Tourist Is Disgusted By Blatant Racism On Train, Films Women’s Behavior And The Internet Doesn’t Hold Back After They Find Them
Tourism is one of the largest industries in the world, with millions of people visiting different parts of the globe each year. But instead of facilitating cultural exchange, it can sometimes perpetuate discrimination.
Mahnoor Euceph, a Pakistani-American filmmaker, and her partner, who is half-Chinese, as well as his parents were subjected to a distressing encounter with three Italian women while exploring the country by train.
Euceph captured part of the incident on film and posted it on TikTok, requesting help in identifying the individuals. The women were eventually found and Euceph even had a brief exchange with one of them.
Pakistani-American filmmaker Mahnoor Euceph was on a train in Italy with her half-Chinese boyfriend and his parents
Image credits: euceph
When the group had what Euceph called a dehumanizing encounter with three local women
Image credits: mahnooreu
Image credits: mahnooreu
It got so bad that Euceph started filming the women
Image credits: mahnooreu
She later uploaded the video to TikTok, asking people to help her identify the women
@mahnooreu Reposting we found them. On TikTok we found @lvcr3zja. On insta we found all three: margherita_gentile, llucrezja, _elisatortora_. Their universities on ig: iulm_university, unimib, unicatt Hit them up and let them know that their racist behavior was not okay. To reiterate: I was on the train from Lake Como to Milan on April 16th with my half Chinese boyfriend, his Chinese mom, and his white dad. I am Pakistani. We are all American. I noticed these girls sitting across from us staring me down and laughing and speaking Italian. At first, I ignored it. Then I stared back at them. They didn’t stop so I made my bf aware, then took a nap. I woke up from the nap to them doing the same thing but more aggressively. I asked them, “Is there a problem?” They said, “No there isn’t a problem.” At that point they started saying “Ni hao!” in an obnoxious, racist, loud voice, along with other things in Italian I couldn’t understand. They continued getting more and more aggressive, laughing at and mocking us. Eventually, I started filming them. They were the most calm during the video but you can still hear them saying ni hao and get a vibe of their general attitude. Never in my life have I experienced such blatant racism. My boyfriend said the same thing. I expected better from the younger generation. After I shared this on IG, many of my Asian friends shared their stories of experiencing racism in Italy and Europe. America may have its race issues, but Europe is so behind. Please shame these girls. It was truly disgusting behavior and I hope they learn a lesson from this. Their behavior was steeped in racist, entitled privilege, and they acted this way even on camera knowing full well they could get away with it. I hope you will show them otherwise by writing to them and their universities. Let’s show them what happens to racists in 2023. Don’t fuck with people of color. ✊🏼 #racism#stopaapihate#Italy#Milan#LakeComo#racistItalians#racistcheck#racistoftheday#racistshit#milandesignweek2023#milandesignweek#Chinese#Pakistani#hapa#wasian#racismawareness#racismneedstostop#racismsucks♬ original sound – Mahnoor Euceph
More than half of the Italians surveyed in a 2019 poll have said that racist acts were either sometimes or always “justifiable”, a finding that came after a series of high-profile racist and antisemitic incidents across the country.
The polling firm, SWG, questioned 1,500 people of whom 10% said racist acts were always justified, and a further 45% who said racist acts could be acceptable depending on the circumstances.
The remaining 45% feel that racist acts of any kind are completely unacceptable.
“What this means is that there has been a relaxation in attitudes towards racism – not necessarily that people have become racist, more that they are becoming more accepting of racist acts and do not consider them so scandalous,” Enzo Risso, scientific director at SWG, told The Guardian.
After the clip went viral, the internet found them on social media
Image credits: mahnooreu
Realizing what had happened, one of the women reached out to Euceph
Image credits: mahnooreu
However, she wasn’t having the gaslighting and penned the following reply
A vivid illustration of Italy’s internal attitudes came last year when several thousand black-clad fascist sympathizers chanted and sang in praise of Benito Mussolini as they marched to the slain dictator’s crypt, 100 years after Mussolini entered Rome and completed a bloodless coup that gave rise to two decades of fascist rule.
The crowd of about 2,000 to 4,000 marchers, many of whom were sporting fascist symbols and singing hymns from Italy’s colonial era, was bigger than in the recent past.
The crowd in Predappio, Mussolini’s birth and final resting place in the northern Emilia-Romagna region, also was apparently emboldened by the fact that a party with neo-fascist roots is heading an Italian government for the first time since World War II.
Image credits: mahnooreu
In a follow-up video, Euceph thanked everyone who supported her and encouraged people to call out racist behavior
So that’s that. I just want to thank you guys for all of your support. I also want to say, you know, we don’t need to bully them or stoop to their level or make comments about their appearances. You know, women have enough body image issues as it is. I think let’s just stick to the topic at hand, which is their racist behavior, and let’s try to make them take accountability for that. But thank you so much. You guys have been really, really supportive and it felt at least like a little bit of justice to get the support from the global community and a lot of really nice Italian people have reached out and apologized for these girls’ behaviors, so I really appreciate that as well.
@mahnooreu Replying to @asocialclimber #greenscreen#stopaapihate#racistItaliangirls#racism#Chinese#pakistani#racismawareness♬ original sound – Mahnoor Euceph
However, racists in Italy often do not fear going public. For example, fans of the Roman team Lazio targeted Samuel Umtiti – a French defender playing for Lecce and a 2018 world champion – during a match between the two teams on January 4, marking yet another new and common episode.
On loan from Barcelona to Lecce since 2022, Umtiti finished the match victorious but in tears. He refused a break offered by the referee when he and his Zambian teammate, Lameck Banda, had been subjected to racist chants from Lazio supporters.
The Roman club is known to have extremists among their supporters who adhere to a fascist-inspired subculture. However, the problem is much deeper and hasn’t been stopped for decades.
Image credits: wikipedia.or
Other sports in the country are affected too. Paola Egonu, an Italian professional volleyball player, who was under constant racist, sexist, and homophobic harassment, even considered quitting the national team.
More recently, Italian rugby player Chérif Traoré, with the Benetton Rugby in Treviso, decided to speak out on social media about the latest racist bullying he suffered. In the run-up to Christmas, one of his teammates anonymously offered him a rotten banana.
But it is indeed in the world of football, Italy’s national pride, that the vast majority of discriminatory acts are concentrated. In its report on the 2021-2022 sports season, an Italian agency against racial discrimination stated that 78.7% of the documented cases have to do with football.
Image credits: cherif_traore
Folks have been really appalled by the Italian women and their actions
The universities that the women are attending also announced that they will be looking into the situation
Image credits: unimib
The fact that Giorgia Meloni is the prime minister probably tells you all you need to know.
I am waiting on my jure sanguinis recognition from Italy... I can't wait to vote against the fascists.
Load More Replies...Why would the "real" racists "pour their hate" onto these girls? Wouldn't real racists applaud anything racist? Not sure logic is their strong suit.
Exactly what happens when you F around and find out. That apology was so hollow and ingenuine, perfect example of 'well we're sorry you felt that way' while trying to not to admit that they were in fact being racist. Possibly going to lose their college education over it, too. Parents must be so proud.
Okay, they were bi**** alright. But still, I find it pretty creepy how people managed to find out who they were.
Yes. I agree with this. They behaved very badly. That point we are not challenging. However, by posting their names and personal information, that is actually a crime. If one of them or both, are assaulted over this, the OP can be held liiable. Let's hope (against hope) that this doesn't happen.
Load More Replies...I have an Italian friend whom I went to school with on an exchange semester in Germany, and he's a great guy and not at all racist (I'm Jewish and we had a Turkish-muslim friend) – so I guess there are Italians of all sorts. Having said this, other Italians I've met were rude and obnoxious asshōles, so I see where the stereotype is coming from.
Take any general/generic grouping of people and it would be really really hard to find one without any bigotry at all so it's more about what kind of bigots there are on that group and in what proportion to non-bigots (of that kind).
Load More Replies...Italians have been practicing for decades to be racists (or xenophobic to be more precise) against one another. Once Italy became more cosmopolitan, it was easy to shift from hating each other based on location, to hating the "other". I am ashamed of sharing a birthplace and heritage with these people and I am ashamed we have the fascists back in power in Italy (not that here in the USA we are very far from it). We will overcome, but not today.
I have been reading that a lot of Italian towns are basically dying because there are not enough people in them, so the local governments are appealing to foreigners by selling them cheap houses. Italians need to make up their minds. Do they want/need immigrants or not? We have a similar situation in the US regarding workers. Immigration has been cut so much that now some red states are rolling back laws against child labor. They will NEVER admit that we NEED immigrants. These are the same people who complained that immigrants were taking away jobs from Americans, but now they are panicking because there are not enough people to work, so they think exploiting children is the solution. Brilliant!
Load More Replies...So, does anyone know what they actually said? Because, frankly speaking, some people looking at you and even laughing at you doesn't mean they are racists, but maybe simply rude.
i saw the video they were full out laughing. it wasnt giggles bc they thought they sounded funny. they were being racist and they did say wat the OP said they did. i sent it to my aunt who speaks perfect italian and she confirmed it. she said she actually heard about this from a few friends bc they have dual citizenship as well as a house in italy and a good amount of friends in milan, sicily, venice, rome, etc. it spread quickly.
Load More Replies...i have friends of every race. the worst i heard while with my friends was one of my black friends being called the n word in a negative way. they said "dam (n word) get out of our neighborhood! u dont belong here" and my asian friend who is only half chinese but looks completely chinese. some asked him if his name was fake. his name is as italian as it gets lol. they asked him y he doesnt act chinese then said he should do chinese things. they then started acting out things theyve probably seen on tv and before they left they told him to go home and pick rice from his rice fields. for the first occasion i mentioned i reported hate crime to my cop friend since hes friends with her too. the karen who yelled that got visited by the cops specifically my cop friend, his dad and his uncle all cops so ya that was fun to watch. she got a fine and warning. his dad is cheif of police of the towns department and absolutely hates racist situations. the 2nd situation was teenage girls so i just slapped them both before they got a chance to leave. i was scolded by my cop friends dad for that one....while infront of them at least. afterwards he said just one word to me. "nice" and a thumbs up. a few years later i moved but from wat i hear my cop friend has been keeping an eye out for hate crime situations everyday. its a nice upper class neighborhood so quite a few ppl think it should b a white american neighborhood. my friend recently arrested someone bc a latino man was doing his morning jog then had a woman stop him a tried to get him to mow her lawn and fix up her garden. he told me the poor guy is a surgeon at the local hospital and felt so defeated bc he saves lives and 1 woman thought he was some poor nobody immigrant looking for work. funny enough he was the same surgeon who helped my dad about 8 years ago. he is a very nice guy and didnt deserve to b treated that way just bc hes latino. she even called him mr. mexican meanwhile hes not even mexican hes columbian so that hurt him too. i hate racsism with a passion. this post infuriates me. i feel the OP's anger completely and i understand it completely. those girls deserve every bit of public shaming they get
From an Italian citizen: I'm so sorry you had to experience that. We are not (all) like that but, as in any country, some ignorance and stupidity pockets still persist, even in Gen-Z that should consider itself as "citizen of the world". About those three girls the only things I can say is an Italian phrase: "la madre dei cretini è sempre incinta" (the mother of the idiots is always pregnant). In this case she had a triplet.
Upvoted for that wonderful phrase that l'm incorporating to my vocabulary :)
Load More Replies...I've heard from my British cousin (Polish-Chinese by heritage but born in Cambridge) that Italy can be nasty to foreigners, Asians in particular. Story goes as such: He was visiting with his (then GF) now wife, a Netherlands-born Chinese lass, when he heard some locals making derogatory remarks at her. What they didn't realize is that my cousin's father had spent some time in Italy and passed on his knowledge of the language to him and his wife and when they confronted said locals in their own tongue, things got awkward and silent pretty fast. Probably because they didn't expect an Asian-looking couple to talk back to them in their own language. Now, I'm not one to bash on other countries, but the experience of family members have made me very wary to travel to these places sometimes. Smh!!!
The fact that Giorgia Meloni is the prime minister probably tells you all you need to know.
I am waiting on my jure sanguinis recognition from Italy... I can't wait to vote against the fascists.
Load More Replies...Why would the "real" racists "pour their hate" onto these girls? Wouldn't real racists applaud anything racist? Not sure logic is their strong suit.
Exactly what happens when you F around and find out. That apology was so hollow and ingenuine, perfect example of 'well we're sorry you felt that way' while trying to not to admit that they were in fact being racist. Possibly going to lose their college education over it, too. Parents must be so proud.
Okay, they were bi**** alright. But still, I find it pretty creepy how people managed to find out who they were.
Yes. I agree with this. They behaved very badly. That point we are not challenging. However, by posting their names and personal information, that is actually a crime. If one of them or both, are assaulted over this, the OP can be held liiable. Let's hope (against hope) that this doesn't happen.
Load More Replies...I have an Italian friend whom I went to school with on an exchange semester in Germany, and he's a great guy and not at all racist (I'm Jewish and we had a Turkish-muslim friend) – so I guess there are Italians of all sorts. Having said this, other Italians I've met were rude and obnoxious asshōles, so I see where the stereotype is coming from.
Take any general/generic grouping of people and it would be really really hard to find one without any bigotry at all so it's more about what kind of bigots there are on that group and in what proportion to non-bigots (of that kind).
Load More Replies...Italians have been practicing for decades to be racists (or xenophobic to be more precise) against one another. Once Italy became more cosmopolitan, it was easy to shift from hating each other based on location, to hating the "other". I am ashamed of sharing a birthplace and heritage with these people and I am ashamed we have the fascists back in power in Italy (not that here in the USA we are very far from it). We will overcome, but not today.
I have been reading that a lot of Italian towns are basically dying because there are not enough people in them, so the local governments are appealing to foreigners by selling them cheap houses. Italians need to make up their minds. Do they want/need immigrants or not? We have a similar situation in the US regarding workers. Immigration has been cut so much that now some red states are rolling back laws against child labor. They will NEVER admit that we NEED immigrants. These are the same people who complained that immigrants were taking away jobs from Americans, but now they are panicking because there are not enough people to work, so they think exploiting children is the solution. Brilliant!
Load More Replies...So, does anyone know what they actually said? Because, frankly speaking, some people looking at you and even laughing at you doesn't mean they are racists, but maybe simply rude.
i saw the video they were full out laughing. it wasnt giggles bc they thought they sounded funny. they were being racist and they did say wat the OP said they did. i sent it to my aunt who speaks perfect italian and she confirmed it. she said she actually heard about this from a few friends bc they have dual citizenship as well as a house in italy and a good amount of friends in milan, sicily, venice, rome, etc. it spread quickly.
Load More Replies...i have friends of every race. the worst i heard while with my friends was one of my black friends being called the n word in a negative way. they said "dam (n word) get out of our neighborhood! u dont belong here" and my asian friend who is only half chinese but looks completely chinese. some asked him if his name was fake. his name is as italian as it gets lol. they asked him y he doesnt act chinese then said he should do chinese things. they then started acting out things theyve probably seen on tv and before they left they told him to go home and pick rice from his rice fields. for the first occasion i mentioned i reported hate crime to my cop friend since hes friends with her too. the karen who yelled that got visited by the cops specifically my cop friend, his dad and his uncle all cops so ya that was fun to watch. she got a fine and warning. his dad is cheif of police of the towns department and absolutely hates racist situations. the 2nd situation was teenage girls so i just slapped them both before they got a chance to leave. i was scolded by my cop friends dad for that one....while infront of them at least. afterwards he said just one word to me. "nice" and a thumbs up. a few years later i moved but from wat i hear my cop friend has been keeping an eye out for hate crime situations everyday. its a nice upper class neighborhood so quite a few ppl think it should b a white american neighborhood. my friend recently arrested someone bc a latino man was doing his morning jog then had a woman stop him a tried to get him to mow her lawn and fix up her garden. he told me the poor guy is a surgeon at the local hospital and felt so defeated bc he saves lives and 1 woman thought he was some poor nobody immigrant looking for work. funny enough he was the same surgeon who helped my dad about 8 years ago. he is a very nice guy and didnt deserve to b treated that way just bc hes latino. she even called him mr. mexican meanwhile hes not even mexican hes columbian so that hurt him too. i hate racsism with a passion. this post infuriates me. i feel the OP's anger completely and i understand it completely. those girls deserve every bit of public shaming they get
From an Italian citizen: I'm so sorry you had to experience that. We are not (all) like that but, as in any country, some ignorance and stupidity pockets still persist, even in Gen-Z that should consider itself as "citizen of the world". About those three girls the only things I can say is an Italian phrase: "la madre dei cretini è sempre incinta" (the mother of the idiots is always pregnant). In this case she had a triplet.
Upvoted for that wonderful phrase that l'm incorporating to my vocabulary :)
Load More Replies...I've heard from my British cousin (Polish-Chinese by heritage but born in Cambridge) that Italy can be nasty to foreigners, Asians in particular. Story goes as such: He was visiting with his (then GF) now wife, a Netherlands-born Chinese lass, when he heard some locals making derogatory remarks at her. What they didn't realize is that my cousin's father had spent some time in Italy and passed on his knowledge of the language to him and his wife and when they confronted said locals in their own tongue, things got awkward and silent pretty fast. Probably because they didn't expect an Asian-looking couple to talk back to them in their own language. Now, I'm not one to bash on other countries, but the experience of family members have made me very wary to travel to these places sometimes. Smh!!!






























129
122