Does anyone still remember “the cake is a lie” meme from a decade ago? It was a catchphrase popularized in the game Portal, simply meaning that one’s promised reward is merely a fictitious motivator.

Well, there’s now a trend in the vein of the cake being a lie, but not in the sense that it doesn’t exist but rather “this doesn’t look anything like a cake, it’s actually a [insert random item here] but let me just cut it open and, oh my god, it’s a cake,” leading many to think that anything can be a cake at this point.

Meet Natalie Sideserf, a baker from Austin, Texas, who makes hyper-realistic and cartoony cakes that don’t look like cakes until she slices them open on her YouTube channel. Her videos not only show the process of making each cake, but are oddly satisfying to watch.

Bored Panda made a list of some of the best cakes that Natalie has made over the years that you can check out below, along with our exclusive interview with her. And while you’re there, why not upvote and comment on the ones you liked the most!

#1

Realistic-Quirky-Cakes-Cutting-Sideserf

Natalie Sideserf Report

ƒιѕн
Community Member
2 months ago

Damn those look so real...

View more comments
#2

Realistic-Quirky-Cakes-Cutting-Sideserf

Natalie Sideserf Report

Foxxy (The Original)
Community Member
2 months ago (edited)

I didn’t read the title properly and thought it said she could make cake out of anything. Like ingredients and thought she was gonna put onion in her cake. Geez, I need to get to sleep. Too bad hubby is snoring like a freight train.

View More Replies...
View more comments
#3

Realistic-Quirky-Cakes-Cutting-Sideserf

Natalie Sideserf Report

Doggi
Community Member
2 months ago

At first I thought she used a real apples shell.

View More Replies...
View more comments

Natalie Sideserf of the Sideserf Cake Studio is a fine arts major who one day tried sculpting a cake for her friend—you know, one of the fancy ones you see on TV. One thing led to another and now she does this for a living.

“In 2008, a friend of mine suggested that I try making a sculpted cake like the ones she had seen on TV. So I tried making a cow skull cake and found the materials to be really interesting and wanted to learn more,” said Natalie.

“In 2011, my husband Dave and I moved to Austin, TX where I started working at a bakery. In 2012, I entered a cake in the shape of Willie Nelson into a cake competition. At the time, I tried looking up reference photos of bust cakes, but couldn't find any, so I was going for something that looked hyper realistic because it had never been done before. My brother posted photos of the cake to Reddit where it reached #1 on the front page. So at that point, I knew I was onto something.”

#4

Realistic-Quirky-Cakes-Cutting-Sideserf

Natalie Sideserf Report

Your Mother
Community Member
2 months ago

Wow! You are very talented! Thanks so much for doing the office.

View more comments
#5

Realistic-Quirky-Cakes-Cutting-Sideserf

Natalie Sideserf Report

Loki’s Lil Butter Knife
Community Member
2 months ago

Wow, those are some incredible sculpting skills there. I'm not a fan of fondant cakes, but this is really well done.

View more comments
#6

Realistic-Quirky-Cakes-Cutting-Sideserf

Natalie Sideserf Report

Yoseph Workeneh
Community Member
2 months ago

WHOA THATS AMAZING

View More Replies...
View more comments

Natalie’s channel currently clocks in at 38.7 thousand subscribers and the channel overall has received a million views since its launch in the end of 2017. During that time, Natalie has released many videos detailing how she made cakes in the shape of virtually anything: pigs, brains, aliens, fruit and vegetables, and even full-blown busts of the likes of Michael Scott, Wolverine, Freddy Kreuger, and many others.

“My cakes are a mix of customer orders and personal challenges. Sometimes I want to try out a new material or technique, so I do my best to come up with designs that let me experiment,” said Natalie. “When I put new videos up on YouTube, I am sometimes trying new things that I may have never done before so it's very rewarding when the effort pays off. I feel like trying new things and stepping outside of my comfort zone is the best way for me to get better.”

#7

Realistic-Quirky-Cakes-Cutting-Sideserf

Natalie Sideserf Report

Doggi
Community Member
2 months ago

No no no! Don’t cut him!!

View More Replies...
View more comments
#8

Realistic-Quirky-Cakes-Cutting-Sideserf

Natalie Sideserf Report

Tomasz Jackowski
Community Member
2 months ago

the cognitive dissonance this would bring if you just bit into it expecting pickle taste, I can't even imagine

View More Replies...
View more comments
#9

Realistic-Quirky-Cakes-Cutting-Sideserf

Natalie Sideserf Report

Regina Phalange
Community Member
2 months ago

cooooooooool, i thought the cake was inside the bag!!

View more comments

Natalie’s cakes may look amazing, but they’re no cake walk as they do come with their own challenges, as she explained: “Some complex designs require a structure to hold the cake up, especially when it comes to "gravity-defying" cakes. So, getting a stable structure is super important and sometimes the biggest challenge.”

She continued: “As far as sculpting, my bust cakes are definitely the most difficult. Getting the proportions right and color matching different tones takes a lot of time, usually around 40 hours from start to finish. That's not to say the cake sits out for 40 hours while I sculpt; I always sculpt the faces ahead of time and add the cake at the very end to make sure everything is fresh and delicious.”

#10

Realistic-Quirky-Cakes-Cutting-Sideserf

Natalie Sideserf Report

Mama Panda
Community Member
2 months ago

I am torn on this one. I love, love, love cake but I am allergic to bell peppers lol

View More Replies...
View more comments
#11

Realistic-Quirky-Cakes-Cutting-Sideserf

Natalie Sideserf Report

Regina Phalange
Community Member
2 months ago

its pikachu, its orgami AND its a cake *mind BLOWN*

View more comments
#12

Realistic-Quirky-Cakes-Cutting-Sideserf

Natalie Sideserf Report

ƒιѕн
Community Member
2 months ago

Imagine grabbing a banana off the counter and trying to peel it to find out its just cake.

View More Replies...
View more comments

Now, before you ask what she does with the cakes once they’re cut open because eating every single one of them would probably be overkill for anyone, Bored Panda has you covered. Natalie often shares the cakes with her friends and neighbors:

“Smaller cakes like the fruits and vegetables, we usually keep and eat ourselves but sometimes we will give them to friends or neighbors. The other cakes that you don't see get cut on YouTube or social media are the customer orders, though we try to get pictures of the cut cakes from them as often as we can.”

#13

Realistic-Quirky-Cakes-Cutting-Sideserf

Natalie Sideserf Report

Bunzilla
Community Member
2 months ago

half thought it was going to deflate when she cut it

View more comments
#14

Realistic-Quirky-Cakes-Cutting-Sideserf

Natalie Sideserf Report

La Petite Morte
Community Member
2 months ago

The best way to eat an eggplant.

View more comments
#15

Realistic-Quirky-Cakes-Cutting-Sideserf

Natalie Sideserf Report

Osgood_7
Community Member
2 months ago

In Germany there's actually a dessert called Spaghettieis (Spaghetti ice cream), which is vanilla ice cream pushed through a spaghetti press, topped with strawberry jam and coconut shavings

View More Replies...
View more comments

Lastly, we asked Natalie if she has a favorite among the many cakes that she has already done. She had this to say:

“I think my #1 favorite cake was a bust cake of Jonathan Banks, the actor who plays Mike Ehrmantraut on Breaking Bad and Better Call Saul. I made him sort of beat-up looking, which gave it some extra character, and it was featured on an AMC commercial spot for a season premiere of The Walking Dead. The coolest part, though, was Jonathan Banks brought it up on Conan and personally thanked me for making it while on the show. That's my favorite cake.”

You can check out more sweet goodness on Natalie's YouTube channel as well as her Instagram, Facebook, and Twitter. What are your thoughts on this? Have any ideas on what shape or theme of cake you’d love to see made? Let us know in the comment section below!

#16

Realistic-Quirky-Cakes-Cutting-Sideserf

Natalie Sideserf Report

Tomasz Jackowski
Community Member
2 months ago

in this case I would probably be disappointed that it turned out to be cake :D

View More Replies...
View more comments
#17

Realistic-Quirky-Cakes-Cutting-Sideserf

Natalie Sideserf Report

Daisy
Community Member
2 months ago

AHHHH! My favorite game!!!! :D

View more comments
#18

Realistic-Quirky-Cakes-Cutting-Sideserf

Natalie Sideserf Report

Regina Phalange
Community Member
2 months ago

i was gonna say its just a regular cake but then i realize it was lego XD

View More Replies...
View more comments
#19

Realistic-Quirky-Cakes-Cutting-Sideserf

Natalie Sideserf Report

Podunkus
Community Member
2 months ago

Deadpool doesn’t mind. It will grow back.

View More Replies...
View more comments
#20

Realistic-Quirky-Cakes-Cutting-Sideserf

Natalie Sideserf Report

Brooke Purvis
Community Member
2 months ago

Nooo

View More Replies...
View more comments
#21

Realistic-Quirky-Cakes-Cutting-Sideserf

Natalie Sideserf Report

Regina Phalange
Community Member
2 months ago

i like the added taco bell wraper

View More Replies...
View more comments
#22

Realistic-Quirky-Cakes-Cutting-Sideserf

Natalie Sideserf Report

TheDragonInTown
Community Member
2 months ago

Did not need to see that....

View More Replies...
View more comments
See Also on Bored Panda
#23

Realistic-Quirky-Cakes-Cutting-Sideserf

Natalie Sideserf Report

Brenna Cai
Community Member
2 months ago

HOW COULD YOU

View more comments
#24

Realistic-Quirky-Cakes-Cutting-Sideserf

Natalie Sideserf Report

Elisa Panetta
Community Member
2 months ago

Warhol meets Dali

View More Replies...
View more comments
#25

Realistic-Quirky-Cakes-Cutting-Sideserf

Natalie Sideserf Report

Yoseph Workeneh
Community Member
2 months ago

Red Velvet

View more comments
#26

Realistic-Quirky-Cakes-Cutting-Sideserf

Natalie Sideserf Report

TUBLOVER3
Community Member
2 months ago

Terrific crust !! Fantastic textures !!

View more comments
#27

Realistic-Quirky-Cakes-Cutting-Sideserf

Natalie Sideserf Report

Adie Washington
Community Member
2 months ago

The perfect cake for people who are terrified of clowns!

View More Replies...
View more comments
#28

Realistic-Quirky-Cakes-Cutting-Sideserf

Natalie Sideserf Report

LilicatUK
Community Member
2 months ago

I need a Gary cake!!!!!

View more comments
#29

Realistic-Quirky-Cakes-Cutting-Sideserf

Natalie Sideserf Report

Ing
Community Member
2 months ago

🎵You can only eat him when you're veeeery young~!🎶

View more comments
#30

Realistic-Quirky-Cakes-Cutting-Sideserf

Natalie Sideserf Report

QueenoftheSquids
Community Member
2 months ago

NO THE DOG

View more comments
#31

Realistic-Quirky-Cakes-Cutting-Sideserf

Natalie Sideserf Report

Ing
Community Member
2 months ago

It's Raymond! Some players hate him, most players love him. And now he is literally a CAKE! ♡

View More Replies...
View more comments
#32

Realistic-Quirky-Cakes-Cutting-Sideserf

Natalie Sideserf Report

Daisy
Community Member
2 months ago (edited)

*happy ARMY noises* The cake was made with a lot of Suga. I J-Hope a lot of people will get these puns :)

View More Replies...
View more comments
See Also on Bored Panda
#33

Realistic-Quirky-Cakes-Cutting-Sideserf

Natalie Sideserf Report

Daniela Botella
Community Member
2 months ago

If we Naruto run, they won’t notice that the cake is gone

View More Replies...
View more comments
#34

Realistic-Quirky-Cakes-Cutting-Sideserf

Natalie Sideserf Report

Regina Phalange
Community Member
2 months ago

ive seen a tp one somewhere else but this is more realistic, running out ;P

View more comments
#35

Realistic-Quirky-Cakes-Cutting-Sideserf

Natalie Sideserf Report

ArhomR
Community Member
2 months ago (edited)

Looks a bit off with the piece missing. Sad or something.

View more comments
#36

Realistic-Quirky-Cakes-Cutting-Sideserf

Natalie Sideserf Report

Ms.GB
Community Member
2 months ago

I turned myself into a cake Morty

View More Replies...
View more comments
#37

Realistic-Quirky-Cakes-Cutting-Sideserf

Natalie Sideserf Report

Leonel Roque
Community Member
2 months ago

This is the only one that looks kind of fake.

Fact Perils
Community Member
2 months ago

so did the apple/peach one (not sure what fruit, i thought it was a peach but someone commented apple)

Load More Replies...
¯_(ツ)_/¯
Community Member
2 months ago

honestly......not my fav but ok

View More Replies...
View more comments
#38

Realistic-Quirky-Cakes-Cutting-Sideserf

Natalie Sideserf Report

Brenna Cai
Community Member
2 months ago

i thought it was the corona at first

View More Replies...
View more comments