield to hide behind "I'm not concerned about your future, you're doing good on your own, your sibling needs more help". I have a golden sister and my mom also says this. She didn't let me eat the food she cooked because I ate at school, so it's not for me, to mention only one of her kind deeds... My sister leave in another country, so I'm the one who she calls when she needs to set up her wi-fi or anything. Things she could do on her own but she likes to make me jump.
It hurts as hell, and those who have loving parents or haven't realised yet that their parents don't like them, will never understand. It's not about not loving your parent. It's about being hurt deeply.
Load More Replies...I'm really hoping YTA people didn't read the WHOLE story. Like how OP is spending her OWN MONEY to travel and take care of Mom. Leaving HER family & job when Bro barely has a job and no kids so CHOOSES to be an a$$. Mom SHOULD NOT be driving and the fact that Mom would rather pay for everyone to come to her than travel shows she's pathetic. Because that means less work for her and more time to be pitiful
As someone who has been in a similar situation, I can tell you there is no way to win here. My mother GAVE a house to my sibling--as a reward for getting their act together. Yes, she always had to worry about this one having a job & a roof over their head; never with me, and I was a single parent that owned my responsibilities. When Mom was preparing her will, my sibling was actually living WITH her and renting out the home Mom had given them...Mom chose to put both our names on the home she was living in, and leave me the contents. Sibling got irate that I would get everything in the house, as well as half ownership of it. I acquiesed and told mom to split that too (spoiler alert--when mom passed, sibling got b****y about SO MUCH that I ended up giving them EVERYTHING in the house). To this day, because sibling is agian dealing with demons, everything I've tried to help with has been turned around on me & I've been made to feel like $h!+ for aiming for fairness. Haven't spoken 3 yrs
The house is half yours; make the co-owner pay rent.
Load More Replies...My brother was the favored one in our family. My Mom was a chronic alcoholic. My sister handled her finances and I got all the phone calls — calls saying she passed out in public — calls that she went to the hairdresser naked and poopy, etc. And gold brother who lived the closest? Nothing. However, my point is this to you: Your Mom is an ungrateful person who plays favorites — therefore, a bad Mom. Sadly, I see you unwilling to cut the cord. She taught you to be a "good girl" and it's hard to stop, but at this point you must think of your family. Some of your anger surely sifts into your family life. Stop. trying. to. please. everybody. Stop. worrying. about. what. people. think.
YTA troop ain't never run through all their own finances only to be told they're not getting reimbursed either financially or emotionally. GTFO.
Wow, I really felt this. My mom is very similar. She relies on me to do everything, rarely asking my older brothers for help. I'm the only one that still has a kid at home, but she always thinks I'm avoiding her if I tell her I am busy. Meanwhile, my oldest brother is her favorite. She goes on and on about any little thing he does for her.
If your mother has $250,000, she can damn well take care of her medical and caregiver needs. You are behind time in taking care of YOU and YOUR family. Let your mother and your brother handle this now. She's not broke. NTA.
NTA. Your mom doesn't appreciate all what you've done for her and sacrificed on her behalf. She's had the child moments and family moments that you are now missing with your own. Those are important. Your brother has made his own choices (and yes, I can see how the favor has played for him and being entitled is a consequence of those actions). Your mom needs to realize that the only way to help him, is to not bail him out of life. Leaving him that money is doing him a disservice. She should have discussed things with both of you regarding her POA (especially if he doesn't know what that entails), the will, the future plans, etc. Her passing is an absolute. To do it the best way is communication.
Assisted living takes that money to pay for her care. It won't matter what the will says, the house may eventually have to be sold to pay for her care. When all the money is gone, then that is when government support takes over. Depending upon how long she lives, there might not be 250k left.
NTA ... I bought my birth pod a house, where she wanted to live. After I signed all the paperwork and had the keys, she decided that she didn't want to contribute to the mortgage, she would have received housing benefit due to being retired. Needless to say I ended up with a house in an area I would never live so it's been rented ever since and not to her. Thankfully she's dead now, don't have deal with her or her toxic personality.
Do what my grandparents did and take money out of the equation. Meaning, goes to charity. Then you'll really see who has a fit once the will reading commences. My grandparents were well off. My father's older sister raised holy hell once she realized no one was getting anything. Huge fallout once the dust settled. Needless to say, most of us haven't heard from her in over a dozen years.
Been there, in a manner of speaking. I was the only one who took care of my wheelchair bound mother after a stroke for four years (she couldn't even stand or go to the washroom, I had to supply and change her diapers l, etc etc etc) yet she split everything equally between me and my siblings. But as soon as she passed, they somehow made the time to come and get what heirlooms they wanted, and basically I was forced to sell the house I had lived in for 24 years to settle her estate. Do not for one second think your family is different, money makes people do crazy things! She is totally NTA.
Guess what...once she goes into the home THEY WILL be taking all her assets to care for her. If she has property it will have to sold. That's how it works. Brother dear won't be getting 250,000 anything!
I hate when people generalize about baby boomers and believe we all think alike. I went through something similar, but it was my father who gave away things my mother wanted me to have and I had actually bought some of the items for her. He gave things to my SIL because my niece is the “golden child” in his eyes and he’s trying to buy her affection. I was the one that did all the errands and emergency room visits, but it’s my brother and SIL who will get everything. My feeling is that they can take care of him now (plus I’m disabled!) so I definitely believe she’s NTA and her mom is an AH.
I think if her mother wants the daughter to care for her, the mother needs to move close to her daughters home..we moved my mom into our home after my brother's refused to help in anyw way..I was 150 miles away, they lived in the same city..it was difficult, but had help from my hubby, and she had a great last 6 years..glad we could help her.. Btw, no inheritance was left, she spent it all..my younger brother couldn't believe it..ugh Some people cannot be pleased..same brother visited two times in Six years..other brother came up 2 or 3 times per year
NTA. Yes, it's about MONEY! It's about that OP spent all of HER OWN MONEY to drop her own life on a dime & run to take care of an ungrateful mother, who in turn saved up all of HER money to bestow on the favored but truly unworthy sibling. These days, don't try & act as if money isn't the main factor of EVERY decision, because that's just delusional.
If it wasn't about the money, mom would have hired a care aide, offered money to OP, paid for the whole family to come down, or made sure OOP didn't lose out financially at the very *least*. She should have told her, but she didn't because she knew what she was doing, and how it would hurt. She made it in secret and deliberately kept it from the daughter even as she was *actively helping her with a task*. Mom knew how it looked. Mom knew what and how much it would hurt. If mom had had her way, OP would have continued sacrificing her own life to her mother (and by extension her brother) and would have been dealt this absolute combo slap to the face punch to the gut kick to the groin *as she was mourning her mom*. Money is a two way street, and while money doesn't directly equal love, using someone for their money is the opposite of love - indifference. She didn't give two shits for her daughter or family. Now she can live with the natural and just fallout of her own actions.
I have a sister with autism(eldest) and an older brother. All my adult life, it's been expected that I'm the one to call to help out. I went throug vacation time, time off without pay and my own personal savings to do so. Never any thanks or any thought to the time off or money spent. The will divided the estate equally between all 3 siblings. I have requested reimbursement of expenditures for traveling costs, or personal items for my sister always backed up with a receipt. It is a problem for my brother who has asked the bank to hold any requests until he approved them ( no requests for reimbursement from him, as he never visited her or had her over to his place) . I'm still expected to attend all appointments, pick her up and bring her back to the group home for home visits. Last month I finally said "enough" and stepped away until the finances are worked out. It seems they are coping very well without me.
Mom can obviously afford a home care assistant. I had to move across the country (USA) to get away from my drunken parents who argued and fought constantly. My mother used to call me at work because she needed a quart of milk; there was a mom and pop grocery on the next block and their son would have delivered it for no charge. My mother used to say that I owed her. After she died, I discovered that my parents didn't get married until she was five months pregnant, and this was not acceptable in the 1940s. Apparently, lots of fighting went on.
If Mom wants you around for things, let her know you want to be there for her, but you need to be there for your family, too. So the best way to do that is have you all living near each other! And gosh, Mom, spouse and I can't really leave our jobs, but maybe you could move up near us. Aunt said you were considering a move - I know change can be scary, but with you up near us, I'd get to visit with you not just when you're sick, but also just for fun! And grandkid 1 and grandkid 2 would love to visit with you too - they know how special you are to me, and want to get to know you. This way she moves to a place where she gets some professional care, you get to be there providing support, and you don't have to use PTO and leave your family to do it. And Golden Boy can still come visit when it's convenient for him. Win-win.
I would have been dropkicked the mom and anyone calling to scold me for not going would have gotten chewed the f**k out and cut off. Mom wants to hide in the bathroom instead of talking to me she can suck a d**k from the back. I would tell the mom to drink a lot of icewater where she is going, its hot AF.
I don’t think the OP is at fault for withdrawing. Boundaries should have been set years ago. Help but within reason - not spending vacations, savings or missing important moments with children and spouses to do so. Voice of experience here. Also, sometimes, we incorrectly assume money correlates to our value or regard in the eyes of others. We see our familial relationships as transactional - like employment, which it is not. When you have a close-knit group of friends and one is not as financially solvent as the rest, generally the others will pitch in to allow that individual to participate if an activity is too luxurious for them. No one rants “what about me?”. The OP did say her younger brother is typically employed in low wage jobs - to offer a differing perspective, what if that money was set aside so OP didn’t have to become responsible for him later in life? Inheriting a home and then a quarter mil, would do just that.
No need to put it this way. She did not do this because of the will. She made changes because the will made clear what she needed to see all along! So, AITAH for leaving my injured mom on her own because she cut me out of her will.
Your mother can call the Dept. of Employment if she needs help. No help for a parent who treats you like a stranger on the street.
Load More Replies...Friend, I understand that you want to take care of your mom but I think seeing the will confirmed how you knew your mom felt all along.P.O.A.'s are put in place for a reason and as the role you have played as a caretaker,it's your right to call a family meeting to get everyone that calls you regarding mom-emergencies a part to play in her care.If everyone is that busy hire a full time caretaker and install cameras so everyone can respond to the mom-emergencies. You must have a balance because you are already drained. In my closing,the Bible says to honor your parents but it says parents don't provoke your children to wrath,so parents and children play a part. God bless dear.
After she is gone, bill her estate for your monies spent caring for her. Lost wages, traveling expenses. I have high hopes that the total excides $250,000.00
I know how she feels it's not about the money it's more being not appreciated and shown it. Plus you hear about the ones or one that is loved or cared for that won't take the time to drop a meal by or offer to take to take the parent to doctor's appointment. I feel you and I hear you.Stop! Reset! And change the dynamics of your relationship with your Mother, she's using you Up!
Inheritance isn't a measure of love or app.... BS!!! You must be y2k kids thinking that!! For the boomers that is EXACTLY what it is! Its the post life Bonus for the dutiful children that PROVED thier worth, denieing it means either there wasn't any or you screwed up! Remember this gen was raised on achievement and appearances, and $ was the currency of affection & worth, and if you ever saw an 80's movie you'd know!! Also, why is she so far away if she's so needy? Again, nodding to the generational value system, only "contributors" get feelings and/or are catered to,("when you pay the bills, you get a vote", et al) so by their rules, if they aren't prepared to make financial arrangements and they require your time/effort, then they are obligated to ease the burden or fend for themselves!(ie: move close to you or hire help) You youth be glad we figured out healthier forms of affection since they also spent OUR retirement, so you won't have to worry about this with us! Lol
NTA Just because someone gives birth to you doesn't mean you owe them your life. The money although painful it isn't the issue. (Nice to see you dont care about it ) Your brother is the problem here , it's the principle of the thing. Your mum is selfish as hell just like mine and just expects you to be there and drop everything when ever she wants something . Your brother needs to step up, but won't as you always do. I've walked away from my family for very similar reasons and I'm much happier for it . Unfortunately because you're a good person and obviously capable you've made a rod for your own back and your brother has taken advantage of the situation, and unfortunately your mum like mine idolises the kid who's a d**k as they don't want to have to admit to themselves their kid is a waster. Remind then that your kindness is no sign of weakness . It is strength and can be recinded at any moment of your choosing. You obviously help because you care and no other reason. Good luck :-)
I really don't think we owe our parents anything if they are not offering up reasonably healthy relationships. If she has a quarter of $1 million to leave to somebody, she has plenty of money to hire help around the house. My mother was like this too and my brother and I just freaking gave up. She had more than enough money to hire help -- she was just too neurotic. All she wanted was her two children who lived thousands of miles away to be dancing attendance upon her. And perhaps unlike this woman's situation, my mother was never a nice person and never offered anything resembling love or affection, so we did not care. She was incredibly toxic, so she got exactly what she deserved.
I took care of my mother for 12.5 years as my siblings were all dead. I didn't regret any of it. However, when I was diagnosed with cancer and my mother's needs increased significantly, I arranged for her to go into assisted living. Her response, she tried to commit suicide in my home. When the hospital called saying she was being discharged and could come home, I told them she didn't have a home. Seemed harsh; however, my own physician said she had to go to a facility for my own health. I will never pose such a burden on my own girls. I loved my mother; however, she exhausted her own resources trying to help my d**g addicted brother and his d**g addled wife. The stress she added to our home was crushing. OP should change her phone number or tell her mother she is on her own. OP's family deserves better.
Nine times out of 10 it is the woman who is asked to do the caregiving. Maybe several decades ago that might have been more realistic, but now in two income households from one parent families, that's not viable. The responsibility should be shared! And the brothers a jerk playing. the irresponsible. "I don't know what's going on." Person.
I think you should sit down with your mother and tell her what you said here: I am the one responsible for you, and you are leaving the bulk of your estate to my brother. How would you feel if you were in my position? I'm hurt. I'm offended. I never cared for you out of expectations of remuneration, but your decision shows no appreciation for my efforts. Just be straight. I say that as someone who wishes she had spent more time caring for her mother, whose favored child she was not, and less time going to every ballgame etc. I wish I had been straightforward with my mother about how I felt about her preferences. We both would have benefited. Were I your mother, I'd be deeply grateful for your efforts. But you are right to feel as you do----hurt and neglected. She doesn't see that. Give her a chance to see it, at least. BinThereDunThet
Had similar situation. I gave up work to care for mum full time as needed round the clock care. I gave up my life, even the 2 years beforehand had to keep taking time off unpaid to catch up with mums stuff that needed doing as my 3 siblings were doing absolutely nothing even though one of them used to come down and stay a night and day every week and one next door. Mum passed away a few months ago. Mum had split the will evenly between the 4 of us. None of them gave me any help or respite the whole 4 years. I was exhausted caring for mum all day and up a few times every night. If I hadn’t done this mum would’ve gone into care. Before mums body was even taken away my brother was already talking about the house, the next day getting it valued, third day throwing her clothes out etc etc. It was awful. Mums house was also my only home which I grew up in. My siblings all have their houses paid off and plenty of money. When mum died they were happy to leave me homeless at nearly 60.
Those who attacked OP should have a quiet word with themselves. Yes OP got herself in this position but I’m guessing the dynamic was established a long time ago! Yes it’s hard that her children have lost out but kids aren’t stupid, they know the difference between a disinterested parent and one who’s trying to be there for family. Failing at it, unfortunately but trying is more important that success for most.
Case of mother is a narcissist. Had one of them. She wrote a will which stated "all my children" and named them all singly except me the first born (of her first marriage). Just get a lawyer. As someone commented up above leaving someone out of a will is a denial of kinship basically.
i witnessed dynamic w/my grandmother & the different treatment she gave to my mom & my aunt. aunt lived in alaska; we lived in the same state as "nannie". nan depended on mom for everthing but also treated her w/distain. when my aunt came for her annual visit nan announce we weren't to bother her bc aunt was there to visit her. when my uncle passed my aunt moved close to us. nan expected aunt to take care of her, including living w/her which she did for a while. nan contacted mom & asked if she could move in w/her & my dad as she was unhappy living w/the golden daughter. of course mom allowed her. when nan got very frail w/age mom was there. when she passed all went to my aunt. asked her once about how she felt about that & mom only said 'she was my mom. i loved her even if she didn't love me the same as my sister. let her have it all. in the end mom knew who she could count on.'
The only thing that sounds "off" is how she has had car accidents, cancer, pneumonia etc but she wasn't 'like that' before she retired. What does that mean and who or what was she 'like"? She was like a healthy person who hadn't all the needs? Now she is probably getting dementia or something similar.. With that much money 250 000 that could pay for a little help. Who has power of attorney anyhow? Sounds like you have been doing all this help out of a sense of duty not love. There ought to be a way to set up something that doesn't require you or someone else to be there in person Too bad you feel you cannot speak to her openly or honestly and mute her after all these years of addressing her neediness and helplessness in person...Why not just tell brother mother and everyone else concerned you feel this resentment and feel under appreciated? That it was a sacrifice and expensive etc. But I guess no one will care.] Yet it will make things clearer and might be a relief.
The YTAs are absolutely disgusting. Let them cater to someone that demanding, ungrateful and clearly a hard core gaslighter. Will is the nail.in the f**k you coffin proving she doesn't value her daughter at all. Otherwise she'd be open to explaining why and not hiding from it. The mom is filth and should be NC because thata not how you treat your daughter.
My aunt planned to give the money from the sale of her house (that she lived in for over 50 years) to her brother after he invited her to move down to the coast and live with him. She was only there a year when he kicked her out, saying he "feels like he's got a wife" (he was married at the time; his wife had mental issues and they didn't live together for quite a few years before his wife died) and some other stuff. Apparently they made up, but she can't remember now (she's over 90) and I'm her godchild. But I don't know if she's leaving me anything, or is going to leave money to all her nieces and nephews (she never had kids). I'd rather have her than the money.
NTA- It isn’t about the money. The Will is just the item that is telling her daughter that she is NOT appreciated. There is also a clear “golden child” memo in this. Why keep doing something VERY difficult for someone who doesn’t appreciate it? I’m sure the mom loves her daughter and daughter to mom. Love isn’t the question. How many times has the mom bragged about what a “good daughter” she has?
NTA. The YTA's that think it's about money are being simplistic and have no understanding of what it feels like to be classed as second or third best.
NTA-However, if she's going to spend the rest of her life feeling guilty then I think she should continue some form of communication. Just for her own peace of mind. Boundaries definitely need to be made though. She's being used every which way with that side of her family. I'm glad an aunt stepped up to help.
I am the oldest and when my mother ended up on hospice my sister who is much better off financially (career military officer with 40 years in service) than myself flew me, herself to sit with my mom while she was dying. As the eldest I was the executor of her will. I received my stepdads truck, my brother her car. My sister knowing she was much better off financially than me or my brother stated she was fine with that distribution. We cleaned out their home and property and split the proceeds from the property sale. Thankfully no resentment between us.
Your Mother's care should not fall on your shoulders, PERIOD! Your brother should tend to all her needs going forward. If the hospital or ER calls you, refer them to your brother! Your Mother made her choice, so now she has to live with it. Don't permit your Mother to take advantage of you. Stand your ground!
NTA, it's clearly favoritism on her moms part. The inheritance should be divided equally - the brother too gets 1/2 even when he doesn't contribute much - that should be enough compensation for his low wages. Why should only 1 shoulder all the responsibility, and the other get the entire benefit? Very unfair
Ok this is not a boomer thing unless they are mostly this and that is a Narcissist. It's not just about giving more to the one who has less but to continue to bully the one they can. Over and over. Once u put ur foot down they wail. Complain to any who will listen. And use their situation to get others to side with them. Open ur eyes and see. Yes it's not about the money but about what is just and equal in a family dynamic. Even if u don't like the person, family member, or friend, u can't take the money with u so might as well be fair...
ii understand how OP feels. my mother and sister are more concerned with leaving everything to my good for nothing great niece, even pressuring my childless brother to do the same. my kids mean nothing to them. my brother said he's not leaving a dime to that spoiled brat (27yr old). she can pick my sister a nice little nursing home before frittering away her inheritance. I'm walking away after my mom passes. family should be treated fairly, more so if the care falls to one person. anything else is a slap in the face.
My dad was physically, emotionally, and verbally abusive to me growing up. Guess who ended up taking care of him when he got old and disabled? And I am so glad we took him in. I actually got to know him, minus the alcohol. He became a good friend. Forgiveness isn't for everyone, but I am so glad I gave it a shot.
I wonder, people who writing YTA are the golden children? I heard that “ how can you think about, blah- blah”, then GKid went to the Aid and declared her to return her payments, because those money went from gran retirement, and he is only one on the will, so it was his money… But for all other family members it’s always:“ how can you even think about money, it’s MaMa!”
And yeah, gran was alive and needed this aid ‘s help
Load More Replies...I've been in this situation twice (and betrayed twice) in my life. and although receiving an inheritance is always helpful to one's finances, money is not really the issue. Time, family, and one's own health are ultimately what matters. Sometimes you simply don't have anything left to give, and your own life is in shambles. Help loved ones as you can, but don't wear yourself to exhaustion. It hurt like hell when I had to pur my aunt in assisted living; but what the situation required was beyond my capacity. Vultures who come in and persuade a loved one to give them everything despite doing little or nothing are hurtful and disappointing, but I have always provided for my own famly through good times and bad whether someone gave me a financial boost or not. I love the people in the Bahamas. Even if a cruise ship in in port and there is tons of money to be gotten from tourists, everything shuts down by late afternoon so people can enjoy their lives.
From each according to his ability. To each according to his needs. Doesn't work in government. Doesn't work in family either.
I think those that considered her TA have a screw loose. The amount wasn’t the issue, it was the lack of respect and acknowledgement for providing her time and money to someone ungrateful while baby brother doesn’t do c**p. Also she’s not taking care of the dad, so who cares if there’s acknowledgment there. Brother and mother are TA, daughter is not.
People passing judgement while hearing just one side of the story is wild to me. I've had so many people distort reality when sharing their view of past events that I've become increasingly sensitive to this b******t. While reading I couldn't help notice a frantic effort to paint herself in a good light while doing the opposite for her brother and mother. Judging her brother's lifestyle, claiming he should be doing more cause he doesn't have kids is just one red flag there. I couldn't even imagine chiming in without hearing their side of the story.
There are a few things that seem to be fact in the story. Her brother is the power of attorney, why does he keep having people call the sister? It's his duty. The sister has been going down more frequently than the brother to care for the mother. That can lead to frustration. The mother is leaving the majority of her assets to the brother. To some people that can make it seem that the care that you have given was unappreciated. Even if the brother and the mother wrote their sides of the story, would those three things change? My guess is no.
Load More Replies...The way her mother treats OP is literally on the same level as Disney Step-Mothers are treating their Step Daughters. And they know just as well that they're the Villains and are proud about it
Send your Mom a bill. For all of the travel, loss of holidays and loss of seeing those milestones . Take it to her lawyer and contest the will. Don't take 'no' for an answer.
This is a bullsh*t story. You the daughter are getting what you deserve. You know your mother is an a*s and has been behaving like this forever. You know your brother is an a*s and has probably greatly influenced your mother. After all, you have a husband to take care of you. I would say your husband is married to a man, but you do not have any balls.
You need to be able to live with yourself and your decisions. If you can face yourself knowing you didn't go when she asked you, fine. Your brother seems to do alright with his decisions. Don't let the money be a factor, doesn't sound like you have concrete info, and anything can happen.
Nice virtue signaling. I'm empathetic to this woman who is sacrificing the well being of her marriage and children for someone who doesn't appreciate it. The will was just the last straw and I support anyone who is no longer willing to be a doormat due to "traditional" views on caregiving.
Load More Replies...









































72
168