“Hostile Design”: This Twitter Account Is Sharing 35 Sad And Infuriating Examples Of Design Against Humanity
InterviewWhen you stroll around your favorite city, what do you notice about its architecture? Its famous landmarks? The beautiful greenery among the towering skyscrapers? Or perhaps the lively and inviting public spaces? These elements certainly grab our attention, but that's not all there is. See, bars on benches and spikes on window sills are also a part of the urban landscape, and it’s put in place to control how the environments are used.
There are many things that influence how we feel in our surroundings that we almost never notice. But unfortunately, such aggressive measures are more common than you may think, according to the eye-opening Twitter account titled 'Hostile Design'. The creator of this page collects pictures that show the dire reality of how public spaces target the houseless and don’t actually do any good to the public.
If you’re unsure of what we mean, then take a look at the compilation of pictures we gathered from the account. Just to warn you though, it’s one of those things that once you learn about it, you start seeing it everywhere. Keep reading to also find in-depth interviews with the founder of this page and public space researcher Cara Chellew. Upvote the examples that stunned you most, and if you've ever detected cases of hostile design in your own city, be sure to let us know about them in the comments below.
Psst! More urban madness can be found in our earlier post right here.
This post may include affiliate links.
I understand homeless and homeless camps are undesirable and can be problematic, but a lack of compassion is not the answer.
Uncomfortable people will not linger and talk with their friends. So, less tables are needed because they will be vacated quickly. Does anyone besides me notice that the short people, be they children or short adults, must prop their feet on the table framework in order to not slide off their uncomfortable seat?! What about people with knee or other leg problems? Did anyone consider them? Is this design a direct violation of the ADA? Shame on the designer, and shame on the people that allowed these table / bench combinations to be set up on their premise.
Isn’t that a railing, isn’t it’s intended purpose to be to have people lean and or hold onto it??!?!
If they don’t want people sitting on it, then don’t even build it !
Somebody could really get hurt on that. Can you imagine an old lady losing her footing and hitting that?
You see this in cities a lot to keep people out of private yards. Often in older parts of the city. Looks better than barbed wire, for sure. In New Orleans, it deters the drunk tourists from using your yard as a toilet.
First time a firemen gets cut on one of these bet there will be hell to pay.
OMG! That's the exact bench that I was about to post! It's the one on 39th Ave. In my hometown of Portland OR.
Which is more hostile here, the clown or the multi-national corporation?
Come on. These are clearly to help get up from a particularly low bench. Benches that low can be a serious problem for the elderly or other people with mobility issues. This page is getting more ridiculous the farther you scroll down...
I'm not seeing the hostility here. You sit in the bottom of a curve and it deters a stranger from sitting right next to you. If someone does sit next to you on the top of a curve, then you know to get the helloutta there.
My guess on this is that sitting on a semi-temporary barrier along a roadside is not very safe.
Let's see. Rain drains better, less muddy to walk on and not slippery. Oh, and skateboarders won't take up the space. And since we can't see what's around this space, who knows what the purpose is here.
? I want to see the rest of the surrounding park, because this reminds me of a bench for sit-ups like can be found on a exercise circuit at my local park.
My guess is that many of you don't have to deal with homeless people on a regular basis. I'm a commercial property manager and have to deal with many issues directly caused by homeless people. My responsibilities are to the property owners and rent-paying tenants. I have had too many instances of break-ins, defecation on the sidewalks/landscape, broken water lines/backflows, threatening behaviors, discarded drug paraphernalia, setting fires, and vandalism. A majority refuse social services or interventions when offered to them. I would like to say that there is a clear answer to address the homeless situation. But there isn't. And unfortunately, I have to deal with what's in front of me - not what I wish things could be.
Yeah, I used to work in a small store, the office and safe was one floor up from the store via a stairway that we shared with one private flat, but the stairway had a door to the main street, as well. The door to the main street closed automatically. We had to carry the register-drawer from the shop to the office and back in the morning and evening (both doors had to be opened with a key) and guess what? Some homeless people broke the closing mechanism on the door to the main street and slept next to the stairs. So one morning I found myself alone with 3 sleeping strangers, in a position where I'd have had to carry several hundred Euros past them. You can bet your a** I called the police to make them go away, I've rarely ever felt so unsafe in my life! And I'm all for helping people to get out of those circumstances, but not when they do sh*t like that!
Load More Replies...I understand the point of these photos of benches, but often I see elderly people using the bars to help them up, it helped when I was pregnant or had the baby in the carrier, and too many times they've prevented people from sitting too close to my kid or me, there is a practical side to it.
Maybe they could make the bars retractable somehow? Able to lock up or down. That would be great accessible design I think
Load More Replies...Do people on here realise that sometimes benches toilets etc cost money to keep being replaced!? How about blaming people in power for doing nothing to help the homeless situations !
you mean the elected officials who run councils. what has money got to do with making them in accessible. most this would be cheaper without making them unfriendly to people with disabilities or the homeless.
Load More Replies...My guess is that many of you don't have to deal with homeless people on a regular basis. I'm a commercial property manager and have to deal with many issues directly caused by homeless people. My responsibilities are to the property owners and rent-paying tenants. I have had too many instances of break-ins, defecation on the sidewalks/landscape, broken water lines/backflows, threatening behaviors, discarded drug paraphernalia, setting fires, and vandalism. A majority refuse social services or interventions when offered to them. I would like to say that there is a clear answer to address the homeless situation. But there isn't. And unfortunately, I have to deal with what's in front of me - not what I wish things could be.
Yeah, I used to work in a small store, the office and safe was one floor up from the store via a stairway that we shared with one private flat, but the stairway had a door to the main street, as well. The door to the main street closed automatically. We had to carry the register-drawer from the shop to the office and back in the morning and evening (both doors had to be opened with a key) and guess what? Some homeless people broke the closing mechanism on the door to the main street and slept next to the stairs. So one morning I found myself alone with 3 sleeping strangers, in a position where I'd have had to carry several hundred Euros past them. You can bet your a** I called the police to make them go away, I've rarely ever felt so unsafe in my life! And I'm all for helping people to get out of those circumstances, but not when they do sh*t like that!
Load More Replies...I understand the point of these photos of benches, but often I see elderly people using the bars to help them up, it helped when I was pregnant or had the baby in the carrier, and too many times they've prevented people from sitting too close to my kid or me, there is a practical side to it.
Maybe they could make the bars retractable somehow? Able to lock up or down. That would be great accessible design I think
Load More Replies...Do people on here realise that sometimes benches toilets etc cost money to keep being replaced!? How about blaming people in power for doing nothing to help the homeless situations !
you mean the elected officials who run councils. what has money got to do with making them in accessible. most this would be cheaper without making them unfriendly to people with disabilities or the homeless.
Load More Replies...
