One of the biggest benefits of responsibly bred dogs is that they are more predictable. But if you’re in the market for such a puppy, so still need to carefully figure out which breed is the best fit for you.
It’s important to refrain from focusing solely on looks. There are many more factors that determine your compatibility. And arguably the biggest one is your experience as an owner.
Luckily, there are many choices and people who can guide you through them. Like dog trainer and content creator Karlee Stark who just released a TikTok mini-series dedicated to helping you make this decision.
More info: KarleeStark.com | Instagram | TikTok
Dog trainer of 10 years Karlee Stark believes that inexperienced first-time owners should be cautious of some breeds due to the engagement they require
Image credits: ksdogtraining
So she made a comprehensive TikTok video listing them and explaining her thoughts
Image credits: Jena Fuller
Image credits: VirtualWolf
Image credits: D. Williams
Image credits: Amanda Wild
Image credits: Aline Scaravelli
We got in touch with Karlee Stark, and she was kind enough to have a little chat with us and provide us with more context on her content. “I was introduced to dog training at eight when my parents decided to start a commercial breeding and training business,” Stark told Bored Panda.
“We worked hard to ensure that every dog sold or came in for training had the best care and attention possible. Because I was involved with most of the dogs that came in for training, I gained lots of experience working with many breeds and learning their differences.”
“Over the years, I have been able to distinguish which breeds I am fond of and which I am not. As well as breeds I see fit for different types of owners. I have also seen how environment, nutrition, and ethical breeding affect how a dog thrives in its life.”
Stark’s clip soon went viral
@ksdogtraining Pt 1 This is my personal opinion as a trainer if 10 years #greenscreen #dogmom #dogmomthings #dogsoftiktok #dogtrainersoftiktok #spoilyourdog #trainingtips ♬ original sound – ksdogtraining
Now, Karlee’s typical day starts with personal care.
“My morning routine gets my head right to tackle any situation. A massive part of it is going to the gym to strengthen my body. Weakness does not go over well when you have a dog that nearly outweighs you trying to eat you for lunch,” she said, highlighting that her strength and ability to handle bad situations affect her ability as a trainer.
Karlee then moves on to working with the dogs she’s training.
“Depending on the dog and how far along they are in their training, I will decipher how often I work with them daily. Some dogs need lots of exercise before they are ready to train, so I ensure they get it before our sessions so they are prepared to learn.”
The training sessions themselves may involve basic obedience, socialization, house training, and anything else the dog may need extra help learning.
Every dog I have the opportunity to train holds a special place in my heart,” Karlee said. “All of them come from different backgrounds and live in different environments. I spend hours on end every day developing personal relationships with these dogs and working on improving their lives.
And people started asking for alternatives to these breeds
Image credits: ksdogtraining
So she rounded up large dogs that she thinks are actually good even for novices
Image credits: Manuel J. Prieto
Image credits: rukasthedog
Image credits: Airwolfhound
Image credits: Denise Santos-Cucalon
Image credits: Barbara Dieu
Picking the wrong breed and then having to give up the pup because it is too much to handle is one of the reasons why approximately 3.1 million dogs enter US shelters every year (although it’s important to highlight that about 710,000 of them end up there due to other reasons and are returned to their owners).
Here are a few questions the American Kennel Club (AKC) recommends asking yourself when determining which dog is the best fit for your lifestyle. (Also, keep in mind that a prospective breeder may ask you these and/or other questions when deciding if your home is right for one of their puppies, so it may be helpful to jot your answers down).
- Are you an active person or more laid-back?
- Do you have children or plan to have children?
- Do you have the income to pay for vet visits (unexpected ones in addition to regular examinations and shots), pet insurance (if you choose to buy it), dog food, supplies, and more?
- How much time do you have to socialize and train a new puppy?
- How long are you away from home each day?
- How often do you take business trips and vacations, and what are your plans for the dog during these times?
It was another hit
@ksdogtraining Replying to @breroses239 #greenscreen Some dogs are the exception! #dogs #dogbreeds #dogtips #pets #dogsoftiktok #dogadvice ♬ original sound – ksdogtraining
Now it’s time to think about what you’re looking for in a dog.
- How much time can you commit to grooming a dog (and how concerned are you about shedding)? Also, do you have allergies?
- Are you looking for a dog for a specific activity (such as hiking, agility, or running)?
- Do you prefer large dogs or small dogs?
Contrary to popular belief, your living situation doesn’t necessarily have to dictate the last answer. Even apartment dwellers can easily share their homes with some larger dog breeds. As long as the dog’s exercise needs are met (through long walks, trips to the dog park, and activity sessions), the dog’s living area doesn’t necessarily have to be a certain size.
Later, Stark made a separate video on easier-to-handle small breeds
Image credits: David McKelvey
Image credits: kowal854
Image credits: sⓘndy°
Image credits: madaise
Of course, there are individuals that fall out of the norm. In fact, the more dogs Karlee works with, the more she comes across dogs that do not fit into the stereotype commonly associated with their breed.
Like a German Shepherd who does not have the drive for bite work or sniffing narcotics even though the breed is often seen in police and military K-9 units doing exactly that.
So why don’t all dogs strive to do what they were initially bred for?
“It all boils down to the breeding lines they come from, their environment, and the quality of their daily nutrition,” Stark explained. “If your dog does not come from working lines, chances are they don’t have the instinct to work. If they are not placed in a working environment, they are less likely to show signs of that instinct as well. And if someone fed you nothing but ramen noodles and mac & cheese every day, you would not be able to function at your best. Neither do dogs. If they are not given the proper nutrients throughout their life, their minds and bodies will not thrive at their highest potential.”
Which also garnered a fair bit of attention
@ksdogtraining I love to hear your opinions on things. But don’t bash on others!! #greenscreen #dogawareness #dogtraining #dogbreeds #dogtips #dogsoftiktok #dogadvice ♬ original sound – ksdogtraining
“I am passionate about helping people, and their dogs learn how to thrive,” Karlee added. “I enjoy it so much that I started a blog that gives dog training and lifestyle tips for those wanting to learn more about having a long and prosperous life with their pets. “
“I also work with a customized pet nutrition company to ensure my clients can find the correct nutrition for their dogs. Go to KarleeStark.com to learn more about me and receive updates every time I post!”
Here’s what people said after watching her TikToks
I can't say that I agree with this trainer's logic. She seems to have a bias towards purebreds which can be more prone to health issues due to poor, and accepted, breeding practices. For instance she says to only get a purebred poodle and not a goldendoodle or labradoodle. A hybrid "doodle" (poodle parent + lab or golden parent) benefits from something called "hybrid vigor" meaning that they are coming from diverse gene pools. And while this is purely anecdotal, my sweet rescue has had two different corgis snarl and go after her for absolutely no reason. Anyhow, this list is mostly bunk. Some dogs and breeds are hard wired a certain way but proper training and behavioral training can make a world of difference. The emphasis should always be on training, socialization and exercise. Finally, rescue, rescue, rescue... and spay and neuter your dogs. We don't need more purebred dogs. We need healthy dogs and to stop euthanizing them. End of rant :D
I agree with you! And although I understand what she is doing here, I still miss advocating for mixed breed/mutts from the shelter.
Load More Replies...
I’d add Malamutes to the “Not for First Time Owners” list. They are exceptionally smart dogs. Although difficult, they can be trained. And once trained, if they don’t follow a command… it’s not for lack of understanding… it’s because they’re being willful. Plus, they’re a LOT of dog to handle. I owned two great malamonsters… Polaris weighed 143 lbs. and Regulus weighed 141 lbs. I’m a certified dog trainer. My mals were very well trained. Although, not always well behaved. :) Currently, I own a golden and an American Shepard (aka mini Aussie). My golden is a sweet, playful, goofball, while my Aussie is our house’s disciplinarian. She literally herds our cats. If I start scolding the other animals… she’s right there “scolding” them with me. I unintentionally taught her to discipline when our kitten would do something he wasn’t supposed to (start climbing the curtain or scratch the couch). I’d tell her, “Andromeda, go tell Corvus ‘NO!’” And she would! Now she does it ALL the time!
My last guide dog was a Golden Retriever and she was just the most amazing, patient, smart, loyal, and loving dog. I trusted her with my life and she never let me down. Euthanizing her was the hardest thing I have ever done.
It's the last, best, and hardest thing we do for them. Sorry for your loss Gabby
Load More Replies...
I agree with the list but i want to add one group of dogs you should definitely not own as your first dog, And should actually be on top of that list, And that is the dogs that have part wolf in them, Tamaskan, Saarloos wolfdog, Czechoslovakian Wolfdog, To name a few of them, They are incredibly smart and need a very capable owner, Also chow chows and other Chinese breeds are not good dogs for first time owners, Because most Chinese dogs where bred for meat consumption, And they did not care about temperament, That's different now, But it takes a long time of breeding to get a change in behaviour.
Agreed chow chows are not great pets. They're lazy as hell and don't listen. They also can have so many allergies and health problems
Load More Replies...
Disagree on corgis. They are difficult dogs. Go to any corgi rescue group to read about their behavioral issues. Territorial, with biting/nipping issues. They are fantastic dogs, but not for beginners.
The nipping behaviour has been bred into them. Corgis were developed as a cattle-herding breed. Being small, sturdy, agile and pretty-much fearless, they would run around between the cattle, nipping at their back legs to get them moving in the required direction. Although they are no longer used for herding, the instinct to nip at your ankles remains. I had a corgi/border collie cross for 16 years (see profile pic). He retained the herding instincts of both breeds, and although I managed to stop his nipping, his rounding up skills ensured that my grandsons never strayed too far when we went for walks in the woods.
Load More Replies...
I'm surprised greyhounds (i.e. retired racers) aren't on this list. They are super easy dogs, and very nice temperament.
Iam sorry 10 years is not long enough to give that kind advice 😉 my first dog was a hybrid I was 12 we had a blast growing up he was a great dog but I had help from my brother and he is a experienced animal behavioralest.
My first dog was a chihuahua/rat terrier. Very high energy but I spent tons of time training with her and she was smart as a whip, catching on really quickly to everything. I don't think I would have as much time to do the same with another puppy at this point. That's probably what too many people don't understand: it takes work, consistency, dedication, etc. And the benefit for her was she could come everywhere with me because I knew she would listen and behave. She loved it also.
I'm a firm believer in adopt, don't shop So many rescues are available and would love a nice home
THIS! I've had several shepherds, all re-homes. They are a bit of a problem for the first year or so as they often lack basic leash manners, etc. After a year of guidance they make fantastic pets. Shopping encourages breading and this is a loop of breading -> humane society. Dogs live a long time, and are puppies for a SHORT time.. People need to think very carefully prior to taking on a pet. That cute/clumsy shepherd puppy will quickly grow into a 60+ pound dog..
Load More Replies...
I absolutely agree with her statement regarding a GERMAN SHEPHERD! Those dogs grew tall and muscular with a fair amount of energy! The last one (RIP sweetheart) was taller than me with my little 1,60cm / 5.2 feet, when putting its front paws on my shoulders. You really have to train them when they are still little! Displayed all this clumsy, sweet, bumbling behavior every puppy does. But if you don't, you will be confronted with a 30 kg / 66 lbs dog that truly can get aggressive and overwhelme you if you have not properly trained it (Disrupting his eating, taking away a toy, keeping it close and calm on its leash when being exposed to other (not trained) barking dogs, etc. ). If you are really into making a German Shepherd your best, furry friend and trying it from puppy stage you'll get a very buddy/girl for a lifetime 🥰 (Without proper training - starting in their puppy year -, they can become a major burden and a real danger to others!)
I'm sorry but as a Shepherd owner very little of what you wrote is accurate. (Disrupting his eating, taking away a toy, keeping it close and calm on its leash when being exposed to other (not trained) barking dogs, etc. ). My current re-home which I got when he was ~3 is a 120lb King shepherd. You can take his food away from him at any time.. Heck, you can actually dig it out of his mouth if you want.. Once in a while he finds things on the ground and attempts to eat it.. and I reach in there and take it from him and he doesn't care. As for toys, they are meant to be played with and I take them from him as well. He likes to take "indoor" toys outside and he's not allowed to do this so when he is at the back door wanting out and has his toys he's told to drop them and he does. Shepherds rarely bark. I can't stand barking dogs and this is why I've always had shepherds. Ring my doorbell.. he will get up and go to the front door but never bark.
Load More Replies...
Considering right now as I'm writing this, shelters are full of abandoned dogs who are murdered just because the society cannot and won't take care of them, I find articles about BYING dogs disgusting. Breedera make their money and great gods die in shelters. How about people sticking with their pets and not leaving them as soon as things get a bit tough or they get bored and want a new puppy? Adopt, don't sjop- yoy shop, you kill.
I have to say she is right about many of these breeds, however, I still push people to go to shelters to find their match. I also recommend not getting purebreds if you don't know their health risks. I have a purebred beagle, and I know the risks associated with them, as I my dad was once a breeder. While I love this breed, my boy came to me with an undiagnosed seizure disorder and some back issues. He's 12 and living his best life, mobile, happy, and loved, but I hate he occasionally has this. Meanwhile, my mutts lived just as long with fewer issues. We have a pitt-boxer mix, and can confirm they are energetic and need a job. Mine has one- she is my son's companion and playmate.
So just take the time to train him/her and exercise. It's a matter of how much time you want to put in and how much YOU are willing to be trained to lead the dog in the way he/she has been bred.
Load More Replies...
"Contrary to popular belief, poodles are smart" - WTF. Who doesn't know poodles are the SECOND MOST INTELLIGENT DOG? Also, why 'if you're gonna get one, get a purebred' - nice. Lady seems stuck up as heck. I've had purebred and mixes, and all were wonderful. I do completely agree that you need to be on top of the breed, because they are so intelligent. It's like raising a two year old (or smarter).
Although there are some breeds to be wary of, the breed is not the most important factor when choosing a pup, especially for first-time owners. Unless you are getting your pup from a shelter, always insist on meeting both parent dogs. If they are both friendly and well behaved there's every chance the pups will share that temperament. If the owner refuses to let you see the mother and/or won't put you in contact with the father's owners, walk away, no matter how cute the pups may be. Try to get to see the whole litter, not just one pup. That way, you can spot the more aggressive, dominant pups which are generally harder to train and more suited to experienced handlers. Don't go for a huge, powerful breed unless you have the physical strength to handle it. There is nothing worse than seeing somebody being dragged along by their dog, barely able to stay on their feet because the dog is the stronger of the two and either hasn't been properly trained to walk on a leash...cont
....cont..or still wants to chase anything that catches it's eye, be it another dog, a cat, squirrel or human. Finally, first timers especially should look for a local dog training club, where there'll be plenty of experienced handlers to help, and it will give your pup the ideal opportunity to learn to socialize with other dogs in a safe and controlled environment.
Load More Replies...
I am surprised that Border Collies aren't on the list for not great first time dogs as they are super energetic and smart so they need lots of stimulation. But I guess they qualify as midsized, not large breed. My first dog was a Boxer, then we had a Doberman, Husky, Shepard mutt. Both great doggos!
Border collies get a bit of a bad rep imo. Trust me, there's way too many horror stories of them destroying houses. My border, Loki, is the absolute sweetest. He only attacked furniture as a teething puppy and is now a beautiful role model for our second pup (aussie cattle dog). Admittedly, he is abnormally calm and we are country-based so he has fields to run in. But arguably it's not hard to keep up with their needs
Load More Replies...
You missed the best breed of them all: the mixed breed shelter dog! Not only are mixed breed dogs much healthier than purebreds but they're also uniquely adorable and have good attributes from multiple breeds while avoiding breed-specific health issues. Also, you can't generalize a whole breed of dogs; there's too many individuals and a lot of them don't fit into a box. Every single dog is different and they all can benefit from a full-rounded life with diet, exercise, training, and most importantly, love. Don't deal with overpriced sketchy backyard breeders. Save a life by adopting! If raising a puppy is too much for you, adult dogs from shelters may already be house trained and obedient.
My first dog as an adult is a Rottweiler, he is absolutely the best dog ever. He's almost 14 yrs old now, and needs help getting up because he has arthritis but he is still very well behaved. I started training him at 10 weeks old with a trainer who understood the bully breeds, she breeds Dobermans so she she was able to help me through my dogs hard teen stage. I socialized him like crazy, I took him everywhere and let him meet every person who would talk to him, this made him a very confident dog. His Vet described him as a social butterfly. My point is I think you can get any dog as a first dog if you are willing to do the research and the work. Training, Socialization, and Love, that's how I raised the best Rottweiler in the world. He has been my best buddy for almost 14 yrs.
The picture on my profile is of our Red Doberman princess, we also have a male black and tan, 5 and 3 yrs old respectively, also very smart dogs, train them the same way. Always with love our dogs know we love them so due to good training they do what we ask the to.
Load More Replies... 
She called Pit Bulls a walking med bill, and has the AUDACITY to recommend a Great Dane??
I found the "pitties are the sweetest ever" person 🙋🏿♀️
Load More Replies... 
Take my advice on this. For all my life, I've been with dogs. I've had plenty of pitbulls and I've walked and babysat plenty of GSD and huskies and rottweilers. These are not the dogs for first time owners. If you choose to adopt one or two of these dogs who are older from a shelter, that's perfect. But I know especially pitbull puppies are super energetic. Same goes for all these dogs. You have energy, and then some of them are loud like the husky. And then you have ones that shed like there is no tomorrow. And then you have dogs bred for violence and protecting, you need to properly train them in order to completely trust them. And if you are wondering, the only dog on here that I've had be more aggressive was the husky. But I'm not judging, some huskies are great. I've just had two unfortunate experiences with the same husky. (Not fatal, left a scar on a basset hounds ear and the pug that's cuddling me).
I'd also like to point out that pugs and bulldogs are laid back and more suitable for lazier people or peopler who can't be home for most of the day. They do have their health issues, but you could luck out like I have with my pug. No cherry eye, not overweight, no patellar luxation, never any infections in his wrinkles. One thing he has had for a bit is an ear infection, but we are taking care of it properly and it's basically gone now.
Load More Replies...
Like many others, not inclined to go along with this kid. Pits are so maligned and abused, and here we go again with words of caution about owning one. I've had a few pits rescued from horrendous conditions and loving them made all the difference. I raised 4 great danes too, a chow/shepherd mix and a wonderful labradoodle. She may train dogs, but I raise them. Sorry I even read this. It's all about her ego, typical of someone who thinks they know. Every dog is a good dog. It just depends on who YOU are.
Yes ma'am. You couldn't be more right! I absolutely love pitbulls and I wouldn't mind having chows and great Danes. I've had many pits in my life and guess what, not one has ever attacked anyone or thing. Thank you!
Load More Replies...
I have a standard schnauzer and am a first-time dog owner. She's perfect for our family. She's very smart, mischievous, and high-energy, but she's also loyal, sweet, and well-behaved. 15/10 would absolutely recommend!
This list is bogus imo. I'm a long time rottweiler, boxer and mixed breed owner. All of my dogs have been a dream except my mix. She's half wolfhound and half greyhound. Two supposedly easy breeds but she is anything but easy. She had food aggression, needs constant correction, enforcement training and more attention than any other dog I've ever owned. Rottweiler's are dream dogs once you start the training early and build their confidence in all situations. Get them use to different people, sounds and experiences. They would make a good first dog for anyone willing to put the work in. Just because she's not willing to put the work in, does not make them a bad first time dog. Silly lists.
If people don't have basic common sense, perhaps they shouldn't have children either.
Rather tedious and very random. As a canine behaviourist I tire of 'trainers' giving fairly ill informed advice. Finally, we breed far too many dogs and we should be recommending getting dogs out of the shelters. But, I guess that's not sexy...
I totally disagree with the Pitbull statement. I have owned Pitbulls for 30 years. 4 in total. These are low maintenance dogs, normal vet visits like any dog. Granted they need exercise. A backyard and playtime will work just fine. Walks around the neighborhood or dog park is best. Incredibly smart and loyal dogs. I have a nine year old daughter that basically calls ours her little sister. The two are inseparable. Very loving dogs. Highly trainable and they seek to please their owners. I will never own another breed. Pitbull owner for life. Socialize your pets. No matter the breed early and often. Pitbulls love companionship and interaction. The American Pitbull is the most misunderstood loving dog on the planet. They are silly and fun. Typically a very happy dog. Their tails are always wagging. I would suggest to anyone. If you can parent a child. You can parent a Pitbull. All dogs need exercise, no matter the bread for health purposes. Those that can't find the time to exercise "walk" a dog. Should not own anything with 4 legs. It isn't fair to said animal. Gold fish is the option.
I don't want to own a dog that can physically over power me if it so chooses
Load More Replies...
Each and every breed can be well-mannered if you work with them for at least two hours a day. Any time shorter than that - take yourself a plush animal! I've had tornjak (shepherd breed from Croatia/Bosnia), beagle, and now I live with miniature pinscher. All of them were/are assertive, well-mannered and obedient. All it took for me to teach them well, was time and sh*tloads of love. A lot of exercise, play and positive feedback. And, let me repeat once again - AT LEAST two hours of work, play and training every day!
I do agree mostly with her. I’ve worked with dogs basically my whole life. A lot of working breeds definitely need a job to do, that’s why they’re called working dogs. But how the pups were raised, plus positive training makes the difference. Try to remember, your dog will be their best self when the handler (you) remain calm. Even if you feel so overwhelmed, it’s important to realize that you need your dog to respect you, not fear you. Yelling at them is not okay. And eye contact! A dog/puppy that gives you eye contact is looking at you for direction. So don’t ignore it.
I have an Irish Wolfhound. Great dog. She is right though they are very large dogs. Not heavy but tall. Mine in his prime only weighed in at 127 - 135 pounds. He is heavier now but he doesn't get the exercise he once did. Wolfhounds love to run. My brother use to take my Wolfhound running when he went for a run as my brother lived close by. My brother is my Wolfhounds favorite person even to this day as he use to take him running. I dont run so he would chase around my RC trucks, he loved to run and flip the trucks. FYI no left out food is ever safe with a wolfhound. Their head is at counter height and it is easy for them to grab food. Mine has eaten full boxes of Cinnabons twice.
Was at an Irish Festival and there were some people there with their Irish Wolfhounds. They said that while they’re wonderful dogs, people are not prepared for adulthood when they have to pick up very large poop and if they get sick it’s human amount of vomiting. Same with diarrhea. Sorry to be so blunt, but they certainly were. Because of those reasons they often are given up. With any large/very large dog, that’s what you need to realize and be prepared for. So maybe Irish Wolfhound, Great Dane, Bernese Mountain Dog not so great for first timers. Start out smaller and move on up.
I see Belgian Malinois mentioned all the time. We had a rescue dog, a Belgian Groenendaal, he was the best dog ever. I stole him from my daughter and he was amazing, kept me going through the bad years. When my grandsons arrived I never worried about them with him, he'd be in the middle of their games and never flinched. Came and got my daughter when he thought my grandson was doing something he shouldn't. Still miss him 10 years later.
I have a group of elderly chihuahuas, and my husband brought along a corgi/some kind of sheep dog mix. And then we rescued a pitty boxer mix together I love them all dearly, but to me, the best dog is a lap dog that won't care if I haven't moved in hours. I feel so bad every time I notice the bigger dogs have an absolute stack of toys that they've brought to me, and I just didn't notice. It's been 5 years and I am still not with the picture :(
My first dog as an adult, is a very goofy beagle named Barney. Everyone told me he would be hard to train, be an escape artist, and be very high energy. However, Barney is the most laziest dog on the planet. Very intelligent though. But not big on escaping the yard. Usually my sidekick wherever I am.
One thing missing on the consideration list is: Do you have your own backyard or are you in an apartment? Also how much energy do you have to exercise and play with your dog? Depending on the answers, you're probably looking at completely different dogs as an ideal pet for you.
My dog is a mix of bluetick hound and carolina dog. Best dog I've ever had!
I had a mini pin as a first dog when I was a lot younger and they are so sweet. I currently have a Pitt mixed with a dalamation and she is a lot but lovable.
I grew up with a husky (really fricking big husky/part wolf) had Sasha-keeshond I want to try with a schnauzer. Apparently I'm downgrading
I'll add Elo to the list. They're bred to be extremely calm and patient and not prone to diseases. Because they are bred for their traits not their looks, they come in all different shapes and sizes. My bestie has one and he's the cutest, smartest, most well-behaved dog I've ever met. He has the sweetest fox face and is super-fluffy like a Spitz.
Salukis and greyhounds are great dogs and generally quite easy to look after. They need a good walk morning and evening, preferably where they can have a run off the lead, the rest of the day they will sleep. They do need a very comfy bed/sleep area because they don't have much body far and they can get sores if they have to sleep on a hard surface.
Wow, we accidentally got a Malinois for first dog, she was a stray. Someone asked, if we want her, beacause he can't keep her beacuse of his bigger dog. We never really trained her, just the basic commands, like come, no, sit, and it was enough, we hadn't any problems with her behavior. Exept she sheded an other dog every year for 6 months.
"Exept she sheded an other dog every year for 6 months". What does "sheded" mean? American here.
Load More Replies...
I love all dogs, but I saw more agressive/nasty Belgian Malinois than Rottweilers, to be honest. Been nearly bitten twice (had to deal very carefully with the situation). My MIL was bitten once by one of them. Now I fear this breed.
Because people buy them and cant/won't properly train them. Like it said in the post- they need a job! Even as an experienced handler I had to go to a professional with my mali. We were going to do agility and tracking with him initially. He developed some weird anxiety issues and took several years of work and lots of growing up to become a "normal" dog. It gets worse when people think "oh, smart breed, I'll get one so I can teach it tricks! ... do not get a smart dog just for this reason. Also, vreeders need to select their buyers based on experience with high drive breeds!
Load More Replies...
A trainer of 10 years 😂 I've forgotten more stuff about dogs than that little girl thinks she knows.
I can't say that I agree with this trainer's logic. She seems to have a bias towards purebreds which can be more prone to health issues due to poor, and accepted, breeding practices. For instance she says to only get a purebred poodle and not a goldendoodle or labradoodle. A hybrid "doodle" (poodle parent + lab or golden parent) benefits from something called "hybrid vigor" meaning that they are coming from diverse gene pools. And while this is purely anecdotal, my sweet rescue has had two different corgis snarl and go after her for absolutely no reason. Anyhow, this list is mostly bunk. Some dogs and breeds are hard wired a certain way but proper training and behavioral training can make a world of difference. The emphasis should always be on training, socialization and exercise. Finally, rescue, rescue, rescue... and spay and neuter your dogs. We don't need more purebred dogs. We need healthy dogs and to stop euthanizing them. End of rant :D
I agree with you! And although I understand what she is doing here, I still miss advocating for mixed breed/mutts from the shelter.
Load More Replies... I’d add Malamutes to the “Not for First Time Owners” list. They are exceptionally smart dogs. Although difficult, they can be trained. And once trained, if they don’t follow a command… it’s not for lack of understanding… it’s because they’re being willful. Plus, they’re a LOT of dog to handle. I owned two great malamonsters… Polaris weighed 143 lbs. and Regulus weighed 141 lbs. I’m a certified dog trainer. My mals were very well trained. Although, not always well behaved. :) Currently, I own a golden and an American Shepard (aka mini Aussie). My golden is a sweet, playful, goofball, while my Aussie is our house’s disciplinarian. She literally herds our cats. If I start scolding the other animals… she’s right there “scolding” them with me. I unintentionally taught her to discipline when our kitten would do something he wasn’t supposed to (start climbing the curtain or scratch the couch). I’d tell her, “Andromeda, go tell Corvus ‘NO!’” And she would! Now she does it ALL the time!
My last guide dog was a Golden Retriever and she was just the most amazing, patient, smart, loyal, and loving dog. I trusted her with my life and she never let me down. Euthanizing her was the hardest thing I have ever done.
It's the last, best, and hardest thing we do for them. Sorry for your loss Gabby
Load More Replies... I agree with the list but i want to add one group of dogs you should definitely not own as your first dog, And should actually be on top of that list, And that is the dogs that have part wolf in them, Tamaskan, Saarloos wolfdog, Czechoslovakian Wolfdog, To name a few of them, They are incredibly smart and need a very capable owner, Also chow chows and other Chinese breeds are not good dogs for first time owners, Because most Chinese dogs where bred for meat consumption, And they did not care about temperament, That's different now, But it takes a long time of breeding to get a change in behaviour.
Agreed chow chows are not great pets. They're lazy as hell and don't listen. They also can have so many allergies and health problems
Load More Replies... Disagree on corgis. They are difficult dogs. Go to any corgi rescue group to read about their behavioral issues. Territorial, with biting/nipping issues. They are fantastic dogs, but not for beginners.
The nipping behaviour has been bred into them. Corgis were developed as a cattle-herding breed. Being small, sturdy, agile and pretty-much fearless, they would run around between the cattle, nipping at their back legs to get them moving in the required direction. Although they are no longer used for herding, the instinct to nip at your ankles remains. I had a corgi/border collie cross for 16 years (see profile pic). He retained the herding instincts of both breeds, and although I managed to stop his nipping, his rounding up skills ensured that my grandsons never strayed too far when we went for walks in the woods.
Load More Replies... I'm surprised greyhounds (i.e. retired racers) aren't on this list. They are super easy dogs, and very nice temperament.
Iam sorry 10 years is not long enough to give that kind advice 😉 my first dog was a hybrid I was 12 we had a blast growing up he was a great dog but I had help from my brother and he is a experienced animal behavioralest.
My first dog was a chihuahua/rat terrier. Very high energy but I spent tons of time training with her and she was smart as a whip, catching on really quickly to everything. I don't think I would have as much time to do the same with another puppy at this point. That's probably what too many people don't understand: it takes work, consistency, dedication, etc. And the benefit for her was she could come everywhere with me because I knew she would listen and behave. She loved it also.
I'm a firm believer in adopt, don't shop So many rescues are available and would love a nice home
THIS! I've had several shepherds, all re-homes. They are a bit of a problem for the first year or so as they often lack basic leash manners, etc. After a year of guidance they make fantastic pets. Shopping encourages breading and this is a loop of breading -> humane society. Dogs live a long time, and are puppies for a SHORT time.. People need to think very carefully prior to taking on a pet. That cute/clumsy shepherd puppy will quickly grow into a 60+ pound dog..
Load More Replies... I absolutely agree with her statement regarding a GERMAN SHEPHERD! Those dogs grew tall and muscular with a fair amount of energy! The last one (RIP sweetheart) was taller than me with my little 1,60cm / 5.2 feet, when putting its front paws on my shoulders. You really have to train them when they are still little! Displayed all this clumsy, sweet, bumbling behavior every puppy does. But if you don't, you will be confronted with a 30 kg / 66 lbs dog that truly can get aggressive and overwhelme you if you have not properly trained it (Disrupting his eating, taking away a toy, keeping it close and calm on its leash when being exposed to other (not trained) barking dogs, etc. ). If you are really into making a German Shepherd your best, furry friend and trying it from puppy stage you'll get a very buddy/girl for a lifetime 🥰 (Without proper training - starting in their puppy year -, they can become a major burden and a real danger to others!)
I'm sorry but as a Shepherd owner very little of what you wrote is accurate. (Disrupting his eating, taking away a toy, keeping it close and calm on its leash when being exposed to other (not trained) barking dogs, etc. ). My current re-home which I got when he was ~3 is a 120lb King shepherd. You can take his food away from him at any time.. Heck, you can actually dig it out of his mouth if you want.. Once in a while he finds things on the ground and attempts to eat it.. and I reach in there and take it from him and he doesn't care. As for toys, they are meant to be played with and I take them from him as well. He likes to take "indoor" toys outside and he's not allowed to do this so when he is at the back door wanting out and has his toys he's told to drop them and he does. Shepherds rarely bark. I can't stand barking dogs and this is why I've always had shepherds. Ring my doorbell.. he will get up and go to the front door but never bark.
Load More Replies... Considering right now as I'm writing this, shelters are full of abandoned dogs who are murdered just because the society cannot and won't take care of them, I find articles about BYING dogs disgusting. Breedera make their money and great gods die in shelters. How about people sticking with their pets and not leaving them as soon as things get a bit tough or they get bored and want a new puppy? Adopt, don't sjop- yoy shop, you kill.
I have to say she is right about many of these breeds, however, I still push people to go to shelters to find their match. I also recommend not getting purebreds if you don't know their health risks. I have a purebred beagle, and I know the risks associated with them, as I my dad was once a breeder. While I love this breed, my boy came to me with an undiagnosed seizure disorder and some back issues. He's 12 and living his best life, mobile, happy, and loved, but I hate he occasionally has this. Meanwhile, my mutts lived just as long with fewer issues. We have a pitt-boxer mix, and can confirm they are energetic and need a job. Mine has one- she is my son's companion and playmate.
So just take the time to train him/her and exercise. It's a matter of how much time you want to put in and how much YOU are willing to be trained to lead the dog in the way he/she has been bred.
Load More Replies... "Contrary to popular belief, poodles are smart" - WTF. Who doesn't know poodles are the SECOND MOST INTELLIGENT DOG? Also, why 'if you're gonna get one, get a purebred' - nice. Lady seems stuck up as heck. I've had purebred and mixes, and all were wonderful. I do completely agree that you need to be on top of the breed, because they are so intelligent. It's like raising a two year old (or smarter).
Although there are some breeds to be wary of, the breed is not the most important factor when choosing a pup, especially for first-time owners. Unless you are getting your pup from a shelter, always insist on meeting both parent dogs. If they are both friendly and well behaved there's every chance the pups will share that temperament. If the owner refuses to let you see the mother and/or won't put you in contact with the father's owners, walk away, no matter how cute the pups may be. Try to get to see the whole litter, not just one pup. That way, you can spot the more aggressive, dominant pups which are generally harder to train and more suited to experienced handlers. Don't go for a huge, powerful breed unless you have the physical strength to handle it. There is nothing worse than seeing somebody being dragged along by their dog, barely able to stay on their feet because the dog is the stronger of the two and either hasn't been properly trained to walk on a leash...cont
....cont..or still wants to chase anything that catches it's eye, be it another dog, a cat, squirrel or human. Finally, first timers especially should look for a local dog training club, where there'll be plenty of experienced handlers to help, and it will give your pup the ideal opportunity to learn to socialize with other dogs in a safe and controlled environment.
Load More Replies... I am surprised that Border Collies aren't on the list for not great first time dogs as they are super energetic and smart so they need lots of stimulation. But I guess they qualify as midsized, not large breed. My first dog was a Boxer, then we had a Doberman, Husky, Shepard mutt. Both great doggos!
Border collies get a bit of a bad rep imo. Trust me, there's way too many horror stories of them destroying houses. My border, Loki, is the absolute sweetest. He only attacked furniture as a teething puppy and is now a beautiful role model for our second pup (aussie cattle dog). Admittedly, he is abnormally calm and we are country-based so he has fields to run in. But arguably it's not hard to keep up with their needs
Load More Replies... You missed the best breed of them all: the mixed breed shelter dog! Not only are mixed breed dogs much healthier than purebreds but they're also uniquely adorable and have good attributes from multiple breeds while avoiding breed-specific health issues. Also, you can't generalize a whole breed of dogs; there's too many individuals and a lot of them don't fit into a box. Every single dog is different and they all can benefit from a full-rounded life with diet, exercise, training, and most importantly, love. Don't deal with overpriced sketchy backyard breeders. Save a life by adopting! If raising a puppy is too much for you, adult dogs from shelters may already be house trained and obedient.
My first dog as an adult is a Rottweiler, he is absolutely the best dog ever. He's almost 14 yrs old now, and needs help getting up because he has arthritis but he is still very well behaved. I started training him at 10 weeks old with a trainer who understood the bully breeds, she breeds Dobermans so she she was able to help me through my dogs hard teen stage. I socialized him like crazy, I took him everywhere and let him meet every person who would talk to him, this made him a very confident dog. His Vet described him as a social butterfly. My point is I think you can get any dog as a first dog if you are willing to do the research and the work. Training, Socialization, and Love, that's how I raised the best Rottweiler in the world. He has been my best buddy for almost 14 yrs.
The picture on my profile is of our Red Doberman princess, we also have a male black and tan, 5 and 3 yrs old respectively, also very smart dogs, train them the same way. Always with love our dogs know we love them so due to good training they do what we ask the to.
Load More Replies... She called Pit Bulls a walking med bill, and has the AUDACITY to recommend a Great Dane??
I found the "pitties are the sweetest ever" person 🙋🏿♀️
Load More Replies... Take my advice on this. For all my life, I've been with dogs. I've had plenty of pitbulls and I've walked and babysat plenty of GSD and huskies and rottweilers. These are not the dogs for first time owners. If you choose to adopt one or two of these dogs who are older from a shelter, that's perfect. But I know especially pitbull puppies are super energetic. Same goes for all these dogs. You have energy, and then some of them are loud like the husky. And then you have ones that shed like there is no tomorrow. And then you have dogs bred for violence and protecting, you need to properly train them in order to completely trust them. And if you are wondering, the only dog on here that I've had be more aggressive was the husky. But I'm not judging, some huskies are great. I've just had two unfortunate experiences with the same husky. (Not fatal, left a scar on a basset hounds ear and the pug that's cuddling me).
I'd also like to point out that pugs and bulldogs are laid back and more suitable for lazier people or peopler who can't be home for most of the day. They do have their health issues, but you could luck out like I have with my pug. No cherry eye, not overweight, no patellar luxation, never any infections in his wrinkles. One thing he has had for a bit is an ear infection, but we are taking care of it properly and it's basically gone now.
Load More Replies... Like many others, not inclined to go along with this kid. Pits are so maligned and abused, and here we go again with words of caution about owning one. I've had a few pits rescued from horrendous conditions and loving them made all the difference. I raised 4 great danes too, a chow/shepherd mix and a wonderful labradoodle. She may train dogs, but I raise them. Sorry I even read this. It's all about her ego, typical of someone who thinks they know. Every dog is a good dog. It just depends on who YOU are.
Yes ma'am. You couldn't be more right! I absolutely love pitbulls and I wouldn't mind having chows and great Danes. I've had many pits in my life and guess what, not one has ever attacked anyone or thing. Thank you!
Load More Replies... I have a standard schnauzer and am a first-time dog owner. She's perfect for our family. She's very smart, mischievous, and high-energy, but she's also loyal, sweet, and well-behaved. 15/10 would absolutely recommend!
This list is bogus imo. I'm a long time rottweiler, boxer and mixed breed owner. All of my dogs have been a dream except my mix. She's half wolfhound and half greyhound. Two supposedly easy breeds but she is anything but easy. She had food aggression, needs constant correction, enforcement training and more attention than any other dog I've ever owned. Rottweiler's are dream dogs once you start the training early and build their confidence in all situations. Get them use to different people, sounds and experiences. They would make a good first dog for anyone willing to put the work in. Just because she's not willing to put the work in, does not make them a bad first time dog. Silly lists.
If people don't have basic common sense, perhaps they shouldn't have children either.
Rather tedious and very random. As a canine behaviourist I tire of 'trainers' giving fairly ill informed advice. Finally, we breed far too many dogs and we should be recommending getting dogs out of the shelters. But, I guess that's not sexy...
I totally disagree with the Pitbull statement. I have owned Pitbulls for 30 years. 4 in total. These are low maintenance dogs, normal vet visits like any dog. Granted they need exercise. A backyard and playtime will work just fine. Walks around the neighborhood or dog park is best. Incredibly smart and loyal dogs. I have a nine year old daughter that basically calls ours her little sister. The two are inseparable. Very loving dogs. Highly trainable and they seek to please their owners. I will never own another breed. Pitbull owner for life. Socialize your pets. No matter the breed early and often. Pitbulls love companionship and interaction. The American Pitbull is the most misunderstood loving dog on the planet. They are silly and fun. Typically a very happy dog. Their tails are always wagging. I would suggest to anyone. If you can parent a child. You can parent a Pitbull. All dogs need exercise, no matter the bread for health purposes. Those that can't find the time to exercise "walk" a dog. Should not own anything with 4 legs. It isn't fair to said animal. Gold fish is the option.
I don't want to own a dog that can physically over power me if it so chooses
Load More Replies... Each and every breed can be well-mannered if you work with them for at least two hours a day. Any time shorter than that - take yourself a plush animal! I've had tornjak (shepherd breed from Croatia/Bosnia), beagle, and now I live with miniature pinscher. All of them were/are assertive, well-mannered and obedient. All it took for me to teach them well, was time and sh*tloads of love. A lot of exercise, play and positive feedback. And, let me repeat once again - AT LEAST two hours of work, play and training every day!
I do agree mostly with her. I’ve worked with dogs basically my whole life. A lot of working breeds definitely need a job to do, that’s why they’re called working dogs. But how the pups were raised, plus positive training makes the difference. Try to remember, your dog will be their best self when the handler (you) remain calm. Even if you feel so overwhelmed, it’s important to realize that you need your dog to respect you, not fear you. Yelling at them is not okay. And eye contact! A dog/puppy that gives you eye contact is looking at you for direction. So don’t ignore it.
I have an Irish Wolfhound. Great dog. She is right though they are very large dogs. Not heavy but tall. Mine in his prime only weighed in at 127 - 135 pounds. He is heavier now but he doesn't get the exercise he once did. Wolfhounds love to run. My brother use to take my Wolfhound running when he went for a run as my brother lived close by. My brother is my Wolfhounds favorite person even to this day as he use to take him running. I dont run so he would chase around my RC trucks, he loved to run and flip the trucks. FYI no left out food is ever safe with a wolfhound. Their head is at counter height and it is easy for them to grab food. Mine has eaten full boxes of Cinnabons twice.
Was at an Irish Festival and there were some people there with their Irish Wolfhounds. They said that while they’re wonderful dogs, people are not prepared for adulthood when they have to pick up very large poop and if they get sick it’s human amount of vomiting. Same with diarrhea. Sorry to be so blunt, but they certainly were. Because of those reasons they often are given up. With any large/very large dog, that’s what you need to realize and be prepared for. So maybe Irish Wolfhound, Great Dane, Bernese Mountain Dog not so great for first timers. Start out smaller and move on up.
I see Belgian Malinois mentioned all the time. We had a rescue dog, a Belgian Groenendaal, he was the best dog ever. I stole him from my daughter and he was amazing, kept me going through the bad years. When my grandsons arrived I never worried about them with him, he'd be in the middle of their games and never flinched. Came and got my daughter when he thought my grandson was doing something he shouldn't. Still miss him 10 years later.
I have a group of elderly chihuahuas, and my husband brought along a corgi/some kind of sheep dog mix. And then we rescued a pitty boxer mix together I love them all dearly, but to me, the best dog is a lap dog that won't care if I haven't moved in hours. I feel so bad every time I notice the bigger dogs have an absolute stack of toys that they've brought to me, and I just didn't notice. It's been 5 years and I am still not with the picture :(
My first dog as an adult, is a very goofy beagle named Barney. Everyone told me he would be hard to train, be an escape artist, and be very high energy. However, Barney is the most laziest dog on the planet. Very intelligent though. But not big on escaping the yard. Usually my sidekick wherever I am.
One thing missing on the consideration list is: Do you have your own backyard or are you in an apartment? Also how much energy do you have to exercise and play with your dog? Depending on the answers, you're probably looking at completely different dogs as an ideal pet for you.
My dog is a mix of bluetick hound and carolina dog. Best dog I've ever had!
I had a mini pin as a first dog when I was a lot younger and they are so sweet. I currently have a Pitt mixed with a dalamation and she is a lot but lovable.
I grew up with a husky (really fricking big husky/part wolf) had Sasha-keeshond I want to try with a schnauzer. Apparently I'm downgrading
I'll add Elo to the list. They're bred to be extremely calm and patient and not prone to diseases. Because they are bred for their traits not their looks, they come in all different shapes and sizes. My bestie has one and he's the cutest, smartest, most well-behaved dog I've ever met. He has the sweetest fox face and is super-fluffy like a Spitz.
Salukis and greyhounds are great dogs and generally quite easy to look after. They need a good walk morning and evening, preferably where they can have a run off the lead, the rest of the day they will sleep. They do need a very comfy bed/sleep area because they don't have much body far and they can get sores if they have to sleep on a hard surface.
Wow, we accidentally got a Malinois for first dog, she was a stray. Someone asked, if we want her, beacause he can't keep her beacuse of his bigger dog. We never really trained her, just the basic commands, like come, no, sit, and it was enough, we hadn't any problems with her behavior. Exept she sheded an other dog every year for 6 months.
"Exept she sheded an other dog every year for 6 months". What does "sheded" mean? American here.
Load More Replies... I love all dogs, but I saw more agressive/nasty Belgian Malinois than Rottweilers, to be honest. Been nearly bitten twice (had to deal very carefully with the situation). My MIL was bitten once by one of them. Now I fear this breed.
Because people buy them and cant/won't properly train them. Like it said in the post- they need a job! Even as an experienced handler I had to go to a professional with my mali. We were going to do agility and tracking with him initially. He developed some weird anxiety issues and took several years of work and lots of growing up to become a "normal" dog. It gets worse when people think "oh, smart breed, I'll get one so I can teach it tricks! ... do not get a smart dog just for this reason. Also, vreeders need to select their buyers based on experience with high drive breeds!
Load More Replies... A trainer of 10 years 😂 I've forgotten more stuff about dogs than that little girl thinks she knows.
87
102