“Never Heard Of This Brand”: Woman Crushed By Husband And His Rich Family’s Reaction To Her Gift
We can put as much thought into a gift as we want, but ultimately, the receiver decides if it’s a hit or a miss.
So when Reddit user Complex-Club-6111 got her husband a guitar for Christmas, she couldn’t wait to see his reaction—the woman spent considerably more money on the present than she normally does, so she really wanted her partner to like it.
However, as the Redditor explained in her candid post on r/TwoXChromosomes, once the relatives rolled in and the unwrapping began, things didn’t go as planned.
Gift-giving is a deeply personal act, so it’s no surprise this woman wanted her husband to enjoy the guitar she got for him
Image credits: Kaboompics.com / Pexels (not the actual photo)
But she got the impression that he and his family thought it was cheap, and was deeply hurt by their comments
Image credits: Polina Kovaleva / Pexels (not the actual photo)
Image credits: cottonbro studio / Pexels (not the actual photo)
Image credits: Complex-Club-6111
Image credits: Freepik (not the actual photo)
Roughly one in five Americans argue about money with their in-laws
“Different members of the same family can wind up occupying different class brackets (or appearing to),” said Eleanor Gordon-Smith, an ethicist at Princeton University.
“This isn’t just about ‘what’s in the bank’ but also a whole interplay of knowledge and expectations. What do our houses look like? What occupies our free time? What do we wear and drive and eat and buy? How do we talk? Where do we feel most comfortable? These are all ways of falling into class brackets without even being aware that we are.”
“It’s easy for families to feel divided and mutually resentful when their answers to these questions start to diverge,” Gordon-Smith explained.
In these situations, according to her, phrases like “we don’t have buckets of money!” aren’t very helpful, primarily because the rift might not just be about estimates of capital.
“It might also be about a suspicion, from either side, that the other is privately judging them for where they have wound up,” the academic said. “When a child moves significantly away from the class or lifestyle of their parents, it’s extremely common for parents to experience the shift as a kind of rejection.”
A 2024 survey conducted in the United States revealed that politics is actually the number one argued-about topic between Americans and their in-laws, with 31% of respondents admitting to having these conflicts, exceeding other contentious issues like lifestyle choices (22%), and disputes about a partner (21%). Money came in fourth with 19%.
So, what to do? The important thing, Gordon-Smith said, is to temper some of your resentment about your in-laws’ resentment. “I’m not saying your feelings are misplaced—they could be totally apt. But sometimes these cycles only break when one of us decides to put aside the feelings we’re allowed to have,” she added.
As people shared their reactions to the story, its author provided more context on her situation
After talking to her husband, the woman published an update
Poll Question
Thanks! Check out the results:
Explore more of these tags
Once you get married you need to make your own traditions and not let families bully you into ruining holidays by forcing their plans on you. This happened to us. We spent Christmas with them the first year cause we were living in the house. It was all grown children but they still do all the same stuff as if we were little. The next year we had a baby. We had our own tree and gifts and planned to have a leisurely morning , open our gifts and mosey our way over to their house around noon when my grandparents got there. It wasn't really discussed in detail with my mother but she ruined our Christmas morning by blowing our phones up starting at 8 am demanding to know where we were and everyone was waiting (my 2 sisters and dad and her i.e.) and I told her that we were opening presents and would be there for lunch. She kept calling and calling and calling but we did not let her ruin our 1st Christmas. We turned off the phones, opened the gifts and played with the baby and got there at 10:30. It was as if we forced little children to wait hours to see what Santa brought. My mom and sisters were just super annoyed cause she made everyone wait to open their presents. Didn't have to worry the next year as we had gone no contact by then and had the best Christmas ever despite being on unemployment. My husband bought me the Beauty and the Beast DVD (just rereleased from the Disney vault lol remember those days) and I forgot what I got him. We had a turkey at home and stayed in all day eating junk and watching Christmas movies and have done so ever since for Christmas and Thanksgiving. Thanksgiving is my favorite we cook a shitload of food and get all the leftovers. I don't miss the family drama and rushing around to different houses at all. Anyone is welcome to our house but no one has ever come and we have a blast. Make your own traditions. Do your own thing. It's the BEST part of being a grown up
Who downvoted you?! Take my upvote, and use it in good health!
Load More Replies...damn. I sold my beloved cheap end bass guitar just so I could afford some Christmas presents for my kids. some humans has absolutely no idea. literally no idea.
I'm sorry you had to do that, as a classical guitarist myself I can imagine how much it hurt to let it go, even if it was for the benefit of your children. I sincerely hope that life gets easier for you soon so you can replace your bass as quickly as possible.
Load More Replies...I'm so glad she talked to him like an adult and resolved it. My knee jerk reaction would have been more passive aggressive, Do you want me to just return this since you and your family think it is a piece of c**p!
Load More Replies...It's a Guild? Oh yeah, the family's right. Guild sucks. Only unknown losers no one's ever heard of like John Denver and Brian May of Queen played Guilds /s Guild is a very good beginner guitar. Heck it's a very good intermediate to pro guitar. He won't be able to outplay that guitar for years even if he practices religiously. I feel sorry for the wife, she married into a bunch of ignorant snobs.
I play guitar a bit (not very well TBH) and $900 is about £730 so that is not a cheap guitar for a starter, by any stretch of the imagination. Guitars can and do cost silly money. I'd give my right arm for a $900 guitar.....Oh no! Wait, that wouldn't work, would it?
Just a small correction: 900 CAD is about £510 (but I agree with everything you said!)
Load More Replies...Should’ve just gotten him a $60 ukulele. People who are serious about learning to play an instrument so badly will always find a way. You can even rent one. The fact that he was talking about wanting to learn one for years just means he wasn’t really serious about it. Otherwise, he would’ve been happy with a starter guitar like any other person who wants to learn to play. Then you upgrade when you get really good and stick with it! He sounds so spoiled. I bet he just wanted a popular brand so he can show off.
This. I learned early on with my wife that when she "wants an xxx instrument", to buy her a nice and pretty cheap ukulele so I don't feel bad using it as firewood after 10 years in the closet.
Load More Replies...My parents started dating in the summertime. That first Christmas, my mother was invited to his family home. His mother gave him very expensive pajamas, expensive dress pants, and expensive shirts. My mother was a young woman on a very tight budget. She gave my father sheet music for several Bach pieces. She bought them at the music store, I think they were specifically arrangements for piano. He sat down at the piano, and immediately started picking out the notes. He was very excited, and throughout the day made repeated remarks about what a wonderful gift it was. His mother pouted the rest of the day, and complained that he didn’t even notice his very nice pajamas. She was so upset that her gifts were being ignored, and she was upset that her expensive gifts were being upstaged by a budget gift. She never did approve of my “farmer’s daughter” mother.
I absolutley felt this to my core..I was also raised in poverty and now because of a neurological disorder I can't work which has now forced me to raise.my child in poverty. Sending you so much ❤
Money does not equal class, manners, kindness or empathy. Think of royalty and imagine how they would speak to a commoner. Now imagine someone who just won a lottery and how they would speak to someone who had less. An ambassador once said to me, the way you speak to someone is a reflection of YOU.
That it does not in fact most rich people I’ve met are extremely devoid of and class what so ever they just don’t get real life what so ever can’t stand em myself
Load More Replies...So much stronger than me. I would have started crying on the spot, and probably not stop for quite the while. How nasty! You should NEVER say anything like that about a gift. "I've never heard of this brand." Is okay. But not what his family said. I would have been blubbering about "but that's all we could afford"
Once you get married you need to make your own traditions and not let families bully you into ruining holidays by forcing their plans on you. This happened to us. We spent Christmas with them the first year cause we were living in the house. It was all grown children but they still do all the same stuff as if we were little. The next year we had a baby. We had our own tree and gifts and planned to have a leisurely morning , open our gifts and mosey our way over to their house around noon when my grandparents got there. It wasn't really discussed in detail with my mother but she ruined our Christmas morning by blowing our phones up starting at 8 am demanding to know where we were and everyone was waiting (my 2 sisters and dad and her i.e.) and I told her that we were opening presents and would be there for lunch. She kept calling and calling and calling but we did not let her ruin our 1st Christmas. We turned off the phones, opened the gifts and played with the baby and got there at 10:30. It was as if we forced little children to wait hours to see what Santa brought. My mom and sisters were just super annoyed cause she made everyone wait to open their presents. Didn't have to worry the next year as we had gone no contact by then and had the best Christmas ever despite being on unemployment. My husband bought me the Beauty and the Beast DVD (just rereleased from the Disney vault lol remember those days) and I forgot what I got him. We had a turkey at home and stayed in all day eating junk and watching Christmas movies and have done so ever since for Christmas and Thanksgiving. Thanksgiving is my favorite we cook a shitload of food and get all the leftovers. I don't miss the family drama and rushing around to different houses at all. Anyone is welcome to our house but no one has ever come and we have a blast. Make your own traditions. Do your own thing. It's the BEST part of being a grown up
Who downvoted you?! Take my upvote, and use it in good health!
Load More Replies...damn. I sold my beloved cheap end bass guitar just so I could afford some Christmas presents for my kids. some humans has absolutely no idea. literally no idea.
I'm sorry you had to do that, as a classical guitarist myself I can imagine how much it hurt to let it go, even if it was for the benefit of your children. I sincerely hope that life gets easier for you soon so you can replace your bass as quickly as possible.
Load More Replies...I'm so glad she talked to him like an adult and resolved it. My knee jerk reaction would have been more passive aggressive, Do you want me to just return this since you and your family think it is a piece of c**p!
Load More Replies...It's a Guild? Oh yeah, the family's right. Guild sucks. Only unknown losers no one's ever heard of like John Denver and Brian May of Queen played Guilds /s Guild is a very good beginner guitar. Heck it's a very good intermediate to pro guitar. He won't be able to outplay that guitar for years even if he practices religiously. I feel sorry for the wife, she married into a bunch of ignorant snobs.
I play guitar a bit (not very well TBH) and $900 is about £730 so that is not a cheap guitar for a starter, by any stretch of the imagination. Guitars can and do cost silly money. I'd give my right arm for a $900 guitar.....Oh no! Wait, that wouldn't work, would it?
Just a small correction: 900 CAD is about £510 (but I agree with everything you said!)
Load More Replies...Should’ve just gotten him a $60 ukulele. People who are serious about learning to play an instrument so badly will always find a way. You can even rent one. The fact that he was talking about wanting to learn one for years just means he wasn’t really serious about it. Otherwise, he would’ve been happy with a starter guitar like any other person who wants to learn to play. Then you upgrade when you get really good and stick with it! He sounds so spoiled. I bet he just wanted a popular brand so he can show off.
This. I learned early on with my wife that when she "wants an xxx instrument", to buy her a nice and pretty cheap ukulele so I don't feel bad using it as firewood after 10 years in the closet.
Load More Replies...My parents started dating in the summertime. That first Christmas, my mother was invited to his family home. His mother gave him very expensive pajamas, expensive dress pants, and expensive shirts. My mother was a young woman on a very tight budget. She gave my father sheet music for several Bach pieces. She bought them at the music store, I think they were specifically arrangements for piano. He sat down at the piano, and immediately started picking out the notes. He was very excited, and throughout the day made repeated remarks about what a wonderful gift it was. His mother pouted the rest of the day, and complained that he didn’t even notice his very nice pajamas. She was so upset that her gifts were being ignored, and she was upset that her expensive gifts were being upstaged by a budget gift. She never did approve of my “farmer’s daughter” mother.
I absolutley felt this to my core..I was also raised in poverty and now because of a neurological disorder I can't work which has now forced me to raise.my child in poverty. Sending you so much ❤
Money does not equal class, manners, kindness or empathy. Think of royalty and imagine how they would speak to a commoner. Now imagine someone who just won a lottery and how they would speak to someone who had less. An ambassador once said to me, the way you speak to someone is a reflection of YOU.
That it does not in fact most rich people I’ve met are extremely devoid of and class what so ever they just don’t get real life what so ever can’t stand em myself
Load More Replies...So much stronger than me. I would have started crying on the spot, and probably not stop for quite the while. How nasty! You should NEVER say anything like that about a gift. "I've never heard of this brand." Is okay. But not what his family said. I would have been blubbering about "but that's all we could afford"





































48
62