“I Got Home And My Car Was Gone”: Woman Deals With Robbery Charges After Brother’s GF Ends Up Calling Police
It feels weird when someone takes your stuff without asking. It’s one thing to set boundaries with strangers and coworkers, it’s an entirely different ball game when you’re dealing with, say, your partner’s family members. However, no matter how close someone is to you, they should respect you enough to know that when you tell them that they can’t borrow something, you’re being serious about it.
Redditor u/SafePurple2911 recently went viral online after sharing how she called the police on her boyfriend’s family when she realized that her car was gone. She asked members of the AITA online community whether she was in the wrong. Scroll down for the full story, as well as to see how the internet reacted to it.
Family is important, but everyone needs to learn to respect each other’s boundaries and property
Image credits: SafePurple2911 (not the actual photo)
A woman revealed how she ended up calling the authorities after her boyfriend’s sister borrowed her car without permission
Image credits: JulieAlexK (not the actual photo)
Image credits: Pixabay (not the actual photo)
She later shared some further developments at home
Image credits: SafePurple2911
The family quickly learned that actions have very real consequences
The OP explained how she had made it very clear that nobody should be borrowing her car. However, she pointed out that because her boyfriend had at one point lent her some money for the downpayment on the vehicle, his dad then thought that the car was partly his… and by extension, his sister’s as well.
That argument doesn’t hold much water. Redditor u/SafePurple2911’s name is the only one on the insurance and she is the sole owner. What’s more, she had actually repaid her boyfriend all the money he’d lent her. Taking all of this into account, it’s clear that her bf’s sister and dad went against her wishes.
Even a phone call to the sister didn’t manage to resolve anything. When she still wouldn’t get it back home, the OP had finally had enough and ended up calling the authorities and reported the car stolen. Now, her boyfriend’s family is absolutely livid and is demanding an apology. Most redditors, however, were on the car owner’s side. Some of them even suggested that she and her boyfriend move out of his dad’s place as soon as possible.
It’s essential that everyone’s on the same page regarding each other’s boundaries
Image credits: Peter Fazekas (not the actual photo)
Now, let’s make this very clear: nobody should be borrowing anyone else’s stuff without their express permission. Especially not expensive things like cars. How you react to someone who’s clearly stepped over your boundaries will depend a lot on the dynamic at home.
With some people, gentle, subtle reminders about (in)appropriate behavior will work. Others, however, might need a more direct approach: you might need to spell things out so you’re all on the same page.
If a friendly heart-to-heart conversation doesn’t work, you need to find some other ways to make sure you’re being respected. In short, you need to show people that their actions have consequences. Whether you think that calling the police was a tad too much or just the right approach, getting the authorities involved definitely sends a powerful signal. And it’s bound to make anyone reconsider pulling the same stuff a second time.
Reacting to conflicts in a different way than you normally would can help solve the issue in unexpected ways
Image credits: Josué Rodríguez (not the actual photo)
Even if you’re completely in the right, knowing how to defuse tension and looking for compromises are great skills to hone. According to Dr. Kathleen Kelley Reardon, a professor at the USC Marshall School, communication is like chess and people influence each other’s choices with every move. The expert told Verywell Mind that one strategy during family conflicts would be to avoid saying anything that you’d normally say when provoked.
“If you usually meet a challenge with a challenge, try asking a question instead. If you let someone go on and on and that leads to anger, link something you have to say to his or her topic and then change to another one,” the professor suggested.
Meanwhile, if you feel like someone’s blaming you, instead of going on the defensive, you could try telling them that there’s at least some truth in their words. By gently ‘editing’ how you usually behave during conflicts, you can create an entirely different outcome. Potentially, one where you manage make everyone aware of your boundaries and make them feel like your position is entirely reasonable.
“Above all, don’t be predictable. When we’re predictable, those who want to argue can maneuver us into doing just that,” Dr. Reardon says.
The author of the post shared some more context
The internet was very supportive of the car owner. Here’s what they had to say about the family drama
Utterly NTA. This may vary by country, but in mine it is illegal to drive without insurance, even if you have persmission to drive the car. If caught, this can lead to the car being impounded, fines, points etc. If you don't have permission to drive the car, there is an additional charge of TWOC (Taking Without Owners Consent).
Yeah, if sister had crashed the car, gf would have been SOL
Load More Replies...Even if the LW hadn't paid her BF back for helping get the car, that does not mean that the sister had a right to drive it as well.
I am shocked that there are people that are telling her that she is TA. How?!?!
I agree with you. As for Kat that is absurd and not ok
Load More Replies...Even if she didn't intent on keeping the car, it's still joy-riding and that's illegal. Anyway, the dad has no right to say who owns the car, even if she would not have paid everything back. In that case it would (still) have been a loan, which does not give you any right to use the car without the owner's consent. I wouldn't want people from my bank to drop by and take my car every time they feel like it.
Op was clear that she called the police about reporting her car stolen, because she was worried that she would have to pay for potential repairs. Which with the sister taking the car even after being told "No", and then not showing up after being told to come back - I'd be worried that she wouldn't pay for anything in case of damage too. Plus maybe the car insurance is specific to certain people. I think OP should have set a deadline for the sister along the lines of "My car is back here in one piece in the next hour or I am reporting it stolen (which wouldn't be a lie) for insurance reasons". After she got the car back she didn't press charges, so I think the accusation of "sHe wAs tRyInG tO gEt uS aRrEsTeD" is definitely ridiculous. Sister just got the confrontation with the fact that what she did was wrong (and of course if she ever does something similar again and it doesn't end well and she tries to weasel out of it - there will be precedent)
Taking something without permission is theft. I’m not sure why anyone involved would think otherwise, especially with something as high stakes as a car. I absolutely would not trust them to take responsibility for expenses, given this attitude. Nta
Regarding the edit: NTA. It's about boundaries and never ever have I ever let anyone drive my car. I'd have had her arrested and told my bf that he comes from a POS family and that apples probably don't fall far from trees.
For real. Those people are probably a bumch of moochers. My dad can drive my car. My mom is disabled and can't drive, but she was a professional driver before that. My brother has wrecked 3 cars in the past year so I don't let him drive my car.
Load More Replies...Some people are just like this with cars and to me it is kind of weird. My husband's family for instance. They just drive everyone's cars all the time. Need a truck? You swap keys and drive each other's car/truck for the day. Like no questions asked. Me? I have a panic attack if someone else drives my car. Plus not all insurances cover someone outside of the house driving the car.
I refuse to drive someone else's car, not because I don't trust myself but because I don't trust other drivers! I got hit while parked.
Load More Replies...NTA. If the sister had totaled the car, you would have had 3 choices: (1) sister pays to replace the car; (2) sister doesn't pay and you press charges; or (3) sister doesn't pay and you're left with nothing. Bottom line: you said 'no' to her borrowing the car, so she went behind your back and stole it. Why? Because she has no respect for you or your boundaries, and neither does your BF's father. (Also, loaning someone money for a car does not entitle you to partial ownership of said car, especially after the loan was repaid.)
NTA. Obviously FSIL has a mental block when it comes to the word,"NO!" and Daddy Dearest is responsible for it. I see that as a preview of what's to come. At least OP'S boyfriend has her back; entitled people can't handle a united front. But he needs to sit down with both his father and sister, and lay down the law as follows: 1) They are to NEVER AGAIN "borrow" his or GF'S property without their express permission. 2) Their personal space is to be respected and is off limits. 3) Disrespecting his GF is the same as disrespecting him. If she leaves as a result, he will be leaving with her. These rules are not open to discussion, and refusal to abide by these policies WILL result in going NC.
Utterly NTA. This may vary by country, but in mine it is illegal to drive without insurance, even if you have persmission to drive the car. If caught, this can lead to the car being impounded, fines, points etc. If you don't have permission to drive the car, there is an additional charge of TWOC (Taking Without Owners Consent).
Yeah, if sister had crashed the car, gf would have been SOL
Load More Replies...Even if the LW hadn't paid her BF back for helping get the car, that does not mean that the sister had a right to drive it as well.
I am shocked that there are people that are telling her that she is TA. How?!?!
I agree with you. As for Kat that is absurd and not ok
Load More Replies...Even if she didn't intent on keeping the car, it's still joy-riding and that's illegal. Anyway, the dad has no right to say who owns the car, even if she would not have paid everything back. In that case it would (still) have been a loan, which does not give you any right to use the car without the owner's consent. I wouldn't want people from my bank to drop by and take my car every time they feel like it.
Op was clear that she called the police about reporting her car stolen, because she was worried that she would have to pay for potential repairs. Which with the sister taking the car even after being told "No", and then not showing up after being told to come back - I'd be worried that she wouldn't pay for anything in case of damage too. Plus maybe the car insurance is specific to certain people. I think OP should have set a deadline for the sister along the lines of "My car is back here in one piece in the next hour or I am reporting it stolen (which wouldn't be a lie) for insurance reasons". After she got the car back she didn't press charges, so I think the accusation of "sHe wAs tRyInG tO gEt uS aRrEsTeD" is definitely ridiculous. Sister just got the confrontation with the fact that what she did was wrong (and of course if she ever does something similar again and it doesn't end well and she tries to weasel out of it - there will be precedent)
Taking something without permission is theft. I’m not sure why anyone involved would think otherwise, especially with something as high stakes as a car. I absolutely would not trust them to take responsibility for expenses, given this attitude. Nta
Regarding the edit: NTA. It's about boundaries and never ever have I ever let anyone drive my car. I'd have had her arrested and told my bf that he comes from a POS family and that apples probably don't fall far from trees.
For real. Those people are probably a bumch of moochers. My dad can drive my car. My mom is disabled and can't drive, but she was a professional driver before that. My brother has wrecked 3 cars in the past year so I don't let him drive my car.
Load More Replies...Some people are just like this with cars and to me it is kind of weird. My husband's family for instance. They just drive everyone's cars all the time. Need a truck? You swap keys and drive each other's car/truck for the day. Like no questions asked. Me? I have a panic attack if someone else drives my car. Plus not all insurances cover someone outside of the house driving the car.
I refuse to drive someone else's car, not because I don't trust myself but because I don't trust other drivers! I got hit while parked.
Load More Replies...NTA. If the sister had totaled the car, you would have had 3 choices: (1) sister pays to replace the car; (2) sister doesn't pay and you press charges; or (3) sister doesn't pay and you're left with nothing. Bottom line: you said 'no' to her borrowing the car, so she went behind your back and stole it. Why? Because she has no respect for you or your boundaries, and neither does your BF's father. (Also, loaning someone money for a car does not entitle you to partial ownership of said car, especially after the loan was repaid.)
NTA. Obviously FSIL has a mental block when it comes to the word,"NO!" and Daddy Dearest is responsible for it. I see that as a preview of what's to come. At least OP'S boyfriend has her back; entitled people can't handle a united front. But he needs to sit down with both his father and sister, and lay down the law as follows: 1) They are to NEVER AGAIN "borrow" his or GF'S property without their express permission. 2) Their personal space is to be respected and is off limits. 3) Disrespecting his GF is the same as disrespecting him. If she leaves as a result, he will be leaving with her. These rules are not open to discussion, and refusal to abide by these policies WILL result in going NC.



































98
41