Hubby Proposes Co-Parenting Instead Of Embracing A Child-Free Marriage, Leaves Wife Feeling Betrayed

Boy meets girl, they fall in love, they get married, and bam, kids. However, have you considered that some couples have decided that kids just might not be a part of the picture? But what happens when one party is on board with it, and one isn’t?

That’s exactly what today’s Original Poster (OP) is facing. After nearly a decade with her husband, she’s confronting an issue they both thought was settled: she doesn’t want kids, and he does. But instead of reaching a peaceful resolution, their conversations turned into emotional tug-of-war.

More info: Reddit

In any relationship, one of the most essential foundations is being on the same page about certain things

A woman sitting thoughtfully on a gray couch, contemplating a difficult decision about kids, surrounded by green plants.

Image credits: freepik / Freepik (not the actual photo)

The author and her husband have been together for ten years but officially married for three years

Text about a couple facing a hard decision about having kids after 10 years together.

Text expressing regret over a childfree relationship decision, pondering its viability.

Text message referencing a couple's decision about kids with a playful note to partner.

Text message seeking advice on a difficult couple decision about having kids.

Text describing a couple, age 29F and 32M, together 9.5 years, married for 3, facing decision about kids.

Image credits: whux12

Couple sitting back-to-back on a couch, facing a difficult decision about kids in a bright living room.

Image credits: gpointstudio / Freepik (not the actual photo)

She admitted that she didn’t have a deep conversation about kids earlier in their relationship and in reality, she doesn’t want kids

Text about a couple who didn’t deeply discuss kids, leading to a significant decision in their lives.

Text about a couple discussing kids and considering adoption.

Text discussing a couple facing a big decision about having kids, expressing doubts and reconsidering adoption.

Text about a couple's deep talk and hard decision regarding kids, weighing on one partner.

Text discussing a couple's disagreement on having kids and facing a difficult decision.

Image credits: whux12

Man sitting on a couch, holding his head in his hands, appearing stressed about decision regarding kids.

Image credits: freepik / Freepik (not the actual photo)

After two years of marriage, her husband asked her if she wanted kids, and when she said no, he didn’t speak to her for a week

Text discussing a couple's difficult decision about kids, mentioning co-parenting and nightly talks to find a solution.

Text expressing concerns about parenting and co-parenting challenges in a relationship where one partner doesn't want kids.

Text about a couple in their 30s facing a major decision regarding having kids.

Text conversation highlighting a couple facing a difficult decision about having kids.

Text expressing frustration over a relationship, highlighting lack of deep talks about kids.

Text discussing feelings and decisions by a couple regarding children and making life choices.

Text discussing a couple's hard decision on kids, mentioning challenges and open-ended outcomes.

Text expressing the difficulty of deciding about kids without a prior deep talk, seeking advice and validation.

Image credits: whux12

After some time, the husband began to suggest ways they could be parents, but after she refused, he said he would be okay without having kids

The couple, married for three years but together for almost ten, never had a deep discussion about children early on. While the OP always leaned toward being child-free, moments of self-doubt led to mixed signals. Her husband, a self-proclaimed fence-sitter, assured her he would stay with her regardless. But years later, that promise started to show cracks.

Two years prior, the topic surfaced again; she reaffirmed her stance on not wanting to have kids, but his response was silence for a week. While they eventually talked it out, she momentarily considered adoption as a compromise, only to later realize that was a panic-driven reaction. For her, it wasn’t about how children entered their lives; she simply didn’t want them.

The OP assumed they had settled things, but her husband admitted he had been quietly hoping she would come around. Now, he was trying to find creative workarounds, suggesting co-parenting with a third person and structuring their lives in a way that makes parenthood more manageable. But for her, no arrangement makes sense because her feelings on the subject haven’t wavered.

More painfully, she’s struggling with the realization that their seemingly perfect relationship might not be enough for him if children aren’t in the picture. While he now says he’s “okay” with not having kids, he can’t promise he won’t resent her down the road.

To better understand the significance of discussing children in relationships, Bored Panda reached out to writer and marriage counselor Ronke Adesina, who emphasized the importance of having the conversation about children early on in a relationship, especially when considering marriage.

“Understanding each other’s views on parenting, family planning, and future goals helps prevent misunderstandings and ensures compatibility,” she explained. While it might not be necessary in the initial dating stages, she noted that addressing this topic before making long-term commitments allows couples to align their expectations and avoid potential conflicts.

A couple contemplating a difficult decision, sitting on a bed, illustrating the importance of deep talks about kids.

Image credits: drobotdean / Freepik (not the actual photo)

We also inquired whether a couple can stay together happily when one wants kids and the other doesn’t. Adesina acknowledged that this can be a major challenge and often depends on personal experiences. “Sometimes, experiencing parenthood can change a person’s perspective, while in other cases, disagreements may create a lot of tension,” she stated.

She also highlighted that factors like pregnancy risks can play a crucial role. “A woman who has endured difficult pregnancies may refuse to have more children, even if her partner wants them.” Ultimately, she noted that this issue can either strengthen or break a relationship, depending on how both individuals navigate their differences.

To further explore relationship dynamics, we asked about the impact of unspoken resentment in a marriage, to which she warned that unresolved resentment is incredibly toxic and can lead to emotional distance, bitterness, and even violence. “If left unchecked, it will slowly erode the relationship, making reconciliation difficult,” she cautioned.

Signs of growing resentment include withdrawal, frequent irritation, passive-aggressive behavior, and a lack of emotional intimacy. According to Adesina, the key to addressing resentment is open communication.

“Partners should express their feelings honestly, and the other should listen without dismissing concerns,” she advised, adding that professional help can be beneficial in preventing long-term damage. If reconciliation isn’t possible, she suggested that separation may sometimes be the healthiest option.

Netizens believe the husband is staying in the marriage out of fear of not finding someone “better” rather than out of true commitment. They also pointed out that delaying the inevitable will only lead to more wasted years.

If you were in the OP’s position, would you stay and hope things work out or walk away now? We would love to hear your thoughts!

However, he also mentioned that he couldn’t promise that he wouldn’t resent her down the line, and netizens suggest it might be a waste of time

Text discussing a couple's hard decision on kids and relationship dynamics.

Screenshot of a Reddit comment discussing a couple's deep talk about wanting kids.

Text discussing a couple facing a hard decision about having children, impacting their relationship choices.

Text comment discussing relationship issues and decisions about having kids.

Reddit comment by Queasy_Lettuce4312: "It's the 'quality women' for me.

Poll Question

Total votes ·

Thanks! Check out the results:

Total votes ·

Newsletter

Subscribe to Access
Exclusive Polls

Subscribe

By entering your email and clicking Subscribe, you're agreeing to let us send you customized marketing messages about us and our advertising partners. You are also agreeing to our Privacy Policy.

Thank you! You've successfully subscribed to newsletters!

Anyone can write on Bored Panda. Start writing!

Follow Bored Panda on Google News!

Follow us on Flipboard.com/@boredpanda!