Mom’s Explanation Why She Teaches Son Not To Share Gets Shared 207,000+ Times, Other Parents React
When a group of boys at the park approached Alanya Kolberg’s young son, Carson, and demanded that he share his toys with them, she handled the situation in a way that some parents weren’t expecting. After her story went viral, parents of the Internet weighed in, and you might be surprised by their reactions.
Kolberg’s post, written on April 19th, has already been shared over 200 thousand times, and has garnered just as many likes. Hundreds of parents and others took to the comment section, igniting a tricky but thought-provoking discussion on the true meaning of the old motto “sharing is caring.” Kolberg’s method, however, seemed to unite the opinions of readers more than it divided.
Read the whole story for yourself below, and tell us your thoughts on this issue in the comments!
More info: (h/t)
After an experience at the park with her son Carson, this mom took to Facebook with a message to other parents
The brutally honest rant has now been shared over 200 thousand times, and follows like so:
“You can tell them no, Carson,” Kolberg told her young son. “Just say no. You don’t have to say anything else”
The mom’s actions brought forth praise from many commentators, who defended her parenting methods
Others, however, offered less supportive opinions on the matter, sparking fierce runoff debates
What’s your take? Is sharing really caring? Tell us in the comments below!
576Kviews
Share on FacebookWhen I was a kid in the kindergarten I was forced to share(only my teachers made me do it, luckily) many of my toys and books. The only thank I got for this was to see my belongings ruined. By teaching Carson to say "no" to other children, this mother actually teaches her son to respect his own opinion and choices. Carson chose to share his toys with a close friend(to whom he trusts she wouldn't damage) and making your opinion matter is a very important thing in the adults' world.
Also, she's not teaching him not to share. She's teaching him that he has a right to say no if he wants to.
Load More Replies...life can be complicated. I would expect if he did share with 6 different kids, there's a good chance he'd never see his toys again. I recall sharing an electronic toy when growing up, the older kid wouldn't give it back after several hours. I asked for it back and was denied. had to get big brother to get it back, of course then I was the bad guy.
My nephew has had many toys stolen because he was taught to share by my sister. Now when I'm babysitting him he doesn't have to give his things away.
Load More Replies...You don't teach your kid to share, you teach him that one of the best feelings in the world comes from sharing your stuff with others ! The source of your joy should be the joy you bring to others. But for this to happen, it must be his own decision, as there is no joy in being forced to share. I strongly agree with the mother.
I agree! What you end up doing is creating exactly the opposite, the kind of greedy selfish person who doesn't want to share anything with anyone, ever. She's teaching him boundaries, and loving to share with close friends.
Load More Replies...Sorry, mom is right here. I remember a kid wanting to share a truck my daughter had. I said he could have it when she was finished. You can't "share" one truck. The kid wanted it. Those 6 kids _wanted_ those toys, they weren't going to share. They were going to _take_.
So true! I mean, what do you expect people to do, take a knife and cut the toys in half??? (lol)
Load More Replies...I'm a mom of five ranging in age from 26 down to 12. The mom is right here. I see the huge difference from when my 26 year old was young to now. Back then, the OTHER PARENT would come and apologize to my son for the rudeness of their child. When my 12 year was younger it was the EXACT opposite. And we wonder why kids are so disrespectful/rude/entitled now...
if it makes you feel any better my kid knows better and I would apologize if she did do something like this... in fact I did a few times when she was much younger.
Load More Replies...That comment about "but children are different, more social" is bs learning boundaries is a CRUCIAL part of becoming a functional adult
yeah If I learned to say no and set boundries I'd be better off. I blame me for the record but if I did it i'd probably have less issues.
Load More Replies...People who want you to share your properties are incidentally also the ones who want to take your properties. But it's probably just a strange coincidence...
I absolutely love this mother's response. Which parent is going to step up and pay for the toy when it gets broken? Ya, just what I thought. Those parents would say "if he didn't want it broken, he shouldn't have brought it." Sorry folks, not everyone gets a trophy!!
yeah I'm still waiting for a certain parent to replace the basket on my kid's bike.
Load More Replies...I agree with her! It's very important to learn that sometimes it's good to say no to people, otherwise you just end up burning out.
When I was a kid in the kindergarten I was forced to share(only my teachers made me do it, luckily) many of my toys and books. The only thank I got for this was to see my belongings ruined. By teaching Carson to say "no" to other children, this mother actually teaches her son to respect his own opinion and choices. Carson chose to share his toys with a close friend(to whom he trusts she wouldn't damage) and making your opinion matter is a very important thing in the adults' world.
Also, she's not teaching him not to share. She's teaching him that he has a right to say no if he wants to.
Load More Replies...life can be complicated. I would expect if he did share with 6 different kids, there's a good chance he'd never see his toys again. I recall sharing an electronic toy when growing up, the older kid wouldn't give it back after several hours. I asked for it back and was denied. had to get big brother to get it back, of course then I was the bad guy.
My nephew has had many toys stolen because he was taught to share by my sister. Now when I'm babysitting him he doesn't have to give his things away.
Load More Replies...You don't teach your kid to share, you teach him that one of the best feelings in the world comes from sharing your stuff with others ! The source of your joy should be the joy you bring to others. But for this to happen, it must be his own decision, as there is no joy in being forced to share. I strongly agree with the mother.
I agree! What you end up doing is creating exactly the opposite, the kind of greedy selfish person who doesn't want to share anything with anyone, ever. She's teaching him boundaries, and loving to share with close friends.
Load More Replies...Sorry, mom is right here. I remember a kid wanting to share a truck my daughter had. I said he could have it when she was finished. You can't "share" one truck. The kid wanted it. Those 6 kids _wanted_ those toys, they weren't going to share. They were going to _take_.
So true! I mean, what do you expect people to do, take a knife and cut the toys in half??? (lol)
Load More Replies...I'm a mom of five ranging in age from 26 down to 12. The mom is right here. I see the huge difference from when my 26 year old was young to now. Back then, the OTHER PARENT would come and apologize to my son for the rudeness of their child. When my 12 year was younger it was the EXACT opposite. And we wonder why kids are so disrespectful/rude/entitled now...
if it makes you feel any better my kid knows better and I would apologize if she did do something like this... in fact I did a few times when she was much younger.
Load More Replies...That comment about "but children are different, more social" is bs learning boundaries is a CRUCIAL part of becoming a functional adult
yeah If I learned to say no and set boundries I'd be better off. I blame me for the record but if I did it i'd probably have less issues.
Load More Replies...People who want you to share your properties are incidentally also the ones who want to take your properties. But it's probably just a strange coincidence...
I absolutely love this mother's response. Which parent is going to step up and pay for the toy when it gets broken? Ya, just what I thought. Those parents would say "if he didn't want it broken, he shouldn't have brought it." Sorry folks, not everyone gets a trophy!!
yeah I'm still waiting for a certain parent to replace the basket on my kid's bike.
Load More Replies...I agree with her! It's very important to learn that sometimes it's good to say no to people, otherwise you just end up burning out.


















472
272