The progression of movie-making is never set in stone. There are plenty of variables that move left and right, leaving the producers and directors scrambling to get things right. And while some problems may be avoided with careful planning, there are times when changes are sudden, but for the better. One of such cases would be a change in actors. Maybe they can't play the role or ultimately become unfit for the overall vision, but they are removed from the production and the role is given to someone else. And the replacement actors become the embodiment of the characters we know now.

#1

Stuart Townsend Was Replaced By Viggo Mortensen In Lord Of The Rings

Stuart Townsend Was Replaced By Viggo Mortensen In Lord Of The Rings

Stuart Townsend, a relatively new name in the industry, was cast as Aragorn in Lord of the Rings, but when the filming began, he lasted only a few days. The director was quick to notice Townsend was too young to play the Strider, and the role was given to Viggo Mortenson, who gave an iconic performance.

New Line Cinema , 20th Century Fox Report

TheReader19
Community Member
7 months ago

Viggo sexy as hell though

View More Replies...
View more comments
#2

Sylvester Stallone Was Replaced By Eddie Murphy In Beverly Hills Cop

Sylvester Stallone Was Replaced By Eddie Murphy In Beverly Hills Cop

Beverly Hills Cop is considered a comedy classic, but when Sylvester Stallone was cast as Axel Foley, he wanted to shift the script to be include more heroics for his character, turning Alex into a certified action figure. Such a take on the film was rejected and Stallone was replaced by Eddie Murphy, who gave the film his unique charm.

Paramount Pictures Report

TheReader19
Community Member
7 months ago

Well that's was a very wise choice

View more comments
#3

Eric Stoltz Was Replaced By Michael J. Fox In Back To The Future

Eric Stoltz Was Replaced By Michael J. Fox In Back To The Future

Marty McFly is an iconic character in the sci-fi scene, but the face we all know and love today may have been a different one, as Michael J. Fox initially wasn't available for the filming due to conflicting schedule, so the role was given to Eric Stoltz. Sid Sheinberg, head of Universal, even supported this casting. Despite filming most of his scenes, Stoltz was deemed to be too dramatic and lacking the humorous flair imagined for the role, so Fox was contacted again and the scheduling conflict was worked out. Zemeckis took it upon himself to inform Stoltz of the decision and later said it was “the hardest meeting I've ever had in my life and it was all my fault. I broke his heart."

Universal Pictures , Miramax Films Report

denzoren
Community Member
7 months ago

Fox was perfect for this role.

View more comments
#4

Dougray Scott Was Replaced By Hugh Jackman In X-Men

Dougray Scott Was Replaced By Hugh Jackman In X-Men

Love him or hate him, we all know who Wolverine from the X-Men is, as well as the actor who plays him. But the role of the gruff hero was intended for Dougray Scott, who, back in 1999, was making quite a name for himself. However, Scott's other project dragged on and he wasn't available when the X-Men started filming, thus the role was given to Hugh Jackman and the rest is history.

20th Century Fox , Paramount Pictures Report

John Doe
Community Member
7 months ago

thank you Scott's other project!

View More Replies...
View more comments
#5

Nicole Kidman Was Replaced By Jodie Foster In Panic Room

Nicole Kidman Was Replaced By Jodie Foster In Panic Room

Nicole Kidman had already begun filming for the role of the distressed mother in the thriller Panic Room when she injured her knee. Unfortunately, she had previously injured the same spot while filming Moulin Rouge and now had a hairline fracture which left her unable to continue filming. The role was given to Jodie Foster, who had to shut down the movie she was about to direct because the star, Russell Crowe, was injured.

Sony Pictures , Warner Bros Report

JennyLaRue
Community Member
7 months ago

So, she dropped out of filming, not fired like the title of the article suggests.

View More Replies...
View more comments
#6

Annette Bening Was Replaced By Michelle Pfeiffer In Batman Returns

Annette Bening Was Replaced By Michelle Pfeiffer In Batman Returns

Oscar nominee Annette Bening was originally cast as the Catwoman, quite a prominent figure in Batman's life. However, Bening had to leave the production once due to pregnancy, and Michelle Pfeiffer stepped up to fill in her shoes. The change was unexpected, and Pfeiffer was even said to have worn outfits measured for her predecessor because of the rush to start filming.

Warner Bros , DreamWorks Pictures Report

Vicky Z
Community Member
7 months ago

I don't know how bening would be, but Michelle Pfeiffer is the best catwoman ever!

View More Replies...
View more comments
#7

Kevin Spacey Was Replaced By Christopher Plummer In All The Money In The World

Kevin Spacey Was Replaced By Christopher Plummer In All The Money In The World

Some recasts have to be done out of great necessity. Such is the case with All the Money in the World, where Kevin Spacey was initially supposed to play the role of an oil tycoon. Due to sexual assault allegations involving him, the director Ridley Scott quickly removed him from the movie, reshooting all his scenes with Christopher Plummer, who even received an nomination for an Academy Award.

Sony Pictures , Sony Pictures Report

Vicky Z
Community Member
7 months ago

I don't understand how they chose Spacey in the first place!! The role was for someone a lot older and needed to use a lot of make up!! Why not choose an older actor in the first place!! Plummer was great as always!! RIP 😪😪

View more comments
#8

Lori Petty Was Replaced By Sandra Bullock In Demolition Man

Lori Petty Was Replaced By Sandra Bullock In Demolition Man

Back in the '90s, Lori Petty was making a name for herself as a reliable actress, and was set to appear in Demolition Man together with big names like Sylvester Stallone and Wesley Snipes. However, she reportedly didn't get along with Stallone, and was replaced by a relative newcomer in the industry—Sandra Bullock.

Warner Bros , MGM Report

Requiem
Community Member
7 months ago

Bullock was better for that role. Petty was good for Tank girl

View more comments
#9

Dennis Hopper Was Replaced By Ed Harris In The Truman Show

Dennis Hopper Was Replaced By Ed Harris In The Truman Show

The Truman Show is a very impactful movie with plenty of deep themes and ideas, and what made it half as good is the actors. The role of Christof, the mastermind behind the fake town, was initially given to Dennis Hopper; however, there were difficulties with his portrayal (with a possible allegation of forgetting his lines), and so the role was then assigned to Ed Harris, who excelled at it!

Paramount Pictures , United Artists Report

TheReader19
Community Member
7 months ago

Another good choice made here

View More Replies...
View more comments
#10

James Purefoy Was Replaced By Hugo Weaving In V For Vendetta

James Purefoy Was Replaced By Hugo Weaving In V For Vendetta

The iconic character from V for Vendetta may have had different mannerisms if the director had decided to go with his first pick for the role. James Purefoy inhabited the character of V for a whole 6 weeks of filming before it was decided he couldn't properly emote while wearing a mask. Hugo Weaving was asked to take over as V, and it's his portrayal that we see in the movie.

Warner Bros , Fox Report

TheReader19
Community Member
7 months ago

Why are you showing Hugo with a mask on?

View More Replies...
View more comments
#11

James Remar Was Replaced By Michael Biehn In Aliens

James Remar Was Replaced By Michael Biehn In Aliens

The fans of the Alien franchise likely all recognize the face of Michael Biehn, who played Hicks, but this role didn't land in his lap initially. At first, the character was meant to be played by James Remar, but he was fired after a few weeks of filming due to creative differences. Later, the actor himself admitted he had a drug problem and lost the role because he was in possession of drugs.

20th Century Fox , Paramount Pictures Report

Kim Bush
Community Member
7 months ago

As much as I like James Remar, Michael Biehn IS Hicks

View More Replies...
View more comments
See Also on Bored Panda
#12

Harvey Keitel Was Replaced By Martin Sheen In Apocalypse Now

Harvey Keitel Was Replaced By Martin Sheen In Apocalypse Now

Harvey Keitel was hired to play the role of captain Benjamin L. Willard in Apocalypse Now, despite not being the director's first choice. However, his portrayal lacked the passive feeling that director envisioned, so the role was offered to Martin Sheen, who, incidentally, was the first pick, but couldn't initially take on the role due to scheduling conflicts.

United Artists , Miramax Films Report

TheReader19
Community Member
7 months ago

Replacement choice approved

View More Replies...
View more comments
#13

Julianne Moore Was Replaced By Melissa Mccarthy In Can You Ever Forgive Me?

Julianne Moore Was Replaced By Melissa Mccarthy In Can You Ever Forgive Me?

Julianne Moore was let go from her role in Can You Ever Forgive Me a mere 6 days before the filming started. Moore admitted her opinion diverged from the director's: "I think that her idea of where the character was, was different than where my idea of where the character was.” Reportedly, the actress wanted to wear a fat suit to appear more like the real-life person she would portray. Moore was replaced by Melissa McCarthy, who was even nominated for the Best Actress Academy Award.

Searchlight Pictures , Sony Pictures Report

Yort
Community Member
7 months ago

Wait, I didn’t know McCarthy was n a movie that wasn’t just fat jokes! Is it any good? Why don’t I just google it.

View More Replies...
View more comments
#14

Jean-Claude Van Damme Was Replaced By Kevin Peter Hall In Predator

Jean-Claude Van Damme Was Replaced By Kevin Peter Hall In Predator

Predator in Predator may be recognizable by its look, not the actor behind it, but there was a chance Jean-Claude Van Damme could have embodied the feared hunter. However, apparently the prosthetics and the costume were so stifling, the actor even passed out wearing them. The real reason why Van Damme left the project is a bit of a mystery, but his place was taken by Kevin Peter Hall.

Universal Pictures , SWSCA Report

TheReader19
Community Member
7 months ago

He most probably wasn't tall enough either

View More Replies...
View more comments
See Also on Bored Panda
#15

Kel O'neill Was Replaced By Paul Dano In There Will Be Blood

Kel O'neill Was Replaced By Paul Dano In There Will Be Blood

Kel O'Neill was cast in the role of Eli Sunday in There Will Be Blood, together with the household name Daniel Day-Lewis. However, after the filming started, O'Neill wasn't quite the best fit, and even the actor himself realized it. The role was then given to Paul Dano, who was already on set, playing the role of Eli's brother (the script was simply adjusted to include identical twins).

Paramount Pictures , Kel O'Neill Report

denzoren
Community Member
7 months ago

Paul was freaking iconic against DDL in this movie.

View more comments
#16

Samantha Morton Was Replaced By Scarlett Johansson In Her

Samantha Morton Was Replaced By Scarlett Johansson In Her

Two-time Academy Award nominee Samantha Morton was cast as the voice for the AI assistant named Samantha in Her. However, in postproduction, it became apparent that the voice for the AI needed something other than what Morton could bring. "When we started editing, we realized that what the character/movie needed was different from what Samantha and I had created together," said the director of the movie. So the role was given to Scarlett Johansson.

Warner Bros , IFC Films Report

Crazy Meerkat Lady
Community Member
7 months ago

Oof... that must have stung for Samantha. I can just imagine how she must have felt being given the role and then having it taken away, for no fault on her side really

View More Replies...
View more comments
#17

Colin Firth Was Replaced By Ben Whishaw In Paddington

Colin Firth Was Replaced By Ben Whishaw In Paddington

The wonderful talking bear Paddington was originally supposed to be voiced by Colin Firth, but somewhere down the line (after the actor recorded most of the lines), the realization set in that the actor's voice didn't match the animation of the cute bear. “It’s been bittersweet to see this delightful creature take shape and come to the sad realization that he simply doesn’t have my voice.” Firth was replaced by Ben Whishaw.

StudioCanal , 20th Century Fox Report

Johnny
Community Member
7 months ago

How does compensation work in cases like this? He did most of the work and it's not his fault he was miscast.

View More Replies...
View more comments
#18

Ryan Gosling Was Replaced By Mark Wahlberg In The Lovely Bones

Ryan Gosling Was Replaced By Mark Wahlberg In The Lovely Bones

The Lovely Bones centers its story around a missing girl and her family, and the role of the father was supposed to go to Ryan Gosling, who, in order to better represent the man he was meant to play, put on some weight; Gosling reasoned that he was a stressed father whose daughter was gone, so he thought it was fitting, but director Peter Jackson disagreed, and Gosling was replaced by Mark Wahlberg.

Paramount Pictures Report

Crazy Meerkat Lady
Community Member
7 months ago

I think that is something that should be discussed between the actor and the director before the movie is filmed. And also, I know it is different for everyone, but I would think that losing weight is more common under these stressful circumstances

View More Replies...
View more comments