ADVERTISEMENT

“Okay, Boomer.”

This phrase has become notorious on the internet over the past few years as a response to boomers who say condescending, politically incorrect or presumptuous things to younger generations. But perhaps today we can look at it in a new light. This article might just have you saying, “Okay Boomer. You have a good point there!”

Boomers often get a bad rap for being out of touch or behind the times, but no generation is a monolith. And recently, young Reddit users have been admitting some of the things they can get behind boomers on. From hating loud music in restaurants and shops to begging for actual buttons in their cars, rather than those frustrating touch screens, boomers aren’t the only ones who sometimes want things done the old fashioned way. Below, you'll also find interviews we were lucky enough to receive from Wendy Green, host of the Hey, Boomer! podcast, and Jean Mader and Laura Bettinger, hosts of the OK Boomer podcast.

So be sure to upvote the responses you agree with, and feel free to share anything else you think the boomers are right about in the comments (don’t worry, we won’t tell your fellow millennials/gen zers!). Then if you’re interested in checking out another Bored Panda piece that might make you realize how much you have in common with boomers, we recommend reading this article next!

#1

"Not Everything Needs To Connect To The Internet": 40 Young People Share What Things Boomers Might Be Right About Googling recipes while cooking and having to read everyone’s life story and family history to get to the ingredients drives me bats**t insane.

I’ve gone back to cookbooks.

hippiechick725 , Frank Holleman Report

Add photo comments
POST
firstnamelastname avatar
Firstname Lastname
Community Member
1 year ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

If there's not a "jump to recipe" button, I'm not even considering scrolling to the recipe.

View More Replies...
View more commentsArrow down menu

I love technology as much as the next person, and I really am not sure how I would have functioned had I been born several decades earlier than I was. Traveling to foreign countries or taking road trips without having Google Maps and the option to text or call for help in the palm of my hand? Yeah, no thanks. But even I have to admit that the boomers are right about some things. 

Menus do not need to be a QR code. Music in businesses should not be so loud that I have to shout across the table to my partner, and oh my god, no I will not get a smart watch. I don’t care how many steps you’ve walked today, Brenda. I look at my watch to see what time it is. We’re all going to be old one day, so there’s no need to judge our elders (aka the boomers) for not understanding or getting on board with certain technological advances. After all, some people might find it charming that they couldn’t meet their significant others on Tinder and that they might have no idea what a TikTok is. 

ADVERTISEMENT
#2

"Not Everything Needs To Connect To The Internet": 40 Young People Share What Things Boomers Might Be Right About I’m not downloading a f*****g app to use your menu

Ghostleeee , Nienke Broeksema Report

#3

"Not Everything Needs To Connect To The Internet": 40 Young People Share What Things Boomers Might Be Right About Not everything needs to connect to the internet or have an app attached to it. I just want my fridge to keep s**t cold, I don't understand why we have to bring WiFi into this situation.

Pollowollo , Latrach Med Jamil Report

Add photo comments
POST
anjelabarranco5 avatar
Anjelika
Community Member
1 year ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

I don't like this either or that they invent a gadget for literally anything, (that is easy to do) when we have hands

View More Replies...
View more commentsArrow down menu

To gain some insight on this topic, we reached out to Wendy Green, host of the Hey, Boomer! podcast. Wendy is a boomer herself, but she told Bored Panda, "I think we actually have a lot in common with the younger generation, particularly the Gen Z group who (at least from my perspective) seem to be more focused on activism."

She also shared that Hey, Boomer! was born 3-weeks after the pandemic shut everything down. "I knew that people in the Boomer generation were going to be hit particularly hard by the loss of jobs, and there is an ageist bias that makes it much more difficult to find a new job as you get older. So, my intention was to help people in the 55-75 year old range to recognize that we are still relevant, we still have a lot to give and encourage them to stay engaged."

ADVERTISEMENT

"Many of us were very active politically when we were younger," Wendy explained. "Many of us are re-engaging in that activism and working with young people is a win for all of us. My show also features guests that are reinventing themselves after leaving full time careers, finding adventures and facing challenges. It is a pretty cool show."

#4

just about the furthest left leaning guy you’ll find, and i’m pretty against cancel culture. in theory i understand it, & think it should still be “used” w people like kanye west. but when we’re digging YEARS back to find something someone tweeted once when they were 16… that seems a little unfair. i held opinions at 16 that i now think are silly at 25. people change, they shouldn’t be immediately crucified.

benfein Report

Add photo comments
POST
mcgoon avatar
Gustav Gallifrey
Community Member
1 year ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

If you don't have some dumb attitudes before you're 25, you're not 'normal'. After that, it's then a refusal to review those attitudes that becomes your problem.

View More Replies...
View more commentsArrow down menu
#5

"Not Everything Needs To Connect To The Internet": 40 Young People Share What Things Boomers Might Be Right About I don’t need a subscription for everything. No you don’t need my phone number or email just let me buy my shirt and get the f**k out of the store

anonymouslyinvisible , charlesdeluvio Report

#6

"Not Everything Needs To Connect To The Internet": 40 Young People Share What Things Boomers Might Be Right About Most features in cars should have buttons. Want to turn on your heated seat, button, not scroll through three screens.

Ancient_Wisdom_Yall , Brock Wegner Report

Add photo comments
POST
pass_nad avatar
Nadine Debard
Community Member
1 year ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

Very distracting indeed when you look through 4 screens to figure out how to lower the temperature. Some cars are better than others.

View More Replies...
View more commentsArrow down menu
ADVERTISEMENT

But Wendy is not a fan of using our generational titles to divide us. "I do think we put too much emphasis on the differences between generations," she told Bored Panda. "Each generation is shaped by the events that occurred in their life times. I think learning from each other is the better approach rather that isolating and making fun or different generations. I always cringe when I hear people speak negatively about any one generation. We are all individuals. It does not make sense to generalize. I encourage people to look at their own internal biases and attempt to build conversations and relationships with all age groups. It takes away the feelings of 'the other'.”

If you'd like to hear more words of wisdom from Wendy and check out her podcast Hey, Boomer!, be sure to visit her website right here!

#7

You should be able to live and sustain a family off of one income!

lake_superior_agate Report

#8

"Not Everything Needs To Connect To The Internet": 40 Young People Share What Things Boomers Might Be Right About When you’re in a public place you should respect others around you but not being disruptive with your behavior. For example, not playing music on your phone without headphones while on a bus, in a restaurant etc.

wheresmychin , Mitchell Johnson Report

Add photo comments
POST
god_2 avatar
Vix Spiderthrust
Community Member
1 year ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

That's not old-fashioned, that's just about whether you're a civilised human being or a feral shitbag.

View More Replies...
View more commentsArrow down menu
ADVERTISEMENT
#9

Electronic devices should be repairable. All of them.

Tv's and smartphones should last for at least 10 years. How is that we are all *enviromental friendly* but we switch iPhones every 2 or 3 years?

CapitanFlama Report

Add photo comments
POST
laugh avatar
Laugh or not
Community Member
1 year ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

I went back to France for the first time in two years and was very surprised to see "indices de réparabilité" on all electronic devices and appliances. For those who don't speak French, it is reparability index and means how easy it is to repair something. I don't know how much it influences buyers, but I think it is good to have manufacturers and consumers think about it.

View More Replies...
View more commentsArrow down menu
ADVERTISEMENT

We also reached out to Jean Mader and Laura Bettinger to learn more about this topic. Jean and Laura are two sisters, best friends and boomers who host a podcast called OK Boomer. Awhile back, (hard for Boomers to keep track of time as the years go by so fast, they noted!) Laura started listening to podcasts and announced to Jean, "This seems like fun, we already chat for hours so why not start a podcast?"

"We are blessed with seven Millennial children and their Millennial partners between us," Jean and Laura told Bored Panda. "We consider ourselves experts regarding 'Boomers and Millennials and everyone in between', so boom, the OK Boomer Podcast was born. We launched our podcast in early 2020, thanks to Pat Rullo at SpeakUpTalkRadio."

#10

"Not Everything Needs To Connect To The Internet": 40 Young People Share What Things Boomers Might Be Right About You should really put your phone down when you're out to eat with people. Maybe it's because I grew up with that rule but I know when I'm getting lunch with a friend or something I find it incredibly irritating when they're on their phone

Edit: holy s**t my first award??

FirstPianist3312 , Guilherme Stecanella Report

Add photo comments
POST
ssnx01 avatar
Chich
Community Member
1 year ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

Everyone puts their phone face down. The first one to picks theirs up gets the bill for everyone else.

View More Replies...
View more commentsArrow down menu
#11

I want a human customer service operator not an automated operator or chat bot.

guythatbedont Report

Add photo comments
POST
pavelkrusstev avatar
Pa4040
Community Member
1 year ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

As a person with lots of experience in Customer Service/ Helpdesk: this is the future. ALL corporations are drooling for a proper AI that correctly recognises voices. As soon as a good one is on the market, thousands of people will loose their jobs, on top of other administrative tasks being moved to southeast asia to cut the costs even further

View More Replies...
View more commentsArrow down menu
#12

"Not Everything Needs To Connect To The Internet": 40 Young People Share What Things Boomers Might Be Right About Music in bars is too loud.
(Edit to add that I've been a touring musician and live sound technician. I love music but it actually sounds better at lower volumes, and I want to be able to hear it in to my old age)

EternityLeave , QUI NGUYEN Report

Add photo comments
POST
lilliemean avatar
LillieMean
Community Member
1 year ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

Loud music turns into a mush. You can no longer distinguish the nuances from it and your ears hurt. Who wants to purposely be uncomfortable and suffer from tinnitus for the rest of their lives? The music is too loud even in shops, not to mention the cinema. I read a while ago that a woman suffering from misophonia found a solution in earplugs intended for this, which dampen the sound, but not as much as traditional earplugs. Sounds heavenly.

View More Replies...
View more commentsArrow down menu
ADVERTISEMENT

"The name of our podcast is based on the retort, 'OK, Boomer' which is often used to mock Baby Boomers and those who are perceived as old-fashioned and being out-of-touch," Jean and Laura shared. "We podcast twice a month, and we try to find the humor and joy of living this life. Listen in as we encourage all Boomers, Millennials and everyone in between to be happily okay together."

We were curious if there's anything boomers typically get made fun of for that Jean and Laura actually agree with. "Hey, we love to make fun of ourselves," they shared. "And we understand that Millennials are spot-on about many things we Boomers do our say. But no matter what our Millennials tell us, we are still going to carry cash, because electronic wallets befuddle us."

"Yes, we know we can text businesses and restaurants, but we would rather call a person," Jean and Laura noted. "Uber and Lyft are indeed beyond us. Ordering fast food online and picking it up, or having it delivered is very confusing and stressful for us. We’ve had computers and smartphones for 25 years now, and we still need our kids to help us reboot them. Or explain what those funny symbols are that we can’t really see without our glasses. And don’t put us in a Granny Flat!"

#13

"Not Everything Needs To Connect To The Internet": 40 Young People Share What Things Boomers Might Be Right About Not everyone deserves a trophy. You SHOULD experience failure and disappointment in life. It's a teaching experience, stop getting so p**sy when you don't automatically get your way.

NeverEnoughSleep08 , Ba Tik Report

Add photo comments
POST
ssnx01 avatar
Chich
Community Member
1 year ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

Some of the best lessons I learned in life was screwing something up 14 ways from tuesday and getting called out on it.

View more commentsArrow down menu
#14

"Not Everything Needs To Connect To The Internet": 40 Young People Share What Things Boomers Might Be Right About Certain things shouldn't require you to download an app and/or create a whole account, including:

- Ordering food in a restaurant
- Paying for parking
- Buying something online
- Sending a parcel

PropellerHead15 , Campaign Creators Report

Add photo comments
POST
christineschneider avatar
Beeps
Community Member
1 year ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

Especially when paying for parking and there’s a different app for each car park.

View More Replies...
View more commentsArrow down menu
#15

"Not Everything Needs To Connect To The Internet": 40 Young People Share What Things Boomers Might Be Right About I don’t really know if this is a boomer opinion per say but you don’t need to document everything thing you do and post it to your social media. Sometimes it’s better to just live in the moment and enjoy what’s happening around you

rylhi552 , camilo jimenez Report

We also asked Jean and Laura if they disagree with anything Boomers often say or believe. "At this point in our lives, we are ready to love everyone," they told Bored Panda. "But we do think Boomers should be more like Millennials when it comes to taking care of your physical and mental health. Millennials are not 'snowflakes', they are just not as 'seasoned' as us oldies."

#16

"Not Everything Needs To Connect To The Internet": 40 Young People Share What Things Boomers Might Be Right About If you’re walking on a crowded sidewalk, get off your f*****g phone it’s not the job of other pedestrians to avoid you while you make your vlog. Awareness of your surroundings is important.

Kanedi4s , Guillaume Bolduc Report

#18

"Not Everything Needs To Connect To The Internet": 40 Young People Share What Things Boomers Might Be Right About Physical keyboards are better than virtual keyboards.

rntopspin100 , Ilya Pavlov Report

Jean and Laura just want to see all generations living in harmony. "We put too much emphasis on generational differences, we can all learn and grow from each other. We truly adore our Millennial children and friends and love learning from them, keeps life interesting, maybe keeps us young! And 'Wordle' unites us all!"

"We live in beautiful Ohio," they also shared. "In fact, Laura played the piano and recorded the opening music you hear at the start of each podcast episode. The song is 'Beautiful Ohio'- the official song of our state. We want everyone to have a beautiful life. Oh and we tried the Tik Tok Balsamic Vinegar & Sparkling Water Coke Hack challenge on our podcast!"

If you'd like to hear more from these fun ladies, be sure to check out the OK, Boomer podcast right here!

#19

It’s ok if you’re non-binary, but it’s also ok if that notion takes a little bit of getting used to for the rest of us.

Also, the amount of attention this issue gets is *far* out of proportion to the scope of the actual issue.

robbycakes Report

Add photo comments
POST
censorshipsucks11 avatar
censorshipsucks
Community Member
1 year ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

yep, it's something like 2% in firstworld countries and almost non-existent in others.

View More Replies...
View more commentsArrow down menu
#20

Basic home appliances (fridge, washer/dryer, etc) do NOT need a touch screen

No_Seaweed6739 Report

#21

"Not Everything Needs To Connect To The Internet": 40 Young People Share What Things Boomers Might Be Right About Screw fast fashion, my clothes should be made to last.

I’m not rich so it’s unavoidable, but I’m willing to spend extra on clothes that aren’t made of plastic and I do my best to repair my damaged clothing instead of throwing it out.

mercurialpolyglot , Fernand De Canne Report

Add photo comments
POST
pass_nad avatar
Nadine Debard
Community Member
1 year ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

Some cheap pieces can last very long time (but may not be sustainable), some expensive clothes are of poor quality (and not sustainable as well), you have to keep eyes open.

View More Replies...
View more commentsArrow down menu

Are you suddenly feeling like your vision and hearing aren’t working as well as they used to? Do you feel immediate rage when you can’t figure out how to work a new piece of technology? Do you not understand TikTok and why the young people are obsessed with it? You might have more in common with boomers than you think! Keep upvoting the responses that you resonate with, and let us know in the comments if you think the boomers have made some good points about anything else. Then if you want to check out Bored Panda’s last article on this same topic after you’re finished with this list, you can find another piece featuring things that are better done the “old-fashioned way” right here.  

#22

"Not Everything Needs To Connect To The Internet": 40 Young People Share What Things Boomers Might Be Right About GIVE ME BACK MY HEADPHONE JACK

PizzaTammer , freestocks Report

See Also on Bored Panda
#23

"Not Everything Needs To Connect To The Internet": 40 Young People Share What Things Boomers Might Be Right About Things aren’t made like they used to be. Everything you buy now is so cheaply manufactured. Even high end furniture uses cheap particle board and crappy joinery. We bought a pretty high end couch a few years back and it’s barely holding together.

Edit: thanks everyone for commenting and thank you for the award! I’ve been on Reddit since 2008 and have never had a comment get this much action

talag1ga , Ryan Riggins Report

#24

"Not Everything Needs To Connect To The Internet": 40 Young People Share What Things Boomers Might Be Right About Standard headlights on new automobiles are too bright. Literally being blinded by every other car DURING THE DAYTIME wondering if their brights are on

Fiendsquatch , Atahan Güç Report

Add photo comments
POST
star44886 avatar
Will Cable
Community Member
1 year ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

LED headlights when they fail. Old headlights much simpler, bulb fails, get bulb and replace but thanks to LED tech so many headlights need to be fully replaced and dumping the whole unit is just so wasteful when you have all the companies talking about how environmental their cars are. Things should be more modular.

View More Replies...
View more commentsArrow down menu
#25

Turn the music down, no, you don’t have “excellent taste in music” and nobody wants to hear it. Stop being jerks.

ChickenBootty Report

#26

"Not Everything Needs To Connect To The Internet": 40 Young People Share What Things Boomers Might Be Right About TV is getting too dark. Not emotionally - it is visually too dark and I can’t see it

mostly_browsing , Mathieu Improvisato Report

Add photo comments
POST
luke-branwen avatar
Luke Branwen
Community Member
1 year ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

Okay, but "emotionally" is true, too. Like 80% of the modern media are those bleak grimdark craps without a shred of positivity and sincerity which think that "mature" means "extreme violence, gore and erotica".

View More Replies...
View more commentsArrow down menu
#27

"Not Everything Needs To Connect To The Internet": 40 Young People Share What Things Boomers Might Be Right About I prefer reading on paper, not on screen

Fit-Rest-973 , Kateryna Hliznitsova Report

Add photo comments
POST
mcgoon avatar
Gustav Gallifrey
Community Member
1 year ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

I'm a boomer, and i love physical books. But i also love my Kindle. I can carry dozens and dozens of books with me. If, for some reason, i don't feel like reading THAT one right now, i can take a look at THIS one.

View More Replies...
View more commentsArrow down menu
#28

You are a clueless idiot if you pay 150$ for a concert ticket and spend the whole time watching it on your cell phone.

Unsimulated Report

Add photo comments
POST
dmattock avatar
Daniel Mattock
Community Member
1 year ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

And if you’re holding up your phone/tablet and blocking my view doing so, I will kick you lightly in the back of the knee

View more commentsArrow down menu
#29

"Not Everything Needs To Connect To The Internet": 40 Young People Share What Things Boomers Might Be Right About The sheer amount of younger people I’ve seen with horrible people/social/conversational skills blows my mind, and I firmly believe it is greatly in part due to phones and social media.

Boomers always say s**t like “go play outside, interact with the world, spend less time on your phone” etc etc and I wholehearted agree.

iceman_x2 , Becca Tapert Report

#30

A lot of products *were* made better in the past.

Pyrex is a prime example but there's thousands more.

Planned obsolescence as a consequence of prioritizing quarterly profits over customer satisfaction is another nail in the coffin of this current version of the economy we live in.

hankbaumbach Report

Add photo comments
POST
elizabethkrigsvold avatar
Elizabeth Krigsvold
Community Member
1 year ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

My grandfather taught my dad who taught me, how to build furniture. Handcrafted, dove tail joints, real wood not particle board....I'm teaching my son how to now as well. Owning all the furniture my dad made for me and my son, now that dad passed away, is priceless to me. Plus it's things that'll last FOREVER

View More Replies...
View more commentsArrow down menu
#31

If you have shared walls or live in an apartment building, you need to respect quiet hours of 10pm - 8am.

I get so grumpy if my building neighbors are loud past 10pm.

phat-turnip Report

Add photo comments
POST
matthew_fox avatar
Matthew Fox
Community Member
1 year ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

Even if you DON'T have shared walls. No one in a house wants to hear the rowdy party down the street.

View More Replies...
View more commentsArrow down menu
#32

Just because you CAN say something, doesn’t mean you SHOULD. Think twice, speak once. I’m only 28, raised by my father who was 39 years older than me. Just seems like people pop off at the mouth way faster than in previous generations.

All these comments make me feel much younger now, glad I wasn’t the only one who got the old school raising.

lolncpls Report

Add photo comments
POST
eyelessonex avatar
Corvus
Community Member
1 year ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

Knowing when to speak up is great, knowing when to remain silent is even greater.

View More Replies...
View more commentsArrow down menu
See Also on Bored Panda
#34

I really don't want to hear about anybody's sex life in graphic detail

SashaBraus Report

Add photo comments
POST
star44886 avatar
Will Cable
Community Member
1 year ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

They slip it in and beat it about, ramming their sex life down our throats. They should think long and hard before just whipping it in to the conversation. We should stop beating about the bush and tell them "NO' they are a pain in the a*s with it.

View More Replies...
View more commentsArrow down menu
#35

Family dinners with everyone sitting down, eating and talking, no tv and no phones are essential

crazymissdaisy87 Report

#36

Social media is the reason for a lot of problems

MastermindJay Report

Add photo comments
POST
lunacrow avatar
Luna Crow
Community Member
1 year ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

Yes, and solutions also. Depends on how you use it, and who you're connecting with, much like IRL

View More Replies...
View more commentsArrow down menu
#37

"Not Everything Needs To Connect To The Internet": 40 Young People Share What Things Boomers Might Be Right About Having to create a username and password to join just about anything online is a royal pain in the a*s

Good gravy this got way more attention that I was expecting. I will check out Password Manager seeing as it is highly recommended.

For the record-I often see boomers much more fed up with computer requirements that require jumping through hoops more than younger generations. I don't think younger generations love these irritating requirements but if anyone feels this is not a boomer opinion I really don't have the energy or care enough to argue

WinterBanana89 , Mourizal Zativa Report

#38

"Not Everything Needs To Connect To The Internet": 40 Young People Share What Things Boomers Might Be Right About tipping has gotten out of control- coming from someone who relies on tips for income. it hurts people who actually should be getting them because now people are extremely agitated about any and all tipping. i was just at a music festival and the guy who exchanges your cash for drink tickets (not even the person who pours the beverage) had an ipad with tip options starting at 18%

shearsntears , Dan Smedley Report

Add photo comments
POST
star44886 avatar
Will Cable
Community Member
1 year ago DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

Where will this tipping situation end... getting a circumcision and leaving the doctor a tip...OK, bad example

View More Replies...
View more commentsArrow down menu
#39

"Not Everything Needs To Connect To The Internet": 40 Young People Share What Things Boomers Might Be Right About Sometimes it's faster (and easier) to just plug something in, instead of dealing with bluetooth connectivity. There's something nice about knowing how to get it connected and being able to physically connect/disconnect.

claytondb , Wengang Zhai Report

#40

Language has evolved really quickly and what's socially acceptable changes every year. I'm with the boomers in that if we use language that is outdated, please assume ignorance not malice! I accidentally used a slur a few years ago that is common in my community (referring to eye shape) and had no idea it was a slur until someone told me...thankfully kindly and privately. I do wish the assumption was "you probably didn't know this but..." and not "YOU ARE A BIGOT!"

cmc Report

Add photo comments
POST
eyelessonex avatar
Corvus
Community Member
1 year ago (edited) DotsCreated by potrace 1.15, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2017

Also note cultural peculiarities - some words or hand gestures can be offensive in some countries, but not in others.

View More Replies...
View more commentsArrow down menu

Note: this post originally had 77 images. It’s been shortened to the top 40 images based on user votes.