40 Times Producers Chose The Wrong Actors For The Role, According To People In This Online Group
Sometimes the casting for the role is so good, it's hard to imagine someone else playing it. In other cases, the wrong actor choice just puts the audience out of the story, especially when actors playing a couple have no chemistry.
One person asked the AskReddit forum "What actor/actress was completely 100% wrong for the role?" And over 32K other users chimed in. Some actors gave these people unfitting to the character vibes, some were too far off the described look in the books, some were a different race than their character. Bored Panda has selected the best answers. Share in the comments if you agree.
More info: Reddit
This post may include affiliate links.
Mr. Ed. The role required a horse that could talk. The horse they hired couldn't talk so they had to dub all his lines
That's wrong, Mr Ed was dubbed because the rest of us can't speak horse.
I heard he came to set drunk half the time too. It was a different time, yes, but have some degree of professionalism.
It's funny how studios make such a big effort to dub movies into other languages and match actor's mouth movements, but end up making it look worse, or changing the meaning of the words. Mr. Ed's lips don't fit the words at all, but nobody cares.
Childhood ruined. Next you’ll be telling me coyotes run faster than road-runners.
It's a good thing Green Acres hired enough actors that could understand a pig. ;)
There are plenty of websites offering advice for starting and experienced filmmakers. You know those never-ending titles at the end of the movie? Yes, that many people are actually needed for large productions, and each type of crew is an important gear in the big machine. One of them is the casting crew: casting directors, associates, and assistants. The casting director is a senior role, they follow the director's, producer's, or writer's guidelines and make deals, negotiate. They have a lot to consider: talent, suitable chemistry, actor availability, and pay. The associate helps them find actors and make deals.
Any movie that takes place in high school, but all the actors are in their 20s or 30s.
I agree. It gives teenagers a lot of insecurities about their looks and since the actors are old they add a ton of kissing/sex that is also not realistic for teenagers. It seels them the harmful idea that everybody had sex by 15-16 and that there is something wrong if they didnt.
It is mainly due to child labour laws. They can't have real 16-17 year olds working on set for more than short times.
Check out "Puppet Killer" sometime; The 17 year old is played by a man in his early 50s
Just watched the preview and it looks awesome! Hahaha!
Load More Replies...Same for Sex Education. I can't get over the fact that most "teen boys" look like they could be dads in some family and "teen girls" look like they might be going to work in their lawyer office or maybe as dentists, professors, or in general, some very grown up jobs. They just don't look like children.
Curious how old are the films you refer to? Kids did dress 'older' back when a lot of those old educational films were made.
Load More Replies...I was just watching a period drama and having this same complaint with an actress who is supposed to play an easily manipulated, scared young woman (and knowing the period, the woman would have been in her late teens at most). The actress looks twice that age, is taller than most of the cast, and throws me off every time she is on screen...and she speaks with the most childlike voice she can muster, which is obnoxious because it is clearly not her natural tone.
That's par for acting gigs . Kids in shows usually play a child that is younger than they are
In TV series or Movie series it is often continuity issues. Beside the child protection issues. Series often depicts a shorter timespan than movie series really takes to film/product/send out. They need everlasting teenagers, that don't get at to big of a growth spurt. Example; The Ghost teenager in the Harry Potter Movies, Moaning Myrtle. Actor Shirley Henderson was about 36 Years old at that time.
TV shows set in high schools are just as bad. The chick who played Andrea Zucker in the original BH 90210 was 31 when the series started....
Colin Farrell as Alexander The Great. As one of my old University professors once said, "I wouldn't follow that guy to the end of my DRIVEWAY".
Also Alexander died like in his early 30s so he is way to old to play him.
To be fair, if you've seen Colin Farrell interviewed on The Graham Norton Show he pretty much admits how mis-cast he was.
Colin Farrell is awesome! He's like sex on toast for me for some reason. He's not even my usual type but I find him incredibly hot. Just rewatched Ondine again. His hair is fabulous in that. sex-on-toa...cbcc47.jpg
Nothing in this film worked. It was terrible beginning to end. The casting, the dialogues, the script, and wasn't this the one where they had a map of the mediterranean world as a mosaic, complete with English names? That says it all, doesn't it? It's baffling - all that wasted talent and budget. How could Oliver Stone mess up so badly?
Someone ... Greek? Or at least somehow greek-looking?
Load More Replies...Their assistant helps with various technical details, such as running the audition waiting room, camera work, reading the lines, etc. so the casting director can focus on the actors. If one is interested in becoming a casting director, it is advised they gain experience as a runner or assistant first, having graduated in Film and TV also helps. These beginner roles can be found on dedicated websites and social media groups dedicated to filmmakers in a particular area.
Tom Cruise as Jack Reacher. If you’ve read the book he is the exact physical opposite of the character as written.
Nobody should hire this guy because he's a terrible actor!
Load More Replies...I love Jack Reacher, and was scandalized to see a very un-intimidating Tom Cruise playing him.
Tom Cruise also comes of terribly pretty boy smug face, which is the opposite of Reacher's working man yet surprisingly aproacheable style once you get over the scary big guy stuff.
Load More Replies...In the books Jack Reacher is 6’5”, 250 pounds and built like a brick wall. Tom Cruise…… isn’t.
Even the author was very ticked off with the casting and criticized Cruise.
And in every Reacher book he wrote after that he made a point of saying how tall and big Reacher is. It’s very funny.
Load More Replies...Reacher is about a foot taller than Cruise, and sixty pounds heavier.
Felt same way about Jack Nicholson in One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest. McMurphy was a large, red-headed Irish American. Nicholson never worked for me
Kristen Stewart as Snow White in Snow White and the Hunstman. Terrible.
Old, recycled jokes about Kristen Stewart just get funnier and funnier.
Load More Replies...She's an actress. And she's good at acting. Don't understand why you're confused. Was she bad in Twilight? Yes, so was everybody, they're bad movies. Has she since done incredible work? Yes. This is such a boring, unoriginal take.
Load More Replies...If we’re being honest here her in anything. I find her to be a horrible actress
I agree! I actually find her role in twilight her best cause the character was also flat and boring in the books and i think she was mostly herself!
Load More Replies...I always call Kristen Stewart "Zero Charisma" - she's so bland and boring, like a human piece of Wonder Bread.
Kristen Stewart in ANY role. Acting is just not her forte, or her talent. She is terrible
I might get hate for this but I really liked her character in the new Charlie's angels
Jesse Eisenberg as Lex Luthor.
And in The Social Network, he has that snotty arrogance perfected.
Load More Replies...What a great thought! One of the major keys to Lex is his ability to get you to underestimate him. That's a brilliant cast right there.
Load More Replies...I didn’t watch the newer films as I’m not big into hero movies, but out of everyone they choose the guy who played Mark Zuckerberg?
To run the casting process professionally, there are several things to consider. Some available types of auditioning: watching showreels, which is a filmed collection of clips from different productions the actor has been in, it's cheap and quick, an actor's self-filmed reading for a particular role, it gives a sense of how suitable the actor is for the role, and more expensive - in-person auditions with or without giving script excerpts for actors to prepare in advance. The latter requires a professional and comfortable setting which would create an impression of what the production will be like.
Mickey Rooney in Breakfast at Tiffanys --- straight up plays an Asian man in the most racist performance you've ever seen
No, it wasn't cheap gag insulting. Rooney's performance was.
Load More Replies...I understand the sentiment but judging these movies by today's standards is pointless.
Louder for the ones in the back. The feigned outrage over this is cringeworthy if you stop to think for two seconds.
Load More Replies...This movie is feom 1961. Before you attack, know the context and adjust according to time period.
1961 wasn't back in the Devonian. There were people who recognized this as a racist stereotype. Even the people responsible for the movie likely did. The difference was, they thought it was still funny and didn't care enough not to do it. That doesn't make it acceptable, and there's really no need to cut anyone involved any slack today.
Load More Replies...Horrible. From head, with bad hair and terrible fake teeth and stereotyped accent badly done on down.
So glad we have finally reached a point where *most* filmmakers realize it's not okay to use white people to parody other ethnicities.
Yeah, back when white actors played Asians, Native Americans, and Egyptians and no one thought anything of it.
He played it as he was directed. Remember that. But I agree it was horrible.
Cats.
Heck, using sock puppet cats would have made for a better movie
Load More Replies...There must be something wrong with me, because I actually liked this 😭
It's not too late to get help ;) (not judging...I enjoy a lot of trash movies)
Load More Replies...You could have made a film about your cat using the litter box and made a better movie.
Rebel Wilson was a total embarrassment in a total embarrassment of a movie!
It was fun, I mean it's a musical about singing cats for broadway, what did you expect?
This should have been kept as musical only. Or at least put the actors in costumes like the musical
Yes, please! It looks like a nightmare-furry-kink-assembly! (No kink-shaming here. Just Cats-CGI-shaming!)
Load More Replies...
Steven Seagal as a person who can kick ass.
He was a person who could kick ass, just google it. He knows aikido karate, kendo and judo. But yeah, his movies are pretty bad...
He liked to sucker punch people, most film martial artists despise him, he's a petty bully which is why he's mates with Putin.
Load More Replies...This would be priceless. Maybe we can make it a Global Production and cast a lousy, talent- less actor/actress from each country. Another actor who has always stunned me is U.S. Sam Worthington. I've seen him in a few things - he seems to have been the Hot Male of Whatever era he was making films in, so he had a lot of parts. He was in Terminator Salvation. The man's face and forehead literally never move. I assumed it was Botox Overkill but then I realized his acting is just crappy. AND his forehead never moves.
Load More Replies...A person whose arms go limp when he runs as shown in most of his early films, hes too fat to run these days
I used to work in TV production and I know a guy who used to be a pretty successful production designer did all kinds of major motion pictures worked with the biggest names in the business actors directors producers etc. He told me he worked on one movie with Steven seagal and his agent called him and said hey they want to do another movie with you and Steven seagal and he said do not ever call me again to work with that guy he is a complete asshole a total loser a disrespectful jerk and I hate him I will never ever work with him again!
Steven Seagal playing a human is the worst casting ever. My toaster has more expression.
Often, when two actors have to interact, there is chemistry read. There, shortlisted actors play together, to see as the name suggests, if they have chemistry. This is lacking in many of the films in this list, particularly noticeable in romantic ones, people mentioned 50 Shades of Grey. However, the Pulp Fiction poster wouldn't hang in every other film student's dorm room if John Travolta and Samuel L. Jackson's acting didn't complement one another so much in this drama.
Jared Leto as the joker
You should see the Joker-team memes. He's like the "shame" among the other three
I did too! I think he only gets stick because of the two guys that followed him in the role being flawless. Also his script was way worse than those guys got to work with. You can't make a silk purse out of a sow's ear.
Load More Replies...So many things wrong with Suicide Squad, and Jared Leto as Joker was not even top 10
Agreed. Cara Delevigne was SO bad and so obviously self-conscious, she should have banned herself from acting. The director brought out the worst in her.
Load More Replies...I actually loved Leto as the joker! It was different approach on the character and I can appreciate that!
Jared Leto is such an amazing actor, I think the writers are more at fault. They cut his screen time SO much you never got a feel for the character. A really waste of an Oscar winner
Two that come to mind but weren't cast were in Lord of the Rings. Sean Connery was offered the role of Gandalf but turned it down because he couldn't understand the script. Could you imagine how bad of a casting decision that would have been now that we've seen Sir Ian McKellen in the role? Or Nicolas Cage as Aragorn?
Mckellen is fantastic. I cannot imagine LOTR or zthe original XMen without him
Viggo Mortensen was so intense and truly noble as Aragorn. He's an actor's actor.
Cage as aragon would have single handedly brought down the franchise like the last season of GOT
Hooray for Ian Mckellen! I also love George Ezra's music video with him, it's hilarious. 😂
Tom Cruise as Jack Reacher. Reacher's supposed to be 6+ feet tall, 240+ pounds, basically a brick sh^#house of a man. And someone pulling the strings said yeah, that totally sounds like Tom Cruise to me!
Probably the same moron who suggested Julia Roberts for Harriet Tubman.
Doesn't Cruise own the film rights to the books? If so it was pretty egotistical of him to think he was suitable for the role.
Well since Tom himself produced and directed this movie, you can now stop wondering how Tom got the role.
It was my understanding that Tom Cruise had bought the rights to the stories, so it was somewhat inevitable, however silly.
Many of the casting controversies come from changing characters' sex or race from the book or previous film or one ethnicity character being played by different ethnicity actors. The general opinion is that the actor doesn't have to be like the character in their personal life. However, in some cases such as when there is a leading transgender role, many people ask that it go to a transgender actor as they do not get many opportunities and might bring more life-like representation of the character's complexity.
Schwarzenegger in Twins. He looks nothing like Danny De Vito...
The difference was on purpose. It was part of the joke.
Load More Replies...What are you guys taking about? De Vito and Schwarzenegger…I can’t tell them apart!!
I always thought the problem was Danny De Vito looked nothing like Schwarzenegger.
Keanu Reeves as Jonathan Harker in Dracula (1992). He's charming and pretty, but he shouldn't have been in this cast against such titans as Gary Oldman and Anthony Hopkins. And the English accent was atrocious. In over his head. It's like Jennifer Lopez trying to sing a Céline Dion song.
Keanu is a graduate of the D**k Van Dyke Dialect School. So is Winona Ryder - their scenes together were excrutiating
Winona! "I'm so teddibly worried about Jonathan." And I kept waiting for Keanu to end a line with "seriously, dude."
But if you think him to play opposite of Gary Oldman you witness human versus immortal. I love Keanu but not because of his acting skills.
Yes! He is a great guy but he is really weak in very demanding roles
Load More Replies...He was utterly out of his depth in that wonderful film of Much Ado About Nothing. The rest of the cast were all brilliant: Keanu was very decorative, but struggled to keep up. To be fair to him, Kenneth Branaugh would have been terrible as Ted "Theodore" Logan.
Keanu in Much Ado About Nothing: “I am a man of few words.” Me: “Thank God.”
Load More Replies...His acting was atrocious, too. Very wooden. But then he is not known as the world's greatest thespian.
Also Winona Ryder's pronouncing "Death" like she is Daffy Duck in what is supposed to be a dark and theoretically sexy moment almays makes me guffaw.
Between Copolla's Dracula and Much Ado About Nothing, back in those days Keanu Reeves was considered the go to actor whenever anyone wanted to talk about bad acting. The Matrix helped his image a lot but, still, it is quite surprising the renaissance he had recently!
Did you guys forgot Ben Afflek in Daredevil?
I watched that movie only because Jennifer Garner was in it and i was a big fan of "Alias' at that time. Sadly, this movie spawned an even worse movie starring her("Elektra")
Uh, wrong Daredevil, that’s photo is Charlie C*x from the tv series (amazing), and definitely not Ben Affleck from the movie (never seen it). ETA they now changed the photo to Ben Affleck, I’m not “trippin’”, I just don’t generally come back and look at my comments and update them.
They've fixed the pic, but you forgot to mention how badly written the movie was, and then they tried again with Affleck as Batman!!
Load More Replies...No, we didn't. God, that movie was terrible. The series is just SO much better.
The Academy Awards introduced representation and inclusion standards for eligible films. While there was a lot of blowback, the standards are not that hard to meet. Though, some of them do require keeping some statistics about cast and crew composition. There are 4 standards, at least 2 of which the best picture nominees for 2024 must meet. Such as "at least one of the lead actors or significant supporting actors is from an underrepresented racial or ethnic group", "The film’s distribution or financing company has paid apprenticeships or internships that are from the following underrepresented groups: women, racial or ethnic group, LGBTQ+, people with cognitive or physical disabilities, or who are deaf or hard of hearing."
Shia Leboeuf in Crystal Skull. That part should've been Short Round as an adult.
That would have gotten me to watch that movie. His name is Jonathan Ke Quan, just btw, and he also played Data from The Goonies :D
"Why do you call him Short Round?" - "Because he is" - Best line in the whole movie :)
That whole movie wasn't right. It was a Sci-Fi history mystery featuring Indiana Joned
Oh yeah because raiders of the lost ark or the last crusade were just full of genuine facts, weren't they...
Load More Replies...
Jamie Dornan and Dakota Johnson in the 50 Shades trilogy
Aside from the movies being absolutely sh&^$y, the two had no chemistry with each other and it was awkward as hell to watch. More so when I found out that Jamie was married while filming those movies. The movies shouldn't have even been made.
Why does an actor being married make any romance movie/scenes awkward? Not every actor in the world is single.
Yeah i didn't get that comment either! It's their job!! Marriage has nothing to do with it! If you can't do it because you are married then you cannot be an actor
Load More Replies...It's called acting. Who gives a crap if the actor is in s relationship?
this is from a person who doesn't understand what actors actually do.
I read somewhere that the author had an "ask me anything" event on twitter and someone legit, asked, "Is it true that you are nothing but a burlap bag full of spiders and bad ideas?" XD
You should check out the AMA James Corden did. It was a disaster.
Load More Replies...And yet he was sooo good in The Fall. His performance was just chilling. 50 shades is just all round bad - I don't think any actors could have made it a good movie!
Jamie Dornan is a pretty good actor. He did a great job in The Fall. You can only work with the script that you have though.
Emma Watson as Belle in beauty and the beast. I actually thought she was the perfect choice before I saw it. But belles main qualities are supposed to be her warmth and kindness, and it felt like Emma was genuinely judging all the people living in her town. She’s a good hermione though
I only heard this idea recently: maybe belle is bored because the whole town was enchanted to forget the beast, so they might also be stuck in some loop. Belle and her father joined the village after leaving Paris, and after the beast enchantments were cast. Maybe she found the village boring because it really was super-monotonous (cause of the spell) 🤷♀️
Oooh that's a really interesting theory, has some merit!
Load More Replies...She is also a mediocre singer so all her songs sound horribly autotuned...
I disagree with that one and had the opposite feelings! Didn't like the choice when i heard it but she changed my mind! Belle is judgemental in the animation too! The Belle song is the most judgemental song ever!!
This is it. She's nice to the Beast, but her song is pretty judgy. "Look at the baker with his shitty bread. Wow, everyone here is boring as hell. Can't wait to get away from all these lame poor people."
Load More Replies...Maybe it's the director's fault. Emma Watson is a good enough actress, but her Belle is strangely inexpressive.
I was so looking forward to this remake and was sorely disappointed. Emma Watson may be a good actress, but she CANNOT sing
I thought Belle’s redeeming quality was that she learned not to judge after meeting the Beast. She was quite “judgy” of beast in the beginning like how she was w her village people.
Tell us what role you would like to witness being played by a different actor and why in the comments. Do you agree with the list? What do you think about diversity and inclusion standards in the entertainment industry?
Maybe an unpopular opinion, but Sophie Turner as Jean Gray.
I like her as an actress, but I just couldn’t get into it. I felt like she struggled with hiding her accent.
Yeah. I liked her as Sansa Stark despite not really liking the character at the start, but as Jean Gray, I couldn't even watch Dark Phoenix because it just didn't feel right.
Load More Replies...I didn’t see Game of Thrones, but I watched Dark Phoenix. It was really terrible, I laughed a lot, but I don’t think I was meant to. I didn’t feel that Sophie Turner was lead actor material by any stretch of the imagination.
This movie should have never happened. It's dull, boring, and nothing like the comic book. And the ending scene is a compilation of clichés about Paris, France, making the movie even worse.
Everybody gets this one wrong. She was NOT Jean Grey, but the Phoenix Force trying to be Jean Grey. Those of us who read the comics remember that the real Jean Grey was in a stasis pod on the shuttle at the bottom of the Hudson River which was found by a joint expedition by the Avengers and Fantastic Four several years after the Dark Phoenix had been defeated.
Whats unpolular about that? The film was a flop for a reason. I dont like "cast by current popularity" anyways. Just because Game of thrones was the hype doesnt mean that every friggin movie has to have the same people in it (i also disliked GOT actors in Avengers) and am very doubtful about Dune (loved the books) - where the trailer basically looks like a Marvel+DC mashup.
I don't know about her accent but I didn't like her in the role, or Jessica Chastain. Or the plot of Dark Phoenix. I'll just keep waiting.
Whoever the dude was in 50 shades. Christian Bale would have crushed that role
They actually went to Ian Somerhalder initially for this role, and he denied.
I think Christian Bale is one of the most fantastic actors of all time and thankfully he didn't play role in this rubbish
It would have been a very different movie. Different from the books, too.... Honestly, he'd probably be able to make it a strangely amazing film, but there would be no white-washing the rape-y quality of it. He'd be wonderfully sinister.
Load More Replies...he wasnt one of the ppl they asked. but if they did i wouldnt doubt hed turn it down.
Load More Replies...They could have done us all a favor and just not make this movie.
Jamie Dornan is such a good actor (see The Fall i.e.) that in this saga was a waste of time. of course he said he did it for the money, fair enough. Plus they should have given this role to a much taller and more muscular actor.
Henry Cavill yes please. I also think he'd be a perfect cast for The Mister.
Henry cavill was offered it I think? Or someone who played superman was, but turned it down
Load More Replies...
I have no issues with Pierce Brosnan. Made a fine bond even though his scripts weren't strong. Can do comedy even.
But singing in Mamma Mia? How was that ever allowed to happen?
I admired that he gave it his all for the singing. He wasn't great but he was sincere.
I agree. He went for it, did his best and was way better than critics claimed. I love both films - and coincidentally am listening to the soundtrack from Mamma Mia! right now
Load More Replies...He can't sing, but he was well cast as the man you'd still want 20-odd years later. Really, really want!
no no he was perfect! perfect mix of genuine awesome bit of cringe that goes with that film!!!
He makes up for his so-so singing with his charisma. I don't object.
Is it now the time to talk about Topher Grace as Eddie Brock/Venom?
I read that even Topher Grace said "...Have you SEEN Eddie Brock?!" when offered the role. But the rational was to get someone physically close to Tobey, for that dark mirror effect to the role. I get it, but I don't agree with the choice...Dwayne Johnson was my first thought, he could bring the physique and the intensity
Horrendous? Yes. Still better than the current Venom. That slapstick bulls**t...no tie to Spider-Man? Pfft. Still waiting for a proper Venom.
everyone in the last airbender movie, especially considering the fact that they took the waterbenders (canonically the nation with the darkest skin coloring) and made all of them white, then made the firebenders dark-skinned.
It is even worse. The main actors in the tribe (Sokka and Katara) are played by caucasian people but the "not important background characters" are inuit looking.
Didn't see the mvoie because of the whitewashing. Seriously, don't produce this knd of film if you can't commit to the original. I am glad it flopped. hopefully, producers will finally get the message that whitewashing is not accepted in this millenium, anymore.
If they were going to make this as a live action, and not have the compression of storyline issues, would have been much better done as a series. Also using actors that are actually from the cultures/races supposed to be in the series. Surely there are enough people around the planet to do it
I LOVE M. Night movies...but he seriously butchered this one! Even the characters' names didn't get pronounced right.
I’ve seen several fanposts about possible actors for the ATLA movie. 90% of the suggestions were a better fit than the actual cast…
Has anyone said Emelia Clarke as Sarah Connor yet? Also Jai Courtney as Kyle Reese. Actually the whole movie sans Arnold was cast fu$^king horribly.
Basically any Terminator after the first two. How many times can you milk a cow before you have to put the poor thing out of it's misery.
Load More Replies...Emelia Clark is one of the greatest actors out there today… and yet some of the films she’s been in have not let her show her talent properly
Whoever is particularly marketable at the moment is cast for the presumably highest grossing movie of the upcoming season. It's Hollywood logic. The producers want big names who can attract the big crowds. It has nothing to do with acting skills or suitability for a role.
I personally loved Emilia as Sarah. I thought she was perfectly cast out of the actresses in the required age bracket at the time.
The best Sarah Connor outside of Linda Hamilton was Lena Heady when she played her in the highly underrated, "Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles." I like Emelia, but as Sarah? Eh.
Load More Replies...
Just wanted to say for anyone doubting future casting, look at Robert Downey Jr as Ironman. When that was announced so many fans were up in arms and now he IS Ironman...
Yes, but the complaints were all BEFORE the movie, then he went and nailed it! Then, he did Dolittle. We don't talk about Dolittle.
I heard the same about Michael Keaton as Batman. And Daniel Craig, because we can't have a blonde James Bond. And both aren't the best in their roles. But pretty damn close to best.
It's still a no from me for Daniel Craig as Bond, sorry.
Load More Replies...if it was for RDJ the whole franchise would fall apart i think honestly. he was perfect for ironman
I doubt the franchise would have been possible without the choice and succes of Iron Man. The perfect choice for this character, even though for lovers of the comics, it would have probably looked absurd.
Load More Replies...Yeah but a lot of that was from his old antics which actually made him perfect for the part.
To be fair, if you look back into his roles, Tony Stark as he was in the comics would not have been an obvious choice. But there's the thing: he's a REALLY good actor (when he's sober)
Load More Replies...I don't remember anyone being up in arms or against that casting. Long before he was even cast Wizard magazine listed RDJ as the best choice for the role........ Before they were even casting for it. The only reason that casting him was a problem was that his previous drug problems and particularly previous arrests that had made him unable to fulfil previous acting jobs, made it impossible to insure him. Not because fans didn't like him for the role.
I never got into the comics; RDJ is the reason why I now love Ironman so much.
Hmmm... not so much, but the movies are still fun. So it's forgiven
Load More Replies...Ginny Weasley... that actress just never grew into that role. I know it’s hard to cast kids that young, but man they should have replaced her for the last few movies, it was harsh seeing Harry have more actual chemistry with a Muggle coffee shop girl (who was amazing) than the supposed love of his life (who was nothing like fiery character in books).
I think that the problem here is direction and not the poor actress. Book Ginny is funny, athletic and cool while movie Ginny is super akward. They made her play the stupidest scenes like tying Harrys shoelaces or the coolie scene. I dont think that the poor girl had much to work with.
Her role definitely seemed a lot smaller in the movies! The love story with Harry seemed that came out of the blue! It was better built up in the books
Load More Replies...I have to disagree as how she looked and acted is how I read the character and imagined the character in the books. Isn't it interesting how two people can read a book and view a character in such different fashions!?
Hysterical to think the most powerful boy wizard, Harry was that eras “rock star” , would settle for the female version of his best friend, Ron. Shes the only chick he can pull? He would have groupies in reality. How did Harry not see how boss he was and how he could find that times “supermodel”?
Um it makes perfect sense that he would fall for a female version of his best friend. You're just speaking of what makes sense in stereotypes.
Load More Replies...
Cameron Diaz in Gangs of New York. It’s the only time I’ve really be pulled out of a movie because the casting didn’t seem right.
I was waiting for this one. I was watching it for the first time yesterday and she just can't keep up with DDL and DiCaprio. The movie would have been better without a love interest, she was just awful.
Totally, and I like Cameron but this was a bad choice. DDL is a genius.
Load More Replies...Funny, the differences of opinions here. I was expecting Cameran Diaz to be well out of her league in Gangs of New York. I thought that she was more than fine. This is one of those movies that I found disappointing when I first saw it. Some years later I watched it again, and thought that the movie was fantastic. I had a similar experience with Full Metal Jacket.
John Malkovich in Being John Malkovich. It just seemed a bit too on the nose.
I agree, John Malkovich was miscast, there was someone who could play John Malkovich better than John Malkovich.
Just watching that scene is surreal - can you imagine filming it?!?
Load More Replies...Someone would have complained she was appropriating white male roles.
Load More Replies...John Dorian as Dr. Acula. He is way to hammy, and not very threatening for a vampire who is behind loads of mysterious deaths in the hospital. He clearly only got the part because he wrote the darn script for it. It was also a very racist filming process where multiple times Chris Turk was told to "act blacker". In good conscience I can't support the film
Oh, and from now on, whenever I'm in the room, you're definitely not allowed to talk. Dr. C*x rules.
LOL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! The site edited his name!!!!!!!!!!!
Load More Replies...
Johnny Depp as Grindelwald. Not because of the whole situation around it, but after reading the books and the cameos in Potter, I just don't see him as Grindelwald, just as albino Depp.
I agree. I was a big fan of Depp but he is not a good one to play Grindelwald. You know who could have pulled it off? The guy who plays Magneto in the new movies.
Fassbender would have been fab! He's terrifically! And he can play a German convincingly, Depp didnt even try.
Load More Replies...I'm surprised people didn't like him for it. When people say "he's not right for Grindelwald, what are you going off of? Cause there's no books with him in it right? What makes him not right to the "real" Grindelwald?
I also don't get it! Personally i really liked him in the role he finally didn't remind me of jack sparrow and was a great villain!!! We didn't have a description of Grindelwald in books anyway just a slight mention of a horribly bad wizard if i recall correctly
Load More Replies...Hm...I didn't even recognize him a Depp, at first. I thought his performance as Grindlewald was fantastic. - he has that weird mix of serious and slightly ironic. totally believed he would pull off mass murder while looking apologetic
100% agree. Then seen Mads Mikkelsen, it was like, “THAT’s who they should have cast!”
I loved Depp but I am stoked to see what Madds Mikkelsen will do with this role. He is a very, very talented actor and the perfect fit for a wizard supervillain.
They should have kept the pre-reveal actor. My god. Depp is a decent enough actor, but he's absolutely not Grindelwald!
Cameron Diaz was horrible in the 2014 Annie remake. She hasn't made a movie since.
She wanted to have a life. Now has a baby! She's happy. A really radiantly lovely person.
I have been a fan of Annie since I was little, even have Annie collector items. I dont think this is the worse Annie remake and I dont think Cameron did a horrible job, its very hard to live up to Mrs. Hannigan after Carol Burnett did such an amazing job. And she retired from acting, her departure has nothing to do with this movie.
To be fair, Cameron Diaz was horrible in pretty much everything she did.
John Wayne as a Native American or Anthony Hopkins as a black man come to mind.
John Wayne as Ghenghis Khan. John Wayne as a Roman soldier. John Wayne as anything apart from a wooden cowboy
Loved all the John Wayne movies great actor in any part
Load More Replies...I've seen John Wayne portray a German steam freighter Captain. He doesn't portray anything well other than American Cowboy. I don't find him a good actor, sorry.
I was raised on John Wayne. Didn't like him then, still don't like him. Won't watch his terrible movies.
Load More Replies...as a brown skinned person I appreciated Anthony Hopkins in The Human Stain because to me it would have given non- brown skinned viewers a point of pause - that the historical visual depictions of Indigenous and brown skinned people are social constructs to which social 'value' is attached. I think that having an actor Hopkin's calibre was a means by which to attract a wide variety of viewers and an opportunity to draw those conversations/analyses. Aboriginal Australians are often questioned on their % of Aboriginality (which is not an identity measure for Indigenous Australians) because they have 'fair skin' blue eyes and fair hair
Well, that Hopkins role was about a man who was able to pass as white. But your point is taken.
Wayne had the range of a slug. if he wasn't playing a cowboy or a soldier, he was useless.
Johnny Depp as Tonto... (I really thought it would appear on the list)
That whole movie was a bad idea. I mean, did Hollywood really need to blow 200+ Million on a Western based on some ancient radio/TV franchise?
Load More Replies...
Jon Voight as a snake hunter in Anaconda is fine......but him as a PARAGUAYAN snake hunter?.....just......why lol
Hollywood has not yet figured out that there are great actors of color all over. . . . Other than their go to tokens.
A person feom Paraguay doesn't have to be a person of color.
Load More Replies...Perhaps he was naturalized as a Paraguayan in the 2nd half of the 1940s after coming from Europe?
Just a little tidbit . . .most Paraguayans are of European and Guaraní ancestry."
I love this casting because it made the movie even more deliciously terrible.
Jon Voight as a creepy guy that's ultimately planning on stabbing you on the back? That's pretty well cast. But a PARAGUAYAN creepy guy that's planning on stabbing you in the back? Makes no sense.
Pretty much everyone from the Percy Jackson movies
It was the writing and refusal to stick to the books that was the problem, not the actors
They put in multiple scenes that weren't there to begin with, and the casting was definitely in the top five of 'That's Inaccurate' for this movie
I thought Logan Lerman portrayed the character's awkwardness rather well.
I feel the actors never read the books or cared for the mythology. There were so many unnecessary scenes, getting high off flowers in the casino?
Jafar in the new Aladdin. He wasn’t believable or menacing and way too young. Plus for much of his screen time he’s standing next to Navid Neghaban, who would have been a MUCH better choice.
Navid would have been a good choice...but Marwan is super hot...so...
What bothered me most about that movie was that they cast a white-passing British woman for the role of Jasmine. Like, come on. Let's give a non-white looking women more opportunities in movies.
The chemistry between her and the guy who played alladin was great though.
Load More Replies...When Will Smith was cast as Genie i thought NOOOOO... no one can replace Robin Williams. But i actually prefer his role. Sorry for doubting you Will.
PLAYED the part very well yes, but did not LOOK it at all. Cartoon Jafar was an old, greasy, UGLY character.
Load More Replies...Nicole Kidman is cast as Lucy in Aaron Sorkin's Lucille Ball movie. She can't move her face anymore. And I like Nicole Kidman, she's done some great stuff lately but this doesn't make sense.
My wife and I have just finished Nine Perfect Strangers. She was very good in that.
Goodlooking yes, but good… I don’t really agree. Loved her in ‘Australia’ though.
Load More Replies...Debra Messing would be perfect, but she's not enough of a "name" for Hollywood.
I liked her in My Life, where she's playing Michael Keaton's wife and he's dying of cancer, but I haven't seen much else she's done that really grabbed me.
Every actress cast as Sue Richards, The Invisible Woman, from the Fantastic Four so far
Right!!! Jessica Abla had to wear a blonde wig with blue contacts it was off-putting. Was there no blue eyed blonde actress available?
She doesn’t have to be blonde haired and blue eyed or white. Those are just superficial features. But them trying to make Jessica Alba look like a white lady was just weird; no reason she couldn’t just look like herself.
Load More Replies...Why is this a picture of Emily Blunt from Edge of Tomorrow? I know everyone wants her and krasinski to play Sue and Reed, but they haven't yet.
Is that where it's from, a still of Blunt from Edge of Tomorrow? I could've sworn that that was Betty Gilpin.
Load More Replies...You wouldn't think it would be too difficult to play an invisible woman.
Now that the F4 are finally under the Marvel/MCU umbrella, maybe there's hope that a good F4 movie will finally get made.
Everyone cast in all three versions of the Fantastic Four was horrible... Except Chris Evans.
thats bc chris evans is one of those actors has fun with his roles and really gets into it. hes an amazing actor
Load More Replies...Looks like someone's getting familiar. I thought it was always Susan unless you were family.
Load More Replies...It's not like there isn't SIXTY YEARS of source material to peruse in order to prepare for the role....
Dane DeHaan - Valerian
That move is pretty awesome except for him, it felt entirely miscast and I couldn't believe this guy was the kind of character they were making him out to be.
In general, I feel that the movie had a lot of potential (and probably the comics are great) but it was mediocre
Disagree. The only slightly unbelievable part of casting both DeHaan and Delavingne was the discrepancy between their apparent ages and their higher ranks and responsibilities. Personally, I loved the movie; the storyline, sets, costumes, and overall production were top notch. It's not a classically great movie, but a lot of fun nonetheless.
Valerian should have been some Indiana Jones-type character. Then they cast this guy. He's not a bad actor, he was great as Billy the Kid. But his physique is not suited for this movie.
the casting of both leads was the paramount misfire. They're nothing like the characters in the comic - just dumb, smart a**e kids. As others have written it's a shame because the movie had such potential
Valerian was actually a kind-of-competent movie that a lot of people missed, heck I didn't even remember the title, because it was so much CG and space fantasy stuff in a market super-saturated with the stuff. It didn't leave the biggest impression, but plenty of creativity went into it and I liked it.
The movie was in my opinion, regarding visuals, imagination and story, way, way better than any star wars movie to date, but I must agree I also thought there should have been other actors for both main characters...
Dane DeHaan is such a great actor. He just needs to land a few really good roles which fit him well and he could become a much bigger name. I hope he does!
I think he’s great in the role. Physically he looks like someone who is not a hero(That’s why his casting as Harry Osborn in Amazing Spider Man was perfect) but he’s great at playing the hero in this film.
Joel McHale as Roy in the ill-fated US remake of The IT Crowd.
We want a scruffy and misanthropic IT nerd, so let's get an actor known foorrr... charisma and confidence? OK.
That was awful casting. It was even more cringe-inducing that he was alongside Richard Ayoade in a WORD-FOR-WORD remake.
I didn't even know this was a thing o_O Why do they think they have to remake British stuff for American audiences? We like the British stuff as-is, that's why we watched it and made it popular here in the first place! And on that note: FU American version of "The Office" you're a pale imitation! What's next, an American "Kids in the Hall"? UGH!
There was a remake? Well I guess they had to try turning it off and on again at least once.
Remaking British comedies is usually a huge fail. The Office is the exception because they tailored it to more american style office antics. And Michael Scott was the best character on tv in the clueless, worship me but I’m a total moron, boss role. Otherwise British comedies always over their shitty US remakes.
There's also a Broadchurch-redo for US audience. Which - surprise - didn't really work that well. Although I admit that I haven't seen it, because I love the original so much.
Load More Replies...I had no idea they tried an American remake. Ugh. Just leave it alone. The original was brilliant.
Zoe Saldana as Nina Simone
I wouldn't mind seeing is because I love Nina, but the Netflix documentary "What Happened, Miss Simone?" is probably much more informative.
Probably gonna get shot down on this but white people shouldn't cast black icons. Inevitably miss the mark.
Yes I agree. Part of her story is like so many dark skinned black women. We are passed over as we are not the beauty standard. This likely contributed to her essential bitterness. This was a missed opportunity to deal with a subject that could help to enlighten other people outside of the community about the psychological damage it fosters.
Load More Replies...How about nobody as Nina Simone. There’s enough real Nina out there. Just go watch video clips of her and listen to her performances and soak that in. Even the bad stuff (house of the rising sun, really?) is brilliant.
Ryan Reynolds as Hal Jordan, he would have been more believable as Kyle Raynor then Hal Jorden... he was regularly thrown around to play Wally West as the Flash. They took a big(ish) popular actor and throw him at a role without any consideration that his personality matched the character. Everything that makes Reynolds perfect as Deadpool makes him wrong as Hal Jordan.
They should try Green Lantern again. He's one of DC's elite and deserved better than what he got.
Ferdia Shaw as Artemis Fowl. He conveys none of the intelligence, shrewdness or relentless determination of the book character. He comes across as a child dressed up in a suit and handed cue cards with smart-sounding lines to read unconvincingly. He's a child so I'm going to lay the blame for that one on the casting director.
The entire movie was terrible. The whole point is that he is evil and a genius and they made him into a soft daddys boy who believes in fairies not because of evidence or greed like in the books but because daddy told him so. It was such a easy book to adapt and it was a disaster.
I still haven't dared to see it, because I saw the trailer. All I could think of was "this is not the books, they just borrowed the names for the characters..."
Load More Replies...I hate that movie so much. The books were so good and the movie portrayed none of the good parts. It was horrible
The books were awesome. I had such high hopes for the movie. Sad sigh.
Load More Replies...
Idk their names, but the main protagonists in the live action remake of dragon ball and also the one in the last airbender
What's crazy to me is how these movies still were able to make a profit
Me watching previews: Jim Halpert for Jack Ryan... Me after watching it: Ah s^#t he rocked it.
Is he good? Bc I specifically passed bc how do you go from "Aw shucks" to bad a$$?
Load More Replies...Jim Halpert is a much nicer guy than real-life John Krasinsky.
I will take a look in the future and say Mark Whalberg as Sully in the Uncharted movie
I will take a look in the past and say Mark Wahlberg in almost every movie.
Neither of the co-stars of this film are exactly good casting choices. Wahlberg as Sully is bad enough, but I also can't see Tom Holland as Nathan Drake.
Tommy lee Jones could do that role if he were younger too much action for him now.
Dominic Purcell as Dracula in Blade: Trinity.
That movie has A LOT of problems but Purcell just isn't believable in the role. He's also the smallest person in the movie which just makes it harder to buy him as the king of the vampire world.
Hell, Parker Posey would have made a much better Dracula because she is 100% going for it in her role and was the best part of the film.
Edit: a few people have mentioned that Purcell is 6'1 and I get that he isn't a short guy, the problem is he's shot as if he is and doesn't come off as imposing whatsoever. I left his acting off because, well...it speaks for itself.
That's not Dominic Purcell, that's Triple H. Someone is just pulling photos at random on Bored Panda. Wonder how quick they'll fix this.
Dominic Purcell is 6'2" (1.88m). That's hardly "small." Wesley Snipes is only 5'9" (1.75m). This entire entry is a dumpster fire of misinformation.
Blade trinity does not exist, my therapist says so. Just like Matrix being a single film.
You have a very good therapist, nothing good comes from questioning what you're being told.
Load More Replies...Recently watched the new series The Equilizer and saw Queen Latifah lay out a gigantic bad guy and thought “What?
She's a big sturdy gal. I totally buy the action scenes. I really like the casting of a big girl instead of the standard dainty waif. It's distracting to have to watch a tiny little woman pretend to beat up a couple of big men, but the Queen has the necessary energy, size and presence.
I tried to like it, but a busy woman running all around town and still getting her hair done several times per day in different styles? just no
Very bad miscasting the equilizer like Bond should alway be a man as it was originally written for a man.
If it's not a big, middle-aged white man, or Denzel Washington, it's not "The Equalizer."
Meryl Streep as whomever that was in Mary Poppis Returns. That whole scene was atrocious
No way!! If you've read all the Mary Poppins books, Meryl was great as Topsy Turvey!
Movie hasn’t even come out yet but Kevin Hart is playing Roland in the new Borderlands movie and i can already tell you right now, it’s gonna be a terrible fu#^ing time.
They're making a Borderlands movie? F**k, what's next, a movie based off of a cereal box? Don't get me wrong, I loved the game (and 2 and the prequel) but a movie??? SMH...
Chloe Grace Moretz in the Carrie remake.
I think the problem was making a remake in the first place not so much the casting.
I thought she turned in a great performance! But perhaps came off as too attractive and confident to be that believable as the bullied dropout, which they could have done something to fix with makeup. **shrug**
This version of Carrie came out nearly a decade ago.
Load More Replies...Kevin Hart as Roland in the upcoming Borderlands movie. Everyone who knows anything about Borderlands will agree with me. Terry Crews should be playing Roland. He's big, has comedic chops, and can play the no-nonsense straight shooter BADASS when everything else is wild.
Anybody who disagrees hasn't even loaded the game, the intro on the bus shows how wrong Hart is for playing Roland!!
My guess is that they're just taking it in another direction, possibly for comedic effect. I'm concerned, but I hope it will turn out cause I love the games.
Annabeth in the "Percy Jackson" movie. The main physical feature was supposed to be the blond hair, and they somehow messed up on that.
In the movies, she has brown hair and blue eyes. This is the third movie
Load More Replies...They just strayed way to far from the books. Didn't even get the spirit of them right.
I would have said grey eyes were the mail physical feature, considering how many times it's mentioned by other characters that they have seen eyes like that.
I haven't seen the movie and have no opinion about how she performed in it, but her hair not being blonde enough seems more a design choice than an actor choice. They change actors' hair all the time for movies. If they wanted a blonder character, hair dye and wigs are a thing.
Non-British (particularly male) actors cast as protagonists in a medieval settings. The accents aren't just often bad, they're extremely distracting too. What's crazy is that the supporting (often antagonist) casting are very often British and often.. very good. Russell Crowe vs. Mark Strong in Robin Hood (2010) Dennis Quad vs. David Thewlis in Dragonheart Kevin Costner and Christian Slater vs. Alan Rickman in Robin Hood (1991) There's a few exceptions. Namely Braveheart and A Knights Tale.
Alan Rickman as Sheriff of Nottingham was my favourite!!! Love this film!!! RIP Alan Rickman.
Alan Rickman was the only good thing about that movie...he's so hilariously evil, that I'd watch it just for that
May be ok with the idea of better actors playing secondary parts (Alan Rickman we all miss you) but about the accent I have no problem. One of the Brando’s best interpretations is as Marc Anthony in Julius Caesar, and meanwhile everyone in the film had a transatlantic his is the opposite (don’t know where his accent is from).
I'm an old so I'm gonna say the roles of Tom Cruise and Brad Pitt should have been switched in Anne Rices' "Interview with a Vampire". I mean come on Pitt was made to play Lestat and Cruise is who you envision when you read Luis. Interview-...fb1069.jpg
michael gambon as the dumbledore who replaced richard harris. physically, harris was spot on per description in the books but, due to his illness, he did lack a bit of the energy. if he had lived to continue the character i don't think he could have carried the character well due to his fragile condition. gambon seems to not have read the books or just didn't want to play the character as rowling intended. personally, ian mckellen would have been a great dumbledore but, from what i have read, he didn't want the part because of his wizard character in lord of the rings.
Call me crazy but I always thought Liam Neeson in a good amount of makeup would have been a fantastic Dumbledore. That’s just how I imagine Dumbledores voice. Firm and rough but with a gentle quality. I think seeing him play Zeus is what gave me the idea. Also as QuiGon in Star Wars.
Load More Replies...AMBER HEAD IN LITERALLY ANYTHING. Altho can we take a moment to appreciate the galaxy sized cringe the latest version of the Stand causes? Just... no.
I love her, but I think Julia Roberts was the wrong cast for Eat Pray Love. The main character was supposed to be way more bubbly, and her being a bad fit added to the movie being so terrible.
I'm an old so I'm gonna say the roles of Tom Cruise and Brad Pitt should have been switched in Anne Rices' "Interview with a Vampire". I mean come on Pitt was made to play Lestat and Cruise is who you envision when you read Luis. Interview-...fb1069.jpg
michael gambon as the dumbledore who replaced richard harris. physically, harris was spot on per description in the books but, due to his illness, he did lack a bit of the energy. if he had lived to continue the character i don't think he could have carried the character well due to his fragile condition. gambon seems to not have read the books or just didn't want to play the character as rowling intended. personally, ian mckellen would have been a great dumbledore but, from what i have read, he didn't want the part because of his wizard character in lord of the rings.
Call me crazy but I always thought Liam Neeson in a good amount of makeup would have been a fantastic Dumbledore. That’s just how I imagine Dumbledores voice. Firm and rough but with a gentle quality. I think seeing him play Zeus is what gave me the idea. Also as QuiGon in Star Wars.
Load More Replies...AMBER HEAD IN LITERALLY ANYTHING. Altho can we take a moment to appreciate the galaxy sized cringe the latest version of the Stand causes? Just... no.
I love her, but I think Julia Roberts was the wrong cast for Eat Pray Love. The main character was supposed to be way more bubbly, and her being a bad fit added to the movie being so terrible.
