This Homeless Woman Explained Why People Should Stop Donating To The Salvation Army
According to their 2017 financial report, The Salvation Army–USA received over $2 billion from direct public support that year. Heather Snow, a homeless woman who had been living in one of their facilities, however, said nobody should donate a single penny to them ever again. She shared an emotional twitter rant about the ‘abusive’ experience she and other women were having in one of Salvation Army’s centers in Portland, saying the sole purpose of the organization is to make a profit (in 2017, it reported a surplus of $622M). The thread ignited a discussion where others responded that one rotten apple doesn’t mean the entire tree is bad. Scroll down to read the debate and leave your opinion in the comments!
She also posted this picture of locks on the fridges
Salvation Army responded to her thread
Image credits: SalvationArmyUS
Image credits: TehRedCoat
The 30-day exclusion Heather has received for “disrespecting” the staff and Salvation Army programs
Some people said they’ve experienced something similar
While others defended the organization
As a sister if a captain of the Salvation Army, I can tell you exactly where their money goes. As a captain, my sister is given a home, rent free, fully furnished. If she dislikes the curtains, carpet, kitchen table, whatever, she has it replaced by them free of charge. That goes for all captains. That is where your money is going. I gave up donating to them a long time ago, and instead donate to a charity that provides books and clothes to school children.
Had some furniture my boys had outgrown still in very good condition. I called the S A to donate it thinking it would be given to a needy family. Two scruffy men in a S A truck arrive and refuse to accept it because it was only pine timber and quote " we don't get a good price for pine furniture". i found a nearby church in the phone book and they were glad to accept it for a needy parishioner.
Had the same experience with a wardrobe I was trying to donate. It had a tiny water stain ON THE BACK and so the SA wouldn't take it.
Load More Replies...As in every institution there will be people working for the Salvation Army who really shouldn't be allowed to even enter the premisses. And they should be fired or re-educated. Denying that this problem exists doesn't serve the Salvation Army. I'm sure that the Salvation Army has people who really want to help people in need and I'm sure it's the majority of their employees. So why not investigate the accusations and take appropriate action? Throwing the woman out makes the Salvation Army look suspicious and untrustworthy.
I never, ever donate to religious charities. I used to...but after about the third time I had a volunteer scream abuse at me and threaten to hit me for not packaging donations "correctly", I decided that no one needs to listen to that c**p. Everything I donate goes to Goodwill now.
You do realize Goodwill is a FOR PROFIT organization. You donate, they sell, they keep All the money. It's not a charity. None of their profits go to help others. Look it up.
Load More Replies...Sadly I had a very bad experience myself. I had to flee an abusive relationship and I had no where else to turn. I did have a job but no money to rent a place. No one else who stayed there had a job. Some of the men in the shelter would refer to the females in very obscene terms. After work, I would come in and volunteer to help with resumes, interview practice, new admissions, etc. I was trying so hard to be helpful. The manager, a Pastor, called me into his office and told me I had to be a bell ringer full time. I reminded him I had a job, but I would gladly work 12 hour shifts on weekends. Next morning, I was told to pack my things and leave. I spent the next few weeks living in my car in the coldest part of the year! Merry Christmas. I wound up renting a room for $125 a week in a little rooming house. On bad days, I can still hear those men screaming obscene words at me. And the irony of the only employed resident being tossed out still amazes me.
I stayed at the SA too, and had very negative experiences with them. I constantly got in trouble mind you I didn't do anything wrong. It was valuable lesson though this place taught me how to tell people whatever they wanted to hear and in my head I said f**k off.
Load More Replies...I can’t speak for all of the Salvation Army, but I do know of one good member. It was in Australia and there was a door knock to raise money. My mother answered the door and said she’d donate if she could but we had no money. The officer reached into his pocket, pulled out his wallet and gave my mother $20. She cried. Little did he know we didn’t have any food and his $20 fed us for several days. That was Christianity in action.
CONTINUED - ungrateful along with the threat of eviction. I walked out; there was no way I would allow my kids to eat that ptomaine poisoning waiting to happen bacteria laden slop. I didn’t have much money, but enough to manage a little packaged coffeecake to split with my kids down at the 7-11 on the corner. I felt fortunate I didn’t have to subject them to meals of rotten garbage unlike many of the other mothers. Needless to say I went back to my abuser, at least we had a clean house and fresh food but because of the dirty shared pillows we all ended up with the worst case of conjunctivitis in the century. It took months to heal emotionally and physically and another year to leave to a real safe house. I will NEVER EVER donate, shop, support or have anything to do with the Salvation Army and I take every opportunity to tell people just what a horrible un-charitable organization they run.
CONTINUED pockets. Less than 3% of money actually found its way into the programs. A short time later I found myself and 2 children in desperate need of a safe house and because my abuser had an incredible knack for finding me I went to the Salvation Army in downtown San Diego about 40 miles south. What I discovered were the rudest self-absorbed condescending employees with holier than thou attitudes. We were placed in a room with 4 other mothers and children, 1 pillow provided per family, not per person, but 1 pillow per family and a single bed per family, regardless of how many people were in said family, many women with 5 and 6 kids. The downstairs cafeteria was marginally clean but the food was disgusting beyond belief. The bread was green with fuzzy mold and the lunch meat was green and pink-gray colored, extremely slimy and omitting the putrid stench of sulfur. I asked the cook why the food they were serving was moldy; I was openly scolded and chastised for being (CONTINUE)
Many years ago (1978 or 79) I was the executive secretary to the Director of North San Diego County Salvation Army, Oceanside. Our main function was to place women in safe houses and work with them rebuilding their lives with free classes and job referrals. The office was ground level with storefront windows and one day a lady walked in and handed me a $10 bill, asking me to put it toward helping an abused woman with children. The Director wasn’t in at the time so I held onto the cash until she returned 30 or so minutes later. After she settled into her office I went in, handed her the donation and explained where it had come from and to what was requested it be applied to. The director smiled, held out her hand, took the money, and as she stuck it into her purse said “Good, I needed gas money”. Part of my job was to solicit donations from local upscale vendors for charitable fundraisers. Contributors made sizeable grants and endowments which ended up in administrator and board me
I have not donated to the Salvation Army for years, especially after learning of their (at least alleged) homophobic practices. I'm sure that they do help some people, but it's the bad stuff you hear. I support a local shelter for LGBTQ teens who get thrown out of their homes when they "come out of the closet." I also volunteer at a local food bank.
My family live mostly in England. My eldest daughter is lesbian and she and her partner are saving to get married. My daughter asked a SA Captain if she could bless the marriage when they get married, her answer ''Yes, of course love''. No arguements, o defining questions, just ''Yes''.
Load More Replies...As a sister if a captain of the Salvation Army, I can tell you exactly where their money goes. As a captain, my sister is given a home, rent free, fully furnished. If she dislikes the curtains, carpet, kitchen table, whatever, she has it replaced by them free of charge. That goes for all captains. That is where your money is going. I gave up donating to them a long time ago, and instead donate to a charity that provides books and clothes to school children.
Had some furniture my boys had outgrown still in very good condition. I called the S A to donate it thinking it would be given to a needy family. Two scruffy men in a S A truck arrive and refuse to accept it because it was only pine timber and quote " we don't get a good price for pine furniture". i found a nearby church in the phone book and they were glad to accept it for a needy parishioner.
Had the same experience with a wardrobe I was trying to donate. It had a tiny water stain ON THE BACK and so the SA wouldn't take it.
Load More Replies...As in every institution there will be people working for the Salvation Army who really shouldn't be allowed to even enter the premisses. And they should be fired or re-educated. Denying that this problem exists doesn't serve the Salvation Army. I'm sure that the Salvation Army has people who really want to help people in need and I'm sure it's the majority of their employees. So why not investigate the accusations and take appropriate action? Throwing the woman out makes the Salvation Army look suspicious and untrustworthy.
I never, ever donate to religious charities. I used to...but after about the third time I had a volunteer scream abuse at me and threaten to hit me for not packaging donations "correctly", I decided that no one needs to listen to that c**p. Everything I donate goes to Goodwill now.
You do realize Goodwill is a FOR PROFIT organization. You donate, they sell, they keep All the money. It's not a charity. None of their profits go to help others. Look it up.
Load More Replies...Sadly I had a very bad experience myself. I had to flee an abusive relationship and I had no where else to turn. I did have a job but no money to rent a place. No one else who stayed there had a job. Some of the men in the shelter would refer to the females in very obscene terms. After work, I would come in and volunteer to help with resumes, interview practice, new admissions, etc. I was trying so hard to be helpful. The manager, a Pastor, called me into his office and told me I had to be a bell ringer full time. I reminded him I had a job, but I would gladly work 12 hour shifts on weekends. Next morning, I was told to pack my things and leave. I spent the next few weeks living in my car in the coldest part of the year! Merry Christmas. I wound up renting a room for $125 a week in a little rooming house. On bad days, I can still hear those men screaming obscene words at me. And the irony of the only employed resident being tossed out still amazes me.
I stayed at the SA too, and had very negative experiences with them. I constantly got in trouble mind you I didn't do anything wrong. It was valuable lesson though this place taught me how to tell people whatever they wanted to hear and in my head I said f**k off.
Load More Replies...I can’t speak for all of the Salvation Army, but I do know of one good member. It was in Australia and there was a door knock to raise money. My mother answered the door and said she’d donate if she could but we had no money. The officer reached into his pocket, pulled out his wallet and gave my mother $20. She cried. Little did he know we didn’t have any food and his $20 fed us for several days. That was Christianity in action.
CONTINUED - ungrateful along with the threat of eviction. I walked out; there was no way I would allow my kids to eat that ptomaine poisoning waiting to happen bacteria laden slop. I didn’t have much money, but enough to manage a little packaged coffeecake to split with my kids down at the 7-11 on the corner. I felt fortunate I didn’t have to subject them to meals of rotten garbage unlike many of the other mothers. Needless to say I went back to my abuser, at least we had a clean house and fresh food but because of the dirty shared pillows we all ended up with the worst case of conjunctivitis in the century. It took months to heal emotionally and physically and another year to leave to a real safe house. I will NEVER EVER donate, shop, support or have anything to do with the Salvation Army and I take every opportunity to tell people just what a horrible un-charitable organization they run.
CONTINUED pockets. Less than 3% of money actually found its way into the programs. A short time later I found myself and 2 children in desperate need of a safe house and because my abuser had an incredible knack for finding me I went to the Salvation Army in downtown San Diego about 40 miles south. What I discovered were the rudest self-absorbed condescending employees with holier than thou attitudes. We were placed in a room with 4 other mothers and children, 1 pillow provided per family, not per person, but 1 pillow per family and a single bed per family, regardless of how many people were in said family, many women with 5 and 6 kids. The downstairs cafeteria was marginally clean but the food was disgusting beyond belief. The bread was green with fuzzy mold and the lunch meat was green and pink-gray colored, extremely slimy and omitting the putrid stench of sulfur. I asked the cook why the food they were serving was moldy; I was openly scolded and chastised for being (CONTINUE)
Many years ago (1978 or 79) I was the executive secretary to the Director of North San Diego County Salvation Army, Oceanside. Our main function was to place women in safe houses and work with them rebuilding their lives with free classes and job referrals. The office was ground level with storefront windows and one day a lady walked in and handed me a $10 bill, asking me to put it toward helping an abused woman with children. The Director wasn’t in at the time so I held onto the cash until she returned 30 or so minutes later. After she settled into her office I went in, handed her the donation and explained where it had come from and to what was requested it be applied to. The director smiled, held out her hand, took the money, and as she stuck it into her purse said “Good, I needed gas money”. Part of my job was to solicit donations from local upscale vendors for charitable fundraisers. Contributors made sizeable grants and endowments which ended up in administrator and board me
I have not donated to the Salvation Army for years, especially after learning of their (at least alleged) homophobic practices. I'm sure that they do help some people, but it's the bad stuff you hear. I support a local shelter for LGBTQ teens who get thrown out of their homes when they "come out of the closet." I also volunteer at a local food bank.
My family live mostly in England. My eldest daughter is lesbian and she and her partner are saving to get married. My daughter asked a SA Captain if she could bless the marriage when they get married, her answer ''Yes, of course love''. No arguements, o defining questions, just ''Yes''.
Load More Replies...














































192
145